Imran was the best performer on saturday - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

25

Views

3.2k

Users

11

Frequent Posters

200467 thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#11
^^ ID, I think I have made it clear many times before that I do not judge them based solely on musical technicalities because I do not have that much knowledge of music. I go by my ear and mostly I comment on the over all "performance" which includes lot more facets than pure singing..... but of course, good singing will always be the most important criteria. I may not be able to figure out where they slipped from sur but I can definitely make out the over all good vs. bad singing. May be that's the reason I don't consider Debo or Asma good singers despite the blatant favoritism shown by the judges. Similarly, I can figure out Pratibha and Naina are better than Yahsita despite my utter lack of sur-taal knowledge. Yaar, hum ney kab claim kiya ki hum sangeet pundit hain😆

I feel Yashita did great yesterday. You can count how many times uss key sur phisley and totally miss the over all impact of her performance while counting. I prefer to go by the over all feel like millions other. Hope I have made it crystal clear now😊

dockaul thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#12

Originally posted by: Gauri_3

^^ ID, I think I have made it clear many times before that I do not judge them based solely on musical technicalities because I do not have that much knowledge of music. I go by my ear and mostly I comment on the over all "performance" which includes lot more facets than pure singing..... but of course, good singing will always be the most important criteria. I may not be able to figure out where they slipped from sur but I can definitely make out the over all good vs. bad singing. May be that's the reason I don't consider Debo or Asma good singers despite the blatant favoritism shown by the judges. Similarly, I can figure out Pratibha and Naina are better than Yahsita despite my utter lack of sur-taal knowledge. Yaar, hum ney kab claim kiya ki hum sangeet pundit hain😆

I feel Yashita did great yesterday. You can count how many times uss key sur phisley and totally miss the over all impact of her performance while counting. I prefer to go by the over all feel like millions other. Hope I have made it crystal clear now😊



Way to go Maa'm!!! ID saheb ,hum sab KANSEN hain TANSEN nahin.. Nusrat saab ke live performances suniye... Kitni baar sur phisalte hain... But for Me he is the ultimate singer.. coz he connects... & how :-)
Indradhanush thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: Gauri_3

^^ ID, I think I have made it clear many times before that I do not judge them based solely on musical technicalities because I do not have that much knowledge of music. I go by my ear and mostly I comment on the over all "performance" which includes lot more facets than pure singing..... but of course, good singing will always be the most important criteria. I may not be able to figure out where they slipped from sur but I can definitely make out the over all good vs. bad singing. May be that's the reason I don't consider Debo or Asma good singers despite the blatant favoritism shown by the judges. Similarly, I can figure out Pratibha and Naina are better than Yahsita despite my utter lack of sur-taal knowledge. Yaar, hum ney kab claim kiya ki hum sangeet pundit hain😆

I feel Yashita did great yesterday. You can count how many times uss key sur phisley and totally miss the over all impact of her performance while counting. I prefer to go by the over all feel like millions other. Hope I have made it crystal clear now😊

hmmm to be honest even I am not a pundit (and never claimed) but agar koi sur se fisle to I fail to evaluate ise meri kamjori samajh lijiye 😊

@ dockaul: apun bhi kaansen hai bhai. Taansen was genius but his history is marred with false claim of raaga creations and getting those killed who lost the war of sur taal to him in court of Akbar when he was challenged by some one else , it is so strange that he was defeated by none other then Baiju Bawra.
His history is very unique.
Edited by Indradhanush - 17 years ago
-shehzaadi- thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#14
I didn't like Yashita's singing that much..maybe since I don't like the song itself. But at some times I felt she was singing in falsetto.
Indradhanush thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: shehzaadi91

I didn't like Yashita's singing that much..maybe since I don't like the song itself. But at some times I felt she was singing in falsetto.

did you read this shehzadi?
'I'm not ashamed of singing at private weddings'
Sonu Niigaam's talk session with Rachana Dubey.

So Rafi Resurrected is finally releasing in India.
Yes, Sa Re Ga Ma released the album in the international market before bringing it to India. It's already a hit in the US and in Europe. It found a market in the UK too because of the presence of the Symphony Orchestra.

What's happening with the private album of your father (Agam Kumar Niigam)?
He has collaborated with T-Series on three very successful albums. He's committed to a fourth one now.

And what's the update on the careeer of your sister Neekita's career after Marigold?
To make it the top you need to be super-ambitious. She'll always get work but I don't want her to go through the grind. If someone wants her to sing, they will call. She's done good work with Shankar-Ehsaan-Loy, MM Kreem and Sandeep Chowta.

You're supposed to be playing the lead in two movies. Apparently you want Sunidhi Chauhan as your heroine in one of them.
Don't believe half of what you hear. It's true I'm getting quite a few offers. I've been reading plenty of scripts in the last eight months but I haven't zeroed in on a project yet. I'm proud of is Love in Nepal. The other films started off well but then went somewhere else. This time I want to play safe. I won't do a film I'll be embarrassed by all my life.

You once said that you are the highest paid singer.
Singers aren't paid much. Sunidhi (Chauhan) and Shreya (Ghoshal) are among the highest paid singers. I don't sing unless I get my price.. at the same time, I'm not stubborn about my fee. Most of us prefer to concentrate on live shows which get us big bucks. But for friends, we sometimes sing for free.

You sing even at private weddings.
What's wrong with that? It's nothing to be ashamed of. These functions earn me my bread and butter. I've been performing since I was three..sometimes at melas, weddings and government functions. Those who say they don't do shows have probably never been invited. It's not a joke to sing for two hours at a stretch, without a sip of water or a visit to the washroom. I'm not like those actors who dance for 20 minutes and take home a fat cheque. I justify every rupee I'm paid.

You once hosted Sa Re Ga Ma Pa. Today, Abhas Joshi and Aditya Narayan have taken over. How do you feel when you see them on the show that made you a household name?
I was one of the first one to exploit the medium of television. Mika recently messaged me to tell me that he's learnt the art of exploiting TV from my experiences. When I hosted Sa Re Ga Ma Pa, I spoke from the heart. Shows weren't scripted then. Who says singers always have to be behind the mike? Today, music is visible.. composers, singers, lyricists, they are all doing shows. There's a face associated with every show, whether it's Madonna or Sunidhi Chauhan.

Does your son, Neevan, show signs of following in your footsteps?
(Smiling fondly) I have a recording of him trying to match sur and taal with me. He was only eight months old then. He's a bright kid. I'll support him irrespective of whether he wants to be a singer, a cricketer or a sadhu.
-shehzaadi- thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#16
^^nice interview, thanks for posting. 😊 but what does that have to do with this topic? or is it in response to my signature? 😆
Edited by shehzaadi91 - 17 years ago
afridi10 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#17
I would love to see Sunidhi host saregama...lol...i know it has nothiong to do with the article but thought i would mention it
Dabulls23 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 17 years ago
#18
I did not care for Yashita's rendition in Imran khan episode. Usually she is good.
I think history was much higher than what she deserved.😳
Hit was appropriate.
Actually Sara did better job than her previous performances.
I feel judges were not fair to Zaheer. He did wonderful job. I agree with Shanker on his comments.👏
Shutjat also was given History for a super hit performance
DD is always over hyped so no comments
Tarun was disappointing.
kaushik was superb.👏
Naina and Pratibha always puts out there best efforts at singing.
Dunno what is about IK that everyone is going goo goo ga ga over 😕 I fail to understand 😳
Edited by Dabulls23 - 17 years ago
Dabulls23 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 17 years ago
#19

Originally posted by: SonPan

^^ are u a guy or a girl?

Lord have mercy 😆 Take a guess after checking my profile. Should clear your dilemma 😳
-shehzaadi- thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#20

Originally posted by: Dabulls23

Dunno what is about IK that everyone is going goo goo ga ga over 😕 I fail to understand 😳



lol...pasand apni apni. 😛 Us mein kuch aisi baat hai jo kaafi ladkiyon ko achi lagti hai (mujhe bhi) 😆

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".