What We JB Fans Can Live With-Pia Baby? - Page 11

Originally posted by: fsam

Harveen there is always a first time.

Yep-- we're groundbreaking like that... esp with the number of letters/petitions we have sent to them.. they must be surprised..

Originally posted by: m3ghna

That is what they are setting up for if the baby is JW's. Pia will always be front and center in the realtionsip with baby in tow. I thought it was going to be a J-B-T track, now and Pia sidelined. Why with sinking TRP's do they keep on pushing Pia onto the audience. The disgust factor in the whole scenario of 2 sis carrying babies of the same man at the same time is so high that I might have to break my addiction. I think this track will be even more nauseating than the ONS track. Here we will have Pia rubbing the fact in at every point, JW completely guilt ridden and Bani out of sorts and heartbroken. The storyline of the trio that we have so revolted against will continue. They have thrown us a bone with the drugging issue but the end result is still the same....Pia in between the JB relationship.

I know JW is completely not at fault, he was tricked and drugged but it will be hard for any wife to see a child by her husband from her sister. It's jsyt gross.

As usual, i am joining in late when almost everything has been said, but i just had to add my two cents again:
I completely agree with both, K's and Meg's statements.
All the analogies with raped women apart, I just can't accept JP kid angle!
Besides as Oval pointed out, the raped woman has a choice, where is JW's choice?
and who, given a choice would opt to father Reptile's baby?
as for story line, they could always show the child to be Pushkar's given up by reptile to be raised by JB. Reptile would be willing to give it up once she realises that the kid is not a meal ticket, and then they could still pursue the sibling jealousy etc.(the usual kekta khichdi!) angle.
or they could be really smart, make the kid pushkar's, drop the kid angle, and use Pia to pursue the "hell hath no fury like woman scorned" angle.
ultimately, jp kid is too repulsive and disgusting and that is that!
whoever is planning to rais ean uproar, count me in!
Armana

Originally posted by: scifichick

Cordelia wrote:
"but if Bani forgives him, i am sure with time he will do the same - especially if Pia is killed off and he never has to see her again! 😡 "

What an easy solution to my dilemma 😆 no more fast forwarding or leaving the room to make tea.

edjactly!! 😆

Bani is superhuman in her capacity to forgive - sometimes too much so 😡 .

completely agree! 😕

Do you think that their relationship could survive this with Bani's forgiveness? Or regardless of Bani's forgiveness will this put a strain on the relationship that will tear them apart (albeit still in love)?

real forgiveness means that you cannot hold any part of it against that person any more.

in this entire ONS issue everyone else should be asking forgiveness (in particular st. billo 😡) from JW for condemning him without knowing the entire truth.

i think the question is Bani's ACCEPTANCE of that child that is the consequence of this whole fiasco. if she fully does accept him then she is no position to then turn around and crib.

this is all assuming that reptile is actually pregnant - she is behaving like such a psycho these days that i would not be surprised if the entire thing was a delusion!!! 😆

Finally getting to go home but back again tomorrow.

like i have said before, the mainstay of this show is J-B (RK and PD) - if they are together, by that i mean not in the ridiculous Banigiri / Jaigiri sense of togtherness, but real Nahar-Saloni of Saath Phere style togetherness - then however many Pia's are thrown their way they will handle it!

Cordelia wrote:
real forgiveness means that you cannot hold any part of it against that person any more.

I think that Bani being Bani would forgive our hero Jai, but deep in her heart and soul she would be tormented by this and ultimately their relationship would change. As an audience member, I have forgiven Jai, but I would be tormented if Pia's child were his. In fact I am tormented with just the thought of it 😡 🤢 .

in this entire ONS issue everyone else should be asking forgiveness (in particular st. billo) from JW for condemning him without knowing the entire truth.

Yes Maassi needs a good dressing down 😡 . She needs to beg JW for his forgiveness. Being the standup guy that he his, I'm sure he has forgiven her already 😕

i think the question is Bani's ACCEPTANCE of that child that is the consequence of this whole fiasco. if she fully does accept him then she is no position to then turn around and crib.

If the hurtful words that Jai spoke to her in the hopes of getting her out of her stupor, broke her spirit and heart to the point that she couldn't stop thinking about them, could she really accept Jai and Pia's child without losing a vital part of her own being? I think that the child would be tangible evidence and a physical reminder of the whole sordid episode and this would weight on Bani's mind and soul . Being the person she is, she wouldn't let her feelings affect her love for the child, but I think in the long run JB's relationship would never be the same 😭 and JDD moments would never reach intoxicating heights again.

this is all assuming that reptile is actually pregnant - she is behaving like such a psycho these days that i would not be surprised if the entire thing was a delusion!!

This is the only hope I have left - that she is delusional or somehow completely insane I work in a hospital and will personally make sure there is a bed in the lock down psychiatric unit kept on hold for Miss Pia 😆


Kajolfan,
Waiting for you to start that petition. I am sorely missing true, dizzying guiltfree JDD moments.

Originally posted by: armana

As usual, i am joining in late when almost everything has been said, but i just had to add my two cents again:
I completely agree with both, K's and Meg's statements.
All the analogies with raped women apart, I just can't accept JP kid angle!
Besides as Oval pointed out, the raped woman has a choice, where is JW's choice?
and who, given a choice would opt to father Reptile's baby?
as for story line, they could always show the child to be Pushkar's given up by reptile to be raised by JB. Reptile would be willing to give it up once she realises that the kid is not a meal ticket, and then they could still pursue the sibling jealousy etc.(the usual kekta khichdi!) angle.
or they could be really smart, make the kid pushkar's, drop the kid angle, and use Pia to pursue the "hell hath no fury like woman scorned" angle.
ultimately, jp kid is too repulsive and disgusting and that is that!
whoever is planning to rais ean uproar, count me in!
Armana

Armana, could not agree more with you. There are million diff ways to have Pia in the storyline other than her having JW's baby. Having her there with JW's aby will forever taint any JDD moments for both the viewers and the J & B characters. Like i said it is all well and good that JW is not responsible but the baby would be a constant reminder of what happened that night for both J & B and you can trust Pia to forever rub it in their face. If we have to have Pia let her play her million diff tricks to get money by marrying sahil, nattu, tony....just so long she is not a shadow in the JB equation.

meghna

Megs,
I think part of the problem stems form the TRP's. they are low right now, they were high initially post ONS. and then through all the deception of Bani by Jai they remained high.
Mayi might erroneously conclude that they go up because of the Reptile angle. What she does not seem to realise is that in order to pursue the Reptile angle, she has to have JB constantly around, and that is what makes the TRP's shoot up.
I think we seriously need to create an uproar regarding the Reptile's Progeny (RP for short!) before they go ahead and show JW as RP's father 🤢 🤢 🤢 .
Besides, i think that:
1. JW's character has been mutilated enough- to show him as a father who disowns his own kid is unnecessary mutilation.
2. If JW is shown as rp's dad then we also face the near certain prospect of Bani transmorphing into Tulsi II and that is devoutly to be hoped against! I have never been a viewer of KSBKBT but the little that i have seen convinces me that it would be an awful scenario!
3. yep, JB is forever tainted, tarnished and haunted by the slimy droppings of a reptile. and what, i ask mayi, have we the poor, heartsore JB fans done to desrve that?
As fsam said it, it's time mayi realises that ks became a success not because of her regular k-watching brigade but because of a niche audience. who preferred ks for its originality and freshness....

Let's make a loud uproar and save JB, and ourselves in teh process!
Armana