Yash's Decision:Right or Wrong:Lets debate

jyoti06 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Master Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 12 years ago
#1
Yash brings Aaksh and Radha in house ... is he right or is he wrong .. lets debate 😊


This is my POV

Yash is in double minds after the shocking truth of his life has come out regarding his own identity .. At this stage he wants to b fair to all parties because somewhere his inner conscience has a certain guilt that he is actually the result of his father's mistake but even then his family accepted him after the truth and so now he feels indebted to his family but at the same time he cannot really b unfair to his own biological mother Radha either as it goes against his principles ... so a very complicated situation for Yash indeed 😊


Yash wants to keep all parties happy ... He does not want SP to feel guilty about the mistake he committed 30 yrs back simply because Yash knows he is the result of that same mistake and so when SP was getting hyper and feeling guilty in front of family , we saw Yash coming to his rescue 🤔... At the same time , Yash wants to b fair to his brother Akash here since he knows again his birth is the reason why Akash was snatched away the legitimate rights in his childhood and so he takes it like a duty to give those rights back to Akash again by bringing him in the house 🤔... At the same time , Yash wants to b fair with his biological mother too who gave him birth since years back she was denied the legitimate rights by SP and so as a son , he feels its his moral duty to give a proper secure shelter to his biological mother and do his karma this way as a son 😊...


In the process of keeping all parties happy , Yash forgot to think about his other mother Gayatri .. Yash feels Gayatri wll feel proud of him since he selflessly brings her biological son in the house but what Yash is not able to understand here is that Akash's presense will always remind Gayatri that Yash is actually the result of her husband's betrayal which will result in Gayatri suffocating inside since her motherly instincts will always remain with Yash but as a wife she will always remember that Yash is result of her husband cheating on her ... Last nail in coffin was Radha's entry in house in the last scene which shocks Gayatri and this is where Gayatri might further distance herself from Yash thinking he is trying to get justice for his own biological mother 😭😭.. Yash's intention was to make all parties happy and at the same time fulfill his moral duties as a son towards both mothers by returning back Gayatri's real son and by giving shelter to his own biological mother but in the process Yash and even Aarti forgot that Radha shares same equation with Gayatri which mayb Prashant shared with Yash or Arpita would hv shared with Aarti if they were alive and so by bringing Radha in the house they r actually being unfair to Gayatri:the woman 😊


I dont hold Yash or Aarti wrong here because at present both r blinded by fairness and trying to fulfill their duties towards all parites as Yash is feeling indebted to Scindias and at the same time Aarti influenced him never to compromise his principles 😊... But they r not really realising the future consequences and the fact that Akash's presense in house will always remind all of SP's betrayal towards Gayatri whose result is Yash and this might end up in all distancing themselves from none other than Yash only ...


In the end I will repeat again , its a very interesting story-telling because for once I m happy Yash did what his heart told him to do rather than blindly follow SP's footsteps

Created

Last reply

Replies

24

Views

3.1k

Users

20

Likes

96

Frequent Posters

kriti07 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#2
Agree totally and as much as my sympathies lay with Gayatri equal sympathies lie with Radha too actually shes suffered even more at hands of the society
TanShi_CrazyLuv thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 12 years ago
#3
50 50... bt feeling soorryy for gaytri maan

she is ignred by arya ryt nw
gcluv thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#4
yash decision to bring Aakash and Isita home is right decision ..
But bringing Radha in house to stay is wrong
this will soon create rift in the family
I feel that slowly Isita with her cunning mind will remove or force ARYA out of Scindhiya house


awesome post jyoti
amrithatec thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#5
Little Bit Sick myself😛😛

Jyo Yash decision is partially right..As a son and kind hearted soul..Yash wants to give akash his rights what he lost due to his biological mother and father.He is trying to compensate akash 30Years of Life..But again Yash and aarthi reallt hats off..Standing as One in each and every problem.Whatelse is needed for a cute soul mate.But bringing Radha really i just cannot accept.Any woman in Gayathri situation cannot tolerate and feel insecure about her position as a wife..Ishita words in precap may be shocking for us..But sharing the bed room is not a thing a woman cannot ask another woman naa..Something other than that i would say..I wont be surprised Yash and aarthi would leave the scindia mansion due to problems ishita going to create.But really the awkward situation is Yash really the soul of the family and his lose SP wont be disgusting it..Yash is the main ATM Machine for him naa😆😆


Edited by anituram - 12 years ago
TanShi_CrazyLuv thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 12 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: anituram

Little Bit Sick myself😛😛


Jyo Yash decision is partially right..As a son and kind hearted soul..Yash wants to give akash his rights what he lost due to his biological mother and father.He is trying to compensate akash 30Years of Life..But again Yash and aarthi reallt hats off..Standing as One in each and every problem.Whatelse is needed for a cute soul mate.But bringing Radha really i just cannot accept.Any woman in Gayathri situation cannot tolerate and feel insecure about her position as a wife..

UPDATING


agreee
-Zahra15- thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#7
It's unfair to bring Radha in the house with Gayatri there, But i think Yash is not thinking of her in that way.

For him, it's HIS way for compensating for HER loss XD
jyoti06 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Master Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 12 years ago
#8
We all r forgetting that Radha has given life and birth to Yash .. so even if Yash has no emotions for Radha , still he cannot simply leave her alone on roads .. isn't it ... till now Radha was staying with Akash but now with Akash gones back to his real family , where will Radha go in this age ?? ... this is where as a son Yash fulfilled his duties ..

Yes from gayatri's pov he is wrong for sure .. but thats the story .. he will realise this eventually that he was being unfair to gayatri in the process of giving justice to radha 😊
lovely_nikki thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#9
Wonderful post Jyoti. 👏

Yash and Aarti lives in a dream world, where they think that everything will be alright and they all will stay happily ever after as one big happy family.

Yash wants to be fair to everyone and wants everyone to be happy. To bring Aakash and Ishita to SM was a right decision on his part. But to bring Radha along, well it's a BIG NO from me.

When Prashant was alive, Yash thought that Aarti wants to go back to Prashant, as Aarti was forced to do this PV. This even created a MU in his mind and he was even ready to let Aarti go back to Prashant.

But he is forgetting here that by bringing Radha to SM, G3 will go through the same experience and tourture, that Yash went through with Prashant. Based on his own experience he should have thought from G3's POV also.

If Yash wants to justice to Radha, he could have made proper arrangements for her to stay nearby. AarYa could visit her everyday if they want 😕. I know that sounds weird. Even to me also it sounds weird. 😕
Edited by lovely_nikki - 12 years ago
Pooja_11 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#10
Its Unfair Bringing the Radha to SM..Ok thats Aarya BIG Heart ...But I am Surprised why Radha Wants to Enter SM ? She just Wants Aakaash to be Accepted by G3 and SP and then She Leaves them Forever...So why She is Entering SM ? May be She Wants to Check it up again that how g3 and Sp will treat Aakash Now.. 😕😆😃

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".