Critics' Corner # 4 Feb 4th epi pg 142 - Page 7

Originally posted by: rooj-i

@ Aditee and Smitha:

it was edited...her voice was edited due to the sound of baarish...i mean they have to increase it during the scene and if that doesn't work, they make them dub it...and dubbing is always apparent...

Rooj,

Originally posted by: aditee

Rooj,

Yaar hum itney bhi duffer nahi hai😭

I understand......... I was just speaking contextually!

@ aditee😆

addin to dat scene...was d smile plastered ovr her face wen it happend..i..rest u ppl can guess!!!😉

Originally posted by: tvrasika

Jan 25, 2011 episode:

I didn't watch yesterday's episode, so I might be missing something... pls correct me.

The Rain scene: did Shaan try to kiss Khanak right in front of their apartment entrance? By the gate? Why? So strange... it's like Shaan has nothing on his mind except physical intimacy with Khanak! It's possible there are some (or many, as the case may be) young men like that... but Shaan wasn't characterised that way....this was a man who walked out twice on his wife even after she had decorated their room and all for an SR! Sad, seeing Shaan like this.

The only excuse I can think of is that they haven't had time to write Shaan's lines... The CVs seem to be busy shooting this concert.

Is it ok for KT to get drenched like this, so soon after recovering from typhoid? I hope his health is fully alright now.

YM's voice sounded very different in the rain scene. Is that her voice or was it dubbed?

Shaan-Khanak-Sunil scene: Is this the first time Shaan is appearing with his dad Sunil, after KT's illness? Nice one.

Khanak's green churidhar- forgettable. I will faint in shock the day they give Khanak a nice dress, esp when there is an important scene to be shot. She is always dressed like she is going to be in Pakeezah film sets- bright and garish. Someone has a very strange idea of how a heroine should appear. And that neckline😲 Poor Yashu, I feel for her! Felt like watching some BBC period drama with that sort of neckline!

Rahul-Sunny scene: HP's acting is going down day by day... what's happening? His monologue by the river banks or whatever reminded me of some bad Tamil films!

Rahul-Sunny scene in the van was LOL....very amateurish..... this should have been a damaakedar scene but looks like it was very hurriedly shot.

Rahul-Sam scene:
For an important scene like this, am very sorry to say, the acting was extremely, extremely below par. Really unconvincing! PB's dialogue delivery- no movement. Too flat. Shucks, what a gripping scene this should have been- the guy has just sent an MMS of his ex-friend's wife and another man, to his ex-friend, and the girl he loves is giving him a dressing-down! Did not come thru as a strong scene at all!

PB needed to look angry, very angry, like raving mad! Is that not how we would feel if we came to know that a man we love has stooped so low? That slap therefore wasn't so effective. I knew sooner or later Sam wud slap Rahul 'cos thats one thing our TV heroines are good at, slapping people!

What a cold RaSam! No 'hotness' here at all- be it anger, or rage or frustration or whatever.

Precap:
At least one person will be very happy with this track- KT. His desire to be a singer has been achieved, even if only in fiction. Am looking forward to the end of this track. I was never convinced about the 'youth' track but would have enjoyed it a bit more if it had been executed well. I feel like the CVs were struggling to balance many things- ShaNak story, RaSam story, Duck-Boo angle, Shaan the singer, Khanak the saviour, Rahul the menace.... and this kadambam has therefore an important ingredient missing- soul! At least, I have not been touched by the new characters or this Rock On/Off track.... am just waiting for them to bid goodbye.

Montage:
Whatever does this mean, Khanak's odhani brushing Sunny's face?😲

I feel someone should send the CVs the Iktara ShaNak clip Unko shaayad tab bhi nahi samjhega ki hum kis baat se itna dukhi hain..........

Caught the episode late.

frustration i guess😕....as dre isn't any agenda in his lyf....expect 4 dressin up lyk a loofer nd carrying dat dirty blue guitar to all d places🤢.🤢.. thos red shoes r much tolerable(nvr thot i wud say it one day) dan dis wen he wears dem off wid white shirt nd blue jeans!!!😳

Originally posted by: deepa_01

frustration i guess😕....as dre isn't any agenda in his lyf....expect 4 dressin up lyk a loofer nd carrying dat dirty blue guitar to all d places🤢.🤢.. thos red shoes r much tolerable(nvr thot i wud say it one day) dan dis wen he wears dem off wid white shirt nd blue jeans!!!😳

SO after alot of thought and uncertainty and encouragement from saaz-I've decided to post my first SS ever.