is this why Naina was eliminated? - Page 3

Originally posted by: Dabulls23

I am totally with you here abt the way they have been addressed.

Why don't we all agree that we can't tolerate Sara - because she is from Pakistan (I think Zee should stop inviting any contestants from overseas - as we are not as open minded as we pretend to), to me she is as good as any other contestant.

Originally posted by: Indradhanush

Chances are high that finalists would be Sara vs Pratibha.

Originally posted by: jo_jo1214

The majority of persons in IF want the best person to win. sometimes some people from a certain locality may feel obliged to vote for their own village or town persons. But generally the best should come in.

Unfortunately it is not happening as planned and this is upsetting people.

Originally posted by: mdroy

I am very upset that Naina is out while far less deserving singers are in but that is the nature of the show. I am disappointed that Pritam and the others did not insist that they would be offering her work ASAP. Of course Shankar should put her to work ASAP and introduce her to ARR and South directors where there is quality work for quality singers (just ask Sadhna Sargam and Sonu Nigam).

As for Sara, I just don't think she is that good though still better than some others left over. I liked that Reshma song she sang so my thought is that maybe her song picks are not good for her voice. Her voice generally sounds childish and she sounds like she has something in her mouth when she is singing. She attempted to ARR songs and 2 Shamshad Begum songs and all 4 fell short. She could not capture the playfulness of the SB songs or the sort of South Indian classical flavor of the ARR songs.

Putting aside her network manufactued drama, her manner still bugs me. I think it is her childish manner and voice which may charm some people but not me.

This has nothing to do with Pakistan unless you are suggesting that all women from Pakistan have a childish voice and manner, Everyone who knows me here knows that I am a big Amanat fan and most IF members (the older ones anyway) put singing above everything else.

Originally posted by: mdroy

I am very upset that Naina is out while far less deserving singers are in but that is the nature of the show. I am disappointed that Pritam and the others did not insist that they would be offering her work ASAP. Of course Shankar should put her to work ASAP and introduce her to ARR and South directors where there is quality work for quality singers (just ask Sadhna Sargam and Sonu Nigam).

As for Sara, I just don't think she is that good though still better than some others left over. I liked that Reshma song she sang so my thought is that maybe her song picks are not good for her voice. Her voice generally sounds childish and she sounds like she has something in her mouth when she is singing. She attempted to ARR songs and 2 Shamshad Begum songs and all 4 fell short. She could not capture the playfulness of the SB songs or the sort of South Indian classical flavor of the ARR songs.

Putting aside her network manufactued drama, her manner still bugs me. I think it is her childish manner and voice which may charm some people but not me.

This has nothing to do with Pakistan unless you are suggesting that all women from Pakistan have a childish voice and manner, Everyone who knows me here knows that I am a big Amanat fan and most IF members (the older ones anyway) put singing above everything else.