is this why Naina was eliminated? - Page 2

Originally posted by: poo6856

Sorry for all "S" typos in there which is typical LOL, but yeah i was super duper excited to write comments on Ms. Nautanki Sara, so that happend , Cheerz and have fun buddies :-

Originally posted by: Indradhanush

Do you agree with Shankar M that Naina got eliminated because she was only a good singer and not something more, this means one needs to crack jokes/ have X factor to survive. Interesting, but she left with head high and ever smiling face.

Originally posted by: pdesh

if that's true then we'll see vaishali being eliminated too, because she too doesn't have the X- factor.

Shankar hit the nail on the head.Naina cannot crack jokes,she can ONLY sing.We know what he maeant and whom he meant.Unfortunately,he is bound by the contract with the channel and cannot protest.He did the next best thing--telling Naina she is in her good books.No promise of playback opportunity,but thats what it comes to when SM says that.We may see her with SM some day.

As they say he who laughs last laughs the best.In Naina's case she who smiles always will end up with a big smile.

That's true, Vaishali is a trained singer, i mean afterall she has won SAREGAMAPA MARATHI thing, so let's see. I dont think that all works by the way, but i dont know, may be looks?

i think she is gone due to her vote request with AB being them both from UP.

King sad that in another post

if X-factor was what decides the winner then ppl like lata mangeshkar, mukesh, rafi, hemant kumar would never have won had they been contestants in these times!

I think Naina might have offended some viewers by making special reference to her own state in the last episode which indirectly implied lack of appreciation for viewers from other states who regularly voted for her. That's possibly why she didn't get enough votes this time. I think Abhisheikh Bachhan mentined to her that her being from a particular state has nothing to do with votes she gets.

Originally posted by: Your King Anu

king anu dislikes sara because of her fake drama

Why don't we all agree that we can't tolerate Sara - because she is from Pakistan (I think Zee should she inviting any contestants from overseas - as we are not as open minded as we pretend to), to me she is as good as any other contestant.