Star Crossed Lovers, Not A Triangle

The_May_Rose thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 15 years ago
#1
The discussions by my dear friends in the episode DT are the inspiration and reason for this thought😃.....
ShaNak are not the regular soap jodi, who are part of your typical triangle....Their story goes much deeper than this....So rather than look at the surface, we have to look into the reasons for their behaviour....At the same time we have remember to enjoy the drama and give the CVs a little bit of artistic freedom😊....
Both Shaan and Khanak reactions may seem silly and confusing at times....But the point is, they are ment to be confused.....The situation and foundation of their marriage was built on such extreme circumstances.....So it is no wonder both are stumbling and making sillly mistakes....
Khanak is very causious about her feeling towards Shaan and doesn't want to jeapodise her friendship with Shaan....But she no longer blames him for Suraj's death and she has accepted him as her husband....She was pro Natasha, but somewhere deep down I think she knows there is a change in Shaan's feelings....She has thought this many times and she witnessed the whole ' ILU Khanak ' slip.....I really think she knows things are different, but till today she wasn't willing to give it a thought.....
Shaan's constant ' I won't let you go ' ,' You are my wife' , his reliance on her opinion, his behaviour, his closeness, the note, Dadi's & Gopi's advice....Have influenced Khanak's thinking....Maybe this is why Natasha didn't cross her mind when Shaan was proposing....Was it out of charactor?.....Well Khanak has accepted him as her husband and she herself said today, that she intends to furfill her patni daraam....So she is happy to stay married to him, she didn't suddenly realise she was in love....She felt shy like any girl would feel in her shoes and lets face it was Shaan asking her 😉😃.....This whole track will help her realise what she feels and when ShaNak are together, it will be better than just, being a good wife....Khanak needed this shock.....
Shaan never wanted to fall for Khanak....When he made that slip, his reaction was he can never love Khanak....But he fell in love and now he is trying to keep everyone happy.....But in typical Shaan style....He can't deal with one thing at a time and he rushed into telling Khanak before he ended things officailly with Natasha....Chalo that's Shaan for you😆......Many people wondered why he was doubting Khanak, well once again I thought that was justified....Khanak has always said Suraj's place can never be taken....This is reason for Shaan to feel in secure.....Most of the time she feels shy around him and she pushes him towards Natasha....But I think today's behaviour was his gutt reaction, on feeling rejected and his hopes being dashed.....He will start thinking again tomorrow or next week...Lets give our sweet burthal some time to sulk😆....
I mean imagine making everthing perfect for you love and getting a shock likee that....I think he was very controled....After putting Natasha through so much he felt bad....To make things worse his familly were strangely there to witness it all......What could he say then and there?.....
Lets put aside small things like who was listening when, let asume that the others came later.....Shaan lines fitted both girls, at various times....After her shock, Khanak did think Shaan wanted her to witness this.....I thought this would happen and it did.....SD&BD have obviously planned this....The K-men just don't want conflict and are like pentulums, swinging from side to side....Some may say they are useless, or maybe they are waiting for the right moment....Given time Mr.K is bound to talk to Shaan....Now was not the right time, as everyone seemed so happy, with the news.....
What will happen next?....Well Khanak will start to feel her heart break......Natasha needed this because it will help her realise what ShaNak have and that they never intented to hurt her.....Maybe she will be the one to unite them, as she has noticed the changes so far.....Her behaviour tonight was perhaps a little over the top, but she was probubly floored by Shaan's love and cuteness😃....
This is not the typicial soap drama in my eyes, it is much more complicated than that....All the charactors have genuine reason for their actions and behaviour.....Their past relations and new feelings have to be considered.....So lets just sit back and try to see what this track will do for each charactor and in what way is it going to impact them....Lets look at the big pictureand lets not compare this story with things we have seen before....Only then will we see why the engagment was needed and it's not the typical triangle....
P.S. I have a funny feeling that the letter were switched😕....But I can't make sense of why I am thinking this....After the presentation Shaan wondered if she had got the letter and today he was wondering if she rejected his love....Any way lets see what the Cvs have in store for us😊.....

Created

Last reply

Replies

10

Views

1.3k

Users

8

Likes

71

Frequent Posters

-Veena- thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 15 years ago
#2
Haai May....🤗 Awesome topic.. and very thought provoking too.. I am busy getting mad at everyone in the epi(except ShaNak).. thou i love the epi to bits!!!!😳
I agree to what you have to say..
one thing..everyone has their own reasons to do what they did.. but can't understand how the Kmen didn't have the guts to create a firm stand against what happened as they both know that Shaan loves khanak.. i din't understand that!
@the show... it is one apart the others i agree.
I can't wait for the coming epi's ..they are going to be heartbreakingly awesome!😳
Hoping Nattie realizes the 'changed' Shaan is Khanaks and not hers!😳
The_May_Rose thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 15 years ago
#3
Can I just apologise for writing such a long post......I was so tired after reading it and I'm the one who wrote it🤣.....Sorry! Thank you for reading it and commenting😃.....
RACHA90 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 15 years ago
#4
May u really understand the charactersmore than they understand themselves ....LOVED your topic

I agree that this "Twist" is somehow needed to bring the three of them to face the new changes in their lives especially Natasha the girl is breaking my heart she is so in denial that she cannt even notice how shocked shaan was when he saw her face.

But i really dont know how on earth did she get there with the whole family ? and that too wearing similar clothes like khanak.

I think it is like u said khushboo or madhvi or even hetal (as she is always sneeking in ShaNak's bedroom ) found the letter and gave it to khushboo and with the help of madhvi they switched it and they did want khanak to be there to break her heart so they wrote a different letter for her.

MFRanjini thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 15 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: The_May_Rose

The discussions by my dear friends in the episode DT are the inspiration and reason for this thought😃.....

May, I agree with you 100% I know howmuch I was trying to justify everything in DT yesterday😆

ShaNak are not the regular soap jodi, who are part of your typical triangle....Their story goes much deeper than this....So rather than look at the surface, we have to look into the reasons for their behaviour....At the same time we have remember to enjoy the drama and give the CVs a little bit of artistic freedom😊....

Really, that is why Shanak is my favorite, they are so different from other couples😃
Both Shaan and Khanak reactions may seem silly and confusing at times....But the point is, they are ment to be confused.....The situation and foundation of their marriage was built on such extreme circumstances.....So it is no wonder both are stumbling and making sillly mistakes....

Just think what they had to face in their life. Khanak a chulbuli village girl was expecting a happy married life in Dhulwadi, She had to marry the killer of her husband and come to Mumbai with him and to stay here with SD and her gang.

Shaan was the irresponsible, pampered youngest member of a rich family where he never had to do any serious thing and even nobody expected any serious thing from him. Now what he had to face? he killed a guy (though unintentionally), then the village people were ready to kill him, then he had to marry that girl who hated him for killing her husband.

So when both of them came to Mumbai they never wanted to stay with each other.

But gradually they understood that there is something between them. But till today that something is not totally flourished, they need some more twists in their life so that their relationship goes much deeper.



Khanak is very causious about her feeling towards Shaan and doesn't want to jeapodise her friendship with Shaan....But she no longer blames him for Suraj's death and she has accepted him as her husband....She was pro Natasha, but somewhere deep down I think she knows there is a change in Shaan's feelings....She has thought this many times and she witnessed the whole ' ILU Khanak ' slip.....I really think she knows things are different, but till today she wasn't willing to give it a thought.....
Shaan's constant ' I won't let you go ' ,' You are my wife' , his reliance on her opinion, his behaviour, his closeness, the note, Dadi's & Gopi's advice....Have influenced Khanak's thinking....Maybe this is why Natasha didn't cross her mind when Shaan was proposing....Was it out of charactor?.....Well Khanak has accepted him as her husband and she herself said today, that she intends to furfill her patni daraam....So she is happy to stay married to him, she didn't suddenly realise she was in love....She felt shy like any girl would feel in her shoes and lets face it was Shaan asking her 😉😃.....This whole track will help her realise what she feels and when ShaNak are together, it will be better than just, being a good wife....Khanak needed this shock.....

I agree, Khanak cannot be blamed. Love cannot happen following logic. She is a young girl, her life with Suraj ended before anything happened . She spent more difficult time with Shaan, she shared more difficult situations with Shaan. And Shaan was always there with her. Any girl will fall for Shaan in this same situation. I know she was not thinking about Natz at that time but please give some break to this girl, why will she sacrifice all the time? Its difficult to be that perfect and I am glad that she is not that "all good" typical "saas Bahu type drama bahus".

Shaan never wanted to fall for Khanak....When he made that slip, his reaction was he can never love Khanak....But he fell in love and now he is trying to keep everyone happy.....But in typical Shaan style....He can't deal with one thing at a time and he rushed into telling Khanak before he ended things officailly with Natasha....Chalo that's Shaan for you😆......Many people wondered why he was doubting Khanak, well once again I thought that was justified....Khanak has always said Suraj's place can never be taken....This is reason for Shaan to feel in secure.....Most of the time she feels shy around him and she pushes him towards Natasha....But I think today's behaviour was his gutt reaction, on feeling rejected and his hopes being dashed.....He will start thinking again tomorrow or next week...Lets give our sweet burthal some time to sulk😆....

I mean imagine making everthing perfect for you love and getting a shock likee that....I think he was very controled....After putting Natasha through so much he felt bad....To make things worse his familly were strangely there to witness it all......What could he say then and there?.....

Thanks May I was trying to defend Shaan and you have the same thoughts. Give some break to this guy as well. Can't you see how sad he was? I agree he is too fast, he is still the burthal but he is trying his best.😊 I was happy that he was thinking about Natz, I know he should have told Natz the truth but Natz was soooo happy at that time he didn't want to hurt her
Lets put aside small things like who was listening when, let asume that the others came later.....Shaan lines fitted both girls, at various times....After her shock, Khanak did think Shaan wanted her to witness this.....I thought this would happen and it did.....SD&BD have obviously planned this....The K-men just don't want conflict and are like pentulums, swinging from side to side....Some may say they are useless, or maybe they are waiting for the right moment....Given time Mr.K is bound to talk to Shaan....Now was not the right time, as everyone seemed so happy, with the news.....

I think Natz and others entered the hall in between the talk (after Shaan mentioned Khanak's name)

I have one question to the CVs: How SD came to know that Shaan is going to propose Khanak? And as the CVs' aim was to show the engagement drama Shaan didn't say " I love you Khanak" or "Khanak let us marry again, is baar apni marzi se". If Shaan said these lines then I hope you can imagine SD's face😆 and Natz would have known about Shaan's actual feelings.😊

@ Senior K: We all know he diesn't have the backbone to go against his wife, but he is not against Shaan and Khanak. The way he came to Shaan and looked at him, I think he understood something wrong with Shaan. May be he will talk to Shaan later. He also was not ready to hurt Natz at that moment.

@ Akshay: I don't think he thinks much about the situations. He saw Shaan proposing Natz and possibly he thought his bro is happy with Natz only. He never loved Khanak but he was happy with Khanak as she helped them in their business and she made Shaan more responsible. I think he is not a deep person

What will happen next?....Well Khanak will start to feel her heart break......Natasha needed this because it will help her realize what ShaNak have and that they never intented to hurt her.....Maybe she will be the one to unite them, as she has noticed the changes so far.....Her behaviour tonight was perhaps a little over the top, but she was probably floored by Shaan's love and cuteness😃....

I hope this happens May😊
This is not the typicial soap drama in my eyes, it is much more complicated than that....All the charactors have genuine reason for their actions and behaviour.....Their past relations and new feelings have to be considered.....So lets just sit back and try to see what this track will do for each charactor and in what way is it going to impact them....Lets look at the big pictureand lets not compare this story with things we have seen before....Only then will we see why the engagment was needed and it's not the typical triangle....

Looking forward for the coming episodes. I have high hopes😍

P.S. I have a funny feeling that the letter were switched😕....But I can't make sense of why I am thinking this....After the presentation Shaan wondered if she had got the letter and today he was wondering if she rejected his love....Any way lets see what the Cvs have in store for us😊.....

I don't know May, I think he wrote only one letter😕

pree.mahi thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#6
@May, loved ur analysis.
Wow what an episode it was yesterday. All of us expected very sad moments based on day-befores preview. But the CVs took a step ahead and completely squeezed our hearts. Hats Off to CVs. Now whe I look back at all our our discussion, i cudnt help smiling - how much v all showed r luv, hate, pity, anger over the different characters. That shows what a great job Cvs have done.
@Veena, yep there's really going to interesting shanak moments. Whats interesting is - unlike most soaps/movies - which show initial hate changes to head over heels love and so on - RBO CVs are differenty showing how the shanak moments vary over a rollercoaster of emotions - hatred, empathy, friendship, love, longing, care , hesitation and what not.
@ May completely agree with ur analysis reg khanak and shaan's reactions.
Khanak is a person who thinks b4 she acts. While Shaan is very impulsive. So shaan falling in love for khanak was quicker, where as khanak's realization was slow. The CVs were smart and showed this gradual change in khanak, over the many episodes after she started feeling somthing for shaan. Initially though she felt for shaan, she cntrled her emotions thinking it is not right - the way she got some feelings when shaan hugged her in 100th epi but however she refrained from hugging him back.
When u love someone and u see some changes in that person towards u - u are bound to hope that u end up spending life with him/her. Thats natural. Even whn he crnrd her in paatshaala also, as May rightly worded it in another thread - She was 'AWARE' and not 'AFRAID'. She was aware of what shaan was feeling (passion) at that time.
As u pointed out when Shaan was saying I am not letting u go and u r my wife and so on, she being a gal who subconsciously loves him and is only cntrling bcoz she thinks her feelings r nt right, obviously starts feeling more closer and obviously her hopes rise. That is why she reciprocated shaan's hug as unknowingly or knowingly her hopes rised. And when u r a wife hopes rise more.
Her saying 2 herself that - thr is nothing between shaan and her repeatedly - this itself says she feels thr is something going on between thm. Do v evr say 'he is just my friend' to rself b4 v meet r frnd. She is doing a lip service by saying so again and again to cntrl what her heart says and longs for.
_sana.Magic_ thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#7
May a really nice topic and analysis and i truely understand shanak's position and their reactions are justified for that moment...!!Shan really understood the sensitivity of the situation and kept quite or else if tashu had to face rejection this time she would have totally broken and may be ............ Khanak was really confused as till 2day whatever happened to her was always a confused situation....she married suraj was about to marry munjhal and after so much confusion that why he ran away and all she got married to shan....Then she left shan's house and when she came back she was confused about shan's and her own feeling coz both of them were changing as so much happened when they were out of their house....!!!So it was obvious that she was confused this time and she didnt say anything when the lights were on...!!! But you know yesterday i felt a bit bad coz i always dreamed of Shanak being together and their funny moments their chup chupata pyaar their mixed emotions....shan constant "Focus dude and then when he saw khanak all focus gone....!!!"tum meri patni ho ,khanak tum alag ho ,tum kahai nahi jayogi"i'll miss these dialogues....!!!
Cnt cum 2 terms that shanak have 2 face some disastrous days when shan forcefully have to be with tashu and this will hurt khanak but she wont b able 2 express her as she'll be confused abt her feelings or she'll think shan always loved tashu and she is the 1 who came in btwn....!!!
Hopefully Shanak's audience doesnt have 2 wait for a very long time before they come together....!!!Just hoping to see them together as fast as possible
I know the CV's of RBO thinks differently and we should give them some space to show their creativity also so hopefully they'll plan a Shanak union as fast as possible😃
destinylove thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#8
OMG., i found some time today morning and look what i got such lovely posts from may ,pree.nahi., and ranjni.
yes dears now i sort of seem to understand in the best way what shaan/khaank's feelings would have been.
and yes shaan is highly impulsive and having not undergone any big trilas and tribulations in life seems to expect everything to happen his way so soon.The same he expects for khanak too to accept his love with one letter.
on the other hand khanak has suffered so much at auch an young age and she having come from a simple family knows that life is full of stuggles and so is highly cautious in her approach.
As for natasha she has the support of the entire k family literally and she madly loves shaan as well., so no wonder she failed to observe the sadness in shaan's eyes and the hesitaiton.Even if she had known about the sadness she would have dismissed that because she was overjoyed on the occasion.
And senoir k and akshay do not wish to have any confronations with their respective wives., akshay especially because natasha happens to be his saali as well.
so nobody is now interested in seeeing things from khanak's side or for that matter even if what shaan felt.
And it is the poor girl khanak who is bearing the brunt of all this.
It was becoming clear that the entire k house hold is behind natasha and somehow wants shaan to marry her. at asny cost.
shaan was the only solace for khaank and now he too is a confused person who gets carried away by things easily..
and mangal/hetal are also plotting to get khanak out of k household..gopi is a young girl and dadiji is tooo old for fighting and all that so one cannot rely upon them to take up khanak's cause.
even if they speak for khanak nobody is really interested in analysing the truth behind this...Now skhanak is on the verge of losing her only firm supporter shaan as well as natasha may object to shaan moving with her even as a friend., and burthal shaan does not think on his own always....
After a long time i had tears watching khanak's plight yesterday.she had done her best for the k family inspite of being tortured verbally and physically.,and what did she get in return...nothing at all...
and the same applies to her relationship with suraj's family.
she was there in k's family only for suraj's family welfare and yet she is put to too much suffering by hetal/mangal and earlier gopi as well for some time.
And i put myself in her shoes being bombarded with bomb from all sides with no shield to proetect., only a temporary shield in the form of shaan was avialble that too being sntached away...i am worried about her future...i feel like giving her a break from all including shaan.
and i felt and literally cried for khanak
(never done that before) to be misunderstood by your most beloved one is the worst of a ll sufferings.,and shaan is thinking about her in that way....misunderstanding her....
well RBO cvs really u have done a superb job in making us feel for the characters and the heart ache they are undergoing espeically shaan and even more khanak.
That was a real cruel blow but well shown .Yashashri outscored kt there (I keep saying this because she did a real funatastic job by not over playing it) .
The_May_Rose thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 15 years ago
#9
Thanks for the replies evryone....Loved all your comments...I feel positive about the coming episodes....Like Veena said we are going to see some exciting things in RBO😊....
kubare thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 15 years ago
#10
@ May darling loved reading all that you said dear....and agree too...we sure are in for some great intense drama and scenes and me too can't wait to see how the CV's go about it as they ahve always suprised us...😆
Rajni said it fro Sunil and Akshay I think...on their being mum...
Dont want Nattie to be the Martyr...let Shaan tell her the truth for once as a Man...in love...but donot want to see Nattie being the ultimate sacrificer..just can't see her as that..she accepts what Shan has to say to her and move on gracefully..but not being the one to bring them together... that they Shaak should do on their own.
Rousha said something about the mystery of the letter...could be that SD got Hetal to snoop...who knows..or she found out from Hetal that Shaan called her and thus arrranged everything accordingly too...again courtesy Hetal evadroping for BD..
Burthal will definitely sulf for a few days thats for sure...thats so him...😆😆😆Khanak will eb extra chirrpy that for sure too..to cover up her guilt again...and feelings...😆😆😆
So...bring it on the drama, the action the intensity etc...😆😆😆

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".