CM's sacrifice - Page 4

Created

Last reply

Replies

39

Views

4.4k

Users

18

Likes

73

Frequent Posters

libsrocks thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#31

Originally posted by: Skepblun

@Ashasaina and @brick_red - Agree with your posts.

@libsrocks

I feel Shiv was right in what he said. Alok was wrong. Wrong in what he did. Wrong in his silence. Wrong in his defiant attempt to feign denial even as truth was in front of him. Wrong in slapping Shiv. He could have shouted. But he had no right to slap him in such a state.

We can't blame only Anandi here as even Ira learnt truth from Sarla and came marching to know the truth. Truth and past can come out any time. Basant's truth had also come out no? Singhs thought Gudia chapter was over but years later their lives again got entwined as she came back as Gauri.

I agree it is too early to blame CM. But I blame Alok for sure. He was selfish.

I don't think CM could have EBed and pressurised Alok to accept her kid - UNLESS Anup had also been party to this. If she did this WITHOUT informing Anup or without his consent then she was definitely even worse than just wrong.

Anyway, history of Ira's pregnancies and miscarriages compared to CM's makes me wonder if Alok was so available to Ira and so much with her, while Anup was mostly away? 😆

that a different story that truth can find it's way any how but for now truth came out becoz someone wnated it to and not becoz it of destiny...had annaid not tried to find the truth she won't have anyhting to hide to shiv and then shiv wouldn't havr talked to sarla and then sarla wouldn't be asked to leave udaipur and then she wouldn't have met the accident...the truth for now would ahve kept hidden if anandi would have got so curious to know about it
do you mean to say alok wasn't really with ira 😲...i don't think so 😕...he doesn't seem to be that dheela character type 😆
seraal thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#32
...well...relieved to find CM as honorable as ever...nice to see she has brought up her son shiv like the way she desired...as is mahi... bcz u see sanchi's upbringing is quite differet under iraz control
642126 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#33
@Libsrocks

I said Alok was with Ira. A lot. 😉

I hate Anandi's snooping around too especially if her husband and family are good. But if Alok was desperate to hide the truth then he should have never gone to that hospital function, or destroyed hospital records 30 years ago or got something else written there, got CCTV switched off when he came to hospital records room and arranged a flight for Sarla and escorted her out of Udaipur himself.

I don't think Sarla's death is connected to Anandi's snooping around. Sarla panicked because of Alok's pressure. I don't even think she needed to panic in front of Ira. Ira wasn't suspicious. And couldn't Sarla lie to Ira? What was the need to fear bumping into Ira? Ira wasn't even looking in that direction as Sarla!

Lastly I am in two minds over this. Don't husbands and in laws do total checking of girl and her family before marriage and often keep a check on wives even after marriage? Then what's wrong if wife wants to know something? Woman is part of family now. Does she not have rights to learn truth?
brick_red thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#34
Why shoot the messenger? Anandi was just a catalyst for truth to come out. Even without Anandi truth would have come out one day.

Good that truth is out now. It would have been very painful if the truth was directly or indirectly revealed to Shiv in the midst of a medical emergency or in somebody's death bed. Shiv is upset now. But he has the chance to talk it out with everybody.
Edited by brick_red - 12 years ago
poorvab thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#35

Originally posted by: Skepblun

@Libsrocks

I said Alok was with Ira. A lot. 😉

I hate Anandi's snooping around too especially if her husband and family are good. But if Alok was desperate to hide the truth then he should have never gone to that hospital function, or destroyed hospital records 30 years ago or got something else written there, got CCTV switched off when he came to hospital records room and arranged a flight for Sarla and escorted her out of Udaipur himself.

I don't think Sarla's death is connected to Anandi's snooping around. Sarla panicked because of Alok's pressure. I don't even think she needed to panic in front of Ira. Ira wasn't suspicious. And couldn't Sarla lie to Ira? What was the need to fear bumping into Ira? Ira wasn't even looking in that direction as Sarla!

Lastly I am in two minds over this. Don't husbands and in laws do total checking of girl and her family before marriage and often keep a check on wives even after marriage? Then what's wrong if wife wants to know something? Woman is part of family now. Does she not have rights to learn truth?


very good post
@bold
i totally agree. i dont understand why is anandi being blamed for this whole thing.
she got suspicious when she heard sarla saying she clearly remembers about ira's still born so isnt it natural to get curious. and its her husband we're talking she has every right to know the truth and also let her husband know about it.

and i'm still confused over the whole truth.
didnt all shekhars know meenu was also pregnant that time n had her delivery on the same day?
GoodDoc_2105 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#36
I don't think Anandi went around snooping.
She over heard what nurse Sarla said to the other nurse and that disturbed her very much and she told her husband that she is disturbed about it and as usual her husband brushed away her concerns.
Then she let go of it.Happened to go to that hospital and she decided to check the records it was not a planned act on her part.She found what is written in the records.

Then back home she heard nurse telling that she was mistaken.It bothered her a lot because by then she came to the right conclusion and it worried her a lot because the truth which was buried has come out after so many years.

For her it didn't matter whether he is a Shekhar or not but she was scared what will happen to her husband if her he gets to know of it.

She needed some one to talk to about this.Meenu was totally adamant about it.If Meenu had been not so vehement about she would have felt reassured.

But later her husband learnt it from some other source that his wife knew something and not telling him.So he made her tell all this to him and he went on the mission of finding the truth on his own with his wife giving him all the support needed unquestioningly.

She would have never said anything if it were left to her.She was trying to find out the truth about her husband and she has every right to do so.

Anandi is definitely not the root cause but somebody's pathetic attempts at trying to bury the truth are the root cause.
Shinya thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#37

Originally posted by: aparnauma

I don't think Anandi went around snooping.

She over heard what nurse Sarla said to the other nurse and that disturbed her very much and she told her husband that she is disturbed about it and as usual her husband brushed away her concerns.
Then she let go of it.Happened to go to that hospital and she decided to check the records it was not a planned act on her part.She found what is written in the records.

Then back home she heard nurse telling that she was mistaken.It bothered her a lot because by then she came to the right conclusion and it worried her a lot because the truth which was buried has come out after so many years.

For her it didn't matter whether he is a Shekhar or not but she was scared what will happen to her husband if her he gets to know of it.

She needed some one to talk to about this.Meenu was totally adamant about it.If Meenu had been not so vehement about she would have felt reassured.

But later her husband learnt it from some other source that his wife knew something and not telling him.So he made her tell all this to him and he went on the mission of finding the truth on his own with his wife giving him all the support needed unquestioningly.

She would have never said anything if it were left to her.She was trying to find out the truth about her husband and she has every right to do so.

Anandi is definitely not the root cause but somebody's pathetic attempts at trying to bury the truth are the root cause.


Why did she decide to check the records ?

She had reached the hospital for some other purpose, her plan was not to investigate. Yet she did it because SHE HERSELF wanted to know the truth. And when no one supported her in her mission, she decided to do it secretly which is rightly called snooping.

hooked thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#38
Lets be clear about certain things !
Sarla didn't know she was cracking open a can of worms, but Anandi made sure it was not only opened, it was turned upside down ins shiv's lap so that he cudn't have looked away even if he had tried to ignore it.

This is the same Anandi who shud have told Shiv so so many things about Jagya, about her thoughts about Ganga and most of all about his darling sister Sanchi and her not so darling harkatein !!

Couple of times in the beginning when she told him- he ignored I know - but the big bloopers later on - she never even breathed about them and totally swallowed the whole pandit episode.

So am sorry - but I don't buy the - "she tried to hide but he wormed it out of her. In the past - she has shown us how effectively she can lie. But here she was just plain nosy and even though warned by Meenu - just impossibly curious about stuff that had the potential to blast in everybody's face. And now Alok and Meenu are facing anger fromt he two people they love the most in this world.

Anandi shud be shown apologising to atleast her Kanhaji for being nosy and creating this mess when she shud have listened to Meenu and trusted her judgement and left things alone.

I hope Meenu never forgives Anandi ever after and and keeps Anandi at a distance and is cold to her.
Edited by hooked - 12 years ago
brick_red thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#39
Even if we argue that Anandi went out of her way and found the truth, actually what is problem with that?
Anandi discovered a hidden truth(that happened to be very important) about her spouse. And she choose to share it with her spouse. I think Anandi did the right thing. Sharing the truth(bitter or sweet) is anytime better than hiding it from the spouse. Shiv is much more important to her than CM or Alok or Ira. She wants to be honest with her husband in a matter directly concerning him.


Unlike Alok, Anandi is confident about her spouse's ability to face truth. Unlike Alok, Anandi doesn't think she knows what is best for her spouse. She leaves it to Shiv to decide.
Anandi chooses to be honest with Shiv than playing drama with him. Did for once Shiv ask her why she is trying to find the truth? He didn't. That means he wanted to know the truth. If Shiv thinks it is better to know the truth than turning a blind eye, what is wrong in Anandi revealing it to Shiv? Anandi acted in Shiv's interest. For a change, she chooses to be a good wife than a good DIL.
GoodDoc_2105 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#40
How does it become wrong even if people say that she went out of her way to dig the truth.How does wanting to know something about her husband make her nosy???
She has every right to know if she felt something that concerns about her husband's life is being hidden.And it is her prerogative what she decides to do with the truth that she found out.
If she wants to keep it to herself because what she did not matter to her much or if she decides to disclose it to her husband it is her business.
In this instance she decided to tell her husband because she trusted him and she knew he will trust her.

If Meenu gets angry with her than it will be wrong on her part.She decided to give up her son for what she thought was a noble cause and hid this noble act of hers.It all came out because they decided to bury the truth under lies.

If anybody needs to apologise to anybody it is Alok and Meenu who need to apologise to Ira and Shiv.

Edited by aparnauma - 12 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".