About interpretations. - Page 18

Created

Last reply

Replies

192

Views

19.2k

Users

11

Likes

663

Frequent Posters

bunmaska thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago

Originally posted by: RainFire125

i so concur with what you said Lata. And those two shows (Zindagi Gulzar hai) and (Humsafar) are a class in itself and I watch it again now and then. Such depth of emotions and layers in characterization as per situations and very much relatable. Sad that Indian shows are not able to think of such shows and telecast it!! The whole industry is just after trp and they will do what ever possible to garner that ... not leaving mytho too and I will be bold and brave today to say that we audience are largely at fault to accept their crap from Day 1 :) :)


Exactly we are only responsible for this mess...EK and her clan are out to mint money...they can give us the best stories and shows if they want to but choose to show us this trash...sad really.

bunmaska thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago

Originally posted by: Viswasruti

Many people expressed their views against this show! Which is depicting a story far beyond our imagination! I strongly feel that this serial is not about our Divine romantic couple Radha Krishna,it is a serial written for gaining TRPs , not the original love saga of our Radha Krishna! In the spiritual world, Krishna came to earth to settle peace but this show has erased all that spiritual concept and showing every action Of Krishna related only to Radha!

Killing Putana, did he really flew off to Barsana just to open Radha's eyes? They have shown Radha, who was herself the goddess of love, with flaws by giving the reason that she was born as a human. Then, Krishna, Balarama was also born as a human, they didn't have any flaws.!! In fact Nand, Yashoda would not have so many flaws, but why only Radha has all those Badhas?!!

Krishna was supreme God himself and he would never do adharma. But in this show, he has done things which are actually far from Dharma!

He did not care that his father and Vrishbhan, in fact, both the villages were breaking up with each other, he just wanted that Radha gets liberated from fear!

Kalia Mardana.I can't believe that they have shown that no one except Radha remembers it. Krishna just vanished the memory of Kalia mardana from all the people!!----this was the point I started disliking this serial.

And there were many people who had flaws in those two villages, then why Krishna only liberated Radha from flaws. This is partiality!!

All the Asuras were harming all the villagers but Krishna did something only when Radha was in danger. This is too much partiality. When Vrishbhan was taken away by Aghasura, he did not do anything!

Also, adharma was done when the serial showed 10 days of Mela which was organized to earn money to repay those saahukars. No problem but saahukars[ money lenders] were the wise men. They helped Radha when she needed to pay loan to Kansa. But ultimately what happened?? They got killed in the hands of Kansa. Really? Is this not adharma?? What did Krishna do? Nothing. This is the biggest problem. It is not easy to make a story which is not violating dharma.

Ayan and jatila.. the most dreaded humans to harass Radha in this serial, and literally Ayan brought all the trouble to Barsana. He made Vrishbhan fell from a height. he even tried to kill the villagers by poisoning the food grains.. You know even after all this and after all what he did.. If he got Radha then this would be the worst show in mythological serials!! I am sorry to say this!

They have wrongly presented the character of Krishna, Balarama and also lord Shiva. I thought Shiva was Adi yogi. His personality was not making jokes. But here he is shown as making jokes!

The story of Radhakrishna was simple. Krishna loved Radha.. But at the age of eleven, Kansa called Krishna and Balrama to Mathura, so he needs to left. And he did not come back. So Radha and Ayan got married.. and later Ayan started spending time in front of the statue of Maa Kali! Simple. No extra role of Ayan! Why they made him the hero of this serial and at times even made Krishna a side character in their obsessive love for Ayan!!

I am not against any actor who plays the roles..Sumedh, Basant, Mallika are fabulous. But I am saying against the storyline and characterization of the main characters!! Dealing with such a well established and the well-known story is not easy for any creative team, but making it such a mockery of a great Mythological story ... it is difficult to accept by any normal viewer. As Minakshi earlier said, if we start believing that -- these are only fictional characters, not the Divine lovers, then we will be at peace!

Thank you Lata, for sharing your views which sounds similar to many members' of this forum.🤗


Thank you Viswasruti for sharing your pain here that is what hurts us all of us here too....I wonder who has given them the liberty to make such jokes on Shree Krishna and Shiva Bhagwan and the others...why make a show in that name if they just wanted to show a love story..just to garner trps...and here I thought the maker is one smart sensible person to make such shows and all we get is a soap opera.

bunmaska thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago

Originally posted by: mnx12

Lata, thanks for your kind thoughts.

The best part about initial period of DKDM was, they would just present a track & we would go on R & A journey to find out what does it actually mean. There was an interesting element of mystery in the story. Not only Purans but other scriptures's subjects were added too eg. Kundalini, Chakras etc. It appealed to both class & mass. Only towards the end it got boring when they started direct preaching.

Lets hope some day they'll improve standard of Mytho shows & some one would actually represent a unique version, sticking to the popular stories without distorting image of representatives of our faith.


Yes let us hope so...once again thanks Meenaxi for helping us express our views here..rarely will a mod in IF in a forum where she herself is the mod express her views the way you did but so proud of you that you spoke the truth. Hope we get some show and a forum where we all can discuss sensibly without fearing that others will be hurt about the actors playing it.....can understand when it comes to children and teenagers but as adults it is common sense for one to understand that characters of a show and the show they are acting in are totally different...it is absolutely fine to love the actors for what they are doing but to connect them with the show character and then pounce on those who have an opinion otherwise is silly.

Viswasruti thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago

Agree with your views regarding the fan wars and developing a strong connection towards those characters.

I have seen it in the Balika Vadhu forum and in a few forums where I was posted a few of my opinions, and after watching the invasions and deluge of abuses, scared and silently slipped aside to buy peace for myself!!! But in a few forums, there are very good writers who are efficiently writing OS, FF with good analytical skills and writing capabilities. Expected so much from this serial when I read that the creative team did enough research before starting the shooting. Surprisingly the writers messed up the story [ though sounds harsh but it is my true opinion...] But reiterating my view regarding the sets and the highly talented and aptly suited actors as Radha and Krishna. Respect your opinions.

Edited by Viswasruti - 6 years ago
Sutapasima thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago

Originally posted by: mnx12

Lata, thanks for your kind thoughts.

The best part about initial period of DKDM was, they would just present a track & we would go on R & A journey to find out what does it actually mean. There was an interesting element of mystery in the story. Not only Purans but other scriptures's subjects were added too eg. Kundalini, Chakras etc. It appealed to both class & mass. Only towards the end it got boring when they started direct preaching.

Lets hope some day they'll improve standard of Mytho shows & some one would actually represent a unique version, sticking to the popular stories without distorting image of representatives of our faith.

Minakshi ..I think our mytho is too rich 🤗😇n beyond the capabilities of TRP hungry producers directors 😔

vinnas thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 6 years ago

Originally posted by: Viswasruti

Many people expressed their views against this show! Which is depicting a story far beyond our imagination! I strongly feel that this serial is not about our Divine romantic couple Radha Krishna,it is a serial written for gaining TRPs , not the original love saga of our Radha Krishna! In the spiritual world, Krishna came to earth to settle peace but this show has erased all that spiritual concept and showing every action Of Krishna related only to Radha!

Killing Putana, did he really flew off to Barsana just to open Radha's eyes? They have shown Radha, who was herself the goddess of love, with flaws by giving the reason that she was born as a human. Then, Krishna, Balarama was also born as a human, they didn't have any flaws.!! In fact Nand, Yashoda would not have so many flaws, but why only Radha has all those Badhas?!!

Krishna was supreme God himself and he would never do adharma. But in this show, he has done things which are actually far from Dharma!

He did not care that his father and Vrishbhan, in fact, both the villages were breaking up with each other, he just wanted that Radha gets liberated from fear!

Kalia Mardana.I can't believe that they have shown that no one except Radha remembers it. Krishna just vanished the memory of Kalia mardana from all the people!!----this was the point I started disliking this serial.

And there were many people who had flaws in those two villages, then why Krishna only liberated Radha from flaws. This is partiality!!

All the Asuras were harming all the villagers but Krishna did something only when Radha was in danger. This is too much partiality. When Vrishbhan was taken away by Aghasura, he did not do anything!

Also, adharma was done when the serial showed 10 days of Mela which was organized to earn money to repay those saahukars. No problem but saahukars[ money lenders] were the wise men. They helped Radha when she needed to pay loan to Kansa. But ultimately what happened?? They got killed in the hands of Kansa. Really? Is this not adharma?? What did Krishna do? Nothing. This is the biggest problem. It is not easy to make a story which is not violating dharma.

Ayan and jatila.. the most dreaded humans to harass Radha in this serial, and literally Ayan brought all the trouble to Barsana. He made Vrishbhan fell from a height. he even tried to kill the villagers by poisoning the food grains.. You know even after all this and after all what he did.. If he got Radha then this would be the worst show in mythological serials!! I am sorry to say this!

They have wrongly presented the character of Krishna, Balarama and also lord Shiva. I thought Shiva was Adi yogi. His personality was not making jokes. But here he is shown as making jokes!

The story of Radhakrishna was simple. Krishna loved Radha.. But at the age of eleven, Kansa called Krishna and Balrama to Mathura, so he needs to left. And he did not come back. So Radha and Ayan got married.. and later Ayan started spending time in front of the statue of Maa Kali! Simple. No extra role of Ayan! Why they made him the hero of this serial and at times even made Krishna a side character in their obsessive love for Ayan!!

I am not against any actor who plays the roles..Sumedh, Basant, Mallika are fabulous. But I am saying against the storyline and characterization of the main characters!! Dealing with such a well established and the well-known story is not easy for any creative team, but making it such a mockery of a great Mythological story ... it is difficult to accept by any normal viewer. As Minakshi earlier said, if we start believing that -- these are only fictional characters, not the Divine lovers, then we will be at peace!

Thank you Lata, for sharing your views which sounds similar to many members' of this forum.🤗

Word 👍🏼👏👏👍🏼Exactly Put The Points and Plots 😲which Distracted Me from The Serial 😒😳it was OK a Bit in initial epis to take Liberty like Putana Flight Journey to Open Radha Eyes 😛😆 Kaliya mardhan Realised Don't Get illusions like It's Going Proper Route To Purans 😕👍🏼. No more Any one It's Aayan and Jatila The Whole villains/Demons in Dwapar Yug 😈 Krishna entire life Devoted to Liberate Radha from Flaws 😲..
Viswasruti thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago

Originally posted by: vinnas

Word 👍🏼👏👏👍🏼Exactly Put The Points and Plots 😲which Distracted Me from The Serial 😒😳it was OK a Bit in initial epis to take Liberty like Putana Flight Journey to Open Radha Eyes 😛😆 Kaliya mardhan Realised Don't Get illusions like It's Going Proper Route To Purans 😕👍🏼. No more Any one It's Aayan and Jatila The Whole villains/Demons in Dwapar Yug 😈 Krishna entire life Devoted to Liberate Radha from Flaws 😲..

Lata🤗, I used to think that the show was okay because of the grandeur of the sets and the highly talented lead actors[ please don't misunderstand me that I am referring to Jatila and Aayn,-- for the creatives, it seems they are the leads!!!🤣, but not for many of us!] but the ridiculous level has now passed way beyond infinity!!

Now they introduced us to the Bhang plant which was invented only 1000 BC , and Krishna descended to earth sometime between 6000 BC and 5000BC. but there is one scholar, archeologist B.B. Lal who has given the Mahabharata[ Bhagavata] date as between --1200- 600 BC!! So let us believe that the creatives did enough research and following this theory!

I have decided to surrender in front of the logical thinking of the creatives once--- they made Radha ' The Goddess of Love' as Rishi Shounaka[ who sat obediently at Naimisharanya in front of Sootha Mahamuni to listen to Mahabharatha!!] to listen to Vishnu Avtaar stories from Kid Krishna!!! Now it's an educational serial for us!! Krishna subconsciously gives Radha such gyaan who finally will realise one day that the real meaning of 'Prem' and Krishna's life goal of teaching love to her will be fulfilled!! Searching hard for Love since the beginning of the serial! Why Balram is roaming here and there listlessly for a long time, I can't imagine!! In actuality, he was a serious person who never tolerated any sort of nonsense from anyone including Krishna. In Mahabharat and in Bhagavath he reprimanded even Krishna in many occasions! They made him a comic character here!

Agree with you, they brought all the villans of Dwapar yug in front of our eyes to move this serial further and farther!! 😊

Edited by Viswasruti - 6 years ago
RainFire125 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago

Originally posted by: Viswasruti

Lata🤗, I used to think that the show was okay because of the grandeur of the sets and the highly talented lead actors[ please don't misunderstand me that I am referring to Jatila and Aayn,-- for the creatives, it seems they are the leads!!!🤣, but not for many of us!🤪] , but the ridiculous level has now passed way beyond infinity!!

Now they introduced us to the Bhang plant which was invented only 1000 BC , and Krishna descended to earth sometime between 6000 BC and 5000BC. but there is one scholar, archeologist B.B. Lal who has given the Mahabharata[ Bhagavata ] date as between --1200- 600 BC!! So let us believe that the creatives did enough research and following this theory!

I have decided to surrender in front of the logical thinking of the creatives once--- they made Radha ' The Goddess of Love' as Rishi Shounaka[ who sat obediently at Naimisharanya in front of Sootha Mahamuni to listen to Mahabharatha!!! ] to listen to Vishnu Avtaar stories from Kid Krishna!!! Now it's an educational serial for us!! Krishna subconsciously gives Radha such gyaan who finally will realise one day that the real meaning of 'Prem' and Krishna's life goal of teaching love to her will be fulfilled!! Searching hard for Love since the beginning of the serial! Why Balram is roaming here and there listlessly for a long time, I can't imagine!! In actuality, he was a serious person who never tolerated any sort of nonsense from anyone including Krishna. In Mahabharat and in Bhagavath he reprimanded even Krishna in many occasions! They made him a comic character here!

Agree with you, they brought all the villans of Dwapar yug in front of our eyes to move this serial further and farther!! 😊

BRAVO PEOPLE BRAVO!!!!! Loved the critic :) :)

stormborn thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 6 years ago

Recently Krishna talked about how punyavan Ugrapad is (biggest punya probably blackmailing Vrishban into marrying Radha to Ayan after knowing that Ayan was a murderer) and how Ayan is still redeemable.

Meri bas is Krishna se ek hi prashn hai------Bechare Sishupal ki kya galti thi ? sirf 100 paap hi toh kiya tha bachhe ne. Way less than Ayan. Us gareeb ko kyun maare yaar ?

Viswasruti thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago

Originally posted by: RainFire125

BRAVO PEOPLE BRAVO!!!!! Loved the critic :) :)

Thank you Gayatri . After a long time this interaction!🤗

Yesterday while watching the serial I was shocked!😲 This Ayan is quite at ease deceiving the Ashtavakra Muni! If the Muni has a power to curse, can't he able to see the wrong intentions of this Ayan? Where they are taking this serial? What will be their logical conclusions??? Beyond my perception!

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".