Yash's Decision:Right or Wrong:Lets debate - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

24

Views

3.1k

Users

20

Likes

96

Frequent Posters

villager00 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#11
Jyoji, great thought in there..

It's actually interesting because i felt Yash did what was morally right. I think that was very genuine of him and it's not because he is feeling guilty to be in Aakash's place all these years. Somehow, Aakash needs to get what was due of him and i am glad it was Yash who offered it. They were both victims and Yash, true to having a good upbringing, proved his fairness once more.

Before all these unfolded, i already preconceived in my mind that maybe Yash will ask Aakash to come inside the Scindhia house and AarYa will leave with Radha. The invitation for Radha to stay in the SM is a shocker for me and a big risk. I was hoping to see Yash and Aarti move in with Radha not the other way around but surprisingly, she is to stay at the SM too..

Personally,i was thinking i would rather have Radha/AarYa out of SM. That way, both sons will have more chance to be acquainted with their respective biological parents because even if they will try to let things remain as they were, nothing will change the fact that Yash is not Gyatri's son.



ratnaprabhashri thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#12
Yash and Aarti both forgot G3 ma situtation if radha entrs why both didnt had their flash back of their life pra arptia why did yash didnt bring pra with them stay toether and even aarti was uncomfortable with arptia fotos so this means that they both are selfish and they think most of their emotions rather which gives them happy rather than others emotion and radha she was giving so much lecture to aarti that she wants the right for akash and when he get she will leave so that crocodile tears for these were just to get the lusxury she wants in name of mamta and right for akash she is the most shameless person who was ready to agree to enter the sm will aarti stay with any other women of yash and yash should have bought prashant to live with them and poor dubeys would have not lost their son for yash and aarti faults Both for me yash and aarti gives more imp to their emotions Anyways hope to see increase in trp withh such brainless work of cv upto akash entry acceptable but radha entry no would be better yash and aarti left with radha the SM which they dont deserve now and this would be right step by yash rather than bring radha in and giving more emotional torture to G3 for the sin dont by yash mother radha
AaRyArOx thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#13
I really feel so sorry and sad for Gayatri maa!!! 😔😭
Why is Radha coming to saty in their house!!!!????

I really loved AarYa's kindness shown to Radha, Aakash and Ishita, but not Radha...Serioslyyy!!!!
Alamelu thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#14
Decision to bring Akash and Ishita - I will accept, eventually will work out after initial hiccups.

Radha - I am still thinking/hoping she will not accept. If she does, then her intentions are wrong and evil all along. Even if arya persists, she should explain to them about Gayatri and her feelings and that she has no place in that house. Yash and his family are more than welcome to visit her. I dont mind if he takes care of her financially too, but to bring her to SM, my thoughts are ABSOLUTELY NOT under any circumstances.

I dont think this can be their decision first of all, it is still gayatri's house and it should be her decision not even SP's. That is my humble opinion.
jyoti06 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Master Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 12 years ago
#15
Interesting points all 👏👏

I think one party will b always at loss .. its impossible to b fair with all in this case .. if Yash thinks about Gayatri , then he will hv to b unfair with Radha and leave her all alone once again ... if Yash thinks about Radha , then he will hv to b unfair with Gayatri by bringing Gayatri's own sautan in house which we saw today ... So the situationi s such that u cannot b fair to both parties at all ..

I m sure if Yash had thought in favour of Gayatri by kicking out Radha , we would hv still questioned Yash's principles and debated on how as a son he can b so heartless and show no emotions for his biological mother just how we r questioning about how G3 is so heartless and cannot show any motherly feelings for Akash ...

In short its complicated 😆😆
jyoti06 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Master Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 12 years ago
#16
About Radha accepting to stay in Scindia mansion , I think its human ../ mayb she is selfish here and wants to spend her time with her biological son after all these years ... its just that human selfishness of a mother in this case ... 😊
..Mini.. thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#17
tbh i think Yash was right.. in real life that would be a really tough decision.. but i think Yash was right... G3 .. nothing to say..
..Mini.. thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#18
i think Yash's decision was right.. i think
kdsubs thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#19
I don't think its a question of right or wrong anymore Jyo. Yash and Arti by their very nature, were incapable of doing anything else. They both have a strong sense of justice - and both are overwhelmed by the injustice done to Akash and Radha. Add to that Yash's guilt of "usurping" Akash's place in the family - there was no way he could NOT bring them "home".

Did Yash take into account Gayatri's feelings in the matter? I doubt it. The only thing probably running thorugh his mind was his Bauji, the man he revered and wants to put back on the pedestal, made a mistake - a grave one. And he, Yash, was the unknown beneficiary while the rightful laadla was left on the streets. He HAD to fix that.

Just like in law there is a statuette of limitations - after a certain point in time you cannot be punished for a crime you committed - there is a statuette in real life too. In real life however it applies to redemption, rather than punishment:

- Will bringing Akash back into the house now wipe out the 30 years of abuse he faced from society? No

- Will it wipe out all the lost opportunities over these 30 years? No

- Will it give Radha the respect and support she needed to bring up her child single-handedly? No

- Will it give Gayatri a sense of peace, security and trust in her husband, and by extension family, again? No

- Will it make SP feel the wrong he committed has been righted? No

- Will it make Yash feel better and justified in staying on in SM? Yes!!

All righteous people have a streak of self-centeredness in them - they have to, to continue alone on the path of righteousness. And Yash has that in heaps. I am not saying Yash brought Akash in to make himself feel better - i am saying that this action will make only his own life more bearable. It will have other repercussions for everyone else.

Interesting point in the story - and lets see how the production house takes it further.

ApoorvaFan thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#20
Out of all the parties here, Radha accepting to come into SM is a big surprise to me. Till now her character was shown a bit different. She told Arati that she did not want to spoil the family of SP that is why she kept quiet before.

She is overwhelmed with this new chance to be with her biological son and in that emotion she is doing some thing which will create a big issue to Gayatri. Having Radha and Gayatri under the same roof is impossible. SP has done injustice to both the women in his life.

I feel ArYa have gone overboard in dealing with Radha. Yash always has this tendency to feel responsible for parents. He invited dubeys also to stay with him and so many times told to Arati that they have to take care of Dubeys.
With similar frame of mind, he is bringing Radha now into SM.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".