Jasraj Joshi !AT from page 16 !!A future Composer! - Page 14

Created

Last reply

Replies

141

Views

26.8k

Users

37

Likes

225

Frequent Posters

rajsun thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
main thing i like abt jasraj is --he is not scared of going the path less tread upon,,he is willign to explore and also sing in a diffferent style 😳, i dont just mean in his physical attitute which is full of confidence but also his innovatinvness without changing the soul of the song he tries to brign a " twist " i say !! it is diffferent but a welcome change ,😳

like the singham he sang today with his variations -as rahul ramji said got a feel of broadway music in between ., I too liked it .😳
i kwn he missed sme surs during high notes but still it was enjoyable -- he doesnt sing it as in a competition --he sings with all fun and masti, that;s what catches you !!!

u knw i really like all the contestant in saregama this year ,,, like all , i miss madhuri dey for sure ...and
i kwn this is magical jasraj AT --😉

I also want to add ,,, there is smething diff abt this saregama ,,-- like the mentors are positive , no strss ful atmosphere -- no strss on the contestants too-- they have been given full freedom to sing in their comfort zone ,,,

like MA singing full on -- classical and jazim -only ghazals or shenaz slow soulful songs ...

vishwa --- is ful pacakge , jasraj ofcourse is ,

for a change i am liking this no fiercely competitive atmosphere 😊 oh i forgot i like the band too they are good
unlike in KS the atmosphere was too competitive and that got all focus only on the comments than on the contestant's singing

oops i got carried away 😆😆
Edited by rajsun - 12 years ago
music-a-muse thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
Just loved the lion roar😆😆

He is an amazing package, would not like to hear him sing tho.Everything else he does to a song is fine by me.

Even i liked the operatic? feeling he gave to the notes and it blended beautifully with the main song.
music-a-muse thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
His piya haji ali was perfect, but sometimes you just want to hear it simple and soulful bringing out the essence of the prayer without the verbal pyrotechnics.

For me, he lost it yesterday 😳
Dabulls23 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
His rendition of Piya Haji Ali was more of Qawali than sufiana rendition...THough it was waay better than some of his previous performances...He was under control and not shouting alot...I still have Raja's rendition in my brain and heart...I could not connect to god with his rendition which I could with Raja's...Woh soulful rendering nahi tha..😳
NEways did not think it was worth the POTD...But oh well judges and guests know much more than MOI...So all power to him..
Blossom5 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
For me, his Piya Haji Ali was not what i was hoping for. I mean it was classic Jasraj in that he arranged the song in his own way and made the performance unique. His attention was on the arrangement and technicalities, the additions to the song, the accessories to the song and not the song itself. I can not say what was going on in his head or heart and how he felt or related to the song but he was not able to convey the proper feelings while he sang. He doesn't necessarily have to alter every song he is given, for once i would like to hear a song, simply sung and straight from the heart, sung the way the original composer intended it to be. I say this because, while i support originality, he is smart enough to take the song and make it fit his style. He however has not really shown how he can adapt himself to a song which is a necessary quality in a playback singer. Playback singers need to be able to take good dirrections from the music director and sing as they are told. I don't exactly know how to phrase my point properly but, we have seen Jasraj mold a song to his tastes, i want to see him mold himself to a song, i want the original composition in control to test his own adaptability.
liveon thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
Jasraj was outstanding on the weekend

He was out of his voice was not in a condition to sing at all..

but he intelligently transformed his voice & gave it a best shot

genius ..

n during Haji ali , nw I really think god helped him..fo sho

Keep rocking Jasraj & take care of ur voice bro
music-a-muse thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: Blossom5

For me, his Piya Haji Ali was not what i was hoping for. I mean it was classic Jasraj in that he arranged the song in his own way and made the performance unique. His attention was on the arrangement and technicalities, the additions to the song, the accessories to the song and not the song itself. I can not say what was going on in his head or heart and how he felt or related to the song but he was not able to convey the proper feelings while he sang. He doesn't necessarily have to alter every song he is given, for once i would like to hear a song, simply sung and straight from the heart, sung the way the original composer intended it to be. I say this because, while i support originality, he is smart enough to take the song and make it fit his style. He however has not really shown how he can adapt himself to a song which is a necessary quality in a playback singer. Playback singers need to be able to take good dirrections from the music director and sing as they are told. I don't exactly know how to phrase my point properly but, we have seen Jasraj mold a song to his tastes, i want to see him mold himself to a song, i want the original composition in control to test his own adaptability.


So well put across the whole post 👏

The coloured part hit the nail on the head, so rightly you said it !
liveon thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: rajsun

main thing i like abt jasraj is --he is not scared of going the path less tread upon,,he is willign to explore and also sing in a diffferent style 😳, i dont just mean in his physical attitute which is full of confidence but also his innovatinvness without changing the soul of the song he tries to brign a " twist " i say !! it is diffferent but a welcome change ,😳


like the singham he sang today with his variations -as rahul ramji said got a feel of broadway music in between ., I too liked it .😳
i kwn he missed sme surs during high notes but still it was enjoyable -- he doesnt sing it as in a competition --he sings with all fun and masti, that;s what catches you !!!

u knw i really like all the contestant in saregama this year ,,, like all , i miss madhuri dey for sure ...and
i kwn this is magical jasraj AT --😉

I also want to add ,,, there is smething diff abt this saregama ,,-- like the mentors are positive , no strss ful atmosphere -- no strss on the contestants too-- they have been given full freedom to sing in their comfort zone ,,,

like MA singing full on -- classical and jazim -only ghazals or shenaz slow soulful songs ...

vishwa --- is ful pacakge , jasraj ofcourse is ,

for a change i am liking this no fiercely competitive atmosphere 😊 oh i forgot i like the band too they are good
unlike in KS the atmosphere was too competitive and that got all focus only on the comments than on the contestant's singing

oops i got carried away 😆😆


I loved the way u summarized it
it says it all
only 2 deserving contestants to me are - Jasraj for his obvious magic & ability to redifine the song & flawless Moh aman for his super talented classical singing
Shehnaz is not doing anything extra to the song & singing it the way it is
Vishwajeet is now trying hard to go Jasraj way & making fun of himself

now it's like anybody's game though
sushrutapandey thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
I loved his Piya Haji Ali. It was near perfect in terms of tone,emotion and the Sufi madness/energy component.

Edit: I do agree that sometimes he needs to be restrained but that is no flaw in itself. Rahman once talked about Sukhwinder Singh and said that he was a crazy guy who was very hard to reign in as a singer and once or twice Rahman had to put his foot down and force Sukhwinder Singh to follow his directors. I don't think a music director alone makes a song. A song is a confluence of energies from the MD, singer and lyricist and someone like Jasraj can bring a lot to the table.
Edited by sushrutapandey - 12 years ago
tulipbaby53 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: sushrutapandey

I loved his Piya Haji Ali. It was near perfect in terms of tone,emotion and the Sufi madness/energy component.

Edit: I do agree that sometimes he needs to be restrained but that is no flaw in itself. Rahman once talked about Sukhwinder Singh and said that he was a crazy guy who was very hard to reign in as a singer and once or twice Rahman had to put his foot down and force Sukhwinder Singh to follow his directors. I don't think a music director alone makes a song. A song is a confluence of energies from the MD, singer and lyricist and someone like Jasraj can bring a lot to the table.


I agree with your edit a lot. I have not seen the most recent episodes yet, so I cannot comment on his performance. I do feel that his energy would bring something interesting in the recording studios. I would love for him to get a break by Rahman and see what the combination of these two could create! JJ does have a talent that not many possess. I don't think each of his performances are perfect, and actually, some of them can be a bit OTT, but I do overall like his style and feel his inspirational energy.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".