Diverging paths? 13.4.2015 - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

53

Views

4.2k

Users

13

Likes

407

Frequent Posters

MrDarcyfan thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 10 years ago
#11

Originally posted by: KhatamKahani

Tell me, how is closing that file going to protect her from Shashi Kapoor? She has already already in danger from Shashi Kapoor while she is with him. So how is he protecting her by closing that file?

He is wrong! Wrong! Wrong! Wrong! She held his hand and for whatever reason he said to close it. It is not excusable at all. It doesn't even make any sense.Oh, Shashi Kapoor will find it and out his secret, perhaps? Tell Jannat the truth? 😆 Is he worried that in her state it's not good for her to hear the truth? Are these the excuses? And he is continuing on this charade with no issues.



Yeah she "Held" his hand and he DECIDED to make sure that she NEVER finds out who she really is! That must have been done for HER protection! YES! This gentlemen gets more and more SELFLESS each day! The man is a criminal! Full stop!

Everyone cares about this predators so called "Heartbreak!" But no one cares about EXPLOITED Sanam! No she is NOT a person, just an "Object" called Jannat that Shaad is keeping in his house for decoration!
Edited by MrDarcyfan - 10 years ago
AnnzSageflower7 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 10 years ago
#12

Originally posted by: MrDarcyfan

Sage, I give you credit for watching that "Leg sucking" (Just as I predicted that is what the snake bite was for. 🤢) and "Hugging" scene without being sick! Good on you for getting though it! Has Sanam's REAL husband sucked her foot? I bet not! 🤢


Hey Mandy !😳

It didn't look sickening (to me, at least)
It looked like he was terrified and panicking at seeing her like that.

That HUG? Ugh... I hated it. It made me feel ill.

You know I have issues with Jannat and her vacant self.
It should be a cautionary tale, her naive trusting despite no recollection of anyone whatsoever.

I only see a Predator who is using a women for his own benefit. Keeping her with no identity as "Jannat". The identity that HE gave her. "Cancel the report", clearly indicates that he made a "Choice". I don't believe all this "Spur of the moment" stuff. There is nothing spur of the moment about it. Is he a "Child" to act on impulse like this? He is a trained solider. He has committed a crime against this women. THAT is what he did by cancelling the report.

I really think he was about to leave the ambulance to deal with that call from the officer, about her missing person report. He stood up already.

But that grab she made for his hand?

it said, "Don't go. Stay with me please..."

Why did he say, "Cancel the report ? "

WHy not, "Not right now, I'll call you back, We'll right in the middle of something here..."

He better have a conscience attack soon.



He is a selfish man who wants to keep this women "Trapped" with him with lies and through fraud. HE is the only one who knows she is not Jannat, and he is using it to his FULL advantage! I cant believe they play songs and try to show the exploitation of a women as "Romantic". Sickening.

True. Just because he is a cute person, doesn't make the GIANT error of judgement he made about Jannat okay.

This is not love. It is not even Lust! It is clear obsession! The man is obsessed! He has effectively "Kidnapped" a displaced women without identity and now keeping her trapped without ever being able to be found! I bet next he will start to take advantage of her too. We will soon see a Suhaag Raat! Coz now he intends to keep her with him, why would he keep distance? It's not like he has morals that prevent him? The man is nothing but a predator and a pervert! So I have NO sympathy for anything he faces in future! Heartbreak? Please! The man is a criminal! No better than someone like Faiz! His actions are a SHAME to the Army and I hope to see him court-marshaled and then JAILED!

I don't know if its lust, or love or even obsession.

The interpersonal characterization between Shaad and Jannat has been weak and unengaging to me. I don't see their relationship as something gripping.

All we've seen is misunderstanding because of that FIRST lie and second hand memories of Aahil superimposed upon Shaad.

Nothing even remotely CUTE about him! Shaad is a man who has no morals and is a predator and such men belong in JAIL, not Pedestals!

He is in this delusion that he is the only one who can keep Jannat safe.

Maybe he hangs on to this delusion until she regains her own memories.

Then will be his come uppance.



I have basically disabled the notion that Shaad, the army major is a perfect gentleman who follows all rules correctly.

Most QH heroes have questionable traits in themselves.

Asad was a judgemental straight laced guy who insisted everyone in his family must look correct and respectable by his rules.

Aahil was a philandering brat who respected no one but his Ammi. In anger he mistreated his innocent wife Sanam most abominably.

Rehan, was a lovely, honest, kind hearted, sincere man. But he hid the secret of his mother, and watched as she deceived Aahil and kept him emotionally blackmailed under her thumb.

Rahat was a coward who left a woman, Haya, who loved him most sincerely and trustingly, because his brother Faiz wanted her too. He found out she loved him but couldn't face and fight for her, choosing to walk away instead.

Now, Shaad, assumed himself an authority over Jannat's wellbeing. Just because she trustingly believed his one lie, he thinks he can keep her. He is going to pay very dearly when he is found out.

Edited by sageflower7 - 10 years ago
KhatamKahani thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#13
But Sage, you really cannot compare any of.the QH heroes or parallel leads with what's going on now. Closest may be Rahat who initially was not truthful to Haya on the Halala marriage. But even that is nothing compared to this.
Edited by KhatamKahani - 10 years ago
Jiyaaa..... thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#14
In my view, Shaad is not a common man. He is in army. Closing the missing person case is a crime. I don't buy any explanation for this action. This guy needs to understand that she could be someone's wife, sister, daughter or mother who is waiting for her return.

Anyway, I see that he will turn negative...When Aahil comes in the picture, his sacchi mohabat for Janat will turn in to obsession for sure.

What I liked about today's episode. Aahil and Sanam 2 scene. It was a power packed performance by KVB and Aditi Gupta. I am totally impressed with Aditi today. She was good. Her posture, voice modulation, expression everything was spot on.

I am happy to see KVB in power packed role again.

Precap is too good. Aahil and Sanam 2 holding each other's throat. can't wait..

Beside Shaad's action, what I despise about pak track...Sanam and Mishab scenes. It is so boring. Yawn! Looks like we will see those in coming weeks 👎🏼

@KK and MrDarcyfan...Couldn't agree with you more..my views about Shaad are exactly the same.
Edited by Jiyaaa..... - 10 years ago
MrDarcyfan thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 10 years ago
#15
@Sage:

Sorry SAGE! This is NOT an "Error of judgement!". He has committed a CRIME! Because he chose to close off her file and effectively trap her with him for good!


He is a sleaze who is taking privileges from a women who has NO memory and thinks she is HER HUSBAND? How is this excusable Sage? How is this romantic, and HOW can anyone allow this to be appreciated? This man is a predator!


As for having an "Attack of conscience?". NO WAY! That is never going to happen. He has no conscience! If he did, he would not have done what he has done. There is no redemption for him and he cannot be compared to Asad, Aahil and Rahat etc. They had their flaws but they never CONNED anyone and definitely did not pretend to be someone's husband and keep them TRAPPED in their house! Please don't compare this criminal to those guys! They never took advantage of any women. (Anything that happened was always with their consent and full knowledge). But this man has, and CONTINUES to do so!


Also, I think it has now been established that he is NOT a Hero!
Edited by MrDarcyfan - 10 years ago
AnnzSageflower7 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 10 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: chicksoup



Sage!

🤗 How R U doing? My heart is getting ripped apart!😭

😆

I'm okay Soup! A little swamped with work but finding time in between things to come up here...😉
Addict behaviour.😆

Thanx for that Snake Bite Tip.😉

Shaad: Sucking Venom...No romance there...But points for trying his best to keep her alive.../ A pity that the Army Takes First Aid lessons from Bollywood- Hardly his fault!😳.😆

VT was better on Friday...and he is good in the adrenaline scenes..Take him back to Misbah and Phoophi...He doesn't belong there🥱. Guy is better as G.I Joe.

Taking Sanam off the system- Can't ignore the fact that he knows Shashi Kapoor will smell the rat (mouse?) on the database...He just does not want any more info on her out there any more.

Interesting thought.
So he may have cancelled the report because he didn't want " Shashi Kapoor" to find out Jannat isn't who she says she is... plausible.

But it didn't look like that.
It looked like he wanted to create a bubble around Jannat. One where only he can go in and out.

it would have looked better if he made the missing report a covert one, or taken it up himself instead of official lines.

His lines are always contradictory, " I know "Us" is a lie, but my feelings for you are true."
"You may not even be Jannat, but you are my Jannat..."

All leaning towards misguided unhealthy "Saviour- Victim" dynamics.


Sanam- Jannatification of Sanam seems complete.😭 I hope we don't get more of these hugs...But Ahilji has to witness this too..🤢...So there is more coming up...Getting ready to cringe more n more for the sake of...Entertainment?😲🤢

I know right??
Where is our Sanam?? I want her back!
I'm dreading the meeting of this pale whimpering Jannat with Aahil.

She isn't even Ms Dhabewalli anymore.
i hate what the writers have done to Sanam.

Phoophi- Long lost sister of Shireen?😕 What does she want? SK to kill everyone in Shaad's family and get her Misbah back? She doesn't think of confiding in her Major nephew? Poor Shaad- The phoophi takes after his dad...thinks he is useless probably!

Exactly ! I mean, Shashi Kapoor doesn't even look that dangerous. Armed with garden tongs and scary stares. Please.

Fact- The Pak track is draining me out.🤔
We have only more Shashi Kapoor mischief to look forward to. Yawn.
Feel bad for AmG, SK is not a step up from Tanveer.

Ahil- 🥳 What a variety of expressions..👏 So glad KV stuck around..for whatever...That beard..That stubble...How did I miss that on Friday?
The walk- the talk- Handling the press👏- Allah Miyaan!😳

I was amazed that he didn't freak out and run.
I mean he just shot his "wife" in the office with so many witnesses seeing him standing there holding the gun.

Coolly, he makes a no comment statement to the press and goes to the hospital.
😆
Wonder where that's heading...

Chudail- I take back my words about Additi not having anything to do in QH. 😳 She was awesome yesterday.👏 You talked about voice modulation- I thought about that while watching Additi.👏

Her " Aahil Jeee..." is sounding really creepy now isn't it?😆
she looks gorgeous and downright psycho at the same time...Yipes..



AnnzSageflower7 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 10 years ago
#17

Originally posted by: Jiyaaa...

QH Precap 😊

[YOUTUBE]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9L12exf4a6U[/YOUTUBE]


Awesome to see Aahil still uncowed by Sanam2.
But her guts, my goodness.

Is there such a thing as negative chemistry?😆
Loads of it here...👏
AnnzSageflower7 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 10 years ago
#18

Originally posted by: MrDarcyfan



KK there is no excuse for what he has done so far and NOW, there clearly is no excuse left? All this poor lover crap? Please! He has known her what 2, maybe 3 weeks? HE gets to decide if she meets her family, her loved one's again? WHO is he, to make that CHOICE for her? Forget it! The guy is now a criminal! End of story!


I agree with you, that his love confessed came out of the blue.
They didn't take the time to make Shaad and Jannat as a believable love story.

Actually, maybe we should be thankful they didn't.

This way its clear,

1. Jannat doesn't remember anything, only vague memories of someone who really loves her. And her memories don't match that of Shaad's.

2. Shaad, went from arm's length distance, to professing love under duress on his knees, to crying his love for her in 3 weeks.

Fact remains: Jannat is Sanam. Sanam is Aahil's wife.

I'm curious about the hallucinations and delusions Jannat will have with the medication. Will she remember her previous life?

Again, it doesn't have to be memories of Aahil. It could be of Seher, or Badi Ammi or Haya. But they will keep using vague memories of Aahil to taunt us, with the presence of Shaad's deception.

I'm not saying what Shaad is doing is right, not at all.
it's not even the slightest bit right. Very wrong.
I'm not saying its romantic at all.

What I am saying is, Shaad is falling in love with the wrong girl, and going about it wrongly.


MrDarcyfan thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 10 years ago
#19
@Sage:

What I am saying is that Shaad is NOT falling in love, he is in "Obsession" and he has a "Savior complex". Also, he HIMSELF put himself in this position. So whatever comes with it, he will have to wear. Including crying a few crocodile tears when her real husband takes her away!
KhatamKahani thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#20
Sagey, what I'm saying is that it could have never been a believable love story from the time he kept up the lie of being her husband. (Also from the time she acted like a bimbo and didn't question her condition, wonder about obvious things, etc etc).

Also when did he keep her at arm's length really? He really hasn't. This is why I said about two weeks back that he's hardly acting like someone who's been cornered in a lie and mistake of his own making. The possible answer to this came that he is easily falling into his own lie and delusion.

So either way, how could this have been a believable love story?
Edited by KhatamKahani - 10 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".