JA Sep 27th - Iss Jodha ko kya naam doon?

meghanajain thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#1
The relationship between Jodha and Hamida is sometimes shown over sweet. It must be though because of Hamida's sweet nature and her bias towards Rajput for their help in past. As Jodha is cordial with Salima and Bakshi bano, but no sweetness when compared to Hamida. So, my question to Jodha as to why you are not even 1% like this with Jalal is incorrect. As it is not Jodha that started the sweet relationship it was Hamida. Jodha had to lie or hide the truth from her MIL about her leaving for Amer soon when giving the gift. I wonder if Hamida will ever find out, if she does what will she think about all this. Her own son does not tell her about this important decision but he informs MA and Ruqu. She might be even more hurt by Jodha not letting her know about it.

The whole holi affair was dull and boring. I wish they showed Jalal watching Jodha playing colors. They could have easily made him disappear when MA kaand happened so that drama could be built by CVs. Jalal warned Jodha that she should be careful about not hurting other people sentiments and play holi. But, he did not think that somebody could accidentally get color. Why would anyone play holi inside?? So, I don't blame Jodha for playing it outside. I am just surprised that Jodha wanted to play holi in the most hated ghrina to the power of infinity place Agra. Why Jodha?? Aren't you unhappy here, feel suffocated, then why play colors?? Something tells me that Jalal giving you the permission to play holi made you happy. She doesn't give the credit to him completely though. As according to Jodha, Jalal came to know the importance of colors because of her. Really??

MA is going to constantly create problems for Jodha, she is going to leave no stone unturned. She has many accounts to settle- motibai drama, rahim drowning drama, wedding dress burning, Maan singh acquittal, Ruqu MC..Sure enough, she creates a havoc about the color thrown by Jodha on her. She can lie at the drop of a hat, make up stories jet speed and sends Resham to inform Jalal about how deliberately Jodha put colors on MA. I don't know if it such big an offence when a Muslim widow gets color on her clothes, Hindu I know it is. But, still accidents can happen. Jodha asked for forgiveness and the matter should have been forgotten. I would appreciate if someone could shed light on why this is 'Gunahe azeem or something like that'

The reason for my title is I don't know yet what Jodha's character is about.
Kabhi neem neem (with Jalal generally always) Kabhi Shahed Shahed (with Jalal before MC)
Kabhi sakht sakht (with Jalal generally always) Kabhi naram naram (with Jalal today)

Jodha did not really commit any crime, it was an accident. I was thankful that she behaved well and accepted her mistake in front of Jalal. I am surprised though with this good Jodha as she was nowhere to be found during Meena Bazaar. She could have argued with Jalal even today and said I did not do it on purpose and has already apologized. Hume aap se koi bhai nahin, the usual crap she gives him. But, no today she was all mellow and accepted her fault with dignity. BTW, Rajat showed his anger so well. The moment he entered her room, OMG his expressions made me scared. No wonder, Jodha was scared.Why does Jalal think Jodha's biggest punishment is that she has to go back to Amer. Didn't Jalal think that this would make Jodha very happy till sometime back? So why this change in mind now, did he get any hint from the color explanation from Jodha that I did not understand. Friends please help me understand this.

MA comes in and pours more oil in Jodha's already burning soul. She scares her with Mynavati news. I think this is just to push Jodha to the edge and succeeds as per suicide drama coming soon. This is what might get MA in trouble when Jalal later finds out why Jodha attempted suicide. I atleast hope so, as I am tired of seeing this white NAGIN get away with every black act of hers effortlessly.

Precap: Jalal worried about Jodha, hoping we get to see sensible Jodha. Although with suicide and all I don't know what to expect..
Edited by meghanajain - 11 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

17

Views

2.3k

Users

9

Likes

47

Frequent Posters

Tohru thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#2
nice post yes i too wanted some how jalal puts colour to jodha as its her first holi but Alas these cvs

coming back to your question buddy
no its not a problem or guna if muslim widow get colour on her clother & if a muslim is coloured by a hindhu unintentionaly with holi colours its not at all Gunahe azeem .
Islam allowed ,full permission for widows to wear colourful clothes & remarriges.

they represented it in a wrong way i can say as Mahmanaga character is negative & she is a rigid adherence principles lady she don't like hindu religion or festivals before too she not let the dasies celebrate diwali even hameeda banu permited them & the muslim scholar i hardly doubt he is 😆 done a blunder who called it Gunahe azeem without hearing the full story & if they punish jodha for the unintentional act then it will be Gunah for sure.

hope i answer the question 😊

smile.sara thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: Tohru

nice post yes i too wanted some how jalal puts colour to jodha as its her first holi but Alas these cvs

coming back to your question buddy
no its not a problem or guna if muslim widow get colour on her clother & if a muslim is coloured by a hindhu unintentionaly with holi colours its not at all Gunahe azeem .
Islam allowed ,full permission for widows to wear colourful clothes & remarriges.

they represented it in a wrong way i can say as Mahmanaga character is negative & she is a rigid adherence principles lady she don't like hindu religion or festivals before too she not let the dasies celebrate diwali even hameeda banu permited them & the muslim scholar i hardly doubt he is 😆 done a blunder who called it Gunahe azeem without hearing the full story & if they punish jodha for the unintentional act then it will be Gunah for sure.

hope i answer the question 😊



thats absolutely right...why CV showing this i dont know...


ghalibmirza thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#4
i think its gunahe azeem because its done by shehanshah's begum who is supposed to be more responsible and watch the interest of her praja, in a way its just like in today's age and time lady diana, if she was alive, insulting someone's religion, will definetly becaome a big issue..something in those lines..its the way the case was presented by resham in front of jalal that build up the whole gunaahe azeem scenario..as far as jalal's punishment for jodha is concerned i think in previous scenario she would have gone back to amer with full respect and her own will, but now it will be more due to the gunaah she has committed and that her family will also get to know that she has been sent back because of her behavior and not her own will...and jalal also knows that it is insulting for a married woman to go back to her parent's house after marriage, that is why he gave her two options because he thought that maybe she wants freedom from him...well, when it comes to MA, jalal gets personal and sentimental as well which acts as adding fuel to the fire, and then cvz r just trying to make it more dramatic and happening to serve to the majority of the audience that watches it, in order to run a business successfully its important to understand the psychology of the people u r going to deal with and our Kkta madam has Phd in that!
SonyaBlade thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: meghanajain


Jodha did not really commit any crime, it was an accident. I was thankful that she behaved well and accepted her mistake in front of Jalal. I am surprised though with this good Jodha as she was nowhere to be found during Meena Bazaar. She could have argued with Jalal even today and said I did not do it on purpose and has already apologized. Hume aap se koi bhai nahin, the usual crap she gives him. But, no today she was all mellow and accepted her fault with dignity. BTW, Rajat showed his anger so well. The moment he entered her room, OMG his expressions made me scared. No wonder, Jodha was scared.Why does Jalal think Jodha's biggest punishment is that she has to go back to Amer. Didn't Jalal think that this would make Jodha very happy till sometime back? So why this change in mind now, did he get any hint from the color explanation from Jodha that I did not understand. Friends please help me understand this.

MA comes in and pours more oil in Jodha's already burning soul. She scares her with Mynavati news. I think this is just to push Jodha to the edge and succeeds as per suicide drama coming soon. This is what might get MA in trouble when Jalal later finds out why Jodha attempted suicide. I atleast hope so, as I am tired of seeing this white NAGIN get away with every black act of hers effortlessly.

Precap: Jalal worried about Jodha, hoping we get to see sensible Jodha. Although with suicide and all I don't know what to expect..



I just highlighted this paragraph because the same question was going through my mind otday after he said that sending her back was the greatest punishment. It doesn't make any sense when he said he was allowing her 2 choices and it was up to her to choose after he behaved poorly with her and when she tried helping him and he didn't listen...

SO when he first gave Jodha the choice I thought he just didn't understand the importance of marriage and how you can't break a hindu marriage the same way as a Muslim marriage, HOWEVER; after today's lines from him, I feel that he is a heartless man, who intentionally gave her those choices because he knew she wouldn't want to live with him, adn this is his last way of degrading her, punishing her, and humiliating her...

And if that is teh case, how in the world are they going to fall in love...so the CV's better have done something BIG...and it has to be BIG...bigger than all of the misunderstandings between the two, bigger than the relationship and bonds he has with MA and Ruq's, bigger than EVERYTHING that we have seen so far, in order for them to overcome this grevious wrong that has been done by Jalal to Jodha...

And we can't say he doesn't know how this separation is going to effect Jodha, because almost everyone who he cares about around him has said to him in someway or another how this will be so humiliating for Jodha. And HE himself confirmed that after his lines today...

I was extremely disappointed in this scene today, because I truly wanted to believe that Jalal was putting the power into Jodha's hands for this one choice after their marriage...BUT instead he snatches it away from her and throws it back into her face. Very disappointing.
meghanajain thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: Tohru

nice post yes i too wanted some how jalal puts colour to jodha as its her first holi but Alas these cvs

coming back to your question buddy
no its not a problem or guna if muslim widow get colour on her clother & if a muslim is coloured by a hindhu unintentionaly with holi colours its not at all Gunahe azeem .
Islam allowed ,full permission for widows to wear colourful clothes & remarriges.

they represented it in a wrong way i can say as Mahmanaga character is negative & she is a rigid adherence principles lady she don't like hindu religion or festivals before too she not let the dasies celebrate diwali even hameeda banu permited them & the muslim scholar i hardly doubt he is 😆 done a blunder who called it Gunahe azeem without hearing the full story & if they punish jodha for the unintentional act then it will be Gunah for sure.

hope i answer the question 😊

Thanks Tohru for explaining it and confirming my doubt. Gunahe azeem - arrrggghhh Ekta!
meghanajain thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: mandyg

i think its gunahe azeem because its done by shehanshah's begum who is supposed to be more responsible and watch the interest of her praja, in a way its just like in today's age and time lady diana, if she was alive, insulting someone's religion, will definetly becaome a big issue..something in those lines..its the way the case was presented by resham in front of jalal that build up the whole gunaahe azeem scenario..as far as jalal's punishment for jodha is concerned i think in previous scenario she would have gone back to amer with full respect and her own will, but now it will be more due to the gunaah she has committed and that her family will also get to know that she has been sent back because of her behavior and not her own will...and jalal also knows that it is insulting for a married woman to go back to her parent's house after marriage, that is why he gave her two options because he thought that maybe she wants freedom from him...well, when it comes to MA, jalal gets personal and sentimental as well which acts as adding fuel to the fire, and then cvz r just trying to make it more dramatic and happening to serve to the majority of the audience that watches it, in order to run a business successfully its important to understand the psychology of the people u r going to deal with and our Kkta madam has Phd in that!

He said the punishment will be discussed and finalized. But, according to him, her going away to Amer was her biggest punishment. I don't think he meant it as your punishment is that I am going to disown you and send you away. I agree though with your point about over dramatization used by Ekta madam for TRP. How I hate TRPs sometimes, it takes away the class to please the mass
meghanajain thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: SonyaBlade



I just highlighted this paragraph because the same question was going through my mind otday after he said that sending her back was the greatest punishment. It doesn't make any sense when he said he was allowing her 2 choices and it was up to her to choose after he behaved poorly with her and when she tried helping him and he didn't listen...

SO when he first gave Jodha the choice I thought he just didn't understand the importance of marriage and how you can't break a hindu marriage the same way as a Muslim marriage, HOWEVER; after today's lines from him, I feel that he is a heartless man, who intentionally gave her those choices because he knew she wouldn't want to live with him, adn this is his last way of degrading her, punishing her, and humiliating her...

And if that is teh case, how in the world are they going to fall in love...so the CV's better have done something BIG...and it has to be BIG...bigger than all of the misunderstandings between the two, bigger than the relationship and bonds he has with MA and Ruq's, bigger than EVERYTHING that we have seen so far, in order for them to overcome this grevious wrong that has been done by Jalal to Jodha...

And we can't say he doesn't know how this separation is going to effect Jodha, because almost everyone who he cares about around him has said to him in someway or another how this will be so humiliating for Jodha. And HE himself confirmed that after his lines today...

I was extremely disappointed in this scene today, because I truly wanted to believe that Jalal was putting the power into Jodha's hands for this one choice after their marriage...BUT instead he snatches it away from her and throws it back into her face. Very disappointing.

I disagree on the point about Jalal being dubious Sonya. His heart and intentions were right when he gave her two choices. I feel it is a CV blunder that Jalal said something like going to Amer is your biggest punishment. Or he has somehow figured out that Jodha does not want to go but will now go??
ghalibmirza thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: meghanajain

He said the punishment will be discussed and finalized. But, according to him, her going away to Amer was her biggest punishment. I don't think he meant it as your punishment is that I am going to disown you and send you away. I agree though with your point about over dramatization used by Ekta madam for TRP. How I hate TRPs sometimes, it takes away the class to please the mass



i know dramatization sucks away all the reality and logic, now going to amer is an issue that has been bothering both, for jodha its an insult that a wedded female has to go back and leave her own house where she belongs to after marriage..and for akbar its more of a hurt feeling because subconsciously he is not happy that jodha chose to go to amer and not stay with him as his begum, but he also knows that how humiliating it would be for jodha and her family if she goes there with the kalank of gunaahe azeem, pehle jalal ki choices thi jo usne jodha ko tohfe mein di thi because he was under the guilt of punishing her and the brothers..and now its like tum jaao kyunki wohi tumhaari sahi jagah hai..in other words he is telling jodha that she is not fit for living as his begum in the mughal sultanat, she should go back to her people in amer and play as much holi as she wants..i hope i am making any sense..ye sab figure out karte mera sar chakra gaya😆..come on yaar its just a show, iski baal ki khaal kya utaarni!
leelu0001 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#10
nice post. The holi track had so much potential to show some nice scenes of ja and then ma kaand cld hv happened but no CVs rushed with it

Related Topics

Jodha Akbar Thumbnail

Posted by: ParijatDeewani

2 months ago

Jodha Akbar Vm Thread

Hey y'all! I've created this thread so that you'll can easily access all the Akdha Vms in one place. Please feel free to add to the list. 1....

Expand ▼
Jodha Akbar Thumbnail

Posted by: Swissgerman

6 years ago

Jodha Akbar FF Who loves Him Most Chapter 78B updated on 08/07/2024

Jodha Akbar FF : --- Who loves Him Most (M) --- Link to my other threads Thread 1 Thread 2 - Thread 3 :::::Thread 4::::...

Expand ▼
Jodha Akbar Thumbnail

Posted by: Swissgerman

9 years ago

Jodha Akbar FF: Shahzada of Her Dreams Chapter 48 Updated 20/7/2025

... Shahzada Of Her Dreams ... ::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::Index::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::: Chapter-1.....The beginning Chapter-2:...

Expand ▼
Jodha Akbar Thumbnail

Posted by: nushhkiee

6 months ago

Jodha Akkineni & Jalal Ahmed of Pale Blue Dot : A Story in Verse 💙

Before you read, This is strictly for die-hard and loyal fans of Pale Blue Dot ...our fellow PBDians ... I've been working on this since...

Expand ▼
Jodha Akbar Thumbnail

Posted by: nushhkiee

6 months ago

Jodha recreated - A beautiful nostalgia 😍

Hello People.....Our Pari just posted her recreated Jodha look for a paid partnership promotion ... absolutely loved it ... she still captures...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".