Created

Last reply

Replies

22

Views

2.2k

Users

14

Frequent Posters

126529 thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#11
she bring her mother and father issue in zee tv. she want to win by using her mother 's and father's personal problem like divorce. she is horrible singer and she knows about herself. she says her mother leave her because of her singing that's why she wants everyone to vote for her. she also think if she wins she will be play back singer but my dear asma doen't know about bollywood. because in bollywood person has to be perfect singer like sunidhi or sherya. they both are perfect example of singing. they are best singer that's why they make their place in bollywood.
m_khan90 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#12

Originally posted by: Summer3

Asma has a very sweet personality which people like. She has a strong Fan Base and she has beaten a lot of singers who are better due to several reasons. I understand her Fan base is in Orkut and Face Book.

There are people who like her singing too and they rank her as one to the top singers.
Generally a lot of people love to watch her on stage and provide a lot of humour and comedy. However, there are also a lot of people who think the other way. Anyway, let the public decide whom they want in the competition.

I agree with you summer, I did not vote for her lately cuz she has already a huge fan following. I like her on the stage from day one. I wish her to be upto top 5 at least.
m_khan90 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: priya1978

she bring her mother and father issue in zee tv. she want to win by using her mother 's and father's personal problem like divorce. she is horrible singer and she knows about herself. she says her mother leave her because of her singing that's why she wants everyone to vote for her. she also think if she wins she will be play back singer but my dear asma doen't know about bollywood. because in bollywood person has to be perfect singer like sunidhi or sherya. they both are perfect example of singing. they are best singer that's why they make their place in bollywood.

You never lose a chance to spit your venom on my poor Asma. She has a huge fan following and now I like her singing as well like many thousand of people. You have to bear her presence upto top 5 at least.
m_khan90 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: klsaigal

I hate her guts. She is soooooooo annoying. What is with the finger in her mouth. Her mother just got divorced because of her and she should do something about it rather than standing there making mockery of music and herself. She should be with her mom in her toughest times. If she can't be loyal to her mom who else can she be loyal to.
Vow what an amazing selfish girl.One of it's kind.

Asma said that she wants to win so that her mother can be happy. Your above highlighted statement you gave as if her mother is dying God forbid. Mothers are angry with the children but after a little while they forgive them too. I am sure Asma's mother will forgive her in due course but this time will never come in Asma's life. Who knows the way she is progressing she might win too.
Rhimjhimsawan thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 16 years ago
#15

I adore Asma. I wanted to see her survive but right now I think she should leave. She has improved a lot and reached this level. It is really sad to see better singers leave the show when she is still here. I wish her all the best! I admire her for her courage. A transition from arabic to Hindi is very tough. She has done what most indian singers won't be able to do. Atleast none of her co contestants.

About the parents issue all due respect I dislike asma for it. if her singing was a such a huge issue she should've put her mother before her wish. I might've understood it if the mother refused and then said I will lock myself in a room till you change your mind. But it is not like that. The issue is HUGE! The family is broken apart. If you can't be loyal to your mother the lady who gave birth to you then who can you be loyal to??
And I honestly doubt the mother will be happy if Asma wins. the mother must be praying day and night for her daughter to get of that stage. I really hope Asma is not that naive. And by any chance her mother all of a sudden happily accept her daughter if she wins then this whole thing is a stunt!
akanna thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 16 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: m_khan90

Asma said that she wants to win so that her mother can be happy. Mothers are angry with the children but after a little while they forgive them too. I am sure Asma's mother will forgive her in due course but this time will never come in Asma's life. Who knows the way she is progressing she might win too.

I agree with Priya that she brought the issue on TV by announcing it in public, which was totally unasked for, and then she kept going and crying that she wishes she wins so that her mom will be happy. It was like a tricky request asking the public to vote for her and make her win to make her mother happy! How can she even hope to win a music show when she knows she is the weakest singer of all? Since this show is based on public votes, she used that tactic to make people feel sorry for her and so vote for her. And Zee spiced up the drama the week after.
She might win with sympathy votes or whatever category votes she gets, but not 'real' talent recognized votes for sure. If she wins and if she becomes happy and makes her mom happy, let it be. After all, the producers have to be really dumb to sign her up for an album contract, and if they refuse, what is Zee going to do about it, and what is she going to do then?! The same producers might sign up one of the other contestants who ahd lost instead - since they are investing money for good ROI, I dont think they will take that kind of risk by signing her up for their music album.
If you notice, none of the directors or producers who have been on the show as mentors or guests have never offered her anything so far - because they are fully aware of the risk if they do. Why did HR make Prathibha sing his new song and not Asma who is in his gharana??
akanna thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 16 years ago
#17

Originally posted by: Perfangel5655

I adore Asma. I wanted to see her survive but right now I think she should leave. She has improved a lot and reached this level. It is really sad to see better singers leave the show when she is still here. I wish her all the best! I admire her for her courage. A transition from arabic to Hindi is very tough. She has done what most indian singers won't be able to do. Atleast none of her co contestants.

About the parents issue all due respect I dislike asma for it. if her singing was a such a huge issue she should've put her mother before her wish. I might've understood it if the mother refused and then said I will lock myself in a room till you change your mind. But it is not like that. The issue is HUGE! The family is broken apart. If you can't be loyal to your mother the lady who gave birth to you then who can you be loyal to??
And I honestly doubt the mother will be happy if Asma wins. the mother must be praying day and night for her daughter to get of that stage. I really hope Asma is not that naive. And by any chance her mother all of a sudden happily accept her daughter if she wins then this whole thing is a stunt!

I agree with you. You have analyzed it very well, and so correctly with respect to the situation. The pictures that were shown by Zee during the show of her family, her mother appears to be a loving and caring mother, and not someone who would disown or forsake her daughter for no reason.
deanu thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#18
A lot has been said about Asma & the way she is dealing with the issue about her mother. But I guess somewhere down the line, it seemed to have skipped our notice that Asma had her father's support to come & sing. It was her mother who abandoned her family on account of her convictions about Asma & her singing. What does that say about her mother. Does Asma have to be the only one to make the compromises?
With regard to her singing I do agree, she isnt exactly there on the top. Her presence on the show can be totally attributed to her likeability factor which is not a rare thing to happen on any reality show. Just accept the fact that many a time popularity supersedes talent. Not fair..but then that's life.
HalleNJ thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 16 years ago
#19

I don't understand why personal matters of the contestants affect the voters/fans a lot.........All these should not be taken as a criteria to judge singers!! Yes you can adore her for her courage and boldness but for singing.....????????? come on guys.....

trippleh thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#20
i wasnt freaken try to critisize her

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".