Illogical Dialogs of Piya! - Page 4

Originally posted by: ka7eela

thanks for the info very enlightening 😉😆 so now i know, i will never use the word Mohbbat in my FF😛 or people will make fun of the dialogs 😆

@blue woooooooo! he confessed his love for you!😲

😆😆depends on how you use it.....it looks okay while reading....but hearing it being said lover-to-beloved or vice versa seems a li'l weird.

er...nooo!!! my poor Hindi teacher was trying to make me spell the word correctly. it was her favourite trick - she knew what words I am definitely going to spell wrong, and then she would tell me about its etymology to get me interested and ensure that I won't forget the spellings. 😆 she did give me roses on my birthday once though. 😉

Originally posted by: amail1601

😆😆depends on how you use it.....it looks okay while reading....but hearing it being said lover-to-beloved or vice versa seems a li'l weird. 😛

er...nooo!!! my poor Hindi teacher was trying to make me spell the word correctly. it was her favourite trick - she😛 knew what words I am definitely going to spell wrong, and then she would tell me about its etymology to get me interested and ensure that I won't forget the spellings. 😆 she did give me roses on my birthday once though. 😉

Originally posted by: baby_doll_2305

yes, I Agree with u. The things she said were illogical. BUT, she is in no stage to think logically. She is in shock, and at this point, the only thing that matters to her is that abhay is a blood sucking vampire. He isn't even a person! So I feel that the writers have not done anything wrong by giving piya illogical dialouges. She is in no state to think clearly about all the things abhay has done for her!

Originally posted by: ka7eela

i see, so the teacher is a she and not a he my bad😛

@ bold now you sound like a Hindi teacher your self😆

@ blue oh thats ok 😛unless she gave you something more then roses like half heart of a pendant for example😉!😆

waise it's so weird about the language - someone said 'vichitra praani' in the college the other day, and everyone was asking what's that....it was something like it's cool not to know Hindi. one wrong word and they come eat you up.

Originally posted by: mahi0809

completely agree...the writers need to pay attention to the dialogues they write and the impact those dialogues could have

Originally posted by: ka7eela

ok guys i have seen topics bashing Piya and few other defending Piya for her reaction in the precap!

So my topic isn't about that, its different,😉 this one is addressed to the writer, who wrote Piya's dialogs😆

i can understand if you show her shocked after witnessing Abhay's horrifying transformation, i can justify her initial shock and being terrified, horrified, scared, frightened, traumatized..etc ( i can still bring other words but i think you got the point😆)

It also would have been justified if she fainted from the shock or even ran away from him at that point.

However Piya calling Abhay darindsa aka a beast, a monster! that can never be justified, seriously what were you thinking?!!!!!!!!!!😕

let me explain my self, i will remind you of your own story track!

Piya never saw him act beastly with her, though he had so many chances of being alone with her!

Moreover he saved her life umpteen times from life threating situations and from Danish and mobs, if it wasn't for him she would have been dead by now!, and he saved the lives of her friends too, as he has rescued Maya twice and stood by her without any hidden agendas, and he had rescued Misha and tracker too, and Piya knows all these facts!

She also has experienced Abhay's tender, loving and caring side, when he carried her and cured her ankle in the woods, when he kissed away her wounds in the class, when he revived her back to life in the hospital, and when he tucked her in the bed! and reassured her that he would be there for her and nothing could happen to her on his watch!

So to show Piya callng him a beast, a monster after all this, after she has experienced and witnessed by her own eyes all of Abhay's heroic acts and his tender, caring and loving side is very illogical! it goes against the human nature!

Again i say her initial shock is justified but her dialogs are not, she was shown doubting him and was disgusted about how could she fall in love with a monster?!, have she forgotten, if it wasn't for the monster aka Abhay she wouldn't have been alive nor her friends too! have she forgotten that he has asked her time and time again to stay away from him!!

so dear creative team please pay attention on the dialogs more, its an advice you can take it or leave it, your choice!😊

Originally posted by: ka7eela

@ blue😆 thats what happens when you have a team of writers who don't agree with each other or don't contact each other ( just my guess)😆

@ brown true when we are angry at someone or someone hurt us we become very emotional and end up blurting out awful things that we don't mean, but Piya's case is different! Abhay didn't hurt her and he wasn't attacking her! if he was then i could understand!

on the contrary he has saved her life so what she says is not justified even if she was in a shock state of mind

@red i have seen the precap twice , and i am sure she wasnt cursing the situation she was disgused from her own self for falling for a beast and she called him a monster, tell me when did he behave with her in a beastly manner ?, how could she

, moreover she suspected him to be a vampire so now she knows she behaves so badly!

@black, true but they felt disgusted before they knew them well, for example Beauty fell for beast after knowing him well how good an caring he was

but Piya already knows Abhay very well, as she has seen his good side, his tender and loving side so how can she still feel disgusted!!

@ pink i beg to differ an infatuation doesn't make a girl behave like Piya was behaving, from whatever we have seen, she is already madly and deeply in love with him

@purple yepe it will go stronger for sure as it is an immortal love between two who belong to different worlds