My take on Yash Tonk's entry today..

smartc thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 19 years ago
#1

Ok folks, so I am going to write a quick review of the episode today with my take on it. By no means do I intend to disrespect anyone's feelings or to thrust my opinion on the readers. Simply stating what's on my mind as I've got some time to kill..

I genuinely believe that this whole kidnapping story was developed to give a decent entry to Yash Tonk who will be playing Shiv Kapoor from this point onwards. After all, it is a challenging job to fill any good actor's shoes, let alone if that person is the most amazing and talented actor of television of all-times. I read all reviews and comments about how Yash Tonk was copying Iqbal's makeup routine and outfits and hairstyle and what not. But I need to be fair to him here. Kudos to him for accepting a role that he knows will bring on more challenges for him in both the reel and real world. It takes guts to try to take a character that was given life by the great Iqbal Khan and then to bring along his own identity to it. Sure, it won't be as great and as popular as it could've been had Iqbal stayed. But the reality is that Iqbal has left the show and we need to embrace the reality as it presents itself to us. I personally feel that Yash did a good job for his first episode today. I am a person who tries not to judge people on appearances. So I had decided early on to give Yash a chance to get him reach his comfort zone so that he can be the evaluated of how good he is as an actor. Whether he will do justice to the role of Shiv Kapoor, only time will tell. But my first impression of him is that he did a decent job and he can definitely act!! I missed terribly the husky voice of Iqbal and the ever-so-melting stares of him. Nobody can do justice to an eyeliner the way Iqbal does. Similarly, I think the scene would've rocked like anything had Iqbal been there. However, I would have been disgusted seeing Iqbal with Ms. Ipshita later on and at least with Yash, I could bear him with her. I think Yash needs to be given an opportunity to prove himself, and that's time consuming. It is your own prerogative if you want to quit the show now. But I would urge viewers to keep watching the show for its storyline, for Pallavi's sake and even for Yash to see how he fares at this task.

Mind you, Yash would never replace Iqbal. However, he will provide something different to us as Shiv Kapoor. And that something different could already be felt today in the episode where his chemistry seemed to be much liked and appreciated with Ipshita. We already disapproved of Ipshita-Shiv's jodi when there was Iqbal involved. However, it was bearable for us to see Yash in his place instead. I believe that different is not always bad. So perhaps this different side of Shiv Kapoor's character would turn out for the best in future.

As far as Yash's entry is concerned, I have to give props to the stylist because I really didn't want to see Yash with his 70s do or partitioned hairstyle that he was supporting in NB2. I had enough of that. But with this haircut, he looked quite good. I think the outfits need to be analyzed now in more depth, as we don't want to see Shiv Kapoor wearing sleeveless shirts now supporting a rocker's appearance. We had one angad already in that respect (hehehe).. But with a more mature look and depth in terms of his outfits, he will continue to make a place hopefully in audience's hearts.

The entry scene was quite good for Yash.. I am glad Ekta actually showed a note instead of a bogus plastic surgery routine or some other weird crap. Who am I to critique on an actor's skills when I don't have any knowledge about acting or performing arts myself.. But I am going to state here that I liked the fact that he fared well here. The two things that I was not convinced with was that the fact that the damn wires to which Yash was attached with was being shaken by him way too much. Darn it, you have a bomb attached to you.. Would you be shaking like a leaf here then? I agree you are being emotional here Shiv but when a bomb is attached to you, you need to take a deep breath and stay in one place. Not shake it to get blasted off right away.. :P Other thing was the fact that his voice intensity was not doing justice to his acting. Yash's tone is low in the dialogue delivery and I think this is what makes him come off much more sweeter across viewers than as a person who used to be arrogant once upon a time. But still, he was pretty good here. I have to applaud Pallavi's acting here.. Gosh, this girl impresses me more and more everyday. She did not hesitate for one second with Yash. She was quite comfortable with him. If not for anyone, I intend to watch the serial for Pallavi's sake. That'd be enough for me for now!!

Talking about the the chemistry between Yash and Pallavi, sure it was not up to the notch. But time is required here folks!! Chemistry may never be there but unless we give some time to Yash to get comfortable with the character himself, it is unfair to have huge expectations from him. But one thing is true.. He rocked the joint with Ipshita today. The way he wished her for her birthday and the way he kissed her on her forehead, it was all very sweet. I would've been puking my guts out if that had been Iqbal there as Shiv. God knows I would've forwarded the whole scene.. But I didn't do so this time. So it wasn't so bad today.

I would end here by saying this.. I don't think there could be anyone who could portray Shiv Kapoor as amazingly as Iqbal Khan did. For me, he's the original and the epitome of what Shiv Kapoor is all about. But reality is that he's gone now. And Yash was apparently not a bad choice as I was dreading it. He didn't make me cringe throughout the episode. He made me appreciate his acting actually. I have seen his work in a movie earlier (Popcorn Khao..) but I was not impressed there with his role. But he displayed his acting skills well as Shiv Kapoor. Whether Iqbal comes back to KAA later on or not is something I don't want to even ponder about because that would mean leading myself to a false hope most probably. So let Iqbal enjoy his time off away from the tinsel town and embrace the new changes as they come our way..A great philosopher once said:


"Since changes are going on anyway, the great thing is to learn enough about them so that we will be able to lay hold of them and turn them in the direction of our desires. Conditions and events are neither to be fled from nor passively acquiesced in; they are to be utilized and directed".


Or as Tupac once sang..

"That's just the way it is
Things'll never be the same
That's just the way it is
Oh, yeah!! "

Cheers,
Sana~

Edited by smartc - 19 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

35

Views

2.1k

Users

19

Frequent Posters

mpatel97508 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#2
i guess he was ok... 😛 😛
spring92 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#3
awesome! i compeletly agree with you !
nicely written! 👏 👏

cheers
😳
rimmy thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#4
i agree with you 100% ... i was really dreading his enrty too... but i think that he will be fine...but no one can be like IQBAL...but i think YASH did a decent work in todays episod.
6219 thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#5
Great post Sana, very well said, but I can't accept Yash as Shiv 😭 😭 😭 I know its tough, but I just can't.

I think Ekta waited to air him cause she needed his stubbles to grow and look like IQ, but the fact is he is not IQ! From what I know personally that was IQ's personal perference. Now ekta is even copying him.

I will try to give him a chance, but I don't think I will be able to. Also, Yash and Gauri's chemistry sucks, it does not light the screen on fire.

This Shiv and IPPY can stick together, they can romance all they want. 😆
*Spandana* thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#6
completely agree sana dii. i liked his acting but dress sence, voice and with gauri i didnot like him. i kind of felt bad seeing gauri loving him soo much. and i think thts acting no matter who ur co-star is. his hair style - i liked it. and i think i need some time to adjust to him. thts it. 😊
*Spandana* thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#7
completely agree sana dii. i liked his acting but dress sence, voice and with gauri i didnot like him. i kind of felt bad seeing gauri loving him soo much. and i think thts acting no matter who ur co-star is. his hair style - i liked it. and i think i need some time to adjust to him. thts it. 😊
smartc thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 19 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: queenkumar

Great post Sana, very well said, but I can't accept Yash as Shiv 😭 😭 😭 I know its tough, but I just can't.

I think Ekta waited to air him cause she needed his stubbles to grow and look like IQ, but the fact is he is not IQ! From what I know personally that was IQ's personal perference. Now ekta is even copying him.

I will try to give him a chance, but I don't think I will be able to. Also, Yash and Gauri's chemistry sucks, it does not light the screen on fire.

This Shiv and IPPY can stick together, they can romance all they want. 😆



Hey Sangeeta Di.. Great to hear from ya.. U're right.. Nobody can take Iqbal's place.. But hey, the show must go on. Now whether it becomes an Ipshita-Yash show, then that's fine with me now.. Gauri deserves somebody who loves her for who she is.. So if Yash aka Shiv can't realize that, then that's okay with me. Perhaps we need a new character (didn't Shiv have like long lost brother or something??) for her.. So let's see what new twists and turns await us..

Meanwhile, I am just trying to make some sense of this new turn in KAA. But I have to say that the style Yash was supporting in Nach Baliye 2 was definitely not in cohoots with the character of Shiv Kapoor. But with his re-defined look, even if that means mimicking Iqbal's look, he is doing more justice to the character in terms of appearance at least.. Chalain.. Let's see what happens next.. But for heaven's sake, don't bail on me just right now.. I need u here dammit !! 😆😆

xoxo, Sana~
ANJANA thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#9
I completely agree with you he did a very good job 😊
*Spandana* thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: queenkumar

Great post Sana, very well said, but I can't accept Yash as Shiv 😭 😭 😭 I know its tough, but I just can't.

I think Ekta waited to air him cause she needed his stubbles to grow and look like IQ, but the fact is he is not IQ! From what I know personally that was IQ's personal perference. Now ekta is even copying him.

I will try to give him a chance, but I don't think I will be able to. Also, Yash and Gauri's chemistry sucks, it does not light the screen on fire.

This Shiv and IPPY can stick together, they can romance all they want. 😆


hi sangeeta dii,
where have u been😆😊

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".