A question for Asma-haters - Page 3

Originally posted by: Khatarnak

Asma ki wajah sey achay achay singers bahar hogaye - aur khatarnak ko yeh gawara nahin, Asma kay alawa aur bhi hain jinko top 7 ka haq nahin - aur Asma ka drama sab jantay hain.

Asma ko ab bahar hona hoga - is mein Hatred ki kiya baat hai - yeh gana ganay ka muqabla hai koi natak nahin.

Summerji Asma ki new sense value sey ziyada koi value nahin.

Originally posted by: prat29

I see a sizable number of people on this forum hate Asma.

Asma gets votes because there are plenty of people out there who find her attractive, and don't really care how she sings. Is this really Asma's fault ?

Week after week, Mentors including Shankar, keep praising her despite her pathetic singing, and believe me, there are plenty of voters out there who get swayed by mentor's comments and ratings. So Is this really Asma's fault ?

All reality shows are about TRPs and Revenues, there is no channel out there who is doing this purely for the greater good of the society. To gain higher TRPs, they need to keep viewers interested, not just those (most of us on this forum would fall in this category) who watch the show purely for enjoying some good singing, but more importantly those who send in votes. A majority of these latter group ones need some action on the show, not just plain singing. Zee appears to be gaining a lot by keeping Asma on the show. Hence they keep coming up with ways to get Asma going with her silly antics. I am sure even Asma realizes that she does not deserve to be in top 14 but why blame her when she is there because of others...... viewers, voters, mentors and more importantly, Zee.
Do you expect her to be so magnanimous that she should walk up and quit on her own because she is not as good as the others ?

And mark my words, Zee will not make her the winner. Zee will bring in the true talent for the finals. But until then, they just want to sustain the interest in the show.

So why all this hatred towards her when she is merely a puppet in the hands of Zee ?

Let me conclude by saying I'm not at all a fan of Asma...and I watch the show only because I get to hear some excellent singing from Pratibha, Zaheer and sometimes, Yashita.

I just felt that all this hatred towards Asma is unwarranted and hence this post.

Originally posted by: Little SK

hey yaar thanks for the post, i really like this post of urs,,really shayad yeh post par kar kuch logo ki aankhe khulli hongi👏

Originally posted by: robinsucroe

it dosent matter if you guys hate or love asma. all members in these forums are nris and not real indians living in india. nris only are 5 crore while local indians are 95 crore and so nri votes dont matter . even if you guys vote for other contestants except asma india will make asma win. i went to india and all indians love and support asma. for them asma is special as asma is the first real foreigner to sing in india and they are ready to give a chance to her even if she improves to sing in bollywood. nris dont like foreigners as they live around foreigners and they miss indians in their home country. you guys are loosers who instead of helping develop their home country with your brain level went to take refuge in other countries. not a single indian living in india participates in these forums as they can discuss about all reality shows and asma with their freinds and family as they are living in india where all are indians. nris live far away from their freinds and family and have few indians to speak to in foreign countries . indians are not jobless like nris to spent their full day in this forums criticizing asma and others. and my guess is that asma is a better person at heart and way better looking than flaminhotkurri.

Originally posted by: Summer3

Kaise ho yaar ! You both are doing fine but there are several sharks here, so please be on guard.😊

Originally posted by: mbharat2007

The existance of ASMA in Saragamapa remains a mystery:

1. When the program started, her singing was absolutely pathetic. In fact, there were several singers better than her who deserved re-entry via Brahmastra. That did not happen. Asma by hook or BY CROOK, managed to get in. How did that happen? Did he really manage to get sufficient votes? I simply don't believe so. Even if the voting is open world wide, majority of the votes will come from Indian voters. And inspite of Asma's nautanki, I don't believe that Indian voters will so overwhelmingly vote for her. Even if all the voters from Oman were to vote for Asma, I do not think she can get sufficient votes to outnumber the other votes.

In all, Zee TV is not 100% honest about this SMS voting and I the rules have been ignored for selected participants. Asma re-entered the program and has remained in the show because of this corrupt practice.

Next question is who favoured Asma and why? My guess is that Asma's father or near relatives are influencial in Zee's management and are perhaps key to Zee's business in Oman or the middle east and under their influence, Zee TV are compelled to bend the rules to keep Asma in the show.

Additionally, I believe the mentors have been paid huge incentives not just to soft peddle on Asma's deficiencies, but to reap unreasonable praises on her even when it is obvious that she does not deserve them ("History! History! History!???).

True Asma has subsequently improved, but this is a competition. If Asma was given so much opportunity to improve, why were the other participants denied the same?

Zee TV and the mentors are largely to blame for this injustice (on other better singers who have had to leave the show), but Asma also has her hands tainted because without her convinnance, this manouvering would not have happened. It is perfectly ok if Asma has to bear some wrath.

Originally posted by: prat29

I see a sizable number of people on this forum hate Asma.
Asma gets votes because there are plenty of people out there who find her attractive, and don't really care how she sings. Is this really Asma's fault ?
Week after week, Mentors including Shankar, keep praising her despite her pathetic singing, and believe me, there are plenty of voters out there who get swayed by mentor's comments and ratings. So Is this really Asma's fault ?
All reality shows are about TRPs and Revenues, there is no channel out there who is doing this purely for the greater good of the society. To gain higher TRPs, they need to keep viewers interested, not just those (most of us on this forum would fall in this category) who watch the show purely for enjoying some good singing, but more importantly those who send in votes. A majority of these latter group ones need some action on the show, not just plain singing. Zee appears to be gaining a lot by keeping Asma on the show. Hence they keep coming up with ways to get Asma going with her silly antics. I am sure even Asma realizes that she does not deserve to be in top 14 but why blame her when she is there because of others...... viewers, voters, mentors and more importantly, Zee.
Do you expect her to be so magnanimous that she should walk up and quit on her own because she is not as good as the others ?
And mark my words, Zee will not make her the winner. Zee will bring in the true talent for the finals. But until then, they just want to sustain the interest in the show.
So why all this hatred towards her when she is merely a puppet in the hands of Zee ?
Let me conclude by saying I'm not at all a fan of Asma...and I watch the show only because I get to hear some excellent singing from Pratibha, Zaheer and sometimes, Yashita.
I just felt that all this hatred towards Asma is unwarranted and hence this post.

Originally posted by: akanna

Very well said. At least someone is thinking in terms of reality with a completely sane mind. 👏

Every time the mentors give History to her, they also quote, "for your standard it is history" - I guess Asma lovers dont hear that out of the excitement and outburst! They completely miss out the hint the judges are giving out as Asma's standard!! 😆

Originally posted by: Little SK

yeah i will, u also help 😃do u also think the same as me?or something else?

Originally posted by: Little SK

yeah i will, u also help 😃do u also think the same as me?or something else?