David thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#1
Umm.. can anyone answer my few question

1.How did PRC die in afghanistan and how did he reach there in first place. I thought fight with ghori and prc were happening in india.
2. How they buried him afghanistan not in india. why he was buried not cremated.
4. why didnt indian government bring PRC 's buried body in ajmer, india. isnt like india govt are poor. Govt have lot of power and money these days. why dont they use it to bring his tombstone in india. Now anything is possible in world. World change alott. why they leave PRC tombstone there. doesnt govt care. OR arent they allowed to bring PRC's tombstone in india.
3.Who become king after PRC death?
4.How did Ghori die and How much he took over india when PRC die?

Created

Last reply

Replies

19

Views

2.3k

Users

11

Frequent Posters

_A_d_i_t_i_ thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#2
1. In the second battle of tarain, Prithvi lost by trickery.they fought in india but he was taken as a POW(prisoner of war) to afghanistan.

2. After killing ghori with his shabd bhedi baan vidya, chand and prithvi killed each other to avoid being killed by the foreigners as it is against their dignity. he was buried by them over there only.

3. the Govt is trying its level best but the afghans are not willing 😡

4. prc was the last hindu ruler of india and the afghans and the slave dynasty came to power but were later defeated by the mughals.

5. prc was blinded in afghanistan but managed to kill ghori with his shabd bhedi baan vidya. so even ghori couldn't take over india as he was killed.

hope i answered your questions.
😃
sword2exile thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: David

Umm.. can anyone answer my few question...Hope The Followin Set of Explanations are apt for ur set of questions😉

1.How did PRC die in afghanistan and how did he reach there in first place. I thought fight with ghori and prc were happening in india?

. - Well Way Back the boundaries of india was stretched till Hindu Kush region Afghanistan - the then "Hindoostan/Hindustan" n wasn't like recent/current day boundaries of India. It was only with The Advancement of Mohd. Ghori - The Gate to India "HinduKush" was destroyed. Though he simply came for loot n plunder in India the then Hindustan. But it was his destruction of the gate of Hindoostan "Hindukush" that make way for other foreign rulers to invade in it n thus Fortifying n establisihng their set of rule/authority.

For more info on Hindu Kush, click here: Hindu Kush Region

Herez a much more visual explanation for - Stretch of Inidan Boundaries!

source link: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ghurids


2. How they buried him afghanistan not in india. why he was buried not cremated?.

- answer seems pretty obvious

3.Who become king after PRC death? -

After Prithviraj III

Prithviraj's defeat and capture at Tarain ushered in Muslim rule in North India by the Delhi Sultanate. The Chauhans remained in Ajmer as feudatories of Muhammad of Ghor and his successors, the Sultans of Delhi, until 1365, when Ajmer was captured by the rulers of Mewar.

Son of Prithviraj III Chandrapal Dev came and established the state of Bhadawar and from there a new Rajput clan evolved that was called Bhadurias.

A branch of the Chauhans, led by Govinda, the grandson of Pritviraj III, established themselves as rulers of Ranthambore from the thirteenth to the fifteenth centuries, until Ranthambore was captured by Rana Kumbha of Mewar.

The Hadas,great dynasty of the Chauhans, moved into the Hadoti region in the twelfth century, capturing Bundi in 1241 and ruled there until the twentieth century. One sept of these HadaRajputs won Kota and ruled their till the merger of state in independent India.

Chauhans of the Deora branch established the state of Sirohi in southern Rajasthan, and ruled there from the fifteenth century until Indian Independence.

In western India Chauhans are found at Devgadh Baria, founded by Dungarsinhji, a member of the Khichi Chauhan clan about 700 years ago.

Rajkumar (Bhadaiyan State of Awadh, UP) and Bachgoti (Diyara State of Awadh, UP) are two other branches of Chauhans (both are primarily in Uttar Pradesh). Dhauhan's are also found in Khurja Dasheri and Arnia.

The last Chauhan king, Raja Tej Singh, ruled in Mainpuri, a district in Uttar Pradesh of India.

source link: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chauhan

4.How did Ghori die and How much he took over india when PRC die?

Two Set Of Theories "Debatable Topic"

First Theory - Prithvi Raj's Revenge, Stated By Prithvitaj Raso Written By Chander Bardai "Court Poet" of Prithviraj Chauha iii

Chanderam told Mahmud that this taunting would avail nothing, for Prithvi Raj would never do as some sundry courtiers bade him do. He said that Prithvi Raj, as an anointed king, would not accept orders from anyone other than another king. His ego thus massaged, and in the spirit of the occasion, Mahmud agreed to personally give Prithvi Raj the order to shoot.Some iron plates were hung and Prithivi Raj was asked to aim at them.A man was to strike the plate with a hammer and Prithvi Raj was supposed to hit that plate.

Thus, Chanderam provided Prithvi Raj with an aural indication of where Mahmud was seated. He gave Prithvi Raj one further indication of the same, by composing a couplet on the spot and reciting the same in Prithvi Raj's hearing. The couplet, composed in a language understood only by Prithvi Raj went thus:

"Char bans, chaubis gaj, angul ashta praman, Ta upar sultan hai, Chuke mat Chauhan."


(Four measures ahead of you and twenty four yards away as measured with eight finger measurement, is seated the Sultan. Do not miss him now, Chauhan).

Mahmud then ordered Prithvi Raj to shoot. Prithvi Raj thus came to know the location of Mahmud and started shooting at the plates.When he hit the target courtiers said "vah" "vah" and Mahmud said "Shabash", recognising Mahmud's voice and turning in the direction from where he heard Mahmud speak, Prithvi Raj took aim based only on the voice and on Chanderam's couplet, he sent an arrow racing to Mahmud's throat. Mahmud was thus struck dead by Prithvi Raj. Prithvi Raj and Chanderam did not want to die from the hands of Mahmud's courtiers so they stabbed each other.

source link: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prithviraj_Chauhan

Second Theory -

In 1206, Ghori had to travel to Lahore to crush a revolt. On his way back to Ghazni, his caravan halted at Dhamiak near Jehlum. He was killed while offering his evening prayers. Many think that the murderer was an Ismaili. However, some historians believe that the murderer belonged to the warrior Gakhars tribe that resided in the area. He was buried where he fell and his tomb has recently been renovated..

source link: Mohd.Ghori

Answer to ur second part of the question: How much he took over india when PRC die?

After defeating Prithviraj Chauhan in the the Second battle of Tarain in 1192 CE, Rajput kingdoms like Saraswati, Samana, Kohram and Hansi were captured without any difficulty.

source link: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Muhammad_Ghori

5.why didnt indian government bring PRC 's buried body in ajmer, india. isnt like india govt are poor. Govt have lot of power and money these days. why dont they use it to bring his tombstone in india. Now anything is possible in world. World change alott. why they leave PRC tombstone there. doesnt govt care. OR arent they allowed to bring PRC's tombstone in india.

Edited by sword2exile - 17 years ago
wagma thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 17 years ago
#4

wow Swordy, veryyyy well said👏👏👏

only one thing i want to add that i don't think there is any problem in transfering of Prc grave from Afghanistan to India. I don't know why people think that way.

lakshmim_84 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#5
india has only now opened consultancy in afghanistan. Till then there was no relation between india n afghanistan ie when taliban was in power. Even when our aircraft was hijacked n taken to kandhahar, the diplomatic talks were carried out with pakistan as intermediatary.
now the relations have improved. india has opened many consultancies and india is an active member the reconstruction work of afghanistan. So might be after few yrs, indian govt can forward its proposal to afghan govt. ie if taliban doesn't come to power again.
ppiyu thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#6

Thanks for the info Swordy, Aditi, Laks....


sword2exile thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: ppiyu

Thanks for the info Swordy, Aditi, Laks....


Hey Piyu,

u welcome😳

n yeah Laks n aditi thnx for more explanatory points😳

sword2exile thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: wagma

wow Swordy, veryyyy well said👏👏👏

only one thing i want to add that i don't think there is any problem in transfering of Prc grave from Afghanistan to India. I don't know why people think that way.

Hey Wagma,

thnx a lot for replyin to my posted reply😳

David thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#9
wow Thanks that lot of info thanks for telling me. appreciate it.
sword2exile thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: David

wow Thanks that lot of info thanks for telling me. appreciate it.

u wlecome😳

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".