Was it O.K.Shaan forgetting khanak totally

Page

Next Last

destinylove

@destinylove

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 14 years ago

hey gals

was it o.k. for u people that shaan totally forgot that he has a dear and understanding wife with whom he can confide all problems under sun.

he gave some excuse that he did not want his wife to know about dad-mom problems and she would break down since she was the one who arranged for party..I was not at all satisified with this....

even in that case of khanak breaking down hearing dad-mom divorcing

since they are going for divorce this secret can he held from khanak fo long. and she has to know sooner or later... .

Then why did he not think of khanak to confide things in her first.

o.k. his parents talked of old days and memories of the old days came to him and that is why he thought of his friend sam first.

.But still he was going on telling he did not have anybody to turn into

..It was totally upsettingme..his not wanting to share it with khanak...giving some excuses..

Why was he like this???Is it because he really does not understand the values of family relationships fully

or is it because in contrast to khanak he has been shown to be a confused

many a timeslike engagement fiasco even after putting ring he did not tell

natasha that it was a mistake..agreeing for marrying natasha., not openly

telling natasha his feelings on khanak which he did only after natasha found out

I am not really able to interpret his thoughts..kindly share ur views..if u wish.

me personally did not approve his self talks ofr telling he has none to go to..i mean ...he totally forgot he was married and has a wife...who is totally understanding..

Thank God The cvs did an awesome job by bringing in the rs.10 note to remind him he had khanak who loved him for what he was...

Edited by sshriyaa84 - 14 years ago

Quote

Frequent Posters

Yasharanrocks

@Yasharanrocks

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 14 years ago

even i didnt liked it.i can understand him sayng dat he doesnt want khanak 2 get hurted after hearng dis but shaan sayng mera koi nahin hain looked foolish 2 me.but i think wat cvs want 2 show is hez feelng low n missing his fren badly at dat moment.last time his frens r der 4 him but now dey r nt der for him.i think cvs r pavng way 4 shaans past track soon...n i think shaans qs will b answerd 2mrw wen he cs dat 10rs note.even he may feel bad 4 thnkng like dat n totally 4gtng khanak.

shaan is some1 who doesnt open up before any1 so soon but now he may share his fellngs wid khanak...

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

wooster

@wooster

Navigator

Posted: 14 years ago

Shaan to me is one of the most flawed characters in a Indian soap....he is selfish, childish'. and yet there is a little boy in him and that makes him the most endearing! Characters in Indian television.

Shaan has gone through and observed a lot.. with his parents fighting and always thinking of separating! But being modern boy he would actually feel it good'that they want to separate than be in loveless marriage'.however this makes Shaan! a liitle boy who craves for love and a family ! my heart goes out to the poor boy! This internal conflict continues and he relies on other support systems like friends, girlfriends, music'escapism ! which a lot of kids do' to get our of their dilemma! My point is Khanak is and was a friend first !!!but he says she will break down if knows the truth!!! therefore he won't tell her but'.

Here is the flaw in the script! If he loves her then he will come running to her to cry on her shoulder and be with her... but he doesn't remember her at all! Why? The there is something wrong in this love , love is not the 10 Rs note'it is the trust, sharing, the building and this boy knows nothing of that!!! May be that crux of this story is Shaan's realization of what is a relationship and how you build it with trust, support and compromise! ' because he is not seen one!!!

anyway going back!!! Shaan is at a stage where he has just begun the journey with Kanak! ( they are in the honeymoon period where couple share everything from glass of milk to abuses) again the script!!! ' an exterior object like the 10 rupees makes him think and realize how important she is to him! makes me cringe because a lover wants you instinctively and internally' but Shaan realizes his affection with an external object '. Shaan has long way to go to be a soul mate!!!

the story has just begun.....

Edited by wooster - 14 years ago

Quote

shilpa

@shonu2

Voyager

Posted: 14 years ago

I just watched the episode.

I agree that I was not happy at all about Shaan forgetting Khanak. He kept saying that he is all alone now and last time at least he had his friends. After months of being in love with Khanak, how could he forget all about her??? I really hope the 10 rupee note reminds him of how important Khanak is to him and that toegether they can get through anything.

Also, did anyone notice that when at home everyone was talking about how late it was and Shaan was not home. Yet when they showed Shaan driving around it was daytime. That was a bit confusing, blooper-maybe.

I am definitely looking forward to tomorrow's episode, just a little worried that the precap maybe Khanak's dream!!!! (hope not)

Shilpa

Quote

Daebak

@Daebak

Trailblazer

+ 7

Posted: 14 years ago

I knw...

I was just about to make this topic...Thank God I saw yours pehle...!

LOL !!

I was actually angry when he kept saying...Tab To Friends they....Ab main kaha jau...Kiske paas jau....!! I was actually like What the Heck....! Do you know sumone called Khanak lives in the house??? Go to her..

And the explanation of not burdening Khanak was just crap ok...

They are his parents....she cant really be more hurt than him....Infact she will be more hurt for him that his parents are getting separated...

She has just known them for 6 months...He has lived his life with them !!! Rubbish Excuse !!

Quote

Daebak

@Daebak

Trailblazer

+ 7

Posted: 14 years ago

Originally posted by: shonu2

I am definitely looking forward to tomorrow's episode, just a little worried that the precap maybe Khanak's dream!!!! (hope not)

That thought did cross my mind...

But we got two precaps...I dont think its a dream...If it was a dream they'd have shown only one precap...I hope its true...But Shaan itni jaldi choot kaise gaya jail se !😆

Quote

dr swati

@supportkt

Voyager

+ 2

Posted: 14 years ago

well shriya...m nt unhappy wid d happenings coz of few reasons 1-its all coz of script........as d creative team wanted to connect nwr track to d main story line thy created all dis.............otherwise wn dhulwadi epi happened ,thn also he cn hv thought of hs frnz......... 2-he ws nt wid hs senses at tht time.......n ws havinr random thoughts.............n ws unable to thnk hw to do n wid whome to share.....n its only wn he saw tht 10 rupee note....he realized khanak is thr...... 3-hs parents were talking repaetedly abt "us raat ko jo hua tha".........n so he hmself start remembering all d happenings of tht day...n sudddenly hs hs frn in hs mind 4-he wanted to keep away of hs home for sum time........as all wt happened thr........he wsnt in condition to go bak thr.....n so he ws thkng to comfort hmself outside d house 5-n at d end he returned to khanak....n ultimatrly he did wt ws right n best 4 hm............. he shld hv benefit of doubt coz of d fact tht he ws too disturbed n coz of the script written tht way......

Quote

Mahi

@pree.mahi

Inactive

Posted: 14 years ago

When I heard the dialogue that he has no one now and he is all alone...even i was feeling like W*H....I wish his dialogue/reason not to share the info with Khanak was played first before the friends wala dialogue....

I am ok with him leaving the house instead of going to khanak...as sometimes when u r very deeply hurt ...one may want to go away from the house...to be faar away from the place where the incident took place

I am okay with his reasoning for not wanting to share the info with khanak ....when u love someone u tend to hide things which u think wud hurt the person u love....if at all u cannot avoid it... u may luk out for the right time and right way to share the bad/sad news...to lessen the effect

Shaan knows that khanak will come to know abt it one day....but if she comes to know abt it the very next day after she had taken so much pain and efforts and love to put together the wedding anniversary party...it wud be more hurtful...

But his dialogue of being alone pricked me...he cud have just told that he missed his friends at such a moment.

Quote

Yasharanrocks

@Yasharanrocks

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 14 years ago

agree wid pree.mahi the dialoguewriter cud hav done a better job.his emotions everthng r perfect but his dilogues r disappointng...

Quote

dr swati

@supportkt

Voyager

+ 2

Posted: 14 years ago

#10

Originally posted by: pree.mahi
When I heard the dialogue that he has no one now and he is all alone...even i was feeling like W*H....I wish his dialogue/reason not to share the info with Khanak was played first before the friends wala dialogue....

I am ok with him leaving the house instead of going to khanak...as sometimes when u r very deeply hurt ...one may want to go away from the house...to be faar away from the place where the incident took place

I am okay with his reasoning for not wanting to share the info with khanak ....when u love someone u tend to hide things which u think wud hurt the person u love....if at all u cannot avoid it... u may luk out for the right time and right way to share the bad/sad news...to lessen the effect

Shaan knows that khanak will come to know abt it one day....but if she comes to know abt it the very next day after she had taken so much pain and efforts and love to put together the wedding anniversary party...it wud be more hurtful...

But his dialogue of being alone pricked me...he cud have just told that he missed his friends at such a moment.

i told it in my post tht more thn shaan writter's did it..........as thy wanna connect d nwr track wid d original one.......so came up wid all dialogues...............vch actualy sounded unnecessary.............

Quote

1 2

Shaan

Was it O.K.Shaan forgetting khanak totally

Related Topics

Explore Topics