Errm, one second. - Page 10

Created

Last reply

Replies

127

Views

11k

Users

35

Likes

586

Frequent Posters

antiquegold thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#91
Classy and sassy dukh!! Neat!
So Mythili gets deposited at the feet of the Toothy Thakur!
Because lifting lugayiaan is mardwala kaam, but chcecking to see if its the right lugayi is lugayioon ka kaam!

Mind it, Sumair kunwarsa!
Sunehri... What is with the pompoms?
showviewer thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#92

Originally posted by: sajni786

How nicely explained.
Writing Team of RR have done such tremendous work that despite the story being about Paro and HER journey after she bumps into Rudra...its seems as though that Rudra is much of an equivalent character to Paro and ofcourse Mr. Sharma is doing the added glaze to ensure some fans misunderstand the story to be about Rudra😆
To be honest...u and I and many here at IF can better understand this story at writing level (u more ofcourse) coz we break down the epis like there is no tomorrow and analysis each move of characters...each scene...bits by bits...going all the way into the angles at which Rudra's eye balls moved😆, cheek bones dropped and the quantity of tear drop in eyes (in micro milli-litres) as he looked at standing Paro at the balcony😆...BUT
People like my hubby who just watch to accompany me or for mere entertainment...for them ...when they look at Rudra searching the hallways of the haveli and missing Paro...there is just 1 reaction... "Oh Dang Paro...U in Danger now"😆


Just a clarification my question was not based on any misunderstanding or Sanaya's lack of acting abilities. 😊 This thread is discussing the screenplay and script and hence my question as to why the creatives are emphasizing Rudra's pathos so much. MKM was kind enough to explain her point of view. The beauty of any creative work is that there is never ONE right way of understanding it, it could be a book, a film or a TV show and that is the fun of discussing it.

I think Ashish AND Sanaya are matched in their acting abilities and each has done justice to what the creatives have given them. This love story would not be enthralling if BOTH Paro and Rudra are not performed by two stellar artists. Sanaya rocked it today.
Edited by showviewer - 11 years ago
kairavi. thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#93

Originally posted by: MoronsKiMallika


Isse zyaada flashbacks dekar screen time waste nahin kar sakte. In case, you have more ideas on showing Paro's feelings as though none are being shown already, feel free to tweet NF , GH, ST.


And if you think showing one's feelings means long drawn out monologues and sad Bollywood songs in the background and aansu bahoing with baal flying, welcome to RR. Yahaan dukh bhi classy and sassy hotaa hai.



Thank you.😉

What a condescending attitude!!! Why should anyone have to tweet NF, GH or ST, this is the Rangrasiya forum and if people who watch the show have an issue with it then they have every right to express that here.
If Paro has no one she can speak to then I want a monologue of whatever length to show what she's thinking. I want flashbacks of happier times because I haven't seen Paro 'glow' since she's been in the haveli be it with Maithali or Sunheri.
I can't say I've read any post asking for a bollywood song but then I haven't read every post but perhaps you have. Even the beautiful bhajan was turned on it's feet and made into Rudra's pain. I don't agree that the points you've raised are enough to show Paro's ongoing thought process. It's not just about showing her pain it's about showing what she's thinking beyond Rudra being a jallad and responsible for the mess her life is in. Today we heard about Rudra's pain again in the letter, what about Paro's pain of losing her parents and then losing her mother figures in Mamisa and Thakurainsa. This girl has been orphaned 3 times over. Not to mention being abandoned by every single person she knew. Why not show her remembering her own loss as a way to show her relating to Rudra's loss.
Personally I don't think there's anything classy or sassy about overlooking the dukh of the heroine of the story.
Nitya16 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#94
Very well written MKM...
Story of Paro, through her eyes...girl also has past, a sad past, but a ever positive girl, who is so strong, never get trapped into the past...always try to find positive in present...
It is so difficult to maintain smile and keep fighting with circumstances, when your life is upside down...
I love love love this character...
sajni786 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#95

Originally posted by: showviewer


Just a clarification my question was not based on any misunderstanding or Sanaya's lack of acting abilities. 😊 This thread is discussing the screenplay and script and hence my question as to why the creatives are emphasizing Rudra's pathos so much. MKM was kind enough to explain her point of view. The beauty of any creative work is that there is never ONE right way of understanding it, it could be a book, a film or a TV show and that is the fun of discussing it.

I think Ashish AND Sanaya are matched in their acting abilities and each has done justice to what the creatives have given them. This love story would not be enthralling if BOTH Paro and Rudra are not performed by two stellar artists. Sanaya rocked it today.



arre baba...looks like u misunderstood me😆

I never meant to say sanaya is less than Ashish or vice versa re...They both have tremendous acting capabilities and at par...so totally agree with u.

What I meant to say was like MKMji said...the story is from Paro's POV...which is true...it is so...but the way writers have articulated the story...they have ensured that Rudra's character is at par with Paro. Not many writers can do that coz usually when stories are told from 1 character's POV...that particular character becomes the highlight and everyone else seems like a supporting cast. But here...even though its technically Paro's story and her journey...it seems more like Paro's AND Rudra's journey. THATS marvelous writing.

Now let's go a step further...
Sometimes writers can do what NF writers are doing also...but the actor playing the part does not do justice and lags behind so still it doesnt come out quite right. So in this case...let's say it was some other random actor playing rudra (who may not be so polished like Ashish)...then Rudra could have hidden behind Paro's character. But here Ashish is not only doing justice but putting his own flavor into Rudra which is why people like my hubby, who are not part of IF or even take time to do any kinda epi analysis think its Rudra and Paro's story.

So no I am not trying to downgrade anyone actor...but just saying...that writing and actors go hand in hand...if u get an actor par the writing...then the results are shining!

Hope that clarified my stand a bit more...

Waise bhi...meri itni himmat...ki I analyze kaun kitna behtar? na muna na😆

Edited by sajni786 - 11 years ago
JazzyMohd thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#96
You rocko u said it all!! 👍🏼
Faerydae thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#97
Amazing post. .very well written. 👍🏼
showviewer thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#98

Originally posted by: sajni786



arre baba...looks like u misunderstood me😆

I never meant to say sanaya is less than Ashish or vice versa re...They both have tremendous acting capabilities and at par...so totally agree with u.

What I meant to say was like MKMji said...the story is from Paro's POV...which is true...it is so...but the way writers have articulated the story...they have ensured that Rudra's character is at par with Paro. Not many writers can do that coz usually when stories are told from 1 character's POV...that particular character becomes the highlight and everyone else seems like a supporting cast. But here...even though its technically Paro's story and her journey...it seems more like Paro's AND Rudra's journey. THATS marvelous writing.

Now let's go a step further...
Sometimes writers can do what NF writers are doing also...but the actor playing the part does not do justice and lags behind so still it doesnt come out quite right. So in this case...let's say it was some other random actor playing rudra (who may not be so polished like Ashish)...then Rudra could have hidden behind Paro's character. But here Ashish is not only doing justice but putting his own flavor into Rudra which is why people like my hubby, who are not part of IF or even take time to do any kinda epi analysis think its Rudra and Paro's story.

So no I am not trying to downgrade anyone actor...but just saying...that writing and actors go hand in hand...if u get an actor par the writing...then the results are shining!

Hope that clarified my stand a bit more...

Waise bhi...meri itni himmat...ki I analyze kaun kitna behtar? na muna na😆


😆 Chalo yeh misunderstanding clear hua. Are aap kyu nahi himmat kar sakte, saab yaha analyze hi karte hai.

That said it is interesting you guys are saying it is from Paro's point of view where as I just finished reading another convincing post which talked of how the creatives are telling the story from Rudra's lens hence bending over back to make audience empathize with him in multiple scenes.

For me a love story is only effective when the script and screenplay gives equal weightage to both protagonists without getting lopsided in narration. Only then we can follow how each changes in their journey towards love and healing. Right now I am hoping for the balance in script, as the actors are doing a fab with what the creatives are giving them.
MoronsKiMallika thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 11 years ago
#99
@All. Thank you for reading , replying and commenting. Much appreciated.❤️

And just to make it clear once more. In a story, when one protagonist is grey and the other is white, the vulnerability and weaknesses of the grey one are CONSCIOUSLY highlighted so that the audience can be convinced that just why the white character fell in love with him/her and became his/her nurturer. Rudra is being given so much empathy because this very vulnerability of Rudra is what will bind a nurturer like Paro to him. Weaker characters need more sensitive handling while the strong ones stay true to their character in every situation.

This story is Paro's POV of Rudra and how she loves and destroys herself in her heart and soul commitment to him. The show could have been named anything but it was titled 'Rangrasiya' for this reason.

You have been seeing TV for years , how can you not see something so obvious? Or is it because you don't look at both Rudra and Paro with THE SAME EYE.

Anyway. There is nothing much that can be done. Keep watching RR.

The following 114 member(s) liked the above post:

Aahaana, *Shruti*, ragtag, juvaria, sweetcheek15, bliss25, babyandme, npnp3456, sangeeta230811, oceanbreeze11, megrl, cebel, chandradg, ipkknd10, hayakhn, mehreenkhan, SherryGS, Nitya16, parud28, bluemoon255, mrsp, Sangana, rithureuben, JJKKL, ShreyaGauti, spring22, habs, rahila1980, div26, stp007, preity4lyfe, Violet125, salmanic, sree-sree, luvipkknd4ever, gangaprakash38, shantellbrown, kashev, nehapushkar, MadihaH8, pearlo, chandarani1, vishruta, Ilin, msg1, awww, aishray, kaykay, JazzyMohd, -R-R-R-, Oldestfan, asyafan6, SIFAN87, Lemonsunrise, nainasharma123, Tanisha99, .SmokeySilence., PutijaChalhov, surabi, shreya_rc, INGCIV, prettypri, lams, Siesta, bengalirani101, sparikh, kdsubs, divyadollar, libran90, shagun-rocks, Rubab4137, golpokobita, DN2012, ddFan2012, I-Heart-Sanz, sushk123, Radaz, Dazee, tvbug2011, binimoti, -Swetz-, msin, bidz, sweet_gargi, Siri22, P.Srinivas, -Paro-, Jaz1990, ..Damsel.., -Zara-, _Mohabbatgirl_, aamir18, eveline, TheMogambo, Guinea, Lizzy2012, Deedeepa1, shree10, GodhuliLogon, -Dynamite-, Nisbahx, CrazyAmie, CandYlicious_S, FairyLiquidSoap, _SenbonZakura_, sajni786, islandgirl007, pinky0902, Sofna, Suchi.R, incandescent, riyya6, SublimeSanz.., PhoenixRising,
MoronsKiMallika thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: kairavi.

What a condescending attitude!!! Why should anyone have to tweet NF, GH or ST, this is the Rangrasiya forum and if people who watch the show have an issue with it then they have every right to express that here.
If Paro has no one she can speak to then I want a monologue of whatever length to show what she's thinking. I want flashbacks of happier times because I haven't seen Paro 'glow' since she's been in the haveli be it with Maithali or Sunheri.
I can't say I've read any post asking for a bollywood song but then I haven't read every post but perhaps you have. Even the beautiful bhajan was turned on it's feet and made into Rudra's pain. I don't agree that the points you've raised are enough to show Paro's ongoing thought process. It's not just about showing her pain it's about showing what she's thinking beyond Rudra being a jallad and responsible for the mess her life is in. Today we heard about Rudra's pain again in the letter, what about Paro's pain of losing her parents and then losing her mother figures in Mamisa and Thakurainsa. This girl has been orphaned 3 times over. Not to mention being abandoned by every single person she knew. Why not show her remembering her own loss as a way to show her relating to Rudra's loss.
Personally I don't think there's anything classy or sassy about overlooking the dukh of the heroine of the story.


You are free to think what you like. And I don't deny that am grey.

Thanks for visiting my post. 😳

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".