PR Today: Comedy Circus 4: April 30, 2013

sashashyam thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#1

Well, folks, I was in two minds about whether to spare you this one or not, but today's high decibel slugfest, which was more of a walkover for Manav than a contest of any sort, needed some special notice. But I promise to keep it brief, by my standards, of course!

The first thing that strikes one about this conclave was the attendance. It was obviously held in the D residence, so why were Manju, Vinod and Ruchi (with all her super abundance of pearly whites in place) there at all? I cannot even guess, and I wonder why, while they were about it, they did not rope in Mittal and Punni as well.

The only ones missing were, in that order, Onir, who was probably out collecting more job refusals, and Pari, who was.. where do you suppose she was? In that rickety jholi all by herself while Mommy dearest was shedding picturesque tears in discreet silence as her Manav baba roared at her? Perhaps Onir was not wearing out his chappals after all, but was babysitting (now) his ladli beti .

Next, it seemed, as Manav was holding the videocam, that he had had a viewing of Ovi' s touching farewell message to her spouse. It is an open question whether there was a general showing for the whole assemblage, but since there was no big screen in the D residence, one presumes that the rest of them were expected, as they listened to Manav shouting louder that one has ever heard him do before, to dot the 'i's and cross the 't's for themselves.

DK of course did not need all these grammatical aids, but he was moustache-heen today (I say today since these days, his moustache appears and disappears at random, like the grin of the Cheshire cat), and without the hirsute decoration for his upper lip, he is like the shorn Samson. He thus does not utter a word all through.

Manav worked himself up to fever pitch, and let Arjun and Purvi have it with both barrels. The point was not whether he was fair in the blame he laid, vociferously and with a pointed finger eerily reminiscent of his now comatose ardhangini, on the twosome. When one is the prosecutor, one does not 'understand' the defendants or the lawyer for the defense. One goes for the jugular, and this is exactly what Manav does.

In the process, he gets the First Person Award for actually asking Ms. Mahaanta, for the first time in this benighted serial, what she was thinking of when she saddled meri beti ( the distinction he made was as sharp as a knife cut; for him, Purvi is now beyond the pale) with the child of her husband and a 'doosri aurat' . Did she imagine that she was doing some mahaan tyaag?

Since this was precisely what Purvi had thought ' a take echoed, then and now, by her two devoted followers, Arjun and Onir - she not surprisingly held her peace, and let her tears roll down her cheeks silently. Arjun took up her slack, and while even he did not dare touch the tyaag angle, he did stoutly defend his love against accusations of dhoka. And himself as well.

In the process, he terms the tryst in the dirty, wet shack that led directly to Pari, as a bhool that was committed anjaane me. To listen to him, one would have assumed that it was nothing out of the ordinary, but rather like Kunti trying out the mantra and ending up with Karna.

Arjun's having summoned up the courage needed to offer that defence against the dhoka charge had an unexpected follow through. Manav, after fixing him with a basilisk glare, grabs him and literally drags him into the adjacent room and bolts the door.

What follows furnished enough grounds for Arjun to sue the CVs for the assassination of his character; yes, yes, we all know it has been going on for months, but today, they defined what 'nadir' means. Or for Rithvik to do the same for making him do such pathetic scenes.

He literally cowers before the glowering, menacing Manav, and if like me, you thought these adjectives, applied to Manav, are a contradiction in terms, well, think again.Arjun's mouth droops, his Adam's apple works convulsively. His otherwise expressive eyes mirror nothing but an abject hangdog expression. As Manav demands to be told whether he loves Ovi, and barks Itna hichkichate kyon ho? , Arjun, far from attempting some sort of nuanced explanation, gulps, and babbles that yes, he does indeed love Ovi. I was astonished that (a) such an astute business negotiator did not see what was bound to come next, and (b) that having lied about his loving Ovi, he could not tell one more lie, that he no longer loved Purvi.

In one sense, I applauded Rithvik for having played so much against his natural grain and still managed to carry off such a pathetic take on Arjun, but then again, this is not the sort of scene for which an aspiring young actor seeks to be applauded. The bulk of the TV audience, which cannot distinguish between the actor and the character, is more likely to sneer at Arjun's dismal display of weakness than to admire Rithvik for a bravura performance.

When Arjun comes out and announces that he is going to give Ovi time to 'understand this rishta' (some expression, that), Savita makes it unambiguously clear that this cannot be his decision alone, and that she will make sure that their marriage does not fail. Arjun looks blank, and almost forgets to look miserable. But when she adds that they do not believe in divorce in their family, and that marriages are for saath janam, the poor chap looks, understandably, appalled.

The rest of the episode consists of trivia. The only noteworthy scene was in Onir's chawl kholi, where Sulochana has just made a visitation to warn Purvi to stay away from Arjun. When Purvi's patidev lands up, and the baby starts crying, what does her aai do after she has deduced that Pari is hungry, which is a not unexpected development? She does not, as you would expect, go to the kitchen counter to warm up some milk. Instead, she investigates Onir's by now empty purse. Was she going to get the baby milk from the bazaar and then feed it? So much for careful parenting.

She also seems to be astonished that the poor chap's purse was not like Draupadi's akshaya paatra. Perhaps she has forgotten how to count.

When she informs him that there is nothing in the purse, Onir gives a spirited imitation of a ticketless traveller when collard by the TT, looking in each pocket in vain. But of course, the fact remains that they are, apparently, bankrupt, and Pari will, barring some miracle, have to survive on mamta and fresh air.

In the precap, Purvi is shown telling Arjun (who is, as I had predicted, already there for the first of what would undoubtedly have been very many visits) that she has been 'asked not to meet him'. It is a strange statement, that too from one who is not overly hesitant about departing from the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth when it suits her. If she does not amplify on it tomorrow, Arjun is likely to be left with the entirely wrong impression that the objector is Onir.

Let us thus await what the morrow brings us, on this and other points.

Shyamala B.Cowsik

Edited by sashashyam - 12 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

17

Views

2.7k

Users

9

Likes

70

Frequent Posters

Not_a_fan thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 12 years ago
#2
Aunty,

Great post again! I'm glad you're taking the time to do these pieces, they're very comprehensive and "on the nose" so to speak 😃. Anyways, I already wrote my take based on the WU in Kool's thread so will copy-paste it here.

Excellent posts Kool, Varsha, masti, tanya and everyone else (sorry loved all posts here, too many to name 😊). I'm really glad the turns the story is taking wrt Ovi and even, manav.

Yay! for daddy manav. And for Hiten for being so good at it.

Yay! for ovi confiding in only her dad before leaving. Very practical, thank god we don't have to see her struggling. PR has enough of that farce as it is. And loved their bond again---her dad is her rock. Even when he loses his brains once in a while, he's always been there for her during crunchtime.

Yay! for the perfect questions put to arjun and to purvi, and for his conclusion that one cannot love 2 women (or men) at the same time so he is not going to search for Ovi. Awesome!

Nay! for savita still trying to keep arjun-ovi marriage intact. She didn't encourage vandu to leave her abusive husband because she believed in the institution of marriage. Understandable, because she comes from such a background and she's old with set beliefs. She herself didn't leave damodar who's one of the worst examples of the kind. But her fierce protective instincts for ovi, whom she clearly loves, should outride any such beliefs. Vandu didn't want to leave ajit, but ovi wants out. She has much greater understanding of marriage, and she has the support of her dad and opportunities to live life the way she wants to. Marriage is not the be-all and end-all for ovi, like it was for savita and in a way for vandu who didn't have the resources or the instincts to leave.

🤢 for arjun. I felt for him yesterday, but today. Gosh! Why is he not taking his freedom when he's not sure of his love for ovi and knows he loves purvi? Even if purvi is married, how does it matter? Can't he stay alone if purvi doesn't want to go away with him? 🐷

😡 for purvi. This lady is the limit! I think people's words goes through her ears and only parts of it reaches the pea-sized brain. She must have hit her head somewhere, and the rest of it seems to be under the weight of those icky wigs. Again, she's overcompensating and over-reacting. She is forbidden to meet arjun, which should be automatically understood by her if she wants to stay married to onir and wants arjun-ovi to stay married. She shouldn't need sulo's orders to get that. But when she gets the orders, she takes it as forbidding arjun to not meet pari. What's the connection? Onir can take her to meet arjun, spending some quality time together while they wax poetic about purvi's beauty 🤢. Or she can give pari back to arjun. Pari needed maa ka doodh , so arjun gave pari to her. Now she doesn't have any doodh--maa ka or otherwise. And Ovi who "hated" pari is gone. Why's she still keeping pari with her in that dangerous place with no money to take care of her, and forbidding arjun to see the baby. Ridiculous!🤪


Sowmya.
tejaswiniwenham thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: sashashyam

Well, folks, I was in two minds about whether to spare you this one or not, but today's high decibel slugfest, which was more of a walkover for Manav than a contest of any sort, needed some special notice. But I promise to keep it brief, by my standards, of course!

The first thing that strikes one about this conclave was the attendance. It was obviously held in the D residence, so why were Manju, Vinod and Ruchi (with all her super abundance of pearly whites in place) there at all? I cannot even guess, and I wonder why, while they were about it, they did not rope in Mittal and Punni as well.

The only ones missing were, in that order, Onir, who was probably out collecting more job refusals, and Pari, who was.. where do you suppose she was? In that rickety jholi all by herself while Mommy dearest was shedding picturesque tears in discreet silence as her Manav baba roared at her? Perhaps Onir was not wearing out his chappals after all, but was babysitting (now) his ladli beti .

Next, it seemed, as Manav was holding the videocam, that he had had a viewing of Ovi' s touching farewell message to her spouse. It is an open question whether there was a general showing for the whole assemblage, but since there was no big screen in the D residence, one presumes that the rest of them were expected, as they listened to Manav shouting louder that one has ever heard him do before, to dot the 'i's and cross the 't's for themselves.

DK of course did not need all these grammatical aids, but he was moustache-heen today (I say today since these days, his moustache appears and disappears at random, like the grin of the Cheshire cat), and without the hirsute decoration for his upper lip, he is like the shorn Samson. He thus does not utter a word all through.

Manav worked himself up to fever pitch, and let Arjun and Purvi have it with both barrels. The point was not whether he was fair in the blame he laid, vociferously and with a pointed finger eerily reminiscent of his now comatose ardhangini, on the twosome. When one is the prosecutor, one does not 'understand' the defendants or the lawyer for the defense. One goes for the jugular, and this is exactly what Manav does.

In the process, he gets the First Person Award for actually asking Ms. Mahaanta, for the first time in this benighted serial, what she was thinking off when she saddled meri beti ( the distinction he made was as sharp as a knife cut; for him, Purvi is now beyond the pale) with the child of her husband and a 'doosri aurat' . Did she imagine that she was doing some mahaan tyaag?

Since this was precisely what Purvi had thought ' a take echoed, then and now, by her two devoted followers, Arjun and Onir - she not surprisingly held her peace, and let her tears roll down her cheeks silently. Arjun took up her slack, and while even he did not dare touch the tyaag angle, he did stoutly defend his love against accusations of dhoka. And himself as well.

In the process, he terms the tryst in the dirty, wet shack that led directly to Pari, as a bhool that was committed anjaane me. To listen to him, one would have assumed that it was nothing out of the ordinary, but rather like Kunti trying out the mantra and ending up with Karna.

Arjun's having summoned up the courage needed to offer that defence against the dhoka charge had an unexpected follow through. Manav, after fixing him with a basilisk glare, grabs him and literally drags him into the adjacent room and bolts the door.

What follows furnished enough grounds for Arjun to sue the CVs for the assassination of his character; yes, yes, we all know it has been going on for months, but today, they defined what 'nadir' means. Or for Rithvik to do the same for making him do such pathetic scenes.

He literally cowers before the glowering, menacing Manav, and if like me, you thought these adjectives, applied to Manav, are a contradiction in terms, well, think again.Arjun's mouth droops, his Adam's apple works convulsively. His otherwise expressive eyes mirror nothing but an abject hangdog expression. As Manav demands to be told whether he loves Ovi, and barks Itna hichkichate kyon ho? , Arjun, far from attempting some sort of nuanced explanation, gulps, and babbles that yes, he does indeed love Ovi. I was astonished that (a) such an astute business negotiator did not see what was bound to come next, and (b) that having lied about his loving Ovi, he could not tell one more lie, that he no longer loved Purvi.

In one sense, I applauded Rithvik for having played so much against his natural grain and still managed to carry off such a pathetic take on Arjun, but then again, this is not the sort of scene for which an aspiring young actor seeks to be applauded. The bulk of the TV audience, which cannot distinguish between the actor and the character, is more likely to sneer at Arjun's dismal display of weakness than to admire Rithvik for a bravura performance.

When Arjun comes out and announces that he is going to give Ovi time to 'understand this rishta' (some expression, that), Savita makes it unambiguously clear that this cannot be his decision alone, and that she will make sure that their marriage does not fail. Arjun looks blank, and almost forgets to look miserable. But when she adds that they do not believe in divorce in their family, and that marriages are for saath janam, the poor chap looks, understandably, appalled.

The rest of the episode consists of trivia. The only noteworthy scene was in Onir's chawl kholi, where Sulochana has just made a visitation to warn Purvi to stay away from Arjun. When Purvi's patidev lands up, and the baby starts crying, what does her aai do after she has deduced that Pari is hungry, which is a not unexpected development? She does not, as you would expect, go to the kitchen counter to warm up some milk. Instead, she investigates Onir's by now empty purse. Was she going to get the baby milk from the bazaar and then feed it? So much for careful parenting.

She also seems to be astonished that the poor chap's purse was not like Draupadi's akshaya paatra. Perhaps she has forgotten how to count.

When she informs him that there is nothing in the purse, Onir gives a spirited imitation of a ticketless traveller when collard by the TT, looking in each pocket in vain. But of course, the fact remains that they are, apparently, bankrupt, and Pari will, barring some miracle, have to survive on mamta and fresh air.

In the precap, Purvi is shown telling Arjun (who is, as I had predicted, already there for the first of what would undoubtedly have been very many visits) that she has been 'asked not to meet him'. It is a strange statement, that too from one who is not overly hesitant about departing from the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth when it suits her. If she does not amplify on it tomorrow, Arjun is likely to be left with the entirely wrong impression that the objector is Onir.

Let us thus await what the morrow brings us, on this and other points.

Shyamala B.Cowsik

Dear Aunty,
I promised myself that AK would not get another commentary from me. but you have been voicing my commentary with utmost finesse. i'm happy to just read and indulge myself than propagate such a character further. they should have changed the name of the serial just for today's episode to 'Character Assassination- Arjun aur Mahanta ka' and instead of the first 10 mins, the entire episode should have been just that- the last two scenes were faltu anyways. Aunty whats your take on everyone touting ovi's misunderstanding as the reason for her departure?
Love
Tejaswini
sashashyam thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#4
Soumya dear,

Thanks, but I hope you also found it funny. There is really no other reason for my inflicting these on a long suffering public, for the serial is becoming unbearable unless one saves one's mind by mocking it. And there is no shortage of ammunition there either,even if not in every episode.

As for Arjun, as my mother noted sapiently after watching him gulp and babble today, he is now a creature of straw and sawdust. But you have to watch Rithvik bringing this pathetic creature to life. If one can set aside one's welling irritation at this excuse for a man, one can and should admire the performance. It could not have been easy.

I saw your post on the other thread and, unsurprisingly, liked it. Which is a not uncommon occurrence!

Shyamala Aunty

Originally posted by: sowmya_jairam

Aunty,

Great post again! I'm glad you're taking the time to do these pieces, they're very comprehensive and "on the nose" so to speak 😃. Anyways, I already wrote my take based on the WU in Kool's thread so will copy-paste it here.

Excellent posts Kool, Varsha, masti, tanya and everyone else (sorry loved all posts here, too many to name 😊). I'm really glad the turns the story is taking wrt Ovi and even, manav.

Yay! for daddy manav. And for Hiten for being so good at it.

Yay! for ovi confiding in only her dad before leaving. Very practical, thank god we don't have to see her struggling. PR has enough of that farce as it is. And loved their bond again---her dad is her rock. Even when he loses his brains once in a while, he's always been there for her during crunchtime.

Yay! for the perfect questions put to arjun and to purvi, and for his conclusion that one cannot love 2 women (or men) at the same time so he is not going to search for Ovi. Awesome!

Nay! for savita still trying to keep arjun-ovi marriage intact. She didn't encourage vandu to leave her abusive husband because she believed in the institution of marriage. Understandable, because she comes from such a background and she's old with set beliefs. She herself didn't leave damodar who's one of the worst examples of the kind. But her fierce protective instincts for ovi, whom she clearly loves, should outride any such beliefs. Vandu didn't want to leave ajit, but ovi wants out. She has much greater understanding of marriage, and she has the support of her dad and opportunities to live life the way she wants to. Marriage is not the be-all and end-all for ovi, like it was for savita and in a way for vandu who didn't have the resources or the instincts to leave.

🤢 for arjun. I felt for him yesterday, but today. Gosh! Why is he not taking his freedom when he's not sure of his love for ovi and knows he loves purvi? Even if purvi is married, how does it matter? Can't he stay alone if purvi doesn't want to go away with him? 🐷

😡 for purvi. This lady is the limit! I think people's words goes through her ears and only parts of it reaches the pea-sized brain. She must have hit her head somewhere, and the rest of it seems to be under the weight of those icky wigs. Again, she's overcompensating and over-reacting. She is forbidden to meet arjun, which should be automatically understood by her if she wants to stay married to onir and wants arjun-ovi to stay married. She shouldn't need sulo's orders to get that. But when she gets the orders, she takes it as forbidding arjun to not meet pari. What's the connection? Onir can take her to meet arjun, spending some quality time together while they wax poetic about purvi's beauty 🤢. Or she can give pari back to arjun. Pari needed maa ka doodh , so arjun gave pari to her. Now she doesn't have any doodh--maa ka or otherwise. And Ovi who "hated" pari is gone. Why's she still keeping pari with her in that dangerous place with no money to take care of her, and forbidding arjun to see the baby. Ridiculous!🤪


Sowmya.

nicegirl_good thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#5
Thank you Aunty for this review today !
Well I was glad that someone today asked Purvi WHY she did it and expect an answer
But I am also incredibly shocked seeing Savita the way she is acting
And I am annoyed by Purvi
It takes common sense to know she shouldn't meet up with Arjun
But that has nothing to do with Pari
I am sick of her
sashashyam thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#6
Dear Tejaswini,

I think it is not a question of galatfahmi at all, but of realising and, finally, accepting a bitter truth.

There is not, technically speaking, any post-marriage dhoka by Arjun, but in the emotional sense, there is a sharp contradiction between what he feels, and what he now claims, that he will make everything as it should be for Ovi. He cannot help it, this craving for the old bond with Purvi, and the fact that Onir is an incredibly 'understanding' husband makes this even more of an addiction. If he had been sharply warned to stay away from her by an irate husband, it would have been easier for him to kick the habit.

I never thought Ovi should go back to Arjun, even if she had another baby. But what puzzled me today was the about turn he makes between how he was with Ovi yesterday and how he is today. Like a drug addict in recidivism, I suppose.

I enjoyed the rebooted Manav/Hiten today. The fact that he is tall, and can thus tower over Arjun, who is anything but, also helps, perhaps!

Shyamala Aunty

Originally posted by: tejaswiniwenham


Dear Aunty,
I promised myself that AK would not get another commentary from me. but you have been voicing my commentary with utmost finesse. i'm happy to just read and indulge myself than propagate such a character further. they should have changed the name of the serial just for today's episode to 'Character Assassination- Arjun aur Mahanta ka' and instead of the first 10 mins, the entire episode should have been just that- the last two scenes were faltu anyways. Aunty whats your take on everyone touting ovi's misunderstanding as the reason for her departure?
Love
Tejaswini



Edited by sashashyam - 12 years ago
sashashyam thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#7
Waneeka,

I am glad you liked it, but I do not like to see you fretting over all this tripe. Just laugh at it, as I do.

Shyamala Aunty

Originally posted by: ilovedhanjanird

Thank you Aunty for this review today !
Well I was glad that someone today asked Purvi WHY she did it and expect an answer
But I am also incredibly shocked seeing Savita the way she is acting
And I am annoyed by Purvi
It takes common sense to know she shouldn't meet up with Arjun
But that has nothing to do with Pari
I am sick of her

MannMeinRadha thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 12 years ago
#8
Very nice analytic post n funny too. Enjoyed reading everyone's 2 cents.
Just lovvved Manav today. Go papa bear go. Excellent performance by Hiten Tejwani. Finally some1 said a few apt n long overdue words on the face of Loser guy n Purvi. I don't have any respect left for them now after watching today's episode. The CVs have butchered their characters beyond any redemption. :/
pesi11 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#9
wonderful analysis by one and all 👏
Not_a_fan thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 12 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: sashashyam

Soumya dear,

Thanks, but I hope you also found it funny. There is really no other reason for my inflicting these on a long suffering public, for the serial is becoming unbearable unless one saves one's mind by mocking it. And there is no shortage of ammunition there either,even if not in every episode.

As for Arjun, as my mother noted sapiently after watching him gulp and babble today, he is now a creature of straw and sawdust. But you have to watch Rithvik bringing this pathetic creature to life. If one can set aside one's welling irritation at this excuse for a man, one can and should admire the performance. It could not have been easy.

I saw your post on the other thread and, unsurprisingly, liked it. Which is a not uncommon occurrence!

Shyamala Aunty


Dear Shyamala Aunty,

I did find it funny, though there's not really too much of the dramatic for fodder. I found today's episode quite good actually, and serious in tone. Of course, anything with purvi and probbaly arjun in it will always have unintended funny moments. I love your analyses not just for the satire, which is a hoot, but coz you catch the nuances and express them beautifully 😊. So please continue, and even if I don't always find it funny or even agree to it, I will always like it.

I just watched the episode, and it was good! HT was amazing as a dad, and you're right---finally someone asked the right questions. So proud of him today, but then I've always liked HT and especially as a dad in PR. He plays it so well 😳. Arjun was good though. You're right, it's not a very good role for him to be associated with. It's become pathetic, it would have been better if it was negative. Pathetic wimps exist, but we don't want to see them as leads on tv. It must have been difficult for him to do such degrading scenes, but at least I'm glad he's stepping it up in the acting department instead of just being there. Can't really make out his reaction on savita declaring she won't let them divorce though---was he hopeful that hhis marriage will be saved or appalled that somebody, anybody is not getting him a divorce from ovi. He of course can't do it by himself, for reasons I can't understand. Let's see what's in store for us with the explicitly forbidden rishta. Nothing good, I'm afraid

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".