How about if the story went like this... - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

25

Views

4.4k

Users

14

Likes

44

Frequent Posters

Annu.. thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#11


Asad turns to Ayaan and he agrees to marry Zoya with the plan to divorce her. It is upon her marriage to Ayaan that Zoya soon finds out that her father is mamujaan. Mamujaan is delighted to find out who is his true daughter. He thinks Asad married and divorced her to get back at him and embraces her with open arms as Ayaan's new wife.

The relevant point here is that a Halala cannot be planned in advance, as a Nikah between her and the second husband with an understanding of a divorce afterwards will not be valid. If she does so, it will be an illegitimate relationship with the second husband and with the first husband also with whom she comes to live after a pre-planned Halala. The Prophet (Pbuh) has cursed both such men who perform Halala and for whom Halala is performed. The second Caliph Hazrat Umar ruled during his reign that he will punish with stoning to death, those who perform a pre-planned Halala. Imam Sufian Sauri says: " If someone marries a woman to make her Halala (for her ex-husband) and then wants to keep her as wife, he is not permitted to do so unless he solemnises a Nikah afresh, as the previous Nikah was unlawful." (Trimizi)

http://www.islamawareness.net/Talaq/talaq_fatwa0008.html

It is Nikhat and Nuzat who eventually reveal to Asad that Zoya is pure as the snow and that nothing ever happened to Zoya. Will Asad be convinced and willing to love Zoya again and will Dilshaad embrace Zoya again?

A man divorced his wife thrice (by expressing his decision to divorce her thrice), then she married another man who also divorced her. The Prophet was asked if she could legally marry the first husband (or not). The Prophet replied, "No, she cannot marry the first husband unless the second husband consummates his marriage with her, just as the first husband had done." (Bukhari, Volume 7, Book 63, Number 187)

http://www.muftisays.com/qa/question/2668/halala.html

Edited by Annu.. - 12 years ago
Humaya thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#12
I didn't quite understand this part:
They do argue...and then one day the marriage simply falls a part. That is when Asad divorces Zoya who is madly in love with him. A devastated Zoya breaks down and Asad realizes his stupidity and wants to marry her again, but this can only happen if Zoya remarries.

Asad turns to Ayaan and he agrees to marry Zoya with the plan to divorce her. It is upon her marriage to Ayaan that Zoya soon finds out that her father is mamujaan. Mamujaan is delighted to find out who is his true daughter. He thinks Asad married and divorced her to get back at him and embraces her with open arms as Ayaan's new wife.


Why would Zoya have to remarry? And why would Asad make Ayaan marry her?! That's kinda wrong on so many levels. I wouldn't be able to see my sister marry the man I love, even if it is fake.

Originally posted by: ffkhan

It will be awesome if Asad marries Zoya so that she can stay in India to find her father..and even after marriage they will share a good friendship, and after then eventually it will be developed into love.
but whatever, audiences prefer only AsYa and I doubt if there will ever Ayan-Zoya marriage happens bcoz many viewers would stop watching the show then.

There is possibility that Ayan will marry Humaira for the sake of his mother's happiness. After marriage, Ayan's heart will grow fonder for humaira.

There are a lot of viewers who love both Asad-Zoya and Ayan-Humaira as couples. And creatives won't ruin it.

Just my POV.

I like the idea of Asad and Zoya having a fake marriage. It's like the Arnav-Khushi thing. It's been done a lot before but I'm pretty sure it will be done again. And when the "contract marriage" is about to be over, one of them will realize the mis-judged the other person and try to get them back somehow.

I cannot imagine little Humaira evil even for a minute. She's the sweetest little girl. If anything she'd be heartbroken to see Ayaan not love her but I think she'd be a true friend to him. I like the idea of them getting married by Razia and eventually falling in love. They should really focus on two couples and not have a triangle.
Laila2009 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#13
😆😆😆

Originally posted by: Annu..



Asad turns to Ayaan and he agrees to marry Zoya with the plan to divorce her. It is upon her marriage to Ayaan that Zoya soon finds out that her father is mamujaan. Mamujaan is delighted to find out who is his true daughter. He thinks Asad married and divorced her to get back at him and embraces her with open arms as Ayaan's new wife.

The relevant point here is that a Halala cannot be planned in advance, as a Nikah between her and the second husband with an understanding of a divorce afterwards will not be valid. If she does so, it will be an illegitimate relationship with the second husband and with the first husband also with whom she comes to live after a pre-planned Halala. The Prophet (Pbuh) has cursed both such men who perform Halala and for whom Halala is performed. The second Caliph Hazrat Umar ruled during his reign that he will punish with stoning to death, those who perform a pre-planned Halala. Imam Sufian Sauri says: " If someone marries a woman to make her Halala (for her ex-husband) and then wants to keep her as wife, he is not permitted to do so unless he solemnises a Nikah afresh, as the previous Nikah was unlawful." (Trimizi)

http://www.islamawareness.net/Talaq/talaq_fatwa0008.html

It is Nikhat and Nuzat who eventually reveal to Asad that Zoya is pure as the snow and that nothing ever happened to Zoya. Will Asad be convinced and willing to love Zoya again and will Dilshaad embrace Zoya again?

A man divorced his wife thrice (by expressing his decision to divorce her thrice), then she married another man who also divorced her. The Prophet was asked if she could legally marry the first husband (or not). The Prophet replied, "No, she cannot marry the first husband unless the second husband consummates his marriage with her, just as the first husband had done." (Bukhari, Volume 7, Book 63, Number 187)

http://www.muftisays.com/qa/question/2668/halala.html


Well that sucks 😆😆😆 Perhaps that is the reason why Ayaan goes to Asad for help and perhaps asks him to marry Zoya so he can get back together with her. (The orginal Zee Synopsis).

Even though the husband is the one who divorces the wife, it is she who has to pay the price for the (hasty) divorce. It is she who is humiliated by yet another marriage and divorce before they can come back together. Why does only the woman have to marry and get divorced another time before she can be joined again with her original husband? Why not the husband who in most cases initiated and pushed through the first divorce? Why is the wife punished if the husband makes this mistake?

Now apparently, there is rule that three divorces are allowed before the woman has to do this...so we can assume that this is their first divorce 🤣
Laila2009 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#14
OK...we can revise the storyline so we don't violate the laws and upset a bunch of folks out there; here is a possible revision:

Since a divorce is allowed THREE times, the first time Asad and Zoya divorce, she moves out. Now it is not required, we have her move out. That is when she and Ayaan become friends and although Ayaan wants to get her back together with Asad, it during that time he falls in love with her and confusion arises that she had Ayaan are having an affair.

It then Asad feeling deceived in a fit of anger sends the second divorce to Zoya; will he send her the third. We still have her move into the house of Ayaan's family - Rashid invites her - and she finds out that Mamujaan is her father. Maumujaan wants the divorce so she is out of Asad's clutches.

Ayaan is torn; he wants the divorce so he can be with Zoya and Humaira becomes the advocate; realizing she is stirring the pot by presenting an ugly side of Zoya to Asad, is the catalyst behind preventing the third divorce as is Ayaan who insists that is brother instead of destroying his marriage to Zoya with the third divorce (great trp suspense ratings), we have him say "qubool hai" as opposed to talaq a third time to Zoya.

There you are folks. We keep in with Islamic law...but the accepting of Zoya back still brings with it a lot of strain...and we go back to where I left in the original post.
Annu.. thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: Laila2009

😆😆😆


Well that sucks 😆😆😆 Perhaps that is the reason why Ayaan goes to Asad for help and perhaps asks him to marry Zoya so he can get back together with her. (The orginal Zee Synopsis).

again its a pre planned Halala..
Even though the husband is the one who divorces the wife, it is she who has to pay the price for the (hasty) divorce. It is she who is humiliated by yet another marriage and divorce before they can come back together. Why does only the woman have to marry and get divorced another time before she can be joined again with her original husband? Why not the husband who in most cases initiated and pushed through the first divorce? Why is the wife punished if the husband makes this mistake?

first of all, if a husband divorces his wife in haste then why this woman wants to go back in his life once again.. just move on in life naa..

a preplanned Halala is not allowed means she cannot marry someone just for the sake of getting divorced from him.. so how can she be humiliated by yet another marriage here?


Now apparently, there is rule that three divorces are allowed before the woman has to do this...so we can assume that this is their first divorce 🤣

Laila2009 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#16
Annu, I don't think they (the PH) are particularly concerned if it is against Islamic law.
asyaarshilover thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#17
nie post
if u will extend this post so plz pm me

JeanieBeanie thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#18


A preplanned Halala is wrong? Then what Zeetv posted is DEFINITELY happening.
It's exactly why they'll show Ayaan-Zoya marrying first then Ayaan asking Asad for help. It's wrong by Islamic law hence what Ayan is asking for is wrong. Isn't that aim of the show anyway... breaking stereotypes and wrong misdoings and portraying the right notions, etc etc.

Edited by JPRules - 12 years ago
adeeti10 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#19
Sounds interesting Laila! I can't comment on whether the practice is unIslamic. But if the synopsis suggests that it's going to be the reverse, as in Ayaan asking Asad for help after Zoya and he separate, then it would the same case.

I'd say either way, it's a bold move by the creatives to show something that's against the way to been interpreted.
fee-fee thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#20
wouldn't all this second-marriage thing be another version of what happened to Dilshad-Rashid-Shireen?

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".