Similarities between Sana and Gauhar Khan - Page 13

Created

Last reply

Replies

140

Views

21.4k

Users

50

Likes

488

Frequent Posters

..Bebolove.. thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 12 years ago
Both represented themselves as s**ts.
Because if you ask a practicing muslim woman or an average muslim who has her own dignity ... their answer will be that both are going to hell. As muslim women they should have worn decent clothes (ignoring revealing clothes) but they actually chose to wear exposing clothes. So they can never earn respect. And they can never be known as "muslims".

And ofcourse i am no one to judge but gobar she didn't even listened to her elder sister before shooting a bikini shoot ... same goes to veena malik.

About your question, yes three of em have got similarities... "flirting" "self obsessed" "s**ts".
Forever-KA thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago

1- I think the answer lies in your own post. lol. You are talking as an Atheist and I wrote that as a Muslim.

2- Of course over religious people can be bad. I don't know about Asa Ram but taliban types who claim to be conservative real muslims are one such example. that was never my point

3- You too perhaps are showing lack of awareness. Even if we put aside conservative and liberal mindset among muslims, from our knowledge of teachings of islam, what these two women showed is a contradiction. You can take any interpretation of Islam and you won't see behavior of wearing bikinis and posing allowed. That is a fact. This does not mean I am saying she should be wearing burqa. I am sorry like it or not it is just not there. There is no excuse or a way around it. Then at the same time we see them offering namaz and being religious. That is the disconnect I was trying to understand. I asked maybe that is a pattern among Indian Muslim women.

4- These are not two random women. They came back to back in a show

5- Overall point was why are such muslim women picked for the show? why can't we see normal ones like sampat paal etc.

Women including muslim women are still free to live their life as they want to and that includes wearing anything or nothing as it is not my business nor do i care. lol. However since I know about Islam this contradictory behavior and that too year after year made me think is this a coincident? Every year there is gay type, a star, a fighter, a lover and then add to it this.
Edited by King-Anu - 12 years ago
LovelyPlanet thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
equally not sure what you are trying to say.. asa ram is in jail because of the obvious(though we should nt judge since excessive weath invites jealousy and enemies).. Raping anyone should land religious and non-religious behind bars regardless.
KA expects that if you follow a certain religion you should atleast follow at least some main teachings. However, considering how free and flexible as nation we are, it is all justified. Certain sections of Hindus are supposed to be hard-core vegetarians(dairy somehow remains vegetarian in our country), but we all flex the rules as per convenience, yet keep visting temples even when one is hard to find. Yet some despite suffering starvation manage to stay vegetarianism.
Forever-KA thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: LovelyPlanet

equally not sure what you are trying to say.. asa ram is in jail because of the obvious(though we should nt judge since excessive weath invites jealousy and enemies).. Raping anyone should land religious and non-religious behind bars regardless.

KA expects that if you follow a certain religion you should atleast follow at least some main teachings. However, considering how free and flexible as nation we are, it is all justified. Certain sections of Hindus are supposed to be hard-core vegetarians(dairy somehow remains vegetarian in our country), but we all flex the rules as per convenience, yet keep visting temples even when one is hard to find. Yet some despite suffering starvation manage to stay vegetarianism.


okay you put it in a better way. lol. yes my point is about the contradiction. maybe some are not getting me and thinking i am not happy or against women but point is that there is a contradiction and i see such people being selected - for trp and taboo purpose i guess or it could be that they are from entertainment industry. that was my only point.

otherwise i am not the one to judge people. lol
LoveYourself thumbnail
Engager Level 2 Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
I am really amazed at the number of people especially non-indians, who may be see tits and bits of india only through television and bollywood, comment at length and provide their expert opinion about indian (muslim/non-muslim) culture. The only thing they forget that boolywood and television is a work of fiction and not facts...India is a culturally and religiously huge country...so a simple advice from my side to all non-indians i.e a foreigners--- to understand india and her masses well, please plan a month long vacation. or skip watching TV soaps and bollywood, start watching documentaries on india by national geographic. You'll find them on you tube, coz they represent the REAL INDIA!
Forever-KA thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: LoveYourself

I am really amazed at the number of people especially non-indians, who may be see tits and bits of india only through television and bollywood, comment at length and provide their expert opinion about indian (muslim/non-muslim) culture. The only thing they forget that boolywood and television is a work of fiction and not facts...India is a culturally and religiously huge country...so a simple advice from my side to all non-indians i.e a foreigners--- to understand india and her masses well, please plan a month long vacation. or skip watching TV soaps and bollywood, start watching documentaries on india by national geographic. You'll find them on you tube, coz they represent the REAL INDIA!


This is a serious discussion ..so spare me foreigner nonsense.

No where did I at least say I am an expert on India. If anything I framed my topic asking rather than passing definitive comments. My advice to you would be to explore this topic first before advising me to explore India.

Thanks lol
Forever-KA thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: knursingh


Of course you did not offend me. Your input is appreciated

ishakumar thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
there are many modern muslim families, that would allow their daughters to do such things! so i dont think that this is a really big issue to talk about and argue about! 🥱
PiscineMolitor thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: ..Cinderella...

Both represented themselves as s**ts.

Because if you ask a practicing muslim woman or an average muslim who has her own dignity ... their answer will be that both are going to hell. As muslim women they should have worn decent clothes (ignoring revealing clothes) but they actually chose to wear exposing clothes. So they can never earn respect. And they can never be known as "muslims".

And ofcourse i am no one to judge but gobar she didn't even listened to her elder sister before shooting a bikini shoot ... same goes to veena malik.

About your question, yes three of em have got similarities... "flirting" "self obsessed" "s**ts".

Do you even hear yourself right now? Who are you to decide if someone goes to hell or heaven? Leave that to our God. The least you can be is respectful if you dont like someone. Gauhar may dress as she please and may end up going wherever she has to go based on her attitude towards others and her basic nature. Start looking out of what is written in some ancient scriptures and use your intellect. To even harbour such far fetched thoughts for people you dont even know is sick. All you'll do is judge her. And for that i think your chances of ending up in the worst place ever is much higher than any gauhar or sana.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".