Serials make mockery of marriage - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

43

Views

5.2k

Users

29

Likes

238

Frequent Posters

DMKJ_VB thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#21

Originally posted by: pensense40

The comparison to Geet was inadvertant since it was probably the first serial I have seen. The story writers can always show the protagonists to be virtuous and giving and will eventually make a great marriage. But the point I was trying to make was that in the real world this seems a little fictional. Stage is now set for a marriage of convenience, and lots of family drama with an antagonistic mother-in-law who resents Ansh coming to the family, a very vindictive and bitter bua who resents the marriage because she herself was not able to re-marry, a reluctant Yash who wants to live with his memories, a very helpless Aarti who still loves her husband, well meaning parents in law who tell a half lie that she is a widow. To deal with such problems requires great maturity and it would be good for all these family members to first realise that marriage is not meant for bringing a maid / d-i-l into the house. The woman is as important as the man and should be respected. It is also very naive to assume that the wife will make a wonderful mother and that the new husband will be the father to another's son without first meeting and talking about it and getting each others views.


i hv only one question for u...why create a new id? why didn't u come with ur old one...😆 we r not exactly fools here...😃

and this is a show...which is meant to entertain people.so its natural there will be sm drama...as far as Yash's parents' mentality is concerned...the makers r showing it becoz such mentality does exist among real ppl...don't tell me social evils r not shown in any serials! GHSP started off with the concept of honour killing..shall we debate about how immature and criminal honour killing is?!
Aarti will not be a maid or nanny but Yash's wife and mother of his daughters and the show is how these two broken-hearted ppl rediscover love , happiness and basically life through each other again...
sorry if i sound rude but if everything is 100% logical in a show just like u want it, we would not hv a daily show...it would become a documentary instead!
Edited by DMKJ_VB - 13 years ago
pensense40 thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#22
You all are very right. This post was not meant to be a comparison between story lines nor should it have been on this page. It was meant to be a general comment on marriages shown on Indian TV (which the world watches) and triggered by the latest shown on PV. My endeavour is to post topical issues and not about actors or specific serials but mainly about concepts, so I should appologise if I gave a wrong impression.
Is there a "general issues" page on this forum where we can post such issues without creating the impression that we are biased about particular programs? I would appreciate if any one can help out.
iMadz thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago
#23

Originally posted by: pensense40

You all are very right. This post was not meant to be a comparison between story lines nor should it have been on this page. It was meant to be a general comment on marriages shown on Indian TV (which the world watches) and triggered by the latest shown on PV. My endeavour is to post topical issues and not about actors or specific serials but mainly about concepts, so I should appologise if I gave a wrong impression.

Is there a "general issues" page on this forum where we can post such issues without creating the impression that we are biased about particular programs? I would appreciate if any one can help out.




May be Debate or Discussion Section! 😊
SriB thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#24

Originally posted by: kamal desang

I know a young lady who got marriaed second time to a guy from india this was second marriage for her . Her first husband devorcied her becaouse her family refused to gave him chare of her fathers land after his deth .She also had a child from first marriage bouth of these marriages wher ranged first one faild but the secend marriage is doing fine . her second hisbend was not married before this was his first marriage and he agreid to acsepit her son as his own.

Hats off and salute to him for accepting the kid too
uluvmg thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#25
your post is not accepted... as to pv compairing to others serials specially geet which is differnt topic only GC is common... so your post is like...
GC is awesome in yash's character.. now he is known as YASH only..😆
adigaag thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#26

Originally posted by: maanddy




May be Debate or Discussion Section! 😊

I wa sgoing to say the same thing maanddy
kelly12 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#27
Haters gonna Hate.. cant really do anything about it!..Geet and Punar Vivah are two totally different shows..so comparing them is irrelevant..just coz Gurmeet was in the show doesnt mean u compare them! appreciate the fact that he is playing a very different role.
aanyakunat thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#28

Originally posted by: pensense40

You all are very right. This post was not meant to be a comparison between story lines nor should it have been on this page. It was meant to be a general comment on marriages shown on Indian TV (which the world watches) and triggered by the latest shown on PV. My endeavour is to post topical issues and not about actors or specific serials but mainly about concepts, so I should appologise if I gave a wrong impression.

Is there a "general issues" page on this forum where we can post such issues without creating the impression that we are biased about particular programs? I would appreciate if any one can help out.


posting topical issues and debating about it is great... but as i said i would have respected ur opinion and would have liked to have a discussion about it if u had not brought in an unfair comparison... btw i think it would be a great topic for the debate section... out there u'll find a lot more unbiased opinions...
teletubby thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#29
GHSP was sorta a milestone in indian tv ...ppl across board came to love maneet n so it's incomparable poularity!!!

so ya comparing it wid PV wud b lyk comparing an established superstar wid a rookie newcomer...th newcomer needs time to establish n prove his mettle...whether he has talent or not is not enuff,,,u hav to prove urself... n eventually there is space fr evryone under th spotlight if u r gud enuff!!!

wen we compare 2 shows n put one down...we shud remembr their r lotsa ppl who hav a very strong bonding wid those characters n we might hurt them inadvertantly!!
n as every1's saying...these r two different shows..diff story,diff characters,diff cast, diff treatment...sooo!!!
the one point of yours which warrants discussion is ...very strange how both arti/yash agreed to th marriage wid out meeting each other ,,,not even seeing each other's photos...li'l strange but not unbelievable as they both hav full faith in their respective families n trust them enuff to make this decision fr them..so once they do agree fr a remarriage,,they accept th choice their families have made fr them...😊
faria86 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#30
i like point regarding marriages on tv shows but want i don't like is the comparing of the shows

i love GHSP so much & i like PV too i'm watching it bcoz of GC
PV is a nice & different show & comparing it with GHSP or anyother popular show is unfair coz it has been ony 2 week that PV has started it has a lot to show
every show needs time to win hearts of ppl yes it has good trps
& GHSP have world wild fans...

it will take time 4 PV to reach that point but still it not like PV isn't a nice show or doesn't have good actors...
every show needs time to reach a high point...
& 4 that we need to give them chance to prove themselves...
what i want is plzzz friend respect the actors/actresses & their hard work...
both of the shows are totally different concepts

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".