So many platforms...what's the purpose?

Page

Next Last

tulipbaby53

@tulipbaby53

Trailblazer

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

I love watching musical reality shows, but it really pains me to see some much good talent and not hear much about them after the show is over. Let me just take Indian musical shows as an example. We have Sa Re Ga Ma Pa, Little Champs, Indian Idol, Star Voice of India, Chote Ustaad, X Factor, Fame Gurukul, Waar Parivaar, Surkeshetra, etc... (These are just the ones I have watched. I'm sure there are more.) Then there are shows that use popular reality show contestants like Jo Jeeta Wohi Superstar and Music Ka Maha Muquabula.

What really happens to majority of these contestants? Most of them do not really have much work after the show is over. Some of the more popular ones might do some stage shows, release an album, and if they are really lucky, get a movie song. Some even try to go into music directing.

However, how helpful are these shows to the contestants participating? Is there any point in having so many platforms when the opportunities for success are so few? Also, as audience members, how do feel these reality shows can be of better use for the contestants? Do you feel that these shows are just giving false hopes to these contestants who are hoping to make their dreams come true?

I know there have been some success stories like in the case of Shreya Ghoshal, but how feasible is it for everyone to achieve the success she has received?

I don't know, but I just feel that there should just be one or two musical reality shows maximum. I feel there's too much talent being discovered and not even opportunities available. The judges should really help build the contestant's careers by giving them the right advices for being successful in the industry.

Quote

Frequent Posters

music-a-muse

@music-a-muse

Dazzler

Posted: 12 years ago

Valid point.

First, most of these contestants invariably are busy doing stage shows. good enough.

Some of them do think they have reached exalted status appearing on these shows, esp once they reach top 10. riyaz goes flying out of the window. Too much fame and they start spinning in the stratoshphere. This is especially true of child stars, unless they have parents who have their feet firmly tethered to the ground.

Too many shows and merry-go- round is expected to happen.

The judges very very rarely give honest judgement and guide them properly.

If a musical layman, like me, can make out shoddy judgements and unwarranted praise, imagine the contestant s feelings.

Chances in music industry will be less. When we have music directors/judges wielding the megaphone, where do these contestants stand a chance?

May be a song or two or may be more, mostly inconsequential.

Where does it leave the contestants?

i think they should be happy with the exposure on TV and move on being happy doing what they can and get😊

Edited by music-a-muse - 12 years ago

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

tulipbaby53

@tulipbaby53

Trailblazer

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

Yeah, but it's really sad because so many of these people come (and some are so young) with the hopes that they can become a singer, but so many of them try here and there after the reality show, then they have to go back home in disappointment. I just really wished these judges would really mentor some of the extremely talented and rare finds from the shows. I know it's hard to help everyone, but there some that are really extraordinary, but I don't hear about them much after the show.

Quote

music-a-muse

@music-a-muse

Dazzler

Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: tulipbaby53
Yeah, but it's really sad because so many of these people come (and some are so young) with the hopes that they can become a singer, but so many of them try here and there after the reality show, then they have to go back home in disappointment. I just really wished these judges would really mentor some of the extremely talented and rare finds from the shows. I know it's hard to help everyone, but there some that are really extraordinary, but I don't hear about them much after the show.

It takes a very large hearted and confident person to do that. Unfortunately, the truth is it is a very small field and most of them are very insecure and like kids.They want to retain their position and rarely like anyone else to threaten what they have achieved. Very few realise theres always space for everyone.

Quote

Dabulls23

@Dabulls23

Stunner

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

One good thing comes out of these shows is kids getting exposure..They get to do road shows in India and abroad..Which gives them some income better than none..Not everyone is really extra oridinary or lucky enough to get into industry to sing. But even getting one or two chances is better than none..Who you know and luck , which genre shongs are popular at particular time plays bigger part then being an awesome singer these days...

These days we have alot more genres or type of songs which are given to new comers...We have alot more singers than handful that India had before.

I agree with you both TB and MAM...RIyaz does go out of the window with most of them as road shows take toll as well as fame gets to their little heads..At the end of the day they may not get hindi songs but do get into regional songs to sing..

Also agree on judges not always giving true judgements and guidance..Constructive criticism is very important...Hoping they are getting it on backstage...Than again we have some mediocre judges on panel...They are there judging as they don't have any singing contracts either... Be it singers or MDs..For them it is money making job to judge. .. I am being honest here.

Not speaking of any of the judges on SRGMP 2012 panel...In general.

This time we have some really good singers just like each contest have had some very talented contestants..

Q abt will another one be as successful as Shreya??? Time and era is different...When Shreya came, Sunidhi came times were different compared to almost 2013..

Excellent topic ...

Edited by Dabulls23 - 12 years ago

Quote

tulipbaby53

@tulipbaby53

Trailblazer

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: music-a-muse

It takes a very large hearted and confident person to do that. Unfortunately, the truth is it is a very small field and most of them are very insecure and like kids.They want to retain their position and rarely like anyone else to threaten what they have achieved. Very few realise theres always space for everyone.

That is true. They feel that if they give opportunities to so many people that they might not find work. What they forget is, if no one gave them a chance, then they would not have been known either.

Quote

tulipbaby53

@tulipbaby53

Trailblazer

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

@ DB23: You also do bring up some good points.

They do get good exposure, and I do agree with that. They get some money from touring, but that's their dream or ultimate goal. They came to be singers and make their own songs; not just sing other singers' songs.

Yes, the time was different when singers like Shreya Ghoshal and Sunidhi came. They came when there was only one platform for serious singers to come on. The judges judging were different people who really valued good talent and wanted their success. The moral value of people is changing a lot too.

Quote

Dabulls23

@Dabulls23

Stunner

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

Insecurities, Power struggle and Ego trips stops some from giving newcomers a chance...One has to be confident with their talent not to get scared with competition..

Quote

sushrutapandey

@sushrutapandey

Navigator

Posted: 12 years ago

There are too many good singers and not that many opportunities. The same goes for top levels of any art based industry. So, imo, by now anyone who goes for these shows should have realistic expectations of where they might end up. Success is largely a matter of luck and being at the right place at the right time. The fact that this is a business venture for the TV channels is also to be factored. To gain even the amount of limelight these kids get is a lot. After that, it's a matter of their continued desire to be successful and how lucky they get.Neither the audience nor the singers should expect any more out of it.

Quote

kavmuks

@kavmuks

Dazzler

+ 3

Posted: 12 years ago

#10

Can't agree more with music-a-muse..

The reason are stage shows and lack of Riyaz.. reduced time of span for fame , quick fame, money , need … fear of being left out in the race … many of them .. and unfortunately our shows fail to select good talent also.. they praise talent overboard and not prove try music based feedback…

I am glad this year things are different…

see any music show with older participants ' you won't feel like listening to them' they will choose bouncy numbers and try to perform as dancer than as singer..

Most of them become wedding singers or new year party singer, dandy, ganesh chaturthi, singers..

It is sad but then .. the one who really works hard stands out ' Sunidhi and Shreya .. Shekhar or Vishal Shekher

Edited by kavmuks - 12 years ago