Gopi and Ahem

isnt the story the same is gopi and ahem from saath nibhana saathiya? now the cvs needs to be something different

Omg! I was thinking the same thing! Granted the treatment is very different but at a very basic level they are comparable. Both shows are promoted to highlight the hopes, desires, aspirations a newly wed bride holds as she steps into her in laws home. Both urmi and gopi had/have certain hopes and a vision of what marriage means to them and what they hope to experience and the love they want from their husband.. that love and respect is their right as a wife. Lets see where cvs take doli armaano kii.. With saath nibhana saathiya we've seen gopi struggling to gain her husband's affection and her pillar of strength was and is her mother in law

Maybe but cvs will deffo plan somat different cvs in saathiya took ages for gohem love and I doubt they will take as long as sns

Dnt like samrats mother she seems to cover every mistake Samrat makes where kokila from sns is seen as a caring mil and someone who does nt hide her sons mistake

I think they're completely different.

I think they're completely different.

Basic track is same but treatment is different I guess

i think they are different because unlike Gopi who had nothing else going for her Urmi has her whole family loving her.
unlike Gopi who was so dumb enough to wash a laptop Urmi is educated.
Unlike Gopi who doesnt have a voice,i think Urmi stronger
Unlike Ahem who had a romantic girlfriend during the period of his marriage, Samrat doesnt believe in love at all.
Unlike Ahem who respect his family and other people's feelings to a point, Simrat is like RK who only in love with himself.

Unlike in SNS where Kokila rules the house here, Simrat is the rular

Kokila's one look would have shut Simrat off in some cases.

Kokila is a supporter to good and the punish-er of evil...regardless of who is involved. while Simrat's mom,is just a yes-sir toy to her stupid son ( by the way i love the actor... hate the character)

Originally posted by: skar1984

I think they're completely different.

In Saath Nibhana Saathiya Ahem wasn't really chauvinistic and he didn't want his wife to just be a housewife. In fact it was the complete opposite, he hated that Gopi was illiterate and that was one of the main barriers in their relationship. I think he's expectation's were reasonable, as he just wanted a wife that was slighlty similar to him, as in she should know how to read/write, be slightly modern but with traditional values, just someone compatible, but Gopi was the complete opposite. Gopi was very timid, and didn't have many thoughts of her own, and just followed her mother-in-law, and often didn't seem much like a wife. She didn't come across as romantic or anything.

In this story the lead is chauvinistic and unlike Ahem, he simply wants a housewife, he can't stand the thought that a woman has a mind of her own.

Urmi is also completely different to Gopi. Urmi is more intelligent, she has traditional values but she also has her own thoughts and beliefs. She has a very idealistic and romantic idea of love.

Here the lead is very egotistical, but he doesn't even want someone compatible to him, he wants someone who will obey him.

Not disagreeing with you - the points you make are totally valid but it's outside the context of this thread - the whole idea here is to say that both shows started from the newly wed bride's point of view where every bride comes to her husband's home with hopes and desires - that is the only point of comparison here. Everything else stated and the points I made above explain how the treatment of these shows are clearly different. :)

no idea as i never seen that show.