What do you all think about this Ramayana now?

Durga1994 thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#1

NDTV Ramayana by Anand Sagar has grown in leaps and bounds since it first telecast on January 21, 2008. Nearly 80% of it is complete now, so it is nearing its end. What do you all think of it? What are the best aspects of this Ramayana? What are some things that could have been taken better? Who is your favorite actor and who do you think is doing full justice to his/her role? Please fill out this form, so that we can discuss all the aspects of this Ramayana.

Favorite Actor:
The actor who is doing best justice to his/her role:
Rate this Ramayana from 1 to 10 (10 being the highest):
The best aspect of this Ramayana:
Something you found irritating about this Ramayana:
Top five favorite songs:
What does this Ramayana have that the one 20 years back didn't?:
What does the Ramayana 20 years back have that this one didn't?:
Finally, which Kanda of this Ramayana did you like the best and why?:
I hope you all like this topic!😃

Created

Last reply

Replies

5

Views

524

Users

4

Frequent Posters

Durga1994 thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#2
Here are my answers for this form...
Favorite Actor: Gurmeet Choudhary (Rama)
The actor who is doing best justice to his/her role: There are lots, but I think the best is Vikram Sharma, who is Hanuman. He is doing a really wonderful job, and in the Sundara Kanda, he showed his feelings really well.
Rate this Ramayana from 1 to 10 (10 being the highest): 7.5 (It's a wonderful serial, but I think there are some mistakes in the story line in some places, so I give it a seven and a half.)
The best aspect of this Ramayana: It covers a lot of of background stories, which makes it very interesting and knowledgeable.
Something you found irritating about this Ramayana: The actor who is playing Meghnadh
Top five favorite songs: Song Hanuman sings in Ashok Vana, Sita Rama meeting song in Pusha Vana, Sita garlanding Rama song, song of Sita entering swayamvaram, and the song when Sita is leaving Mithila
What does this Ramayana have that the one 20 years back didn't?: More Story behind Stories (a really great aspect of this Ramayana😃)
What does the Ramayana 20 years back have that this one didn't?: It elongated in the right places (one thing I realized about this Ramayana was that it stretches in unnecessary places and speeds up in the important spots. I wish the Sagars can improve that before the serial ends.)
Finally, which Kanda of this Ramayana did you like the best and why?: Ayodhya Kanda (I loved the Sita Swayamvaram scenes a lot. They were all very very sweet.)
Edited by Durga1994 - 16 years ago
Vr15h thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail IPL 2024 Participants Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 16 years ago
#3
Okay, I'll bite - here are my answers for this form...
Favorite Actor: Gurmeet Choudhary (Rama)
The actor who is doing best justice to his/her role: Tough to tell, but I'd go with Debina. Reason for this - watching Dipika 20 years ago was painful, particularly due to her very weepy character, and her subservient attitude towards Rama. In this serial, Debina lends Sita both sorrow and outrage, and some places, such as Sita slapping her guards, or threatening Surpanakha, were amusing to watch, even if a departure from the script. In other words, Debina portrays Sita's pativrata aspect well, while lending her a fury born of a pride that would be expected in a kshatrani such as her.

Rate this Ramayana from 1 to 10 (10 being the highest): 7 (I share your reasons - it does deviate from the script quite a bit. For starters, I don't like Ramayans being based on Tulsidas, who distorted a lot of things, but even beyond that, it needlessly defames characters who were actually heroic, such as Vali: other than imprisoning Roma, he didn't molest others' wives, as depicted in the Mayavi episode - that challenge came because Mayavi and Dundoobi were brothers or son/father. Similarly, Bharat was never wounded in battle with Sita's other suitors).

The best aspect of this Ramayana: Unlike the previous serial which would prolong things artificially e.g. Angad walking to Ravan's palace, this one does it by filling in background stories, such as the episodes about Hanuman's birth, Vali's battle with Ravan, etc. Most of the stories about Ravan and Vali are actually covered in the Uttar Ramayan (I'm talking Valmiki here), but here, the stories about them, such as Ravan's war with Kubera and the conquest of Lanka, are beautifully inserted during otherwise boring episodes such as Sunderkand.

Something you found irritating about this Ramayana: The unflattering light in which some of the characters were depicted, such as Vali, Bharat. Also, some of the deviations, such as Ahiravan and Mahiravan happening at the beginning of the war, as opposed to the end. Not all the deviations were irritating - I liked the one where Sumitra slaps Manthara and condemns Kaikeyi for disgracing the throne of Ayodhya.

Top five favorite songs: So far, just 2 - the song played when Bharat and his retinue were going to the forest to fetch back Rama, and when Rama, Lakshman and Sita met the newly widowed Rajmatas.

What does this Ramayana have that the one 20 years back didn't?: A lot more detail and background stories, as mentioned above. Far better sets, and most noticeably, the special effects of the weapons were awesome, particularly in contrast to the 3rd rate 2D effects 20 years ago. Only complaint there - a lot of the Rakshashas are shown as disappearing when they were killed, but such delicate handling was needless. They seemed to improve that in the killing of Ahi & Mahi, so lets hope we won't see that in the yuddhakand. Another thing I liked during the Ayodhyakand was showing the other wives, such as Mandavi & Srutakirti during their husbands' visits to Kekaya-desh, and again when Bharat and Shatrughan were getting the news of their father's demise from Kaikeyi and Sumitra.

What does the Ramayana 20 years back have that this one didn't?: I agree with Durga here again - this serial goes too fast at places, like Hanuman's meeting with Sita, and elongates too much at other less significant ones, like Ahi & Mahi taking 3 weeks. The previous serial did some things a lot better - like when Bharat approached Kaushalya after storming out on Kaikeyi, his conversation with her there was heart-rending and touching, whereas here, it was just the third segment and Kaushalya almost reading his mind.

Finally, which Kanda of this Ramayana did you like the best and why?: For this serial, Kishkinda kand - although I don't like the way Vali was vilified (e.g. molesting Mayavi's wife, which didn't happen), I liked his conversations with Tara, demonstrations of valor that were shown by him, the extra coverage of Roma. Oh, and in Sunderkand, I liked how Hanuman's story was shown, and how Sita's defiance against her captors were shown. I do think however, that depending on how it is shown and how many warriors they show getting killed (I hope lots), yuddhya-kand might end up as my favorite, or at least should.

RamKiSeeta thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 16 years ago
#4
Favorite Actor: Gurmeet Choudhary
The actor who is doing best justice to his/her role: Gurmeet as Ram, because although the Sagars gave the role of Ram too many angry lines which were supposed to be said by Lakshman, Gurmeet's expressions and acting are good.
Rate this Ramayana from 1 to 10 (10 being the highest): 7, because there are some faults in the script and the acting of some major characters (cough...cough...Ravan) are not good, but overall, the show is nice to watch, and the songs are melodious.
The best aspect of this Ramayana: The make-up and costumes of the vanaras are excellent, because they look really strong and menacing when facing Ravan's army. And also, I like the background stories as well, especially Hanuman's childhood. The kid who acted as Hanuman was absolutely adorable and did excellent for such a young child.😃
Something you found irritating about this Ramayana: Akhilendra Mishra as Ravan. I'm sorry, but his laughter gets on my nerves and his dialogue delivery is very poor. I also don't like Sitaji slapping the rakshasi, because I clearly remember that she never used physical violence against anybody. Cutting words, yes, but not physical blows.
Top five favorite songs: I only have two right now, and they are: the title song, and Hanuman's song in Ashok Vatika.
What does this Ramayana have that the one 20 years back didn't?: The background stories, which helped explain the reasons of some of the actions of the characters.
What does the Ramayana 20 years back have that this one didn't?: The script kept more to the original story and didn't deviate as much. Also, I like the characterization of Sitaji better in the older one (although both Deepika and Debina acted good), because she seemed more soft hearted and patient. She was not as weepy as some people say, because there were times she was angry when it was necessary. The character of this Sitaji is too headstrong, but I'm not bashing Debina as some people may think. She's only acting how the Sagars tell her to, and she's doing a good job at it (her expressions during Hanuman's song were sooooooooo sweet), but I'm just saying that the Sagar's characterization of Sitaji was a little too angry. Just my opinion though...
Finally, which Kanda of this Ramayana did you like the best and why?: Sundara Kanda, because the story of Hanuman was really nice and Hanuman's song in Ashok Vatika is my favorite (it's been playing through my head all day.)
RamKiSeeta thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 16 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: Chandraketu



What does this Ramayana have that the one 20 years back didn't?: A lot more detail and background stories, as mentioned above. Far better sets, and most noticeably, the special effects of the weapons were awesome, particularly in contrast to the 3rd rate 2D effects 20 years ago.

I don't think we can really blame the older Ramayan for not having as grand sets and more mature technology as the one today. 20 years is an awfully long time for technology to prosper, and it did so very fast. 20 years ago, the sets in the Ramayan, and the way the arrows flew etc. were all that was available at the time. The computerization of today wasn't available at that time as it is today. So for the 1980s, the way the Ramayan was taken was actually thought "technologically advanced". Think about it. 20 years from now, if another Ramayan serial is taken, today's Ramayan may be thought "3rd rate 2D". What I mean to say is, that technology shouldn't be taken into consideration when comparing serials with more than 10 years age difference.
I also like the sets of this Ramayan, because they are grand and beautiful, but I also really like the sets of the older Ramayan, because for those days, it was the best.
muffins2waffles thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 16 years ago
#6
Hello everyone! Sorry I was gone for a while...I hope you can forgive me, lol.. Here are my answers
Favorite Actor: Everyone is saying Gurmeet as Ram, but I have to say Debina as Sita. Though she has some mistakes, she is the best actress. (As in her acting)
The actor who is doing best justice to his/her role: Hanumanji, he is acting very devotional, and the song in the Ashok Vanam is very nice.
Rate this Ramayana from 1 to 10 (10 being the highest): I would have to say 6, there are also many mistakes in this Ramayan.
The best aspect of this Ramayana: The songs are very nice.
Something you found irritating about this Ramayana: The Ravan and Meghnad actor. Are they seriously trying their best?
Top five favorite songs: The one Hanuman sings in Ashok vanam, Narayana, and I don't know...Can't remember, sorry
What does this Ramayana have that the one 20 years back didn't?: The many background stories and technology affects made it look very effective, excellent job.
What does the Ramayana 20 years back have that this one didn't?: All the actors were superb. The Ravan did outstanding, as well as Lakshman. You could see hard work in the acting, as well as this one. Both worked hard.
Finally, which Kanda of this Ramayana did you like the best and why
Sundara Kanda, I love the Hanumanji parts

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".