Discuss: Copyin songs in videomix or not - Page 5

see everyonoe has their opinion.....ashita has faced it therefore she has chnged sides today.....the other feel in a different way and they have their respective reasons for it....theres abs no questionin to their reason cuz its not possible that everyone is like minded.....


the point of wht happened this time is just this:

1.tumse hi mix existed whch ws extrmlyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy special to all ay fans......n most ay fans were hurt cuz d song was used

2. as soon as dis ws realsd d 2nd vmix was pulled off utube

3. guys dis genuinly means d persn got u wnted 2 sy naa...if it were a COPY y wud she do tht! sach mein i really think it ws a mistke....i persnlly know raksha wasnt dre whn dis vmix ws on d 1st pgs on rf.....pls try n believ me if u guys think im nt liein.....


thats it from my side.....i agree n disagree on various points posted above n i have explained myself in all my posts of dis topic.....

Originally posted by: anvesha rulz

I am sorry to say smriti but I dont agree with the first mover concept presented by u......u being a spectator only probably realise the feelings of one side of the story....which is the song being "copied ".....u can probably feel the hurt that one faces when ones song is used for another mix......but trust me smriti the hurt is equally bad when u know that u have to scrap a particular mix that ur making half way thru.......just bcoz someone was quicker than u in posting that mix of urs

As for sending the mix via pm.......yes mabbe if u know that a song has been long used by someone then u can use the pm option but if u r making a mix simultaneously as the other person then y shouldnt she upload it.....n post it in the forum.......why this injustice towards her.......agreed that the ppl who matter see it any which ways thru pm but we cant deny the fact that if a mix is posted in a seperate topic it gets a lot of viewership.....coz there r many ppl esp the UK ones who may not visit AYLS or Kashti to see if there is any vmix but will surely check it out if its posted in a new topic n some of them actually do post a comment on YT after seeing ur mix

n dont all of us make vmixes or siggies or write fan fics to get appreciation......sorry to say but if this entire issue is gonna be resolved the way smriti has suggested then I will not comply by it.....coz like I said earlier I will never make a mix on a song that already exists....but if a mix comes up while I am already making a vmix on that particular song then I will post it in the forum.......the no. of replies that the mix gets be damned

ashita i really wanna thank you for speaking this is am totally agreeing with every word you said about making two mixes at same time😃

we have to allow both the mixes as whoever was not first just because he took time for making mix would always have to scrap mixes and all his time effort will go to vain and if this continue he wouldnt enjoy only making mixes 😭

and what you told about pming thing is also true we cant get that much viewership through pm😉

and whatever you said in your second post after this that here the matter is copying of song not tr or ay😳 i was so happy seeing this

i felt so proud this is remix and we all are so happy to be as a remix forum😳😃👏

and i also want to say that i dont have any problem if anyone uses my song 😃though i have made only 1 mix only till now 😆

i dnt understand from where does the question of scrapping arises noone really has asked anyone to scrap their mixes off all am pitching in is exactly the same thing what ashita said that if you know a particular song has an ay/tr videomix whic actually is a quite famous mix and in all probabilities must have raised huge emotions and have been close to people's hearts then you can atleast pay respet to those feelings and avoid posting your mix in here cant you?

theres no question of copying or whatever its just a matter of being a bit considerate everyone feels bad and horrible at some point of time sometimes one side has to compromise sometimes the other but if none of us want to compromise then lets wage a war on th forum again where two mixes on same song wld compete to grab the same limelight the whole point of makeing a mix would be defeated then and people wld resort to just promoting heir own mixes for the heck of it because try and deny as much as you might there does sets in a level of competition which is highly detterring why do u want to rui it for the videomix makers yaar and also for the viewers atleast for me some mixes mean more than life to me and as i said i would hate to read the same words being used in some other context but obviously am ready to compromise on those times where a tr mix is posted before an ay mix on a song which i feel is meant for ay then obviously even i wld restrict myself to yt or pms but in no which way this wld effect the intensity of my appreciation

vansh realy dont think theres a need to remind us to respect each other had that respect not been there then this topic wld hav been fuelled long back so chill noone is fighting noone is debaeing and i per say am not at all blameing anyone and never raksha coz she deserves every single bit of appreciation for what she did for us

and this is to rach rach you know it pretty damm well tha our intentions weren't to ruin your birthday giftty you know me well enough and you also knw what tumse hi meant to me and to all of us so dnt you ever think for a single second that your birthday was spoiled or watever you know damm well that i wld hav never wished that

Originally posted by: smritisashi

i dnt understand from where does the question of scrapping arises noone really has asked anyone to scrap their mixes off all am pitching in is exactly the same thing what ashita said that if you know a particular song has an ay/tr videomix whic actually is a quite famous mix and in all probabilities must have raised huge emotions and have been close to people's hearts then you can atleast pay respet to those feelings and avoid posting your mix in here cant you?

theres no question of copying or whatever its just a matter of being a bit considerate everyone feels bad and horrible at some point of time sometimes one side has to compromise sometimes the other but if none of us want to compromise then lets wage a war on th forum again where two mixes on same song wld compete to grab the same limelight the whole point of makeing a mix would be defeated then and people wld resort to just promoting heir own mixes for the heck of it because try and deny as much as you might there does sets in a level of competition which is highly detterring why do u want to rui it for the videomix makers yaar and also for the viewers atleast for me some mixes mean more than life to me and as i said i would hate to read the same words being used in some other context but obviously am ready to compromise on those times where a tr mix is posted before an ay mix on a song which i feel is meant for ay then obviously even i wld restrict myself to yt or pms but in no which way this wld effect the intensity of my appreciation

bingooo smriti u snatched alll ma words....srslyyyyyyy each and every word said by u is copied by me rite now.....and if sum1 reli wnat viewwership dne kepp pming every single eprosn u wud surley gt same viewership[...plu by putting on YT u r alredy gettingd viewershuip but u wud atleats nt hurt otehrs feelingsss ....dats wat remix has taught and i geuss on many paths v r itself forgetting wat remxi taught and y v r here ...it was becoz remix's such valuess and love for remxi and our respective pairs v r here and wta v learnt form dem v r foegtting den....and liek smriti said if dis continues srsly lets pic a new war and dis time i m sure it wud nt end ......beczo every single weekk new mixe son same song wud keep arising ...and ever single weekk a new fite created and one day wud cum wne dis forum wud only b saturated wth fites fites fites and dta 2 for all stupid reaosn....y d dam ppl cnat understand and seocnd mix make ron same song compromise....it was firts mix maker's luck ......dat dat eprson was abele 2 postt....

adn secodnly here if u consider time...i thnk me making d mixes since last 1 and half year cna tell u time actuallly doenst ateter much ...d main thng vic matters oev rhere is work....d way u work and how much work u haf dun ...liek if a perosn starst making a mix 3 weeks b4 an done just 2 days b4 but bth do same amount of work firts one does in partly and secodn oen does at a streched ......so time factor doesnt cum much as equal tiem geos over here........

guysss y dun u all ready 2 compromsie ....i rsly believ wateva smriti told tilll now is trueee.......saldyyy but ppl aint reayd 2 compromise alsooo......😭😭

luv ash

ok hmm i realy dnt noe where to start n wt to say..gosh i dnt come fr a day n two n sum mess happens.. i dont even wnt to think wtll happen if i dont come fr a month or so..
bt i really want to say kudos to raksha fr her guts n understanding...its hard to find ppl like u 😊 its also goood dat u guys r sticking to peaceful discussions..i seriusly have no experience in dis arena bt dis issue is exactly like issue wid sigs being copied(idea style brushes textures etc..)
n i agree wid d option..we will soon be coming wid a videomix arcade where u guys n post all ur mixes to date..
ofcouse reserving song is foolishness i may like 50 songs n my choice my match wud sum1 else wud be silly...
bt if u noe frm erlier a mix on dis song is already dere ull nt make it coz 1 wtll be d fun if dere is already one..secondly d idea of comparing may arise.wich is stupid bt nething stupid can happen newhere..n if u relly wnt to make den u shud just ask d maker or sumthing...
i noe many of u may nt agree wid me bt m relly screwed right now n nt in my senses so forgive me 😆

well ash its good that you agree with me and u feel that all of us have to compromise somewhere or the other so that means even you yourself would have to compromise at some point or the other


ashita's problem of takeing three weeks in completing a mix is dammm genuine as she said earlier shes a working lady and its dammm dammt ough to find time to even breathe and think about your own self but kudos to her that she always has time for ay and ay mixes then she has a major mb problem wherein she only has a limited number of mbs available to her every month and she has to do all her inlyne work within those limited mbs only so obviously she has to wait for the right time and the right number of mbs available to actully upload her mix and above all she puts huge amount of thought into every single second of her mixes so obviously she takes time and the end result of all these efforts is always adorabely awesmee and just about perfect...

yiu in the other hand actually do make mixes on a super fast rate your iutcome of videomix production might be one mix per day 😆 and you precisely smack all all new songs and come up with a mix at the very nuext day of the song;s release its grate to se your enthusiasm but by doing this you are actually not giving other members a chance to make mixes on the new songs which i belive is totaly unfair and as ashita said if we follow my theory of first maker theny ou would make sure that you yourself is the first maker ALWAYS 😕 dnt u think thats a bit unfair on the others? so i feel you too would have to compromise on this ground and restrain yourself fro makeing mixes on each and every single new song at a super fast express rate only then this first maker thingmakes sense coz not all people have the time at thir disposal to make a mix everyday as you do 😆 😆 o myself know millions of times wen ashita per say had to restrain herself from posting her mixes because you invariabley came up with mixes on those songs at a superfonic speed

think about it ash this does sets frustration with the videomix maker so i realy do feel you should atleast give others a chance to explore new songs and come up with their mixes insted of you grabbing all of them at the very first go 😳 😳

and yaa if ou try and compromise a bit on this front then am sure everyone else would do the same coz they would atleast get a chance to explore new songs else this first maker thing makes no sense since you would be the first one always which obviously is not the intention of this discussion 😆 😳

am glad our views matched today hope you understand this small little genuine problem too 😃

Originally posted by: smritisashi

well ash its good that you agree with me and u feel that all of us have to compromise somewhere or the other so that means even you yourself would have to compromise at some point or the other


ashita's problem of takeing three weeks in completing a mix is dammm genuine as she said earlier shes a working lady and its dammm dammt ough to find time to even breathe and think about your own self but kudos to her that she always has time for ay and ay mixes then she has a major mb problem wherein she only has a limited number of mbs available to her every month and she has to do all her inlyne work within those limited mbs only so obviously she has to wait for the right time and the right number of mbs available to actully upload her mix and above all she puts huge amount of thought into every single second of her mixes so obviously she takes time and the end result of all these efforts is always adorabely awesmee and just about perfect...

yiu in the other hand actually do make mixes on a super fast rate your iutcome of videomix production might be one mix per day 😆 and you precisely smack all all new songs and come up with a mix at the very nuext day of the song;s release its grate to se your enthusiasm but by doing this you are actually not giving other members a chance to make mixes on the new songs which i belive is totaly unfair and as ashita said if we follow my theory of first maker theny ou would make sure that you yourself is the first maker ALWAYS 😕 dnt u think thats a bit unfair on the others? so i feel you too would have to compromise on this ground and restrain yourself fro makeing mixes on each and every single new song at a super fast express rate only then this first maker thingmakes sense coz not all people have the time at thir disposal to make a mix everyday as you do 😆 😆 o myself know millions of times wen ashita per say had to restrain herself from posting her mixes because you invariabley came up with mixes on those songs at a superfonic speed

think about it ash this does sets frustration with the videomix maker so i realy do feel you should atleast give others a chance to explore new songs and come up with their mixes insted of you grabbing all of them at the very first go 😳 😳

and yaa if ou try and compromise a bit on this front then am sure everyone else would do the same coz they would atleast get a chance to explore new songs else this first maker thing makes no sense since you would be the first one always which obviously is not the intention of this discussion 😆 😳

am glad our views matched today hope you understand this small little genuine problem too 😃

smriti haf alerdyyy pmed ashitaa

and i thnk nt only me but even otehrs shud compromise becoz i do remmerb me making a mix once dat time i scrapeped ma mxi in ebwteen becoz it was ur giftyyy ....just becoz fo ur gifty but aage se i can xcpet dat i shud b only one compromisng alwayssss haf dun mny times b4 .....neways as far as ashita is concerned dat wud b solvedd .....u dun wryyy

secondlyy i just wanna tell u smriti u thnk i cum wth super fast rate nah dats nt actuallly true even i take days 2 make.. its just i start making 2 or 3 mixess simultaneously n earlyyy mayb same tiem wen ashita startsss ......and wen so ever i gt bord wth stdueiss chahe raat ho ya day i keep making bit by bit....and dats y u thnk i m going on super fast rate ...and as far as unfair path it ....i dun completly agree wth u on dat point ....mayb i had gt dat song earlier den otehrss so it doent count mistake on ma path...plejej dun take me rong on dis path.....ya i agree wth alll probs ashita is hafin and even i m aware abt it....neways i haf stopped makingmixes recetly just wud post one mroe sun dat wud end ma making mxiess..(..just one more 2 shoot up vic is indeed d most speical onee...)......but its always ma luck dat even though i start making mxies long bac i manage 2 complete .....but i dun deny abt probs of otehrs...i hope u cna udnerstand .....afetr all creativity goes over here .......and i thnk on dat path i m nt being unfair......and i dun haf ne intentions 2 hurt ne 1.......but der was reason recently dat i kept maself bsy wth mxiesss....(newaysss dun wnana discuss dat much)and smriti ya as i was telling during swariya release same thng happened wth me w8 i m nt pointing out 2 ne1...and i dun deny dta also at sawariya sonsg r menat for only ay ...but i idneed was making for dem .....but i did compromsie dat tiem for sake of nitzy and speiclllly it was ur giftyyy ....neways dats an very odl topic i supposeee and i m sure no1 wud liek 2 discussss much but stilll as u removed dis kidn of topic so i thot of mentioning dis .....

thirdly i haf been pointed out mny timesssss ....but u also cant say i m being unfair or dat it is ma mistake .....if i wnated 2 b unfair every single day i wud produec new mix but nah i dun make at super fast rates vic u all actually thnk its just i start 2 or 3 getherrr ...den sumtims i do one oetrh time i do oethr and even due 2 studies i do take timeeee ........but i guess u ppl again tuk me in rong context adn r nt understanding...

mayb i m nt gr8 mix maker like nitzy and ahsita and mayb ma mixes nt even half goodd liek dem ....but ppl close 2 me knowss dat i liek making mixess and dats d one reason i make....and mayb ma mixes wud b worst of alll ...still i dun mind ...becozzz here i m just trying 2 satify maslef dat yes i haf made mixx.....and nt 2 gain ne publicity and allll.....(..beczo sum do thnk so......😭😭😭)and i haf no intentions 2 show dat i m mroe creatiev den ne1....yet still ma creativity goes for toss.....chahe jaisi bhi ho i m only trying and and haf no intentions 2 show off by making mixes at super fast rate..

but still if u all thnk i m being unafirrr den i knwo i cnat chnage ur minds but its nt even ma mistake and u all cnat term me unafuir even i take laods of tiem 2 make. one single mix......and even i take mroe dne a week 2 make one single mix....

and mny times every1 of u always take me on rong path ....i rlei dun know y but it did happens neways i haf already told ahsita if she wanna post she cna post on RF ....and i told her dun take dis as permision and allll i m nt all seieng in dat way its just she is udnerstanding dat way but wat 2 term dis i rlei dun know.....

and even its nt ma fault dat ashita cud nt post i udnerrstand her probelm but bezo of dat i cannot restrict maslef here luck counts and even liek she lieks making mxies so do i ......u cnat term me as being unfair....

and u point out me making mixes of one per day vci u take it on funny part ...vic is nt at true ....u r only a viewer ....so u wont unerstandd dat much dat how much tiem it goes in making a mixx.....if u cud haf understood dis and udnerstoodd me for once by chnace also u wudnt haf made fun of dis thng and waise bhi hardly ne 1 has able 2 udnerstand me (xcept one or two)

and i hope oen day u all wud udnerstand me ........neways gdu lcuk 2 every1 ...as next weekk d mix cuming form ma side is d last mix i m making ....dats d end of ma making mixes... and smriti liek u thnk i m being unfair ....(vic i dun term it as being unfair...its just ma passion of making mixes..).......and i thnk mny wud b happy...by dis thng ....dat me wud stop making mxies.....

and guys guys dun plejej take me in ne rong context dis days i m maself in veyr tight sitautions due 2 ma 12th xamsss cuming up aheaddd plus ma medical xams preps and tension of its admissions and alll.....if sum1 feels bad for wateva i said i m sry from first only but i rlei dun mean 2 hurt ne1 in d forum ...and i m sry fro all problems caused by me ....sry once again ...and njoy

tc guyss

luv ash

hey bhaggu ash why do u have the tendancy to always invariabely take me wronggg 😕 😕

have i ever said somewhere that you should scrap your mix or stop makeing them??? if u remember you were on a spree of not positng nay of your mixes or not makeing them only then i guess i was the one who actually told you not to do this and to make mixes only because you like them to make...so why in the world wld i ask u to quit makeing them yaar

how so ever your mix might be its oyur creativity your pasison and you should stick to it no matter wat happens all am saying is just dont grab all the new releases because others do get frustrated if that happens

you ar eobviously constantly pointing out towards nappy's jab se tere nanina mix for meee well she made it days before my birthdya as a birthday gift for me and posted it at rf stright away so dnt think theres a quesiton of compromise there she was the firts one ot post hence she got the cake and i got the bestest birthdya giftt in the world but i dnt know why u feleing so grazed about it perhaps becoz for once someone else got to make a vidoemix on a new song

see ash am not makeing fun of anything why the hell should i make fun its actually a talent to make so many mixes so fast it shows oyur speed and efficiancy and i hav no right to make fun of it coz i myself dont even know a b c of mix makeing all am saying is that do let others make some mixes on new releases too thats it

and plz my intention was never to stop you frm makeing mixes you are good you love it you should make them just that go easy with the new releases thats it atleast you can wait for two thre weeks after a new song releases before makeing a mix on it and am not syaing you do this always just on off wne u feel that form the past few times only u hav been makeing mixes on new songs u knw wat i mean

and plz dnt blame me for what u feel for rf or watever i hav not done naything to make u feel that ways and i seriously wld not take the blame at all i wld say its all in your mind the more u think the more it crops up

and anyways i guess the issue itself is quite solved my intention never ever was to hurt anyone and i personaly am butting out of this and wont say more till the time i feel my feelings have been asauged again

thanx for haveing a peaceful discussion and not clawing on each others head 😆 me sowie to all those who felt offended by my words u all know that this was only a point of view and nothing personal what so ever 😳 😳