MM article -Shaad to reunite saHil Mod Note Pg 13

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

Mandy

@MrDarcyfan

Stunner

+ 6

Posted: 10 years ago

#51

Originally posted by: Nikita_Smith
Shaad's character is ruined? I actually find him to be a much better human being than most of the characters on this show ever were. Nevermind, different people different perspectives.
@Rein Am also actually hoping that we get to see a Shaad-Seher love story in future. But I doubt the quality of writing then would be just as good as it is now to be able to pull it off. I don't want Shaad to have the same tragic end as Rehaan.

If you had Amenisa and a man tells you he is your husband, then you go to live with him, act as his wife, stay in his room, sleep in his bed, and THEN suddenly you find out he LIED to you all this time? Will you then think he is a "much better human being" than most? I doubt it! It's very easy to theorise when something is not happening to you, or someone you know! In NORMAL circumstances, his actions would not have been excused! So I don't see why it should be now!

You say he is so good, but what is it that he has done that is so good? ALL this time it has been about his mission and his goal! Even when he feels guilty, he surpresses his conscience and continues doing the same thing! He is even romancing her now, knowing full well she probably has a past! If he is SO much better than so many people, by now he would have told her the truth! He has not. So that pretty much sums it up for me! REHAN was a million times better than him!

Quote

SheAish

@SheAish

Voyager

Posted: 10 years ago

#52

WTH, Sanam is no piece of meat to be dolled up and romanced without giving her a choice as to whether she wants this or not....

I can't believe we as women don't feel for this girl who is being put in compromising situations with a total stranger WITHOUT a choice...She has no choice as along as she is not told the truth...Ughhh😡

Shaad in this sense is the worst character apart from the vamps and villians that Q2 and Q3 has seen so far...

And some have been actually saying that who ever Sanam belongs to Jannat is Shaad's...

Nah...NOTHING of Sanam is Shaads, except the fake name Jannat given by him...

Neither her caring, affection, friendship, companionship...nothing she is offering Shaad right now is being offered by her in her full knowledge...all is usurped under a lie...

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Mandy

@MrDarcyfan

Stunner

+ 6

Posted: 10 years ago

#53

@KK:

I am not looking for jealousy KK! I am looking to see the emotional upheaval of Sanam and also Aahil! When Sanam meets Aahil, she dosent recongise him. But she will know that he is her husband, coz maybe she gets proof? But if Shaad had told her the truth, then she would think of Shaad as the ONLY person she knows and trusts!

She will be emotionally close to him, and distant from Aahil! THAT would have been the issue and eventually the story is how she bridges the gap! Or more like how HE does it! Of course he will feel jealous or insecure sometimes, that his wife is leaning on another man! That is natural! It dosent have to be some HIGH drama of jealousy or SICK like RAHAFA! God save us from that PLEASE! Rehem Karo! Not THAT again!

Quote

Reine Lobo

@Rein123

Rocker

Posted: 10 years ago

#54

Originally posted by: KhatamKahani

😲😲😲

Where was this earlier?

And what exactly had he been doing all this while? Oh, just because he knows for sure now she's married, then only he is obligated to back off?

OK so now you want him to go on lying to her and keep pursuing her even after knowing that's she's involved with another guy?? What is your stand exactly?? I've made mine clear in the above post while yours is still quite ambiguous.

Edited by Rein123 - 10 years ago

Quote

KhatamKahani

@KhatamKahani

Stunner

Posted: 10 years ago

#55

Originally posted by: Rein123

OK so now you want him to go on lying to her and keep pursuing her even after knowing that's she's involved with another guy?? What is your stand exactly?? I've made mine clear in the above post while yours is still quite ambiguous.

My stand is ambiguous? No, my stand is not ambiguous? I've made clear where I stand numerous times and didn't see-saw back and forth.

I don't have to hope for anything. I am saying that the BS excuses given are just that BS. You want to know why I said that? Because you called into question his need to be redeemed, saying he doesn't need to be redeemed. No, what he is doing right now is quite revolting. And yet, here you are, saying he hasn't done anything wrong, it's only from the point onward of him finding out that she's someone's wife where he would be wrong. You are ignoring all he has done till now, making light of it.

Let me finish going through this thread.

Quote

KhatamKahani

@KhatamKahani

Stunner

Posted: 10 years ago

#56

Originally posted by: MrDarcyfan
@KK:
I am not looking for jealousy KK! I am looking to see the emotional upheaval of Sanam and also Aahil! When Sanam meets Aahil, she dosent recongise him. But she will know that he is her husband, coz maybe she gets proof? But if Shaad had told her the truth, then she would think of Shaad as the ONLY person she knows and trusts!

She will be emotionally close to him, and distant from Aahil! THAT would have been the issue and eventually the story is how she bridges the gap! Or more like how HE does it! Of course he will feel jealous or insecure sometimes, that his wife is leaning on another man! That is natural! It dosent have to be some HIGH drama of jealousy or SICK like RAHAFA! God save us from that PLEASE! Rehem Karo! Not THAT again!

Mandy, I know your scenario and what you've talked many times in the past two-three weeks about is not a jealousy track. i was just replying because it needed to be made clear.

Quote

sahil333

@sahil333

Inactive

Posted: 10 years ago

#57

WTH, Sanam is no piece of meat to be dolled up and romanced without giving her a choice as to whether she wants this or not....

Shaad in this sense is the worst character apart from the vamps and villians that Q2 and Q3 has seen so far...

And some have been actually saying that who ever Sanam belongs to Jannat is Shaad's...

Nah...NOTHING of Sanam is Shaads, except the fake name Jannat given by him...

Neither her caring, affection, friendship, companionship...nothing she is offering Shaad right now is being offered by her in her full knowledge...all is usurped under a lie...

[/QUOTE

👍🏼👏

The Truth...the truth...Every word you said is THE TRUTH!

@pink...it boggles my mind, really!!!

Quote

Mandy

@MrDarcyfan

Stunner

+ 6

Posted: 10 years ago

#58

Originally posted by: Rein123
R]
I don't understand what your point is with the above statement? However, I'm sure you wouldn't like it if people trashed and wished ill upon a character that you like? It wouldn't hurt to show some sensitivity, that's all. Then again, it's up to you. Those comments are what makes I-F, I-F after all.

Well like we can see they just don't care as they aren't his fans hence I wonder if it would be considered fair enough if we wished something like Sahil ending up getting killed by Tanveer's daughter?? You know what if that actually happens I surely wouldn't care either!!

We are fully aware of what Shaad fans want for Aahil! They want him to DIE so Shaad can get Sanam for free! That was made more than clear a few weeks back! Us SAHIL fans were supposed to smile and take it, even though we had watched them for 11 months! People who had only seen Shaad for 2 weeks had no empathy for us!

Yes I am sure you don't CARE if they kill SAHIL! But I don't think even Gul Khan is stupid enough to do that now!

At least you got to see them that long while we hardly had enough of Sehaan. Dont give me that crap of being empathetic towards others as quite a lot of you guys wanted Seher to end up being killed even after knowing how that would affect her fans and I'm quite sure that you'll were happy when Rehaan ended up dying as you finally got what you wanted I.e. Qubool Hai without Sehaan. So you know what Congratz!! Your wish has come true.. And speaking of Gul khan well her CVS are actually stupid for coming up with a track like this in the first place so yeah I won't be surprised if she did actually kill Sahil..

@Rein123:

PLEASE keep your OFFENSIVE and UNTRUE comment to yourself! I was NEVER against SEHAN! I liked them! I even liked Seher! I even defended her, when most SAHIL fans didn't!

You clearly know NOTHING about me! So please don't assume! Go to my singnature and open my INDEX! You will see a story there called "Yeh Dooriyan!". THAT is an SS I wrote ALL about SEHAN! I even dedicated it to Rehan when he was killed! I loved Rehan! I was depressed when he died! You have really offended me by saying was Celebrating when he died! Seriously! Know your limit!

Edited by MrDarcyfan - 10 years ago

Quote

KhatamKahani

@KhatamKahani

Stunner

Posted: 10 years ago

#59

Originally posted by: Rein123

Oh!! Even if that's true why does it bother you so much??? Or is it that you your self wanted this track just because it suits your taste?? I like Shajan as a couple but I know that they wouldn't end up together even if I'd want them hence yes I had maintained it from the very beggining that the entire track sucks and that it should have been Seher in place of Sanam ending up in Pakistan. And whether you like it or not sanam/Jannat does in fact look better with Shaad that's my personal opinion which I am pretty much entitled to voice or change on this forum. And yes when I said sanam ending up with Shaad it was if they had decided to end Ahil's character not otherwise.. I would rather see Shaad not getting involved with Sahil as I believe he deserves better.

This is rich! Completely rich!

Did you even read what Mandy wrote? Did you read what she'd written earlier too regarding the way the triangle should've gone?

Okay, maybe you haven't read through our posts and threads. (Though I doubt it.)

How conveniently you ignore that we are the ones protesting and we are the ones STILL protesting and complaining about Shaad's characterization and weak character. Listen, the day KVB was officially back, you know what we did? We had a thread where we wrote what was wrong with the story and characterization. WE are the ones who are criticizing and asking to fix Shaad and the situation. We are the ones who are saying how this is still a violative situation and revolting situation.

We are the ones who have done this, and kept on doing this, and are still doing this.

Nowhere have I seen anyone hope for Shaad to keep taking advantage of Jannat. What we are saying is that things have gone too far already, unlike what you are saying. You want to excuse everything, just like it was excused and ignored from early on. And that is what you are still doing.

And you say, we want Sanam to remain in this situation. No, we are criticizing the story, which has already been too far gone and ruined, and trying to find a way to fix it--that too WITHOUT dear precious Shaad turned into a villain.

You should've criticized the story and characterization early on. If not early on, then later. If not later, then now.

But that is still not what YOU are doing. You are defending his actions and excusing them and making light of the gravity of what's happening even now.

Edited by KhatamKahani - 10 years ago