Viewer's Reviews & Previews -13th July Pg 142 - Page 108

Created

Last reply

Replies

1.1k

Views

58.6k

Users

43

Likes

3.1k

Frequent Posters

MERARAI thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago

Originally posted by: kEEnkEEn

Isnt that kind of the point? She felt no anguish whatsoever IMHO - only anger for much of the episode...none more so during her "powerful dialogue" scene if that's what you can call it...culminating in her walk-off
anguish only manifested itself when she beheld the scene...the extent her dismissal had on the man that "professed" love for her...then her humanity and the enormity of what she had caused propelled her into action...
I dont blame the actress one iota...its the makers I blame as to how P is perceived...I just wonder if they intended this or whether they were simply oblivious as to the effect such a portrayal of the female lead would have...
Krishna isnt the only naive one around the place...She knows it so why such a reaction?😕
PS the hug again IMHO did not redeem the preceding indifference...it simply does one of two things for me...show P to be full of hot air (my preferred position) and a hypocrite if not a liar (she does it with more ease than Krishna at times) or show P reacting similarly to how a mother would react if they saw their toddler fall over and graze their knee...You know where I stand on this one, our laughter fest was the best part after watching that episode.
If it is put to me that no - this is the reaction of a wife to the sight of her fallen, prone husband, thereby somehow redeeming her earlier callous, cold hearted delivery that incidentally caused the husband's condition...heaven help us all...⭐️👏You said it all.



Edited by MERARAI - 14 years ago
Yemi-IF thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago

something has been bugging me... doesn't it look odd that Kesar who's supposed to be 7-8 months preggies does a lot of standing around? shouldn't she be feeling the weight of the baby and reaching for the nearest surface to park herself? especially since she's never been that far along in any of her pregnancies before 😕😕

before the bump was noticabale, she used to sit and have her meal with Shakti.. nowadays she's back to waitressing for him ...and today during the festivities, she's on lady in waiting duties for KP

i feel even if the focus of the track is not yet on the impending bun, little touches like this could make it more realistic
HamiSky thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
11th July episode...

Episode in a nut shell is P is back home and KN throwing a hint of who Ganga is...

On the whole it looked like hurried shot and edited episode...may be due to Mr. Dang's sudden demise, they hurried up the shooting, editing and other related work in a haste..(as we did hear the shoot was canceled for a day)

For such a reason, we can overlook even if the upcoming 2-3 episodes also gonna be presented this way.

Mmm...all looked good today..esp the ladies and SS had the max dialogues and needless to say about AS's acting or dialogue delivery..it was very good.

If its their intention to show K in a dulha look..they should at least shaved off Arhaan's stubble..make him look tidier ..if not for a hair cut.

A watchable episode...!


tanthya thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 14 years ago

Originally posted by: kEEnkEEn

Isnt that kind of the point? She felt no anguish whatsoever IMHO - only anger for much of the episode...none more so during her "powerful dialogue" scene if that's what you can call it...culminating in her walk-off
anguish only manifested itself when she beheld the scene...the extent her dismissal had on the man that "professed" love for her...then her humanity and the enormity of what she had caused propelled her into action...
I dont blame the actress one iota...its the makers I blame as to how P is perceived...I just wonder if they intended this or whether they were simply oblivious as to the effect such a portrayal of the female lead would have...
Krishna isnt the only naive one around the place...
PS the hug again IMHO did not redeem the preceding indifference...it simply does one of two things for me...show P to be full of hot air (my preferred position) and a hypocrite if not a liar (she does it with more ease than Krishna at times) or show P reacting similarly to how a mother would react if they saw their toddler fall over and graze their knee...
If it is put to me that no - this is the reaction of a wife to the sight of her fallen, prone husband, thereby somehow redeeming her earlier callous, cold hearted delivery that incidentally caused the husband's condition...heaven help us all...


I disagree, Kulvi ..Anguish was present as can be seen from her act of clutching the pendant of her chain when Krishna is descending from the tank..but simply over riding this anguish was the anger, which she had held in tight grip whilst he was atop the tank and which she gave a free rein to when he was safely on terra firma !! ..as for 'Powerful dialogues' ..read again, I have clearly stated that it did not gel with the over all scene set up..

Here I again to see it from a different context ...u state anguish came about only when she saw the effects of her anger on her love...but I would say that it was her anguish, her release of tension that propelled her anger and released her tongue to give him a severe set down ..and this anguish and tension came about bec she loved him..

Actor cannot escape scot free..she too needs to interpret, has to coordinate with her director, present her vision and incorporate the feedback too..


No, Krishna is not the naive one around the place ..Pratigya is too..but then again she is young and it is quite natural for her to be naive and trusting ??


Here again our views diverge ..the Hug was spontaneous and had only one thing uppermost, to console him, to indicate that all is forgiven..this was not driven by any maternal instinct but was powered by love..pure & Simple !!

Let me put it this way..this was a reaction of a wife, a loving and caring wife who just witnessed her relationship made mockery off, whose emotions were played with and one who had to tamp down on her emotions lest it lead to untoward incident.. the anger was the release from the tension and the love which was latent came to the fore when the anger was spent ...

Edited by tanthya - 14 years ago
tanthya thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 14 years ago

Originally posted by: yemi3006

something has been bugging me... doesn't it look odd that Kesar who's supposed to be 7-8 months preggies does a lot of standing around? shouldn't she be feeling the weight of the baby and reaching for the nearest surface to park herself? especially since she's never been that far along in any of her pregnancies before 😕😕

before the bump was noticabale, she used to sit and have her meal with Shakti.. nowadays she's back to waitressing for him ...and today during the festivities, she's on lady in waiting duties for KP

i feel even if the focus of the track is not yet on the impending bun, little touches like this could make it more realistic



Look at the way she sits unsupported for long stretches ...plus even weirder is the fact that she has not gone to visit any Doctor...
sweet_bhanki thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago

11th July - felt like a bucket of cold water thrown at me.

Again we had that darn continuity issue that's becoming quite habitual with MKAP. With Friday's scene, in my opinion, ending on a powerful note I had hoped that it would continue on from there. I would have loved to have seen the couple alone. I think it's too much to ask for them to sit down and talk. Maybe that's reserved for when they get back to TN, although unlikely anytime soon what with Ganga there. So maybe some scenes like them running to take shelter under that now famous tanki, a few more eye-locks, possibly another hug, the rain finally stopping and them making their way home. There needn't have been any dialogues. Just looks and gestures would have said it all. Instead it jumped straight to TN.

Amma of course has nothing better to do then sit in her corner; seething in anger and frustration, defiance and silence her only weapons at the moment. Kesamma and KN really are two peas from the same pod when the former's gesture is clearly interpreted by the latter. Loved Komal today when she made her feelings perfectly clear to Amma. And how right you are, Komal, about Amma's jealousy. For it is exactly this emotion, as well as a huge ego, that caused Amma to take the step to break up Krishna and Prats. Looks like you've lost your partner in crime, Amma, although I doubt this will have any real effect on you. Should you really be surprised? Have you forgotten that your daughter was about to blab to SS when she discovered your plot to barbeque Prats a while back. Don't expect any loyalty from her. You've got KN and Kesamma to keep you company - for now a least, although wouldn't put it pass these two to leave her high and dry to save their own skin.

Seems like preferential treatment going on here, SS. When Prats made a beautiful Rangoli pattern last year on Diwali you berated her for making the floor dirty and now Ganga wants to do the same thing you have no objection. In fact you become a bumbering fool whilst being scolded when you accidentally smudge the work of art. In fact we saw how similar SS and Krishna when both resort to using English words and holding there ears when seeking forgiveness.

Wow, Arhaan looked super hot in his kurta. Looked like Krishna had gone back to TN to check that all the necessary preparations had been made and also had time to pop into the shops to get a gift for this babu. Must say that Pooja too looked very beautiful in her outfit. In fact both looked absolute adorable. Loved the huge exchanged between father and son. I like that Komal went to apologise to Prats for her behaviour, but anyone else notice that Prats referred to Komal as 'Komal didi' not 'Komal bhabi'? Is this an indication that Komal may just be Prats didi and no longer a bhabi in the not too distance future? Will Adarsh be serving Komal a set of her own divorce papers? Could the change in her attitude towards Prats be so that she gets our sympathy when this happens instead of enjoy seeing that she gets her just desserts after the way she treated Prats and instigating Amma? Hopefully we'll see a better relationship forming between these two sister-in-laws.

The dance sequence was ok, but nothing special and quite lukewarm. It got better when the happy couple joined in but still wasn't enough to get my full attention or my heart pumping. I did like the eye lock between the two. Amma's reaction was expected when Prats went over to seek her blessings. The way she showed her discomfort at having Prats near her, the defiance and indifference, the smirk on her face when SS was praising Prats for her morals. She must have thanked her lucky stars when KN stepped in and let the cat of out the bag before she could be forced to give it.

Ok. Now coming to this whole SS and Ganga getting married. Not sure about the rest of you but why do I get the feeling that this is all a set-up. Why is it that I can not convince myself that SS would stoop so low, or more accurately that the CVs decided that SS, a very important character in MKAP, would be the chosen as the person to show this happening through SS. I still can not forget SS's dialogues, bellowing that he is not a characterless man and berating the others for their dirty thoughts regarding him and Ganga. Could this all be a part of the game? Is he doing this with the intention that Pratigya will be there to stop the marriage? Surely he didn't think that he would get away with marrying a girl old enough to be his grand-daughter whilst Prats was there. Even if the marriage had taken place before Prats arrival she would have objected and would have got Ganga out of it. Which leads me to believe that maybe this is aimed at attempting to change Amma's feelings towards Prats by having Prats fight on her behalf. We already saw in today's episode that Prats has forgiven Amma by showing her seeking Amma's blessing and SS firing her for not giving it. This marriage could be a last resort after seeing Amma's nautanki today. He knows that with Amma filled with jealousy and ego there will always be unrest in TN, so this will need to be destroyed and the only way to do this will be to change her opinion regarding Prats. Something has to happen to trigger the idea for the marriage as I don't believe that it is premeditated. So will wait and watch what the trigger will be and how the puppet master will play with his puppets.

Edited by sweet_bhanki - 14 years ago
shrutisinha thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago

Originally posted by: kEEnkEEn

On a lighter note, I had heard of Srimaan and Srimatis, Sardar and Sardarnis,

Since watching I discovered Thakurs and their Thakurayens..
But it was for the first time, I heard Babas have Babuwayens!!!!🤣
Jiyo SS!!! Naye naye sabd humka sunaibo, yaar!!! Wah!!! Ghajab!!
👏👍🏼

😆🤣🤣🤣
Love-u-all thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago

Originally posted by: tanthya


I disagree, Kulvi ..Anguish was present as can be seen from her act of clutching the pendant of her chain when Krishna is descending from the tank..but simply over riding this anguish was the anger, which she had held in tight grip whilst he was atop the tank and which she gave a free rein to when he was safely on terra firma !! ..as for 'Powerful dialogues' ..read again, I have clearly stated that it did not gel with the over all scene set up..

Here I again to see it from a different context ...u state anguish came about only when she saw the effects of her anger on her love...but I would say that it was her anguish, her release of tension that propelled her anger and released her tongue to give him a severe set down ..and this anguish and tension came about bec she loved him..

Actor cannot escape scot free..she too needs to interpret, has to coordinate with her director, present her vision and incorporate the feedback too..


No, Krishna is not the naive one around the place ..Pratigya is too..but then again she is young and it is quite natural for her to be naive and trusting ??


Here again our views diverge ..the Hug was spontaneous and had only one thing uppermost, to console him, to indicate that all is forgiven..this was not driven by any maternal instinct but was powered by love..pure & Simple !!

Let me put it this way..this was a reaction of a wife, a loving and caring wife who just witnessed her relationship made mockery off, whose emotions were played with and one who had to tamp down on her emotions lest it lead to untoward incident.. the anger was the release from the tension and the love which was latent came to the fore when the anger was spent ...



I will get bald soon, can the explanation be simpler, i start to pull my hair in an effort to understand the explanations. 😆

Couple of quotes for K & P ' Love is hard to get into, but even harder to get out of '. And for K "You should make Prats angry if you wish her to love you" 😆

Edited by PRAGMATIC - 14 years ago
tanthya thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 14 years ago


@ Prags, We can always get u a wig..even a punk one !!


@ Meethi Bhanki..The last para , even I was thinking the same ...we all know SS is very zealous in guarding his fiefdom and knows unity is needed to maintain the strength and he is very well aware that unity will remain a dream as long as Amma refuses to accept Pratigya, hence this elaborate charade to open Amma's eyes..
Love-u-all thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago

Originally posted by: sweet_bhanki

Ok. Now coming to this whole SS and Ganga getting married. Not sure about the rest of you but why do I get the feeling that this is all a set-up. Why is it that I can not convince myself that SS would stoop so low, or more accurately that the CVs decided that SS, a very important character in MKAP, would be the chosen as the person to show this happening through SS. I still can not forget SS's dialogues, bellowing that he is not a characterless man and berating the others for their dirty thoughts regarding him and Ganga. Could this all be a part of the game? Is he doing this with the intention that Pratigya will be there to stop the marriage? Surely he didn't think that he would get away with marrying a girl old enough to be his grand-daughter whilst Prats was there. Even if the marriage had taken place before Prats arrival she would have objected and would have got Ganga out of it. Which leads me to believe that maybe this is aimed at attempting to change Amma's feelings towards Prats by having Prats fight on her behalf. We already saw in today's episode that Prats has forgiven Amma by showing her seeking Amma's blessing and SS firing her for not giving it. This marriage could be a last resort after seeing Amma's nautanki today. He knows that with Amma filled with jealousy and ego there will always be unrest in TN, so this will need to be destroyed and the only way to do this will be to change her opinion regarding Prats.

Something has to happen to trigger the idea for the marriage as I don't believe that it is premeditated. So will wait and watch what the trigger will be.



😃

Just save this para somewhere safe. We will refer back to these lines in about two weeks time. 👍🏼


Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".