Unpopular opinion: Imran's characterization - Page 4

Originally posted by: whirl

imran and najma broke up with a stupid reason really...it seems their relation was so weak and doubtful...that's why their do this very easily...imran was a very weak person he cannot express his feeling infront of his family...but he was responsible for nikhat's condition..because he can't tells her what's in his heart...i hope in upcoming episode he stands for najma and his love...if he really loves najma he definitely fight against odd ones...this is high time for imran...😎

Najma is equally weak because she can't express her feeling about imran to her mother and brother either. 😆

My opinion Nikhat showed more strength and courage compared to her sister and imran 😃

I agree with u 👏

Originally posted by: penfriend28

what u have said is right...

every one has negative aspect..this serial is showing how their faults are affecting their life and that of those who are related to them...

Originally posted by: MisHumptyDumpty

Good post.

Made me agree. 😆

To an extent yes, if Dev can be shown, why not Imran's?

It was Najma who left him cause of the fear of Asad. To be wrong is Najma! Cause i feel, if she stood up somewhere, Asad and Dilshad would have had accepted the relation, as family and parents do want your happiness nothing more.

As per Tanveer and Imran is concerned, Imraan did say, that it was Tanveer who broke up with him, and now that he is already engaged to Nikhat, he cannot break her heart.

That means he wanted to save the relation - to be Blamed is Tanveer.

But now that Nikhat loves him, and he knows that and also Najma doesn't, why doesn't he stand up for her? Okay you dont love her, then why did you promise her so many things? Then why did you give her so many feelings that you do?? Why did you promise her? Why did you give her false hope?

You wanted to marry her live with her, make her dream this and that, give her false hope and then when she is bring insulted by your mother you like a bheegi billi stand there cause your bachpan ka pyaar ki yaad aa rahi hai?

NONSENSE. 🥱

Personally, i dont approve of Najma and Imran at all 😆 all cause of Haseena Bii 😆

But great way of bringing in the Clash i must say. 😉

p.s. : Loving the feminism tone more over. 😆 All men are so Spineless 😆

Originally posted by: kankabhor

Yeah QH is "Mahabharta" where everyone is grey not like "Ramayana" where everything is either black or white..

I always remember Mahabharta after Sangita made a post relating that and always try to relate QH to Mahabharta.. Crazy I am..

It's as close to realism as we can get on a tv show lol!

Originally posted by: rockztheIF

Since the track has just started, it is too early to pass judgement on his character right now. We need to wait for some more scenes to think whether he is redemption-worthy or not. Surprisingly, Imran is the first character in the show which is grey , all others are in pure black & white (to some extent Tanveer was grey for few initial episodes, but need to check that).

Exactly - he is a grey character and finally we have a back story for the other players in the game.

While I do understand where he's coming from, my only problem is that he isn't able to stand up for himself even now.

Originally posted by: GredandForge

While I do understand where he's coming from, my only problem is that he isn't able to stand up for himself even now.

Najma cited her reasons when she broke up but if he was really in love with her then he should've tried at least once. Whats the point of committing into a relationship if you can't stand for it? I'm not saying that only strong people have the right to be in a relationship but that once you've given into it you shouldn't go down without even trying to change the situation.

Tanveer is probably a one night stand. If she claims its his child then maybe he should try and be responsible for the child? He can get the baby tested later if there were any doubts.

With Nikhat, he tried genuinely and yet he was not going to support her? He wanted to move on with life, he wanted to start a family, how's he going to do so if he succumbs to other people.

Yes he's been made that way. I understand his predicament. I just am not able to stand and see him drown in self pity. Of course its just been a day but still..

The same can be said of najma who knowingly got into a relationship she knew her brother would not approve of. So, I don't hold imran responsible there at all.

With regards to tanveer - if it is his child of course he should stand up for it but his first reaction to tanveer telling him the child was his was that it was not possible because they hasn't been together in months. So, I am going to give him the benefit of the doubt.

Now, Nikhat he has actually wronged and he should most definitely apologize to her. However, his almost uncaring behavior is not spurred by malice - it is driven by fear of his mother and of course his own weakness of character.

I made this post not because I want people to like the character or anything of that sort but because his character actually has been written well with an explanation. Just like asad, zoya and Ayaan had their childhoods scarring and skewing their way of approaching life imran to bears that burden. What is grating to me is the double standard to almost immediately wanting to forgive your leads because they are you leads versus fairly assessing all characters.

As kankabhor pointed out above - none of the characters on this show are perfect. Not one - which is a refreshing change. But to call out one man for not supporting his fianc just because he is imran but support to all that will listen the other who belittled the woman he loved and was engaged to is a tad bit hypocritical.

I am no one to dictate how to watch a show and who to like bit I see characters as characters - I don't like or dislike some one more or less because of the actor playing them or that they are the leads and I need to like them.

I however agree with you on the Nikhat point.