ajay227 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#1
May be I am d only one disappointed wih Shergill being twisted and tricked by Rizwan!!!!And I didnt even lyk d precap too...Its lyk a big let down for a RAW agent!!!!Not lyk as Rizwan's intelligence, but it seemed lyk d foolishness,dumbness,and inefficency of Mr.Shergill as an investigator!!!!RAW agents are powerful contributors to India's safe & secure environment!!!And the characterization of that officer is so lame here!!!I could have enjoyed his character, if it is as shrewd,subtle&smart as Rizwan!!!And I dont even support Rizwan yesterday!!!Becoz he may be a good hearted man or as a person of high values&emotions but at d end he is a threat to India & a terrorist!!!And also we cant gaurantee that he mi8 turn up against Baba becoz it isn't sure that he will know d truth that he is manipulated all thru...And even Hooda family members stand up for Ishaan bored me lyk hell!!!!It doesnt take even a flip of a eye lid for them to turn against Ishaan if someone lyk Naina accuses him...I had lost hope in them when they didnt believe Preet!!! P.S...Its just my opinion...Sry if I offended anyone!!!

Created

Last reply

Replies

10

Views

689

Users

7

Likes

35

Frequent Posters

.SoHu. thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#2
I get your sentiment Ajay and with respect to Shergill's characterization I harbour the same feelings as you. It's extremely disheartening to see a RAW agent getting such a poor character sketch when in reality they are the ones who contribute humongously for the safety and well being of our nation. It's ironical that all of us are siding with Rizwaan, but that's not cause the character is played by a phenomenal actor like Iqbal but because his character graph is applaud worthy. The way his various shades have been scripted and executed, throwing light on his various facets is worth all the apllause; but then again we can't forget the FACT that he IS a terrorist and somewhere it may look immoral to support one. But the strength and enigma of the character is such that you possibly can't stop praising the swag this man carries. On the other hand, the tomfoolery shergill does on screen makes all of us want to smack his face hard cause that downright absurd, unrealistic and hilarious to say the least.
It's mainly got to do with the faulty writing and lack of proper character analysis on the side of the makers and trust me this has been the ONLY big letdown for me so far in this show. I just hope shergill gets sacked from his job and we get an equally better, shrewd, calculative officer who is worthy of being a RAW agent and is of Rizwan's competition. Who knows we might end up praising him more than Rizwaan in this supposed to be thrilling chase!😳
giaa thumbnail
21st Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#3
I totally understand your frustration and at some points I even agree that they have depicted RAW agent as a pretty lame character.

BUT if we detach from patriotism and religion for a moment - In this case the terrorist may not know he has been manipulated but we as the audience do - can we not garner empathy for who is and what has made him who he is - this is what the story teller is asking - can we be human beings with compassion and empathy ?
ajay227 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: .SoHu.

I get your sentiment Ajay and with respect to Shergill's characterization I harbour the same feelings as you. It's extremely disheartening to see a RAW agent getting such a poor character sketch when in reality they are the ones who contribute humongously for the safety and well being of our nation. It's ironical that all of us are siding with Rizwaan, but that's not cause the character is played by a phenomenal actor like Iqbal but because his character graph is applaud worthy. The way his various shades have been scripted and executed, throwing light on his various facets is worth all the apllause; but then again we can't forget the FACT that he IS a terrorist and somewhere it may look immoral to support one. But the strength and enigma of the character is such that you possibly can't stop praising the swag this man carries. On the other hand, the tomfoolery shergill does on screen makes all of us want to smack his face hard cause that downright absurd, unrealistic and hilarious to say the least.

It's mainly got to do with the faulty writing and lack of proper character analysis on the side of the makers and trust me this has been the ONLY big letdown for me so far in this show. I just hope shergill gets sacked from his job and we get an equally better, shrewd, calculative officer who is worthy of being a RAW agent and is of Rizwan's competition. Who knows we might end up praising him more than Rizwaan in this supposed to be thrilling chase!😳

My concern is also with the same thing...The writing...The writer who has written Rizwan's character is outstanding...It has more layers,its complex and it holds d main gravity to run d show...And since d writing is bang on when an actor lyk IK portrays it, its for sure gets etched forever in to viewers mind and this is d case with Rizwan...But otherside its not d same scenario of a RAW agent who has to tackle down d mystery!!!!I hope we do get another interesting and drool worthy character lyk of Rizwan in d name of new RAW agent!!!(Too much to ask?????)!!!
Loveforlife thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#5
As Sohu has written ^^ hope we get an intelligent RAW agent rather than one who is complacent, acts as a know all and who thinks he is one step ahead of the enemy... This enemy is really slippery and needs better planning and tactics to defeat it.. The age old tricks to combat an enemy will not work here... Round one was lost by Shergill because of the his own stupidity... Round one was won by Rizwaan because he knew Shergill's stupid tactics in and out. Now if I am not wrong in Round two will see a shrewd Agent who will tackle Rizwaan in a different way... He will not attack him physically but mentally.. I sincerely hope we have a Round two... Someone who makes Rizwaan introspect... Someone who makes him seriously think "yeh Baba aur tumhara nafrat ka rishta zyada important hai ya tumhare aur Preet ke beech ke Pyaar ka?"

Where Love, Logic and Life rewash his brain to make him see the light.. His real enemy.. Who has no 'hamdardi' for Rizwaan but who is taking advantage of Rizwaan for his own personal gain.
ajay227 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: giaa

I totally understand your frustration and at some points I even agree that they have depicted RAW agent as a pretty lame character.

BUT if we detach from patriotism and religion for a moment - In this case the terrorist may not know he has been manipulated but we as the audience do - can we not garner empathy for who is and what has made him who he is - this is what the story teller is asking - can we be human beings with compassion and empathy ?

I do compassionate with Rizwan and understand what he has gone thru...When he was a child, his tender mind was manipulated and was moulded into a powerful tool to accomplish some selfish&deadly motives...I just wish we could get a smart&shrewd RAW agent so that he can be a equal compititor to Rizwan!!!
Loveforlife thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#7
Koi Sharad Kelkar ko RAW agent dikha de...☺️😆
Mehek25 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#8
@Ajay...
I agree with your sentiments Ajay...To be honest after watching Friday's episode I also was of the opinion that they have shown Rizwan to be way cleverer than Shergill... Also the way Shergill was putting allegations on Rizwan without having concrete proof was very poor show...Rizwan had answers to all his allegations...which a clever Raw agent should have foreseen...

As for Rizwan's change of loyalties...wonder when or even if it will ever happen... I only hope it happens... Seeing the Hooda family's blind faith and trust in Ishan/Rizwan makes.me dread their reaction when they come to know he true identity...their hurt will be difficult to see...hoe IsReez wakes up to reality before the hurt he inflicts on them becomes irreversible ...

As for the makers depicting an Indian agent in such poor light just goes to show the ability of the CVs to ruin a good show.
1019702 thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: .SoHu.

I get your sentiment Ajay and with respect to Shergill's characterization I harbour the same feelings as you. It's extremely disheartening to see a RAW agent getting such a poor character sketch when in reality they are the ones who contribute humongously for the safety and well being of our nation. It's ironical that all of us are siding with Rizwaan, but that's not cause the character is played by a phenomenal actor like Iqbal but because his character graph is applaud worthy. The way his various shades have been scripted and executed, throwing light on his various facets is worth all the apllause; but then again we can't forget the FACT that he IS a terrorist and somewhere it may look immoral to support one. But the strength and enigma of the character is such that you possibly can't stop praising the swag this man carries. On the other hand, the tomfoolery shergill does on screen makes all of us want to smack his face hard cause that downright absurd, unrealistic and hilarious to say the least.

It's mainly got to do with the faulty writing and lack of proper character analysis on the side of the makers and trust me this has been the ONLY big letdown for me so far in this show. I just hope shergill gets sacked from his job and we get an equally better, shrewd, calculative officer who is worthy of being a RAW agent and is of Rizwan's competition. Who knows we might end up praising him more than Rizwaan in this supposed to be thrilling chase!😳


THIS...PERFECT..!!!

Yes The Shergill Character need a Special Attention . I would defo says at times He does look Smart but that is like 10 % ..rest He ends up looking a Character right away from Comic Spy Books . RAW Agent being presented like this is a Shame . I agree .

But the Reason we are appluading Rizwaan is not because He was made to look like a Hero by making Shergill look like a fool . NO that's not the case , It's got to do with the Rizwaan Character and his Journey so far .It's very well written and the writer have created a space where viewer can understand Rizwaan's Actions and Sympathize too but at the same time we do Criticize them .
We did pointed out in the LU Thread How Evil Rizwaan is . How Cold Blooded He looked .
But Its just the events and how they were unfolded , we ended up praising that , The Writer and ofcourse the Actor .

Its all the Character and the Actor who has added to the Intensity .
Had Shergill been penned down with proper details , The Intensity would have increased Ten Folds.

1019702 thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#10
Ajay , I agree with you on the Hooda's though , Its funny they are ready to stand up for Ishaan but at the same time could't do that against Preet .
Ver Dysfunctional...

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".