Guys you all have valid points but just remember that Pia has lost her memory, and even since she can remember, Jeh has been the person to give her support, and help her with her feelings. He understood that she still felt something for Abhay, and tried to make him jealous. He tried to help Piya and let her use him, even though he already had a crush on her and knew that he might end up alone at the end. So when all Piya can remember is this, how can she just leave him alone, and cut all ties with him, at the words of a guy who is her sister's boyfriend, and she only has some romantic memories of him? She remembers their time together, which is why she can't let go of Abhay either, but knowing that he is Panchi's "boyfriend" she is trying to respect that limit. Sometimes she can't help herself, but she tries her best. So how can she just leave Jeh like that, who has been her only supporter ever since Abhay came back? He was the only one there for her, because first Misha was "with" Abhay, and now Panchi. Jeh has been her shelter, so she can't just leave him without any valid reason. Just because her sister's boyfriend who she still has feelings for says so, will Piya be able to move on like that? Dont forget that now she thinks that Abhay has feelings for Panchi...And how is she supposed to know that Abhay is her soulmate? Would someone's soulmate leave you and start dating your sister? No. That soulmate also should be completely for you. Abhay is there with his own girlfriend on the side, and he's telling Piya to dump her boyfriend? Just think from Piya's perspective. It's hard for her to make sense of the situation.
Guys, I am still a total Abhiya supporter, and I know that Piya can be really stupid sometimes, but in this situation, it is totally normal for her to be so confused. And that's another thing - she isn't totally against Abhay's words. Somewhere inside her heart, she believes him. But her head is explaining to her that Jeh is her support, so how can she leave him. It's hard to see whether your heart is correct or your mind, especially when the mind makes more sense, but the heart is always supposed to be correct. Piya keeps trying to convince herself that Jeh is a good guy, but somewhere inside, she is confused because of Abhay.
So I think we need to just lay off of Piya for a while, and dont be too hard on her :P
And dont get me started on how wrong Panchi is...not just for Abhay, but for this whole situation. She is using her sister's heartache for her own advantage, knowing that what she is doing is hurting Piya. She's only concerned about breaking her engagement, whereas when Misha did this, she did it just to keep Piya safe. Misha was also wrong, because she thinks she knows what is best for Piya, where its totally not, but still, at least she only did it with her sister's best interests in mind. Panchi doesn't care about that, only about getting back at Neil. And I know she deserves someone who she can trust after all that's happened with her, but dont forget she's the one who created this whole situation with Neil in the first place. He loved her so much, and she stomped on his feelings, along with the other boys who she dated in that one year that Piya and Misha were gone. Neil was the only one to stand up to her, and teach her a lesson. Granted, his way of doing this is wrong, but Panchi started this whole mess. If she had respected Neil in the first place, she would have herself a fiance who trusted her, who she could trust, and who loved her more thtan anything. So she's just all wrong for this whole equation. I don't want to say anything more about her - she just pisses me off more and more everyday 😡
But as for Piya not trusting Abhay - cut her some slack. She's fighting a hard battle - we know her heart will eventually win, and she will be Abhay's. But until then, let's go a little easier on her. :)
Love always,
Aarti
Edited by helloaamir - 14 years ago
Ufff Yeh Love Hai Mushkil
