Asma should stay!

I completely agree! why is it that even though we say we are looking for singer we just don't look for just singers, we look for a good performer, we look for someone who connects with audience.

she can stay but i hope she gets out next after sara i.e.

Originally posted by: gengarjetty

true... 1 piece of coal is better than 300 pieces of silver...

Originally posted by: babii.girl

👏..OMGGGG totalliiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii agreee wiithhh uuuuuuu esp the end about Mitika

Originally posted by: Indradhanush

I am really feeling tired here where support for someone who is hopeless, comes because she can improve. If you make Aishwarya Rai stand here she will sing equally good or bad as Asma and she any day has more charisma, does it mean she deserves a chance here? Asma is certainly not a basic singer even. Someone (who has very good of knowl of music and doesn't write any more here), told some time back, he is avoiding the forum discussion to keep his blood pressure in normal range. I think I also have reached that point seeing barrage of nonsense thread like this.

Time to call it quits perhaps. Lest Rock.

Originally posted by: niruba

you are so right......Saregamapa is a singing contest, not a beauty peagent or comedy show......we need singers, not stars/heroes/heroins/models!!!

After reading all these posts now I'm sure that Asma will remain in the competition longer than I expected

Originally posted by: Perfangel5655

I have been seeing too many Asma hating posts. I am sorry but I like her. Yes there are thousand and thousands of great singers in India. But the judges have said it over and over again they are looking for someone " different" . They are looking for something "NEW". Please do be honest here. Beside debojit being a little mentally challenged who do you see on that stage that is oh so different. Maybe I am blind but I see no one.

Granted it is not a show where they are ready to train singers from abc. But they still do teach them. Singers immensly improve. Asma is probably not the best but she was good enough to enter the show. Her biggest problem is the language barrier. I am not arabic but I do speak arabic. And I have got to give it to the girl for singing in hindi so beautifully even though the difference in our language is HUGE!! HUGEEEEEE. We have sounds in our language they have never used in their whole entire life. She is a pretty good singer. She will improve. She will learn how not to make those mistakes.

Maybe if I didn't like her I wouldn't say this but if the judges want a singer that won't be lost tomorrow they should keep Asma. They said it themselves it's time they make international stars. Well there you have it! Asma can be that star. Yes Yashita is brilliant, Paribha is good but chances are they will live on concert like rest of the GREAT reality show winners. I liked Mitika and I am sad she isn't here. But we will see 1000 more mitikas on that stage. How many Asma's have you seen?