ShaNak:Have come a long way since..

First Previous

Page

Frequent Posters

Shalini

@shalini01

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 14 years ago

#11

i loved it. read it twice and im sure to read it again. i feel the same way. i love this story alot. shanak are tooooooo cute.😳

Quote

garfield1209

@garfield1209

Voyager

Posted: 14 years ago

#12

Originally posted by: dr.dsr

For me, the one thing about ShaNak's journey thus far, that immediately came to mind while reading ur post was something Sunil had told Shaan during one of their earlier heart-to-heart talks, loosely translated as "Khanak is different 'cos she's a woman who not just knows that her victory also implies Shaan's victory, but also believes that in Shaan's defeat lies her defeat, too!!"

Love u remembering that Dyotona

@Blue - That and also their love n acceptance of each other the way they are (with package deal ) is amongst the biggest strength of their relationship ..

For Shaan the package included - Surajs family and Gopi who was Khanaks friend who was dint get on well with Shaan for obvious reasons of replacing his brother..

For Khanak the package includes -Shaans family ,now Shaans friends who are doubtful whether she is right for him coz of replacing Tashu ...

Edited by priya1209 - 14 years ago

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

sana

@_sana.Magic_

Rocker

Posted: 14 years ago

#13

Yup Priya they hv cum a long way & m so happy that I hv been a part of their journey

Quote

garfield1209

@garfield1209

Voyager

Posted: 14 years ago

#14

The reason I brought up this as ..now these two are in new phase in their relationship and we see daily comfortable and natural occurances and their simple way of dealing with it ...Having seen their journey so far ..when their actions/scenes are interpreted demeaning , I cant resist pondering..

Khanak sees a tired Shaan shaan sleeping on sofa with shoes on....she gives a disapproving nod on the shoes and then instead of giving a smart comment or waking him ...she does something comforting..tries to remove the shoes...Shaan was taken abck coz he felt she had done that with the patni duty thing in mind....

Khanaks "yeh gaon ke baat nahi hai " ...this has nothing to do with her being from village or the thought process about wife's duty that villagers harp on ..I guess that line indicated tht for me...

She just says when u can work hard cant I do something to make things to give u comfort ..I guess it was something like...ek patni hone ke nate kya mein unhe itna araam nahin de sakti ...

During the time she refused to ring the bell - that time those two were free of all hinderance and in seventh heaven...During kuch khas hai..when she dint love Shaan ...for her he was good but kamchor and swarthi..Now both are secured of the love for each other and too many things happening in their life ...his fathers disapproval,friends who hide things,audtion etc...

I know many people dont open anyones shoes ...But I have also seen people do that for their loved ones when someone is completely washed out and on bed with shoes..girls ,guys both... Can that action be called demeaning ? or did such consideration make Khanak any less ?

Their light banter on how Shaan is not ready to do these things ...talks on equality both have in the relationship ..Khanaks mein maar maar ke bhaga doongi ..was sweet ..The way he lies down in her lap was so comforting..both of them looked tired and very natrual...they way he shares whats troubling him...both looked so at home with each other ...

Question : Dont we feel down or low or need for comfort ...or the urge to comfort someone ..or is Life always about being right and wrong ,weak and strong ?

PS: I wont comment on the currect track dialogue problem and the need for more spunk in the characters..as it is being discussed galore and I too agree on many counts..this was written just to put my view forward how i see this scene in their entire journey...

Edited by priya1209 - 14 years ago

Quote

May

@The_May_Rose

Stunner

+ 5

Posted: 14 years ago

#15

@Priya - Lovely post and I agree😊....It doesn't always have to be about right or wrong....I loved the comfort that ShaNak share now....Didn't we always want sweet scenes like thes too?....ShaNak have never romanced in a carefree manner and it's cute to see them as any regular couple, relaxing in their room, talking about their day....

Like you I know there are things which the CVs and prodcution need to address, but this scene di not demean Khanak...

Quote

Yasharanrocks

@Yasharanrocks

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 14 years ago

#16

priya completely agree with u.i didnt find anythng bad in dat scene.it lookd natural.n dnt think it demeand khanaks character.but im really upset 2 c sam-rahul scenes in the epi.previously the epis used 2 b full of shanak but now less of shanak......

Quote

destinylove

@destinylove

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 14 years ago

#17

Priya i also agree with u completely..

It is all a mater of how much comfort level a couple share and how they perceive themselves of being in moments of tiredness., confusion etc.,

I abolutely found nothing wrong in the sceen and Infact like @may i felt it was a very sweet scene....

I also feel it i a maater betgween every indivudual husband and wife and nothing like a genralised rule for all couples

if the couple ae compleley ego free I would welcome it rather...