Performances Review And Discussions ~~ Ticket To Finale ~~

behindyou thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 7 years ago
#1
guys discuss this week performances here 😊

Created

Last reply

Replies

96

Views

7.7k

Users

15

Likes

102

Frequent Posters

Raina101 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#2
Loved today's episode. Everyone sang really well.

Akhtar brothers - they were good, but their song selection let them down. At this stage they've got to realize it's not just how they sing, but also the song they choose that's going to get them votes. It's sad, that they lost out on a good chance to get the ticket.

Chetan - he wasn't great, but he was so much better than usual. When he sang, you could hear his harkats, he needs practice and to be shown the right path. He has a wonderful example in his brother Hemant.

Vishnumaya - it's sad that people think she's weak. Honestly, she's probably the strongest song with Hemant. She chooses such tough songs. Loved her today. And so happy she finally got the tutaari. Sometimes I wonder if the production house is on India forums.

Zaid - this kid is a natural. But today when he started you could tell he was under some pressure. But a few seconds into the performance he forgot about the pressure. Still, I think he wasn't as relaxed as always.

Rohanpreet - I enjoyed his performance today. Like always he chooses brilliant songs. Well executed. I was surprised he didn't get more votes.

Hemant - he was the deserving winner of the ticket to finale this week. This guy can sing anything. He doesn't fail to amaze me. I hope this guy makes it in Bollywood.

709927 thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#3
Everyone was great today...here's my take on the performances!

Hemant was great today! He could have been a bit less harsh during the chorus but I honestly thought this was one of his best performances and I loved the Mon Manjhi addition in Bheegi Bhaagi. I'd say he deserved the highest score today. Amazing song choice and execution. I want to see how he will sing a soft song.

For whoever's been following my comments they'd know I like Akhtar bros but this was my least favorite performance of them. I couldn't connect to the song and there were parts of screaming frankly. They have yet to reinvent themselves.Their comments on their comments on Vishnu further put me off as they were uncalled for and came across as a way to put her down because if there's anybody who sounds consistently perfect and shows versitatlity, its her! For them to say she sounds confused, starts off wrong, and that she's good as an actor and not confident as a singer..Ridiculous! Diljit's comments on what they said were on point and I'm glad he told them off! Really did look like they are "playing a game" and trying to change the audience's opinion of this girl! Major respect lost! 👎🏼

Coming to Rohan, excellent song choice! He tried harder this time. I still want to see him do something completely different however. I have a feeling whoever wins this Ticket to Finale will come to 3rd but not win the show and I think that's why Rohan got 84 percent today despite the fact that this was probably his top performance so far! He was decent today.

Zaid had excellent song choice and did well. Love how he immerses himself in music. He didn't hit the "ni SA SA SA SA SA SA" high notes probably cause he wanted the harkatain at the end. I think he could have been even better with some riyaz.

Chetan was fine sur-wise but he is quite limited in the songs he can do justice to and his vocal texture, at least at this point is a bit jarring and doesn't work for a song like this. He needs to go first!

Vishnumaya was great but my expectations from her are sky high! She always challenges herself and I Iove that! Loved the classical end she gave to the song - that was my favourite part. Not my favourite performance - she was sick and I'm proud that she still performed so well and beat Akhtar bros after the things they said about her.

I can't believe the show is ending so soon! Next week is the finale!

709927 thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#4
Also it seems all the backlash she received has made Monali sweeten up and change her ways, at least for the screen! Acha hai... 😛
shaztea thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#5
akthar brothers: i didnt like their performance, i feel like they need to try different genres, its like the same every week.

vishnumaya : she was too good, looking pretty too... me too expect more from her...

zaid: he was a bit disturbed, I guess it was after what Vishnumaya spoke about him, they should stop doing this, last week aafrren group also were demotivated by showing a vdo clip. the mood affects the performance a lot... but he managed to cope up... i just love him...

chetan: ok ok performance

rohanpreet: it was nice, I enjoyed it... he desrved more votes though, he has a sweet voice, would love to hear him singing "teri deewani- kailash kher"

hemant: that was mindblowing, felt like the performance was too short, he is trying different genres and he is proving himself, superb...
behindyou thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 7 years ago
#6
I did not like how they put contestants against each other verbally and there was simply no need of it ... esply before performances 😕 others were still fyn but vishnumaya and akhtar bros took it too seriously! 🥱 its just a singing show not bigg boss!! and now there is less drama so m happy!
1) Hemant : he was the best amongst lot and deserved to win ticket to finale... i thouroughly enjoyed the singing , it used to be my fav song when i was kid , i feel he was screaming a bit on the line "hamari adhoori kahani' so it might not be his best atleast he tried other genre unlike others ...now i want him to sing a soft romantic number .. he will be a deserving winner if he wins based on singing,i dont like him for some reasons thats another thing though! he is confident that he will win.

2) Zaid : he faltered a bit in starting , may be because of vishnumaya but he catched up in between and absolutely loved him during sargam... apart from singing i love his cute harkate too, 😳 how he was lying on golden chair and his one word answers 😆 suddenly judges does not seem to like him much like before 😲 anyone else feels the same? but i loved his performance, song selection was good.. i dont think he was calculative and cunning as shankar said, he jst bonded with rohan more so took his name 😛

3) Rohanpreet - what a soulful singing! its better he got less percentage today atleast he will try to change the genre else he was in his comfort zone, i also feel makers are reading our forum and making decisions accordingly 😊 i feel he faltered a bit in middle on that something raatein hai line .. lets see if he changes genre next week or not! he might get one ticket to finale today ..

4) Vishnumaya : i liked her and i could not connect with her yesterday 😕 i could not understand sargam or few words in line .. she was eating words may be bcz of pressure.. it was certainly not her best ! she did same mistakes with bhare more naina last week... lets see if she will improve next week or not, i have a feeling she might win else runner up to sure hai.

5) Akhtar bros : kya ho gaya unhe?? 😲 i still remember i used to be awake till 11 just to watch their performances and now i care less about them , i dont wait for them like before... they were just screaming yesterday! m so disappointed as fan and even comment on vishnumaya was too harsh! they might go or bounce back i will decide after today performance!!

6) Chetan : better than before but competition is intense so he need to go soon 😊 he should do more riyaaz!
jenny156 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 7 years ago
#7
Hemant - He won me over this time!! The best performance of the episode, brilliant 👏. I absolutely loved his performance and maybe he sang the bengali version in the end which got to me 😆. I got crazy after that 😆. I know my heart is with Zaid, but Hemant deserved to be the first contender for the ticket to finale.

Zaid - He took my heart away with his cuteness 😆. The way he was lying on the golden sofa 😆, his face when Hemant's bar was rising, and all his replies were so cute!! Also to note he was equally sad when Rohan did not score more than him and was giving flying kiss to Hemant when his did 😳. Coming to his performance, I love the song and he sang so beautifully ❤️. Even Vishnu stood up during his song towards the end.

Vishnumaya - Very difficult song to sing, she is choosing these difficult songs and doing justice to them but seems like the audience does not like voting for her enough 🤔. I loved her performance, just like Diljit said she sounds like a CD playing.. But I feel she should take it a little easy, I know now she cannot but more like enjoy the performance rather than focusing on choosing difficult songs.. It will reflect in her performance more!!

Rohan - There was so much soul in his performance ❤️. I was amazed at the classical touch he added in the end. I liked the second part of his song more than the first part. That being said his bond with Zaid is adorable ❤️, Zaid also chose him because he bonds with him more, not because he is clever or something like what Shankar said lol..

Akhtar bros - Forgettable performance, I liked Shehnaz's part more than Sahil's.. I guess they needed this low score coz looked like they were getting overconfident.

Chetan - Well hats off to this boy for choosing a different style but he murdered the song for me!! I love this song a lot and I had to reduce the volume.. Hope he leaves this week, he is clearly the weakest right now!!

Btw why were the scores so low this time?? No one got 90+ otherwise earlier in mediocre performances they would get around 90 🤔. Or has the viewership reduced? 😕
Edited by jenny156 - 7 years ago
lissa007 thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#8
Yesterdays episode way okay. I expected more from the performances to be honest. Most of them (except Hemant and Vishnus) were quite average in my opinion.
But I am happy there was no drama or anything. And I feel they have forgotten their beloved Sindhu Tai 😛


I also didn't like the pitting the contestants eachother at all. The atmosphere was a little negative because of that. 😕

To the performances in order of my preference:

Hemant- Mindblowing performance. 😲😲 I would have never ever thought he would even attempt such kind of song and then he does and nails it!!!! He is the only one in the show who is constantly trying out different genres and putting everything to risk. Shankar ji is right he is a true artist!! 👏👏👏 He deserved to be the contender of Ticket to Finale round but I have a feeling whoever is going to get the Ticket is not going to win the show so I don't want him to get it to be honest. 😛

Vishnumaya- Loved loved loved her performance SO much. Not only was her sur on point but the song needed a little nathkathness and she was really good at doing this. 👏 I don't know why her score was lower than Zaids 😕 She was clearly better than him. But I really want her to sing something more contemporory, she could have sung Deevani Mastani from the same film, because I know she will be amazing. The classical is getting a little repetitive.

Zaid- I absolutely love the song he sang but this time I felt something was missing. Maybe he was nervous or something. Also he did some mistake which even I noticed. And also shouted a little. And I got so angry when Shanakar ji refused to talk about them. 😔 How will this kid improve if they will not talk about his mistakes. What's the point of singing infront of these big judges if they are only blindly going to praise everyone?

Rohanpreet- Same goes to him. Really love this song but I felt something was missing. He usually brings a certain feel to his performances but this time I couldn't feel anything. Maybe he was nervous as well. I won't even go into the same kind of songs thing with him aynmore haha 😆

Chetan- I have a feeling whoever chooses his song doesn't like him. I'm glad he attempted a different genre 👏 but they could have chosen a more popular and better song I feel. The thing with Chetan is that he has already a very deep and loud voice, so his voice will suit only limited songs (if he doesn't modulate his voice), which is not his foult. But it was a good attempt ⭐️

Also Chetan deserves all the love and praise for his response to Akthar Bros. 👏 They were a little harsh to him (and Vishnu) I feel. But his answer was just fantastic and made me so happy. And then he even went to touch their feets. 😊This just shows what a pure and innocent soul he is. ❤️ I just love this adorable kid. And I am happy there was no elimination. 😊

Akthar Bros- Their performance was forgetful but not their attitude 😒 The things they said to Chetan and Vishnu were quite mean. Especially to Vishnu when they said how they felt she is an actress or something. I didn't even understand what they meant. But both of these lovely kids took it very sportingly ⭐️

All in all it was an okayish episode but I expected more from a semi finals round.

However, I am already getting little upset that there is only one week of Rising Star left. I am gonna miss this show and talking about it with you guys here 😭💔

Thanks for reading 😊
709927 thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#9
Is the finale going to have 4 people or is there a double eviction tomorrow or next week?
Edited by sinisterstorms - 7 years ago
709927 thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: lissa007

Yesterdays episode way okay. I expected more from the performances to be honest. Most of them (except Hemant and Vishnus) were quite average in my opinion.
But I am happy there was no drama or anything. And I feel they have forgotten their beloved Sindhu Tai 😛



I also didn't like the pitting the contestants eachother at all. The atmosphere was a little negative because of that. 😕

To the performances in order of my preference:

Hemant- Mindblowing performance. 😲😲 I would have never ever thought he would even attempt such kind of song and then he does and nails it!!!! He is the only one in the show who is constantly trying out different genres and putting everything to risk. Shankar ji is right he is a true artist!! 👏👏👏 He deserved to be the contender of Ticket to Finale round but I have a feeling whoever is going to get the Ticket is not going to win the show so I don't want him to get it to be honest. 😛

Vishnumaya- Loved loved loved her performance SO much. Not only was her sur on point but the song needed a little nathkathness and she was really good at doing this. 👏 I don't know why her score was lower than Zaids 😕 She was clearly better than him. But I really want her to sing something more contemporory, she could have sung Deevani Mastani from the same film, because I know she will be amazing. The classical is getting a little repetitive.

Zaid- I absolutely love the song he sang but this time I felt something was missing. Maybe he was nervous or something. Also he did some mistake which even I noticed. And also shouted a little. And I got so angry when Shanakar ji refused to talk about them. 😔 How will this kid improve if they will not talk about his mistakes. What's the point of singing infront of these big judges if they are only blindly going to praise everyone?

Rohanpreet- Same goes to him. Really love this song but I felt something was missing. He usually brings a certain feel to his performances but this time I couldn't feel anything. Maybe he was nervous as well. I won't even go into the same kind of songs thing with him aynmore haha 😆

Chetan- I have a feeling whoever chooses his song doesn't like him. I'm glad he attempted a different genre 👏 but they could have chosen a more popular and better song I feel. The thing with Chetan is that he has already a very deep and loud voice, so his voice will suit only limited songs (if he doesn't modulate his voice), which is not his foult. But it was a good attempt ⭐️

Also Chetan deserves all the love and praise for his response to Akthar Bros. 👏 They were a little harsh to him (and Vishnu) I feel. But his answer was just fantastic and made me so happy. And then he even went to touch their feets. 😊This just shows what a pure and innocent soul he is. ❤️ I just love this adorable kid. And I am happy there was no elimination. 😊

Akthar Bros- Their performance was forgetful but not their attitude 😒 The things they said to Chetan and Vishnu were quite mean. Especially to Vishnu when they said how they felt she is an actress or something. I didn't even understand what they meant. But both of these lovely kids took it very sportingly ⭐️

All in all it was an okayish episode but I expected more from a semi finals round.

However, I am already getting little upset that there is only one week of Rising Star left. I am gonna miss this show and talking about it with you guys here 😭💔

Thanks for reading 😊


I know..I'm gonna miss this too! 💔😔

Agree with what you said about Akhtar bros! They literally said she is more confident and well-suited to act than sing, which is just about the worst thing to say to a 12 year-old semi-finalist of a music show. They also said she seems confused and is off-pitch. And even Vishnu took it very sportingly and touched their feet.

Regarding Vishnu's performances, she does a bit of both cause she is competent with classical and modern Indian music. She's doing Sun Raha Hai Na Tu and Sathyam Shivam Sundaram today...Super excited to hear Sun Raha Hai. 😳

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".