Crime and Punishment - Page 2

Swati,

(because he is gonna suffer a lot in next 2-3 months )

That's why I still maintain that irrespective of whether he ie guilty or not, he should rot in hell for 3-5 years becuase he must atone for all his sins- real or imagined.

(I think that maasi and aditya, rano also are going to feel the same sorrow )

St. Billo, Adi yes, but Rano, defo NOT. I am yet to be convinced that any Dixit can feel any sorrow for any wrong done to JW.

Rgds,

Pri

St. Billo, Adi yes, but Rano, defo NOT. I am yet to be convinced that any Dixit can feel any sorrow for any wrong done to JW.

Pri,

all this will depend on the way which karuna and pia will take all this story.

pri,

u r saying that as he was drugged he was not able to do anything, what do u feel he was drugged. roshni was drugging him on that day to get hold of him and gave that to bani and she was able to do all that on 19 june and pia gave that to him then why u think that he has not done anything, he may have also done everything and may not be able to remember because of pills.

swati

Swati,

We dont know what happened that night yet but when the unedited CD is out, we will know that J-P did not do it, JW had no intention to even kiss or embrace reptile and the last words on his lips b4 he passed out were ILU Bani.

But anyhow irrespective of what happened you can rest assured that even if Munna is baizzat buried, Rano and Bani (being Dixits) will never feel that they have wronged Munna, St. Billo and Adi may have a diff view on the matter.

Rgds,

Pri

Swathi...

On 19/6 Bani Walia was drugged and JW only drank 7 glasses of wine again he did not drink his favourite Blenders Pride Apple Juice and even after that both of them were very much in control.
BW reached home successfully on her own,gave JW her piece of mind and JW did giv eRoshni a dresing down,drove back,consoled his wife na dthen went along all the way...
Remember bani did go all herself and lie on bed and she even moves her hand up when he .... I will stop.

Originally posted by: majumdar

Angel,

(Do we no longer believe in innonence before proven guilty?? )

Depends. If it is the Dixit sisters, it is innocent till proven guilty, if JW the other way round.

Rgds,

Pri

Pri,

I think Dixits are innocent even after being proven gulity😊...

Do you think a fair punishment was handed out to JW or do you think it was a bit over the top?
*****it was thousands kms over the top.i blame kekta. this lady do not let go a single chance to create melodrama.masi giving fair chance to jw would have counted as reality. kekta's super funda is to keep her serials as away from reality as her destructives can.

more than that i feel Bani is protagonist of KS and hence everyone should agree to how unfair life has been with her. who is bloody JW...he is bani's husband..thats what his identity is. so all mahan aatma' should do mahan deeds.


Do you think St. Billo did a right thing by summarily announcing a sentence. Or do you think JW should have been given a opportunity to explain what happen?
*****i am sure even if given a chance, that lame and shattered JW had nothing to say.he would have accepted pia's fault as her support and st.billo would have
executed him anyways. it was good that he remained silent.

Was St. Billo the only person who should be given the credit/blame for handing out the sentence. Or do you think the rest of the WM crowd by their silence- Dadi, Adi, Rano, Raashi, Anu, Rohit, Ranveer, Jigs and Sahil- are equally to be credited/blamed. (IMHO, Bani is certainly not responsible as she was too numb to react?)
****i think everyone should be blamed as they could have stoped billo from handling out punishment but i guess everyone was as numb as bani to find out about jai and pia or they must be afraid for their own lives 😆 billo's side taken can arouse JW's wrath....JW's side taken could have had their 'chautha' and 'shradh' arranged along with jai.. 😆 😆 😆 so they chose to remain silent and watch clash of titans.

What if JW is found to be innocent? Would you consider his executioners to be guilty of some misdeed? If yes, what should be their punishment? And who would administer that because JW would certainly want to avenge himself even if he finds himself to be innocent?
*****what if?????? i thought he is innocent and karuamma can very well prove that.i would hold executioners guilty for ruining best part of JW's life where he peacefully could have planned krishna's arrival with his wife.
JW will not take revenge. there is only one person he is miffed with (understatement) thats pia. he will be as nasty with her as he can. but he would praise others like st billo for standing by Bani's side when she needed it most.

And if he is innocent, do you think he deserves some apology/amends for what he has been made to go through? If so, what should the amends be?
*****masi sent to Kashi permanently.
Jigs sent to Mars and hiring aliens there to kill her.
Sahil sent to Neptune.
Rano married to nattu living happily but away from WM..rano can slap him anytime she wants.
adi and dadi can be jB's only family.
pushkar sent abroad for higher studies in detective sciences.
Pia??? hmmmmm well Pia who??? 😳

last but not the least,
pri,
if u believe someone right from the bottom of ur heart, no explanation is necessary....but if u dont, no explanation is possible...

that explains about JW.he is not only paying for his deeds alone...he is paying for UW and Karuna's deeds too.

sorry for rambling on

Great post Pri👏👏👏

Loved all your points, and you know my stand.

So i just have one comment, When has anything/anyone ever been fair to Jai Walia? He is expected to be fair, but when it's about him, then who cares about fairness. Whenever Jai Walia is concerned i don't think we are even allowed to raise questions on judgements against him, cuz well he is a MAN, so he has to go through all the nonsense thrown at him.

I am really mad/disgusted with the current KS track, and it's making me madder by the day.

Shina

(On 19/6 Bani Walia was drugged and JW only drank 7 glasses of wine again he did not drink his favourite Blenders Pride Apple Juice and even after that both of them were very much in control.
BW reached home successfully on her own,gave JW her piece of mind and JW did giv eRoshni a dresing down,drove back,consoled his wife na dthen went along all the way...
Remember bani did go all herself and lie on bed and she even moves her hand up when he .... I will stop. )

archie babes tussi great ho 😆 😆 😆
i thought as if i am watching it all over again.
but babes mere wine or for that matter any alcohol is not as potent as an aphrodisiac and i am sure Pia used something like that which washed JW's senses completely.

Him,

(if u believe someone right from the bottom of ur heart, no explanation is necessary....but if u dont, no explanation is possible... that explains about JW.he is not only paying for his deeds alone...he is paying for UW and Karuna's deeds too. )

Best thing I heard in recent times.

Rgds,

Pri

Originally posted by: majumdar

Some questions for you.
Do you think a fair punishment was handed out to JW or do you think it was a bit over the top?
It was over the top. I am not criticising Massi's stand because of Munna but that it was not fair to announce the verdict for him without proper explanations. Every criminal has a reason for committing a crime unless the person committing it happens to be of pshycotic mind which JW is not. He has proven more than enpugh his loyalties to Bni at the time of divorce proceedings. Why Massi chose to ignore tha fact that it is the same JW who could not get himself to raise his hand on Bani when she openly insulted her.

Do you think St. Billo did a right thing by summarily announcing a sentence. Or do you think JW should have been given a opportunity to explain what happen? Should have been given a chance to explain himself but Munna that he is , will not have opened his mouth and accepted the punishment meted out to him. I wonder why this step treatment to Jai because Bani was involved, how aboput Jigs, is a sister not suppose to be loyal to her brother too. Where is her share of punishment? She too committed a crime and is still under the roof of WM enjoying all the perks associated with the name of JW.

Was St. Billo the only person who should be given the credit/blame for handing out the sentence. Or do you think the rest of the WM crowd by their silence- Dadi, Adi, Rano, Raashi, Anu, Rohit, Ranveer, Jigs and Sahil- are equally to be credited/blamed. (IMHO, Bani is certainly not responsible as she was too numb to react?) Ideally I will hold everyone responsible, they opened their mouth but too late. Massi had no right to punish J. I supported his statement that only Bani had a right to punish him and no one else cause she is the only one who he accidentally cheated on. He has done more than enough on his part to maintain his relationship with them where as all that he has received from them is deceit.

What if JW is found to be innocent? Would you consider his executioners to be guilty of some misdeed? If yes, what should be their punishment? And who would administer that because JW would certainly want to avenge himself even if he finds himself to be innocent?
I love J cause he is moron.He will punish only Jigs and her canines plus Pia, no one else.He will forgive everyone else cause he is a kind of person who forgives his dear ones like Massi and Dadi and Aditya Rabno etc,... no matter how ruthless he gets. If Aand ewhen he is proven innocent he will forgive them cause just like him , they too were unaware of his innocence but As far as I think he will maintain some distance in his conduct with them

And if he is innocent, do you think he deserves some apology/amends for what he has been made to go through? If so, what should the amends be? Yes He desrves an apology , But I dot think there is anything that can amend their mistake now especailly Massi. I would have supported her if she had only thrown Munna out of WM but conducting his shraddha and mourning him is unpardonable.

And Yes Jai is guilty even if he is proven innocent cause he is JW , Personal property of Dixit the Great.