ka7eela thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#1


ok guys i have seen topics bashing Piya and few other defending Piya for her reaction in the precap!

So my topic isn't about that, its different,😉 this one is addressed to the writer, who wrote Piya's dialogs😆

i can understand if you show her shocked after witnessing Abhay's horrifying transformation, i can justify her initial shock and being terrified, horrified, scared, frightened, traumatized..etc ( i can still bring other words but i think you got the point😆)

It also would have been justified if she fainted from the shock or even ran away from him at that point.

However Piya calling Abhay darindsa aka a beast, a monster! that can never be justified, seriously what were you thinking?!!!!!!!!!!😕

let me explain my self, i will remind you of your own story track!

Piya never saw him act beastly with her, though he had so many chances of being alone with her!

Moreover he saved her life umpteen times from life threating situations and from Danish and mobs, if it wasn't for him she would have been dead by now!, and he saved the lives of her friends too, as he has rescued Maya twice and stood by her without any hidden agendas, and he had rescued Misha and tracker too, and Piya knows all these facts!

She also has experienced Abhay's tender, loving and caring side, when he carried her and cured her ankle in the woods, when he kissed away her wounds in the class, when he revived her back to life in the hospital, and when he tucked her in the bed! and reassured her that he would be there for her and nothing could happen to her on his watch!

So to show Piya callng him a beast, a monster after all this, after she has experienced and witnessed by her own eyes all of Abhay's heroic acts and his tender, caring and loving side is very illogical! it goes against the human nature!

Again i say her initial shock is justified but her dialogs are not, she was shown doubting him and was disgusted about how could she fall in love with a monster?!, have she forgotten, if it wasn't for the monster aka Abhay she wouldn't have been alive nor her friends too! have she forgotten that he has asked her time and time again to stay away from him!!

so dear creative team please pay attention on the dialogs more, its an advice you can take it or leave it, your choice!😊


Edited by ka7eela - 14 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

46

Views

2.7k

Users

17

Likes

99

Frequent Posters

Petal_Pose thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#2
i agree kaela . i sympathize her far but when she called him a dareenda . i got pissed.
Ritzie thumbnail
Enthusiast Thumbnail 14th Anniversary Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#3
Kahila, I am completely understanding your point of view reagarding the words used for Abhay.

Yes and I totally agree that Darinda or monster word is very inappropriate word to use for an Angel 😍.

On little lighter side, as we have discussed in our earlier posts, the writers must have changed the shifts. One writer lets Pia call Abhay an angel when she is drunk and other writer gives a dialog of darinda when she is in complete senses (at least she is not drunk). 😆

Okay now some serious stuff, I will still give writers some benefit considering these are not sane dialogues, these are just initial reactions and can be extreme. Sometimes, when we are angry or frustrated or are not in control of emotions, we either react by running, crying or using curse words. It's needed to calm down.

I think, here Pia is cursing the situation and not Abhay himself. She is not able to believe that how could this kind of things happen to her. Well, this is my assumption but we need see how she actually takes it.

On a different note, I know Pia doesn't believe in fairy tales but today I was reminded of Frog prince and Beauty and the beast again and again. Both the princesses always looked at the heroes with disgust unless they actually fell for them. What Pia had till now was infatuation for Prince Angel Super Charming but what she will develop in future will be an immortal love for a beast (look I called Abhay a beast but you know what I mean😃).
Edited by Ritz93 - 14 years ago
SimplyAparajita thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#4
Kaheela..will soon come up with something..:) i am not as good as you when it comes o writing.. But do let me know how it is.. Will be back in half am hour
gitika.j thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#5
i wish they edit out the dialogue
luvkasu thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#6
Nice post Ka7eela!

But i need to clear one thing here..
Whenever a person is in state of shock, n that a shock which shake your life like this, u cant just sitdown calmly n recall all the good n bad moments that u have spent with that particular person! Its Human nature, even if u take an example of ur own personal life, whenever we become angry even on small things, we stay stuff which hurt others.. we react suddenly without going thru each n everydetails.
I am sure as soon as piya recovers from the shock n puts 2 n 2 toghther, she'll accept abhay n 'll love him even more!

I know its the word DARINDA that most of us found difficult to digest but of not darinda then whatelse should have used? vampire or monster..?

Ammara
Doris. thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#7
What i found more illogical is Abhays constant *shhhhh*...and 'Bas'..over and over again🤔
In a state of shock you don choose your words properly, she doesnt have a name for what she saw, hence thats what she calls him.
saphira7988 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#8
well written..👏lovely post...i agree with u...yest i was quite pissed with pia's initial reaction then wen i thot abt it i felt sorry fr her n realised tht her being shocked n digusted is quite a normal reaction...but she addressing abhay as a monster even in tht traumatized state is wrong acc to me...wen has he ever behaved like a monster...😕he has proved time n again tht he's got a bigger heart thn most humans put together..pia having witnessed his goodness n love 1st hand shudnt have said tht shock or no shock...😲 its obvious she'll go back to him later as she loves him far too much but pia being d only 1 who knew d real abhay was not justified to say tht...😭
ankana92 thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#9
😒seriously kaheela.... thts a real gr8 post... i mean ths is nt d 1st tym.... half the tyms their dialodues dnt tally wid the situations..... pia zidd karti hai to come back to d hostel whn misha asks y is she nt scared n she says tht she hs her angal aka abhay wid her...... then in d jungle whn she's drunk as ritz said..... darinda ws too harsh a word..... i agree wid u on d fact tht she's really shocked to knw d truth.... bt depending on wht she herslf said yesterday... she said tht abhay thnks she'll nt b able to tolerate d truth regardng whch he ws damned right...... bt she says tht she can tolerate it..... if she cn thn why s she reactng lyk ths...... creative team...wake up n show sumthng more plausible yaar....👎🏼
Sweetzcherry thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#10
Yeah I agree with U kaheela .. the dialogues sholud be modified ...

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".