Alone, bereft, like mother, like daughter

soapwatcher1 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#1

The actors were brilliant today, Ankita was awesome but Archana the mother disappointed. While her angst is logical and her reaction (the slap) is totally understandable, her disowning Purvi is not. We do have to keep in mind that Archana's reaction is the point of view of someone receiving the damning news for the very first time. For everyone else, it is old hat, to Archana the news about Pari's paternity is hot off the press.

Archana knows Purvi well, she questions why Purvi gave up Pari even though she, Archu had forbidden Purvi from making any more sacrifices. All fine and dandy to this point. Purvi confesses about Pari being Arjun's and hers, Archu slaps Purvi, cliche but to be expected. As a mother, Archana has every right to admonish Purvi, to be hurt, to be ashamed. She has to rant and rave, that is a mother, it is a given. The words that fell from Archana's lips though were poor form on the part of the CVs. A mother, however mortified and deeply wounded, would never say those words to her child ESPECIALLY after knowing the circumstances that had led to this current fiasco. Archana is cognizant that Purvi sacrificed Arjun and her own happiness so that she, Archana, could enjoy her family and wedded bliss with the man that left her for 18 long years.

Was Archana upset that Pari was conceived out of wedlock? If so, a totally reasonable reaction from a mother. But the woman in Archana can hopefully comprehend that however wrong in the eyes of society, the hut incident happened the night before Purvi's wedding after a near death experience, that too with her fiance who loved her to bits and who thought he had lost his soon to be wife. If Archana is angry with Purvi for that sole reason, disowning her after all these months does not somehow sit right. At this age, (50's?) if Archana can romance with her husband of 60(?), the hot blood of youth should at least minimally mitigate what happened between her daughter and her would be husband. Shameful, maybe, understandable, certainly.

Or is Archana unspokenly upset that Purvi had the baby and hence "wrecked" her dear darling daughter's happiness? If this latter is the reason, well, Archana then is not the person she is painted to be. Fair, righteous, always just, Archana could not have reacted this way. It is the fault of the CVs for transgressing from the lines of her character.

Archana should remember her own plight all those years ago when Manav abandoned her. Yes, Archana showed ehsaas to Purvi by giving her a home but Archana was allowed the opportunity to shower her mamta on this child and experience all aspects of motherhood vicariously through this sadak ki beti. Those dark years, Archana was alone, bereft, she has said many a time that Purvi was the one that gave her a reason for living. And Archu was not entirely alone, she had Sulo. The same was Purvi's plight, she though was entirely alone, bereft of family and love, she was an outcast, she had been asked to disappear by her selfish sister and so she did. She carried with her the one thing that was hers alone, her baby, and the memories of the man who loved her.

To question Purvi as to why she did not abort the child, is beyond selfishness to me. It is leagues below self-absorption. But then, Ovi had no qualms about aborting her own baby until that light bulb (Savita) went off that perhaps the baby could be instrumental in making Arjun really her own. Purvi, you have given up your love, your family, how dare you not kill your baby for Ovi's sake, for her happiness? Ovi certainly deserves a couple of smacks along with Purvi. Archana should after she regains consciousness slap that selfish daughter of hers and point out to her the nathija of her deal, pain and suffering for all. Please don't tell me, the deal is not Ovi's fault, that Purvi accepted and she should suffer. She is suffering. But what baffles the mind is "how selfish a hand or eye, could conceive that fiendish deal?" And even more, what baneful heart could overlook that selfishness? Manav constantly harps on Purvi being the fault of his little girl's unhappiness. Yes, when he first discovered the truth, the man was blind sided and blamed Purvi, but since then he has had time to digest the facts, realize that his little Barbie doll was no innocent babe in this tamasha. But Manav will be Manav, he has always worn blinders and will continue to do so.

Edited by soapwatcher1 - 12 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

41

Views

3.4k

Users

15

Likes

204

Frequent Posters

soniiyaa thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#2
Your post is one of the best I've ever read on this forum.

I cannot thank you enough for this! You have spoken volumes with this one post. This was much needed!

I agree with 100% of what you wrote. 😊
Tanyaz thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 12 years ago
#3
Just now I saw the show ..
I feel terrible for Archana today .She did not deserve this from Purvi ..
Do not buy this whole thing ' I did this anjaane mein ' at all...no one ever has sex anjaane mein ...this whole act happens with full knowledge of what one is doing ...unless of course a girl is forced into it or she is drunk ...Purvi was neither drunk nor was she forced ...there was no anjaane mein factor at all.
Archana's trust was the last thing Purvi or Arjun even cared about at that time . Foolish Archana was the only one who showed faith in their relationship and was even ready to destroy her own life for them ...
Shame on Purvi and Arjun for breaking Archana 's trust ...
Purvi broke her mother's trust and now she will just have to live with this ..Archana had nothing , this girl was her life ...and out of all the people she betrayed her ...
Also glad that Archana refused to even look at Arjun's face .She trusted her daughter with him and just look at what he did ...
Probably Archana will forgive Purvi after some time but her trust has been broken and that is very sad ...
Sad episode , brilliant actng by Ankita ...she looked as if she had died ...
Edited by Tanyaz - 12 years ago
rajvta thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#4
you have summed up the whole fiasco beautifully. Loved it 👏.
Also, wanted to add another thing, some posters were harping on the fact that Pari is illegitimate and hence Ovi was practical enough to ask why she was not aborted ( as if that makes the question right). A child is not illegitimate or legitimate, relationships are. And as Pari was conceived just a day before her parents marriage was to take place, the relationship being illegitimate is also a moot point IMHO.
As for Archana, I still feel she will come around. She may also be more angry for the fact that Purvi again sacrificed for the selfish d family(read Ovi) when she expressly asked her not to do so anymore.
Tanyaz thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 12 years ago
#5
Archana was angry when she heard about the baby swaping as she had told Purvi many times not to get involved in Ovi's matters ( at that time she thought that Pari was Onir and Purvi's baby ) but when she heard that Purvi , the girl she had raised with so much love and how much she trusted her , she had sex with this guy with whome she was not married to ...that is what broke her completely ...
pesi11 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#6
tanya ..

i totally agree with u ..archu's trust is broken .. ... i can't wait to watch this episode for anki's performance ...
nicegirl_good thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#7
Jhanvi Di,
As always an amazing post 👏

Now coming to Archu's POV, I think she is right where she is. For her, it wouldn't be much of a shocker if Ovi was the one who got pregnant out of wedlock but it's Purvi the one she showers her trust, love, everything to.

The circumstances which led to current fiasco?
For Archana, even to us as viewers the situation Arjun and Purvi had sex under is quite unbelievable. So they had a near death experience, it was raining they got turned on? 😕
Had they married at that point, I don't think Archana would be upset they were only engaged.

I know Purvi sacrificed a lot for her mother, but to her mother Purvi is happy with Onir while Arjun and Ovi sort out their differences.

Her mother, just like any of us would have that one question WHY SHE GAVE PARI

had she not given Pari to Arovi nothing of this sort would happen

Saying "I AM DEAD TO YOU" is quite a natural reaction and not an extra ordinary one
For someone like Archana who gives utmost importance to marriage, this is a shame. Purvi even admitted she left town so Arovi would be happy.
That means she knew of her pregnancy when she left town
If she spoke up then, so many lives wouldn't be destroyed.
nicegirl_good thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: rajvta

you have summed up the whole fiasco beautifully. Loved it 👏.

Also, wanted to add another thing, some posters were harping on the fact that Pari is illegitimate and hence Ovi was practical enough to ask why she was not aborted ( as if that makes the question right). A child is not illegitimate or legitimate, relationships are. And as Pari was conceived just a day before her parents marriage was to take place, the relationship being illegitimate is also a moot point IMHO.
As for Archana, I still feel she will come around. She may also be more angry for the fact that Purvi again sacrificed for the selfish d family(read Ovi) when she expressly asked her not to do so anymore.


I don't think any of us said it because Pari was legitimate or illegitimate
It's practical because PURVI CLAIMED she left town so AROVI could be happy
When you keep someone's baby, you are keeping a part of them
had Purvi not claimed to want Arovi's happiness Ovi wouldn't ask this question
Purvi was always hovering around, interfering in Ovi's life
If Purvi could snatch the right from Ovi to not let her see her stillborn
Then Ovi also had the right to ask this simple question
Why is it that everything Ovi does/ says is a sin
but Purvi's bigger mistakes are overlooked
Tanyaz thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 12 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: soapwatcher1

At this age, (50's?) if Archana can romance with her husband of 60(?), the hot blood of youth should at least minimally mitigate what happened between her daughter and her would be husband. Shameful, maybe, understandable, certainly.

Archana and Manav are a married couple ...they can do it even if they are 70 ...no one will have a problem with that ...
But in India , in a middle class society ( from where Purvi comes from ) It is not accepted to do this without marriage ...and if we don't care about these things then might as well go and live in a jungle ...there no one will ever question ...
But Purvi wants to live in a society , in a parivaar , be accepted as someone's wife , daughter , sister ...then I am afraid that these few rules she will have to go along with ..
She saw her mother's reaction to her SMS with Arjun...Archana was firm , ' my Purvi cannot do something so cheap ' then also she did this ????
If she was drunk then maybe I would have understood it but she was full awake and In full senses ..There is no excuse for what she did ...
Purvi has butchered her mother;s heart and I hope she hates herself for the way she has behaved ...and at least from now onward be carefull..
Sharafat and izzat are not in the married Bengali saree , the big sindoor and the mangal sutra but sharafat is in your heart and in your eyes ..
Children should not break their parents trust just to have some good time because they are their parents entire life ...their parents have put their whole lives in giving them good values .
soapwatcher1 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: sk11

Your post is one of the best I've ever read on this forum.


I cannot thank you enough for this! You have spoken volumes with this one post. This was much needed!

I agree with 100% of what you wrote. 😊

😊Thank you for those very kind words.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".