Monu killed sk accidentally, kabir witnessed, my guess - Page 2

Originally posted by: violette

Exactly.

Bt thn this action of kabir raises lot of questions and questions his integrity.

The email read,"...aur Kabir wahan tha!" Simply translated it means,"...and he was there!" It's quite apparent that whoever hacked Mr Kash's email ID (looks like Maanav) has no clue about what happened! 1) Was someone holding a gun to Kabir's head at that time?
2) Did he reach the place after Mr Kash was in a bad state? Already stabbed or shot etc
3) Was he called to the same place to witness what's going on and then threatened?
4) Did Mr Kash call him to a secret place which was also known to the murderers?
etc. etc etc
5) Did Kabir visit alone or was anyone with him?
6) Who pushed him off the cliff or was that a story made up by Kabir?

There are so many questions about what actually happened that night? Only Kabir knows. For the others, it could only be what he has told them! 😊 Complete hearsay!

Kabir has to find out quickly who has hacked the email ID -IP address...take Khurana's help. Ananya feels cheated. Who wouldn't? 😃 If she can ignore listening to Kabir's past, if she can forgive infidelity, then why so much hullabaloo around this revelation!! Again Kabir has lied! He is not the murderer. What's the big deal?? 😃


-Rekha

Originally posted by: Danseuse

The email read,"...aur Kabir wahan tha!" Simply translated it means,"...and he was there!" It's quite apparent that whoever hacked Mr Kash's email ID (looks like Maanav) has no clue about what happened! 1) Was someone holding a gun to Kabir's head at that time?
2) Did he reach the place after Mr Kash was in a bad state? Already stabbed or shot etc
3) Was he called to the same place to witness what's going on and then threatened?
4) Did Mr Kash call him to a secret place which was also known to the murderers?
etc. etc etc
5) Did Kabir visit alone or was anyone with him?
6) Who pushed him off the cliff or was that a story made up by Kabir?

There are so many questions about what actually happened that night? Only Kabir knows. For the others, it could only be what he has told them! 😊 Complete hearsay!

Kabir has to find out quickly who has hacked the email ID -IP address...take Khurana's help. Ananya feels cheated. Who wouldn't? 😃 If she can ignore listening to Kabir's past, if she can forgive infidelity, then why so much hullabaloo around this revelation!! Again Kabir has lied! He is not the murderer. What's the big deal?? 😃


-Rekha

Originally posted by: pomegranate

shreya is presenting the half truth, as usual.

if there was anything that would shake up kabir and ananya's relationship, then it would be sudhir kashyap. SK is ananya's achilles heel.

Kabir was there during the murder of her father, how many daughters can look past that? pain is always hard to bear when you are on the receving end of it, this why it is a big deal to Ananya.

Kabir overstepped the boundaries of marriage but ananya looked past that because despite everything, he loved her with everything he had and ananya knew this because she felt it. if their mutual love is what made her forgive his infidelity in a past marriage, then it is a daughter's love for her father that made her react like this.

There is a difference here. Kabir never lied about his past life in terms of married life, Ananya refused to listen to the truth. And infidelity was not directed towards her, Kabir did not betray her. This time it's completely different. I don't think the ONS or break up of his marriage was his fault completely, he had strong reasons that did not concern Ananya so there was nothing to forgive. She just had to make the choice of whether she wanted to be with him or not, not to forgive him or not. This time the injury has been done to her trust and really the first time Kabir has actually lied to her. This is a really haphazard plot and shows Kabir in a bad light (maybe his reasons will change my view), but I've had no issues with his commitment and integrity to the relation till now. Peoples marriages break for a variety of reasons, it's not like they do not deserve a second chance.

Originally posted by: pomegranate

shreya is presenting the half truth, as usual.[/DIV]

if there was anything that would shake up kabir and ananya's relationship, then it would be sudhir kashyap. SK is ananya's achilles heel.

Kabir was there during the murder of her father, how many daughters can look past that? pain is always hard to bear when you are on the receving end of it, this why it is a big deal to Ananya.

Kabir overstepped the boundaries of marriage but ananya looked past that because despite everything, he loved her with everything he had and ananya knew this because she felt it. if their mutual love is what made her forgive his infidelity in a past marriage, then it is a daughter's love for her father that made her react like this.

I agree. If I was Ananya, my reaction would be the same. I would feel let down by the person who I loved and trusted wholeheartedly... 😃 When I said 'big deal' I meant the Creatives because there is more than meets the eye.
1) What if the 'big deal' is that Mr Kash did commit suicide after confessing all to Kabir? He was guilty as charged?
2) What if the 'big deal' is that Mr Kash survived? Nobody knows about it, even Kabir.
3) What if the 'big deal' is that after Ananya reopens the case, Mr Kash comes out of hiding to reveal all and comes on KKN to give the bestest best 'breaking news' to Kabir? 👏 That would be classy. A tight slap to Shreya and Maanav...

For me, as a viewer, Anurag and Tarini hav become passe, (even if the Creatives weave a story now, am not so excited to hear it), but am keen to know about Ananya's father 'cause that's how the lead protagonists are connected...😃 While the daughter was inspired to be a journalist because of her Dad's disappearance, Kabir seems to be the only person who may hav seen him last.

Lets wait and watch...


-Rekha

Sorry but this theory is just too lame