Who u liked more, Aish in D2 or Kats in D3 ? - Page 2

Is this a joke?

Originally posted by: ponymo

Is this a joke?

Can the TM be any more biased? Why include in the options your opinion of their acting? If you just wanted people's opinion you would have kept their names. You are trying to influence people's opinion by trying to diss Ash and praise Katrina by forcing to vote for your opinion about the two actresses. The fact that most people are still voting for Ash is a clear indicator of the answer to your question I guess.

Anyway this is what I thought, coming to the importance of the role, Aishwarya is clearly a winner by a huge margin. Ash's role was significant and took the story forward. Katrina was just an extended item girl, worse than even Bipasha and Esha's roles.

Coming to the performance, Katrina was pathetic and expressionless as ever in whatever little she 'acted' in the movie. Coming to dance, what she did I won't call dance, more like acrobatics, and the tougher stunts were performed by body double and not herself. You can see it in the Kamli song easily.

Aishwarya's role was wannabe and her dialogues were bad, especially in the first half, where she is mouthing dialogues like "Are you like checking me out" - seriously who wrote it? But that is because she was trying hard to impress Hrithik to accept her as his partner. After they come together in the second half, it was a treat to watch. Her chemistry with Hrithik was the highlight of the movie. Her love story was a VERY important track in the film, unlike Katrina's, which looked like it was kept in the film only to make way for a few songs by Katrina where she can titillate the audience.

That six bullet scene with Hrithik that she did, a she had a different expression for a evert bullet. First bullet - not understanding a thing, thinking it was a joke and after it is fired, expression of SHOCK. Second bullet - Hands shaking to carry the revolver, still confused and Hrithik shouts, she fires, having been shit scared. Third bullet - Hrithik's turn to shoot her, sheer horror on her face. Afraid of death, and the pain. Fourth bullet - Her turn to shoot him again, her eyes show confusion and love, she fires bullet closing her eyes secretly praying that there is no bullet for Hrithik, even if there is, she does not want to see Hrithik in pain, dying. Fifth bullet, Hrithik's turn to fire - She is no more scared, she thinks the bullet is definitely in the fifth turn, she shows expressions of remorse and admittance of guilt and expresses that she deserves the bullet for cheating him. Sixth bullet - When she doesn't get bullet, now it is definitely HR's turn to die. She doesn't celebrate her getting saved, she is sad because their love is coming to an end. Takes the revolver, determined, but shoots herself. After which Hrithik drops the real bullet, she realizes it was a bluff "I hate you", "I love you too". Kiss and hug.

WHAT AN EPIC SCENE, THAT! This is REAL CHEMISTRY. Not the fake kiss Katrina gave Aamir, and for which she had to give so many retakes.

And oh, Aishwarya danced amazing in the songs, something which even Aamir admitted. Her songs Dhoom Again, Crazy Kiya Re and Dil Laga Na were super popular, unlike Katrina's songs which weren't even close be it in music or dance.

And finally, there was novelty in Aishwarya's role. Ash had never done a purely commercial film till Dhoom 2, whereas that has been the bread and butter for Katrina forever. More marks to Aishwarya for stepping out of her comfort zone and trying to do something different, and minus marks to Katrina for trying to stick to her comfort zone.