Originally posted by: monaco
Firstly the biggest fault is of every character's weakness/flaw.
Lets see how this situation came up.
What happened with Humeira and Ayaan was purely destiny (on the road). The love birds went out for some personal time, but got attacked. So, here the mistake is the CVs, or Muqaddar. :)
The next fault is of Zoya. She is always impulsive and in a Save the world mode. Her intentions were right, but, she was rash and it is one big big mistake now that has put so many lives at stake.
Then, the biggest fault is of Shirin - who has fed into Nikhat that she is good for nothing, causing her to take the extreme step.
Then, is Ayaan. Who was selfish to objectify his own bhabhi and ask her for saving his sister's life. After having known how much Asad and Zoya have been through, and being in love himself, he should not have asked this from him.
Asad's fault is not that he is making the sacrifice. He is gullible (and as Vikrant says, has always been taken for granted) and emotionally challenged. He has been deprived of love and always been the giver. So, he is compelled in his own morality and righteousness to do what has to be done. His fault is that he is (along with Ayaan) becoming insensitive to what Zoya wants at the moment.
Zoya is an orphan, who has no one to watch her best interest right now. Dilshaad is clueless, and her own aapi jiju are not around. she only has Asad to bank on, and just in a matter of few minutes, Asad has decided to drop Zoya off in this house, where she was once accused of murder, and slapped twice, and he himself knows the kind of people Razia and team are. Zoya is pleading Asad to not make her go through this - but being emotionally manipulated himself into believing this is the only way to save his sister, he is making her go through it. That is wrong.
Zoya wants to explain to everyone and clear the confusion.
He does not.
(atleast so it seems).
I am not angry at Asad for the sacrifice. I have a problem with the fact that Zoya is unwilling to do this, but still has to go through this.
As such, all three are at a loss - Ayaan, Asad and Zoya. No one gains from this arrangement, not even Nikhat in my opinion. Only Haseena does.
And, all three are to blame. In a way each's negative trait - Ayaan's taking Asad for granted, Zoya's impulsiveness and Asad's emotionally wrecked background - have brought them here.
No one is right, no one is wrong. All are right, and all are wrong.
Ayaan was clueless and is making a sacrifice for his sister. He hasn't even spoken to Humeira yet. How will he face her again? How will he face his brother again?
Zoya brought this upon herself. Yes, but should a woman be punished so harshly for a mistake of hers, that was originally only for saving your sister? But even now she has not told Asad the truth. /hiding the fact that Imran is the father of Tanveer's baby - is NOT RIGHT. No matter what her intention. If not anything Zoya should learn not to hide anything from Asad.
Asad is wrong too - not in doing what he did, but in oversimplifying a complex problem. I dont blame him, because he is too shocked to think straight either, but, I can not totally say that he is not at fault at all.
My sypmathies are with all three, but so is my anger.
But there is one person I have no sympathy and all anger - producer, Gul Khan. She really has made a mockery of Islam, marriage, and most sadly, women. Zoya who was supposed to be a proggressive, modern woman has been victimized and manipulated into doing something she detested IN THE VERY first episode. The Zoya I knew would not have done this.
