Sony tv asks cc producers to rein in their actors - Page 4

Created

Last reply

Replies

37

Views

4.6k

Users

25

Likes

221

Frequent Posters

princessunara thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 12 years ago
#31

Originally posted by: kairavi.

Out of all of this mess the one thing that everyone agrees on is that the PH and Channel were both negligent. The PH should have stepped up the moment Farhan gave his first TC interview and responded negating the need for Sanaya to have to defend her character. Perhaps like FK they too thought all publicity is good regardless of the fact that their lead actress was being publically maligned by the person to whom they gave a respectable out. So another truth is out regarding the 'I quit' statement. How many more lies of this lowlife are still waiting to come out. The PH gave FK a chance to leave respectfully and he thew it back in their faces - I hope all othe PH's amd channels are watching this situation and will remember the name Farhan Khan and avoid him like the plague so that we never have to see him again. I can't believe that Iactually wished him well for the future.



perfectly said!
they r too late and even now not done enough! both the channel and PH have redefined too little, too late with their utterly irresponsible behavior!

also one thing to remember, this shit did not happen on online portals only. defense for Sanaya across IF & FB were million times higher than any shit that was said.
But the crap was printed in a main newspaper too. TOI. And that was it.. the PH and channel were utterly despicable to be so low to let her take the fall for some shitty publicity!😡
grr... and i specially agree to the last part u said.
I also hope every PH & channel remembers the name as what they should avoid as plague! well said!!

princessunara thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 12 years ago
#32

Originally posted by: showviewer


The premise of your argument is wrong, Farhan was removed not because of his lack of camaraderie with Sanaya, but because he lacks any kind of acting talent. He was there for 2 months with no improvement. But more than him the casting director, who was FK's acquaintance, and PH are to be blamed for hiring someone with no acting skills.

He was replaced because of the immense negative feedback and criticism his work got both in media and by viewers. If you have time check the articles and reviews over the past two months.

You obviously have chosen to believe what FK is saying AFTER he was replaced...did you read what he said last month about Sanaya, that she was so cooperative and lacked tantrums. Even if you are going by the TB article, there too FK himself said that Sanaya was professional with him, they were not friends. I don't think co- actors need to be more than professional to get work done, what was FK's problem? There are other shows where leads don't get along but they are performing well in front of camera.

Apart from FK's interviews did you get a chance to read what other actors or newsroom reports say about what actually happened or is FK's word enough?

Yes, you are right about when Sanaya first started acting, she was not that great, but the irony is she is the first to admit that and she took up small roles initially because of that instead of lead. Read her latest interview in Hindustan Times for it, where she stated it herself.

Most people here are on agreement, if you read other posts, that FK alone was not the problem here, but he was one of the major one and that finally is taken care of. Now the makers have to address other issues too.

Finally, thanks for wishing the show bad, but I would like to wish your favorite shows and actors well in their careers.



oh I was going to answer this when i saw u already have! di well said.. whatever u did not cover i will only post a single video of less than 5 mins... if miss great lecturer who didn't check anything yet decided to advice has the time for that i really hope she has the time to check this out too.
the 1st video is from exactly 1 year and 1 month back. So now talk.

[YOUTUBE]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NPISn9HOKDs[/YOUTUBE]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NPISn9HOKDs


stg1 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 3 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#33
tfs. i think this is too little too late, and sony r now basically just trying to save face. i know channel and ph is always bigger than the actor and dont bother too much with the ins and outs of a show in the media but obviously fk did some damage which is why they r stepping in now.

not sure why they still dont make an OFFICIAL announcement confirming the facts and backing up their decision to replace, and sanaya's lack of involvement in the process, so people can move on and stop bashing everyone concerned!

the show needs to get away from this negativity but yes, i'm surprised a newcomer is getting this much attention, unless the media r just using him and will let him be thrown him to the wolves once they're done. hope the show can settle down now and pulls in more viewers.

Mogwai thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#34
I blame the PH for the entire fiasco.
incandescent thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 12 years ago
#35

Originally posted by: bhatiyani



Where did u want the article to be from.. ??

How was the replacement justified ?? a total rookie who was given barely 2 months to prove his salt ..who did show tht he was improving .. Deserved another month ... If U say tht FK did not deserve a chance..May I suggest tht you have a look in at the first show of Ms.Irani and offer ur opinion on THAT !!

@ Red.. The PH did not allow the actor to CLAIM..It offered him the option of staying shut by saying that HE QUIT..FK CHOSE not to take that option and broke open the can of Worms ..leading to 'TENSIONED MENTAL HEALTH' of the channel ..which finally intervened and told the Production house to shut their actors up, which includes Sanaya !!

I agree with the Buck stopping with Farhan too ..!!

So Much fuss is not in the actor being replaced but rather in the aftermath of him being replaced..😊



I did not want this article to be from anywhere. As a matter of fact, I do not want any more articles about this from anywhere at all. The actors from the show have moved on, fans have moved on and all of us just want to concentrate on the show. It's only the media that keeps bringing it up now. In case you are unaware, TC has a reputation for sensationalizing things; therefore I was not surprised to see yet another article from TC on this matter.

The replacement was justified because he was given 2 long months to improve and he did not make any significant amount of improvement and his acting was far too weak to be even considered as acting. You don't have to suggest me to take a look at the first show of Ms.Irani. I am her fan and I have done that a long time ago.😊 Her acting surely wasn't as polished as it is now, but it was still acting. Ms.Irani was not the main lead in her first show either. She consciously started off with supporting roles to become seasoned before moving on to lead roles. There are many actors out there who start off lead roles and deliver thousands times better than the ex-male lead of this show. Despite having previous acting experiences in theater and films, Mr.Khan was complete disaster in front of the camera.

Quoting from the article...

'Incidentally the production house had tried to offer a face saving device to Farhan by letting him claim that he had quit the show.'

As per the article the PH offered him a saving grace and all his interviews clearly show that he did take the offer. In all the interviews he claimed that he quit but he didn't stop there. He took benefit of the situation and badmouthed Sanaya in the media which gave rise to speculations about her professional ethics. The PH and the channel should have intervened at that time but they were too slow. Sanaya was left with no choice but to defend herself and her co-actors came to her support because the accusations against her were completely false.

The fuss is indeed about the replacement because the newcomer non-actor made it a big deal himself.

Had the PH and the channel handled things better, there wouldn't have been aftermath in the first place.

jyothi- thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#36

Originally posted by: Joseph_A

...Pathetic !! I am totally fade-up wid SONY/PH stand in this issue. in this Chhan Chhan controversy... they are behaving like Fools.

Why they didn't react first on Farhan's allegation...?? Still they are in silent mode. Farhan replacement rumors was not new for us but,what is the reason behind 1 month 'Yes-No' game...?? They can't handle a Big show in proper way...

Farhan selection in CC is still a mystery for all of us...how can he crack the 'Screen test'..

I am glad to see that finally Mr.Model got a media supporter like TC. but,is he really deserve this attention...??

Joseph agree with u.PH auditioned 50 popular stars and in the end vipul decided to have new face as manav.,As u said how he passed screen test.If his acting is not upto the mark then why should they waited till the IPL end to replace.
They were putting the blame on FK i am not FK fan rite from day 1 but all this has happened because of Vipul shah.This is big budget show vipul has failed in handling this show.
snowwhite28 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#37

Originally posted by: jyothi-m


</div>
<div>

Joseph agree with u.PH auditioned 50 popular stars and in the end vipul decided to have new face as manav.,As u said how he passed screen test.If his acting is not upto the mark then why should they waited till the IPL end to replace.


They were putting the blame on FK i am not FK fan rite from day 1 but all this has happened because of Vipul shah.This is big budget show vipul has failed in handling this show.

agreed jyoti ch and ph should be blamed. And up to certain extent cv's they failed to write the good story.
jyothi- thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#38

Originally posted by: snowwhite28

agreed jyoti ch and ph should be blamed. And up to certain extent cv's they failed to write the good story.

@Tanu do agree even story is not good.They were saying because of FK trp is low but now what happened?Marriage track they did not showed properly.Hope by next week trp should go up.I am not expecting ver high trp in sony .Since this is big budget show for that, trp is very low.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".