Marriage; a lifetime contract. - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

23

Views

2.4k

Users

11

Likes

51

Frequent Posters

sheilasandhu thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#11

Originally posted by: ...Binish...

Marriage is not a game; it's a serious institution and a lifetime contract. Contract marriages were practiced in pre-Arab time period bcz of certain reasons. These were not encouraged by any of the Prophets of Islam. Contract marriage means that the marriage will automatically end when the certain time period of its contract gets over.

If it's allowed then lots of people for fun or just to experiment would be going for it. And if they do so then it is equal to make fun of Islam and the institution of marriage.

Gul shouldn't promote this concept of contract marriage. She is using religion in the wrong way and it's extremely bad of her.

You may have different opinions but being a Muslim I know that what she is showing is not true. I understand that it's a fictional show but many people who don't know abt Islam, after seeing all this crap will form negative opinions abt it considering everything to be true.


Totally agree with you. Religions all or any should never be shown in BAD light.
...Binish... thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#12

Originally posted by: -KSGsmitten-


They are not showing anything against Islam. I'm a Muslim and i would have quit the show if they had, at once. They are just trying to portray what wrong happens in the name of religion in Muslim CULTURE. They are not promoting anything wrong and they'd explain it in the coming episodes I'm sure.
We just have to be a bit patient with QH. 😊


As you have read in my post, I am objecting the concept of CONTRACT MARRIAGE throughout, but suppose they don't go with contract marriage and sign divorce papers only, still they are going to live together as a couple in the eyes of everyone.

I didn't intend to go into detail but when you have pointed out the fact that they are not showing anything against Islam then please do tell me one thing? Does Islam allow to live with the person with whom you have no relation???

Whether the marriage takes place or not Zoya is going to live with Ayan as her wife when she is actually NOT. They are doing it for fake but in front of society, they are legally married. Is this something right to show?? They might not be having any physical relationship as a husband and wife but is it allowed to maintain a fake marriage in front of whole society just to mend the broken rishta of another girl??? Is it correct to cheat everyone in trying to appease one greedy woman??? Does Islam allow all that???

...Binish... thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: -Shayari-

But they aren't married.

Why are people missing the fact that zoyaan aren't married cause even if they sign nikahnama, Zoya is Zoya farooqui and even they do sign nikah bana as Zoya farooqui and ayan Ahmed khan the real nikah is the way it's done properly with qazi reading and asking the couple if they accept. Here the two are confirming a nikah that never happened so how are they marrying?

And forget tat but even if Zoya is married. Why csnt she get divorced? That's the thing isn't it should these pathar ki lakeer rules be changed? Marriage isn't binding. It can he broken if it's unwanted. In fact it should be because marriage doesn't mean accepting a lifetime of unhappiness. If it's accidental and unwanted a couple has every right to get out of it if they want to.

I'm not Islamic so forgive me if I say anything that's wrong or hurtful cause I don't meant to be but I just think that what the cvs are showing is a rather important social message. Marriage u can sign papers and put names together but you cant force two hearts together. Unwanted marriages should be able to be broken. Cause ultimately what's important is the two people in the marriage and where their happiness lies.


ZoYaan are not married at first place I know that. 😊
But I am saying if they go with the concept of contract marriage acc to which the marriage after specific time period will be void, then it is not allowed. And to marry someone Only to get divorce afterwards is NOT allowed in Islam and Contract Marriage means the same.

First, there is no concept of accidental marriage. And yes the marriage can be broken when it is unwanted or unbearable for you to carry on but it's a respectable institution in the view of Islam; once the marriage is done couple should try their best to maintain it for its sanctity but still if they can't then it can be broken. Divorce is allowed in Islam but it should be avoided at the very best of the couple and there might be certain imp reasons for that.

Whether the couple is happy or not in a marriage, after the divorce their feelings, sentiments and hopes are shattered.
Woman especially has to face a lot after her divorce, she is labeled as a divorced woman.
In one of the previous episodes Shireen called Dilshad as "chori hui aurat" and Dilshad called Shireen, "dusri aurat". Our conservative society put these kind of offensive labels on women after they get divorced or when they get married for the 2nd time. It is sad and shouldn't be like that, but it's the bitter reality which exists in our society even in today's modern era.

I hope you get my points.😊
Edited by ...Binish... - 11 years ago
Meaningful thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#14
What ever may be the religion, showing a accidental marriage, and then showing the religious heads make it a serious affair just because they wanted to prove their superiority is foolish and not a healthy scenario.
I was just thinking, what if ayan and zoya were married to their respective partners before this kind of accident happened? Would they leave their husband/wife and become a couple because of this accident, and would the religious heads force them in such situation?

This is utter crap, i wish gul closes the curtains on this show, before making a complete mokery of marriage, religion and sentiments of fans.
...Binish... thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: Meaningful

What ever may be the religion, showing a accidental marriage, and then showing the religious heads make it a serious affair just because they wanted to prove their superiority is foolish and not a healthy scenario.

I was just thinking, what if ayan and zoya were married to their respective partners before this kind of accident happened? Would they leave their husband/wife and become a couple because of this accident, and would the religious heads force them in such situation?

This is utter crap, i wish gul closes the curtains on this show, before making a complete mokery of marriage, religion and sentiments of fans.


Instead of showing the proper legal procedure of marriage, they are making fun of it by not showing its sanctity and value. First, marriage cancelled for so many times and now it happened but with wrong persons in accidental manner. There's no concept of accidental marriage, or contract marriage in Islam.They may clear everything afterwards but what they are showing right now is totally crap.
machar13 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#16
@binish: think you got this switched...


In one of the previous episodes Dilshad called Shireen as "chori hui aurat" and Shireen called her, "dusri aurat". Our conservative society put these kind of offensive labels on women after they get divorced or when they get married for the 2nd time. It is sad and shouldn't be like that, but it's the bitter reality which exists in our society even in today's modern era.

@binish: actually didn't ..dilshaad called shireen doosri aurat and shirin called dilshad chori hui aurat...?

I don't like the mockery of marriage which has been my pinched nerve on this show..I'm being patient now and like to see how they fix this without offending..they r not married but how they get to prove that and get back to asya and ayra will be curious to see.
Edited by machar13 - 11 years ago
...Binish... thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#17

Originally posted by: machar13

@binish: think you got this switched...


In one of the previous episodes Dilshad called Shireen as "chori hui aurat" and Shireen called her, "dusri aurat". Our conservative society put these kind of offensive labels on women after they get divorced or when they get married for the 2nd time. It is sad and shouldn't be like that, but it's the bitter reality which exists in our society even in today's modern era.

@binish: actually didn't ..dilshaad called shireen doosri aurat and shirin called dilshad chori hui aurat...?

I don't like the mockery of marriage which has been my pinched nerve on this show..I'm being patient now and like to see how they fix this without offending..they r not married but how they get to prove that and get back to asya and ayra will be curious to see.


oh ya, thanks for telling I am going to edit it.

I hope they give justification for everything later, for all that they are showing right now.
...Binish... thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#18

Originally posted by: aksasya

I FULLY AGREE WITH YOU...I AM A NON MUSLIM...SO I DON'T KNW ABT ISLAM RULES...IF THEY ARE SHOWING ALL THIS WHICH IS AGAINST ISLAM ,IT IS GIVING US A FALSE MSG ABT THE RELIGION...THEY SHOULD NOT BRING RELIGION INTO THIS...


Thanks for agreeing with me.😊
...Binish... thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#19

She should straighten everything to clear all misunderstandings and doubts taking place in people's minds.
...Binish... thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#20

Originally posted by: CHAYMA

totally agree with you she is giving a wrong image about islam there is No marriage by mistake or accident ...marriage is of great significance in Islam and they are just giving a bad image of the relgion as a muslim i know that it's not true because i know my religion and i know that woman are not taking for granted in islam no one can force a woman to marry if she doesn't want to besides how on earth the nikah of ayan and zoya is a valid one i feel that they are insulting islam by taking such an important institution ike marriage so lightly


Thanks for agreeing with me.
I know that their marriage is not valid but if they go with contract marriage then it's not allowed in Islam. Marriage by accident or by mistake too has no concept. It is extremely bad and unethical to live with the person with whom you have no relation in the view of Islam. Zoya won't be having any physical relationship with Ayan but just to appease hasina bi she is going to live with him in front of whole society as his wife. Islam doesn't allow all that.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".