redwine1 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#1


Welcome to yet another edition of Reflections ... since i 'played hooky' yesterday i will start by writing on yesterdays episode first ... ie Episode 004 ..

But before i go there since we are now on Episode 005 so lets do a quick recap of what we saw in the last 4 episodes ...

😛Episode 1 was introduction of Arnav Singh Raizada ... his ambition & devotion .. basically what makes the guy tick
😛Episode 2 was the story of Iss Pyaar Ko kya naam doon?
😛Episode 3 was the introduction of Khushi Kumari Gupta (Singh Raizada)
& then .. what u saw yesterday
😛Episode 4 ... that was the introduction of the CONFLICT of IPK ... a serial .. or rather any love story has a underlying plot of CONFLICT .. & that was laid out in Episode 04 ...



EPISODE 004 -



Any love story has a common theme .. boy meets girl they have a conflict & then they resolve the conflict to meet ... this is called a 'one line story' & that's what happened in IPK ...

What u saw in the first 3 episodes was boy meet girl ... & episode 4 was the laying of the CONFLICT ...

Most of you have read, watched & written about .. Arnav being the Aethist ..& Khushi being the believer ... just pause for a moment & think why was it important to show Arnav Singh Raizada as an aethist .. & why was it important to show Khushi kUmari Gupta as a BLIND BELIEVER ... ????

That's coz thats the conflict of IPK .. the basis of the story .. ok ok .. explainiya please i know .. here goes ..

The setting ... Dargah ... a house of GOD
The characters ... one a blind believer one a non believer meet
The meet ... she picks up his Mannat ki Chaabi ...

Now lets look at this ..

Khushi the eternal optimist or the eternal BLIND BELIEVER believed that keeping the "mannat ki chhabi'' on ones person will make the mannat come true ...
While Arnav comes there .. does his bit very sincerely (forced or not is not the issue) but does not keep the chaabi .. coz to him he does not need any help .. he forges his own path & destiny ..

This is the conflict of IPK ..

Lets look at the most famous dialog of IPK ( after ofcourse Farak padta hai) ...

'Arnav Singh Raizada apni Kismat Khud likhta hai'

what did he mean by that ... he said i dont believe that things come easily to a person ... you have to take .. grab ... snatch ... earn your way in life ... Now countless times in the serial we saw this dialog repeat in various forms & avatars...
BUT BUT BUT ... yes one needs to work for what one gets in life .. but what Arnav did not beleive in was .. THAT there was a SUPREME POWER which guides you ... thats where the aethist in Arnav proved his downfall ...

Yes Arnav wrote his own KISMAT that day .. a kismat that would shatter his 'ambition & devotion' ... that would pilage his sisters life .. the release of the video footage .. which brought Shyam Manohar Jha in the life of Khushi Kumari Gupta ... this move of Arnav's may have temporarily derailed Khushi's life ... but in the end that was the hand of fate which brought KHUSHI into Arnav's life ... the hand which tied Khushi to Arnav for the rest of their lives ...

So the hand of GOD played ... BUT ... Arnav did write his own DESTINY .. he brought his DESTINY to himself ... But the path to that destiny was the ruin of his sister ...

They say .. be careful what you ask for .. lest you get it ..

And Arnav asked/ spoke .. & asked/spoke in the place of GOD ...

Now when u sit back & reflect ... do u get why showing Arnav as an aethist was important .. & why this scene had to be played out in a place of worship ...

Ok now to the other part of the Conflict .. KHUSHI KUMARI GUPTA ...

A complete blind believer ... Khushi's faith in her God was so complete that she left everything in GOD's hands ... while belief is important ... there is another very popular saying ..

"God Helps those who help themselves"
Now to explain this .. lets fast forward ... Khushi discovers Shyam's true face In Shantivan ... what does she do .. she runs to the temple & says u (DM) tell me what to do .. she asks her Devi Maiyaa .. the next moment ...
Promptly Arnav calls & asks her what happened ???
First sign from DM on what she should do .. did she do it .. NOPE ..
Cut to .. next day .. Khushi goes to Shantivan to reveal all to Anji .. what happens ...
Anji's mangal Sutra breaks ... DM's sign no. 2 .. that the marriage .. that of Anji & Shyam was made to be broken .. come what may the mangal sutra had to break .. & thats what u got in the ultimate reveal of shyam .. Anji breaking the mangal sutra ..
But Khushi caught the mangal sutra .. & took matters into her own hands by not revealing ... hence she catches the broken mangal sutra

Thereby .. aiding in the ruin of Anjali Jha's life .. which would ultimately cost the lady her child ...

Now lets go to the road side reveal of the famous MU ... Arnav constantly tells Khushi .. why did u not tell me .. why did u not make everyone hear ur side ... WHY DID U LET THAT MAN RUIN MY SISTERS LIFE ...

To which Khushi says ... I SHOUDL've MADE MY SELF HEARD THAT DAY ...

So dearies ... basically .. the fact that a blind believer & an aethist met .. was the basis of the CONFLICT of IPK ... coz if KHUSHI had stood up to take action .. she would've avoided a whole lot of problems in her life ..
& had arnav beleived that there was a supreme power which guides us through life he would've met his destiny ... without ruining his devotion

Khushi as i explained in Episode 3 review .. was shown to be a fighter .. she 2 like Arnav fought & worked her way thru life ... but on that fateful day at Shantivan .. she turned blind believer & totally stepped back .. SHE DID NOT FIGHT FOR WHAT WAS RIGHT ... the day she fought for what was right .. SHE HAD THE SUPPORT OF HER MAN >> ARNAV SINGH RAIZADA ... (shyam's frst reveal) ..
Now also connect this to Arnav's snatches of KHUSHI & SHYAM .. & what he says .. Chhap gaya hai woh pal mere dimaag mein .. now go back to that scene .. when Khushi first reveals Shyam's identity Arnav beleives her .. but then gets a flash of the vision of Khushi in Shyam's arms ... NOW .. if KHUSHI had revealed all to Arnav (she had enuf proof then .. he knew she was engaged to man a called Shyam) ... would the 6 months of her life have been different ???

But yes KHushi was Devi Maiyya's favorite child ... hence even if she took some wrong turns ... she landed on her feet ...

A small thot to ponder on ...

BUT ... when u call Khushi as DM's fav child .. do u not for a moment think .. Arnav was also DM's equally fav child ... coz there is a popular saying ... " JISKA KOI NAHI USKA KHUDA HOTA HAI" ...


EPISODE - 005 ..



THE REVEAL OF THE HERO & VILLAIN .. or was it the other way round .. huh ?? Am confused ...

The dichotomy that was IPK ... a lot of people loved IPK coz it had sizzling chemistry .. some loved it for Barun Sobti & Sanaya Irani .. some loved it for the story .. some loved Rabba Ve ... For me my love of IPK was the dichotomy of the tale ... the PRESENTATION of IPK ... & that dichotomy was laid out in Episode 005 for us ... sorry today am in the mood to quote cliches ... so here goes ..
what do they say ... FIRST IMPRESSIONS ARE LAST IMPRESSIONS ...

Well IPK blew that myth apart in a jiffy ... OR DID IT ????

In episode 5 you got the introduction of the villain of IPK .. Shyam Manohar Jha .. who to us was just a knight in shining armor .. saving the damsel in distress .. a regular do gooder ...

In the same episode you got the glimpse of "chotey'' ... a man who for a moment reflects on his actions ... when his sister reminds him of it ...

But the most important part ... you see the action & implication of the devil ...

The dichotomy ... Hero does the villainous act .. while the villain does the heroic act ...

But did u notice the most important thing ... Shyam saves Khushi ... but she doesnt thank him ... there is no convo with him ... only the father thanks him & then they walk away ... this is ur first indication .. that Mr. Shyam Manohar Jha is the ahem bad guy in the plot .. normally the parents would be effusive with their thanks .. the gurl would've gushed her thanx probably tied a dupatta around a hurt .. ( which u saw ( the concern) in the dhaba episode ..when khushi Stops Arnav from fighting) ... What struck me as the most amazing thing of this episode was ... when Khushi goes to the television studio .. & comes to know that Arnav was the guy behind the footage ... (pause here) .. there is a deep hurt reflected in her eyes ...

BANG ON guys .. the CONNECT was there ... the DESTINIES Were joined ... & what DM put together ... no knight in shining armor could put asunder ...

Similarly .. when u saw the Anji & Arnav scene ... Anji tells arnav did u think before u released the footage ... & there is a sligjht pause & arnav murmurs .. yes i thot & hence released ... BUT BUT BUT ... liar liar pants on fire ... the one thing HE DID NOT DO .. was THINK .. he reacted ... & thats where the first look of GUILT was shown reflected in Arnav's eyes .. (suggest u guys watch the Arnav Anji interaction .. reveals a lot) ... Arnav knows what he has done is wrong ... but his EGO .. will not let him accept that ... AN EGO which makes its presence felt in dialog after dialog in IPK ...

Now lets think & ponder for a bit .. or rather speculate ... what do u think ... when Arnav Khushi would next meet on the streets of Delhi ... if Khushi showed sadness ... remorse .. or was downtrodden ... what would be arnav's reaction to it ... ??

Cause the KHUSHi we will c ... will come out all guns blazing ... which will IRK arnav's ego ... but what is mORE ... he will atleast appease his conscious thinking .. my actions did not RUIN this girl's life .. which appeases his guilt a bit ..

THE DAY Arnav realises HOW MUCH HIS ACTIONS have ruined KHUSHI's life ... he falls in front of her to apologise ... Hence ... the past of KHUSHi's meant nothing to Arnav ... he could not add to her ruination anymore ... he had to purge his past & soul to marry her that night ... cause if he did not ... THAT WOULD've been the TRUE RUIN OF KHUSHI KUMARI GUPTA ... & that would make Arnav Singh Raizada the VIllain of IPK ...


Phew todays was a long one .. so i will conclude ..

Many people in IF & elsewhere on other sites .. wrote huge stories on the character called Shyam .. & his reason for being bad ... some famous theories linking SHyam to the past of Arnav & Khushi were concocted as well ... Thank fully those tales did not come true ... Thats cause ... IPK was the LOVE STORY of Arnav & Khushi ... Shyam was the villain ... a villain in a love story .. IS ONLY THE MEANS TO AN END ... thats it .. & thats exactly what we got ... Shyam Manohar Jha was a GREEDY MAN .. who fell in abject LUST on a bright sunny morning in Lucknow when he saw KHUSHI KUMARI GUPTA ... his GREED ... created problems in the lives of Arnav & Khushi .. but ultimately ... LOVE WON ... which is beautifully reflected in the dialogs between Shyam & Khushi during the end of Kidnap track ... Where KHUSHI .. even before she declares her LOVE TO ARNAV ... DECLARES IT TO SHYAM ...

He can do the heroic act ... but ... LOVE ties her with ARNAV ...

PS: there is a very revealing dialog of Arnav's in the arnav anji confrontation ... where he says ... " woh bhagwan hi kya jisse maangna pade" ... made me question ... was he really an aethist?? ... or was he a believer who buried his belief so deep ... that he to could'nt find it ... ??
( if u want to have a discussion on this .. would love to indulge)




ENJOY READING ...
CU AT THE IPK s ...

[YOUTUBE]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_CUCnKrue5E[/YOUTUBE]







Edited by redwine1 - 12 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

29

Views

4.7k

Users

21

Likes

303

Frequent Posters

GirlOfFire thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 12 years ago
#2


Reflections: Episodes 4 & 5 - The Key to Destiny


Like Ruby I played hooky yesterday. So today, I too will concentrate on both Episodes - 4 and 5 - given that they are so intrinsically bound.

In the spate of two days, Khushi bumps into two men - Arnav and Shyam. Two men who will do everything they can to destroy her. Two men who would claim to love her, but only one man would eventually have her heart. And through it all, Khushi bears it. Crying, fumbling, fuming, breaking down, ready to confront, although her fear is clearly visible in her trembling hands, and fisted fingers. Yet she will not back down from either of these men, whenever she confronts them.

Arnav Singh Raizada. His veneer of polish, his sneering arrogance clearly in place, believes he writes his own destiny - and those of others. He controls people by showing them he can buy them. Unfortunately, he has nothing to buy Khushi Kumari Gupta with - as yet. So he controls her fate - or so he believes - by releasing the damming tapes. The tapes that will set forth in motion a whole chain of events which will bring them both together. After all - he threw that challenge on hallowed ground - her court. Her Devi Mayya's court. Not in his world - the world of money and greed. And therefore Devi Maiyya makes him write his own destiny - linking it irrevocably with Khushi's. As Ruby mentions - Khushi wasn't the only chosen one. So was he. He just didn't know it, nor did he ever acknowledge it.

Shyam Manohar Jha makes his appearance now. (Okay - how many were dancing to 'Daiyya Ho'?). The first glimpse of him is like the revelation of Khushi - a truly filmy entrance. The swagger, the bracelet, the flashing heroism, the cheesy dialog.

Yet what struck me most is the first reveal of his face starts with his eyes. Flat. Snakelike.

And Khushi - given her run-in with ASR is naturally chary about being friendly with a guy who saves her and hands her back her modesty.

How well the writers have played with us - the viewers.

When viewing for the first time, it must have left viewers confused. Who is the villain and who is the hero? Is it Arnav - the man who didn't hesitate to "molest" Khushi, then release her tapes to the world, or is it Shyam - the man who didn't hesitate to step into a melee and help save her honor?

Now we know - but then we had wondered.

But IPK has never been a story told simply. And therein lies the magic of the story teller. The leitmotifs in the story are already starting to be set. Words, actions in these and the following episodes will find an echo in later ones. Loops will be opened and closed. And questions will be raised.

I loved that Akash Singh Raizada made an appearance in the fourth episode. What I loved more was how he'd scrunched up his face to look like Arnav (!) while thinking about the man who was obstructing their photo shoot!

Which brings me to the man who would write his own destiny. Yes, for 2.5 crores he can "write" his destiny. But for the life of him, he can't toss away a chit of a girl with a key in her hand.

Edited by GirlOfFire - 12 years ago
redwine1 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#3



Ritzy's message ...

Today's episode marked the introduction of the villain... Shyam Manohar Jha...
I am extremely sorry, but due to work constraints I won't be able to write my post today ! Thanks Ruby, for reserving my spot.
But to make up for it... here's a little bit of Shyam for you...
One of the best made VM by Ragini...
Daiyya Ho !
[YOUTUBE]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MFkFP4zN2lo[/YOUTUBE]


Edited by redwine1 - 12 years ago
GirlOfFire thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 12 years ago
#4
A note from PAYALIA


Arnav Singh Raizada flew in our screens in a helicopter. He was rude, egoistical, self-centered & a control freak. He was the very epitome of an angry young man...who made the life of our young feather light heroine a yawning misery...

A hero in an anti-heros role...ih how we loved to hate him & cheered for Khushi when she won against him time & again...!!

Then came in a charming, gentle, sweet young man...who fought valiantly for the underdogs & ablaa naaris...

Didn't we gave him a standing ovation when he saved Khushi from those low lives...didn't we bless him everytime he aided Khushi...

And then the tides turned & we find...the perpetualy angry guy is the one with a gentle heart & a sad soul...& the charmer is actually a werewolf...changing appearance to suit his nefarious purposes...!!!

Is it any wonder that after almost 2 years...we are still here...trying to find meanings & understanding what they wanted to show...under sooo many layers...


Edited by GirlOfFire - 12 years ago
Ipoona thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#5
Her dupatta is yanked off her yet again!!! What a horrific week Khushi is having... and the ordeal shows no signs of letting up...

In a space of five days we are introduced to Two men...

One saunters in...flashing his trademark blue bracelet... and a winning smile and commences to wipe the floor with the hoodlums...Consummate Hindi movie hero... complete with Ma Baap dialogues, swashbuckling moves...and a earthy soundtrack...Wins the day !!! He respectfully hands over the dupatta to Khushi's Amma... Her modesty restored... Her dignity intact ... And then...with his first glimpse of ASR's Khushi... (She is already marked!!! ) he is lost...She hides behind her Amma, hesitant to reveal her self even to the man who saved her...Finally, she does look back briefly, to express a silent thank you...

The other...A practically villainous, passionate aggressor...and eventually, the perpetrator of this distasteful incident... Yet it is to him that she clings...wide eyed... Her hands clutching at his collar...stricken by his unblinking, insolent gaze ... on her eyes ... on her lips...her breath coming in short gasps...unable to look away...
He orders his Goons to lock her up...and as she is being dragged away...her dupatta tramples under his feet and is pulled off her head...She turns back ...eyes pleading...and then...A brief, unfocused glimpse of her bare back and the pearl dori... Precursors to an unravelling of a tale... (Seems like I am not done with the first episode...)

It takes him a rebirth of sorts to restore her honor and place the dupatta back on her head...but for now, he is back in Delhi being grilled by his Di about him finding his Dhulan and eventually about "Dulhan Kay libas mein Arnav Singh Raizada ki gowd mein aa giri ... Kabhi soocah hai us kya baray mein???"

His eyes hooded, his voice distant.. mumbles... almost to himself ..." Sooch kar hi to kiya tha..."

What is he talking about!!!!!??? The T. V. footage??? I don't think so... I think he is already reminiscing about the pearl dori !!!! ... And then, out of the blue...blurts the " Nari mukti mocha" dialogue...Knows sub-conscientiously , that his actions will not sit well with any woman...Di teases him further... Only to point out a glaring gap in his knowledge... Her name...

Does this explain his repeated chanting of her full name, once he gets to know it..???? Maybe I am reading too much into things??? But ..Maybe not???

Khushi, in the mean time is embroiled in a storm of his making...Small minded society's taunts, Buaji's relentless abuse.. Amma's seething temper, Babuji's disappointment, Payal's heartbreak and her own helplessness at her predicament ... But she will fight back...

And the punishment???...The Sisters are to be banished to Dilli until the "Ho Halla" subsides...right into the path of a larger tornado...


Edited by Ipoona - 12 years ago
dramebaaz.af thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6

Arshi Analyzers

Posted: 12 years ago
#6
I'm at Yale.
Have some pity.
Even my laptops isn't opening!

Updating in a while...
redwine1 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: GirlOfFire




In the spate of two days, Khushi bumps into two men - Arnav and Shyam. Two men who will do everything they can to destroy her. Two men who would claim to love her, but only one man would eventually have her heart. And through it all, Khushi bears it. Crying, fumbling, fuming, breaking down, ready to confront, although her fear is clearly visible in her trembling hands, and fisted fingers. Yet she will not back down from either of these men, whenever she confronts them.


When viewing for the first time, it must have left viewers confused. Who is the villain and who is the hero? Is it Arnav - the man who didn't hesitate to "molest" Khushi, then release her tapes to the world, or is it Shyam - the man who didn't hesitate to step into a melee and help save her honor?

Now we know - but then we had wondered.

But IPK has never been a story told simply. And therein lies the magic of the story teller. The leitmotifs in the story are already starting to be set. Words, actions in these and the following episodes will find an echo in later ones. Loops will be opened and closed. And questions will be raised.

I loved that Akash Singh Raizada made an appearance in the fourth episode. What I loved more was how he'd scrunched up his face to look like Arnav (!) while thinking about the man who was obstructing their photo shoot!

Which brings me to the man who would write his own destiny. Yes, for 2.5 crores he can "write" his destiny. But for the life of him, he can't toss away a chit of a girl with a key in her hand.



Maddy ...

Sublime write as usual ...

Highlighted portion ... is a very thought provoking thot ... yes both men loved her .. both men wanted her .. ONE GOT HER THE OTHER DID NOT ...
Thats simply cause ... Arnav the day he acknowledged he loved KHUSHI .. or his saasein ruk jaayegi .. or his first Dhak dhak moment ( post payash wedding havan) ... NEVER WENT OUT TO DESTROY KHUSHI ...
He married her .. he gave her respect in front of his family & society ... in private he did fight her .. BUT he did not destroy her ...

Now Shyam .. from the day he acknowledged his LUST or in his mind his Love for KHUSHI .. he set out to DESTROY HER ... there in lies the difference ...

Now the most sweetest & revealing part of IPK ... here goes .. am jumping the gun by explaining this here .. but .. chalo ..

Shyam is a committed man .. he is married .. but he wants to have his cake & eat it to .. he wants to remain married to Anji .. while keeping Khushi as his side kick .. in polite society .. Khushi woudl've been his mistress .. SO his love was a DISRESPECT & DESTROYING of KHUSHI ..

Arnav .. was committed ... but the day he acknowledged .. that he wanted his arms around KHUSHI & Not Lavanya .. he broke off his engagement ... his commitment to HER WAS COMPLETE that day ... Now focus on Arnav's dad here ... he was SHYAM recreated ... BUT Arnav was NOT ... hence the fathers character .. beyond the implications of the past was so important & was constantly brought into focus ... THIS was the main reason .. he was called .. ARNAV SINGH RAIZADA .. & not ARNAV MALLIK ... cause he was not a philander ..



chowna thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 12 years ago
#8



Today we got introduced to the character named
Shyam Manohar Jah

Who would have thought he would
manipulate and create
such a disaster in the
lives of Guptas and the Raizadas

Subtitle & english eps link




Subtitle & english eps link





Edited by chowna - 12 years ago
.S.A. thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#9
DC ... Just to say I always enjoyed your takes but never commented before ... Not into analysis.
Kishmish thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#10
As usual ... a beautiful take on the episode through the eyes of DC ...
Thanks so much ... for making us go through the beautiful moments without
seeing the episode ...

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".