I wish.. - Page 2

If we look at it minutely.. RK never crossed their paths.. First Madhu shoved herself down his throat and now Sultan is crossing his path..

Originally posted by: cardio21

If we look at it minutely.. RK never crossed their paths.. First Madhu shoved herself down his throat and now Sultan is crossing his path..

The entire story started with an accident he did.. He was willing to pay compensation for which the guy's family was more than happy.. Please I know he was wrong, but gopher admitted to Bittuji that what he did was wrong..

And Madhu before getting a spine to challenge RK again or leave him to die needs to revise her morals.. She can overlook so many killings done by bhai because of Aryan, what makes her think that people bhai has been cutting like veggies are childless? And one hit n run by RK was a big deal.

She wanted RK to apologize, does bhai call up families and apologize for all the necks he broke.?

Just because they crossed his paths it doesnt justify what he did to them. RK might have admitted he was wrong in front of Bittuji but his ego never let go with it other wise he would have not gone ahead with the revenge. I dont know what others are thinking but with Sultan and Bhujang conversation I got the idea the CVs wanted to portray Sultan as a done who takes the law into his own hands by putting other criminals to justice. Thats what I got when he said I only harm those who harm others.

Originally posted by: Gurtiluv

that one time hit and run could have very well killed Mukand and he would have been charged with manslaughter. They didnt do this but RK would very well have been considered liable for what his men did to shamsher, beating almost to near death. The way he kidnapped Madhu and took her to his house against her will is very well illegal even if she is married to him legally she still has a right to decide whether or not she wants to stay with him.

Yes Sultan is a registered criminal because he got pushed into crime at very young age when his mother got murdered in front of him. He has stated while talking to Bhujang that he only harms those who harm others. If RK's past justifies him intentionally harming innocents to gratify his ego than why cant Sultan's past justify him harming those that harm others.

Whether RK decided to take the case back was his decision his philosphy for taking it back should not apply to everyone else. My take is he was trying to woo Madhu so he could take revenge. He even called Shamsher being the killer a gift from God when he was narrating Madhu his revenge plan. He said to Bittuji that he was wrong in the hit and run case but did he ever apologize to Mukand. If he knew he was wrong than why did spread false rumors about Madhu for filing a complaint. He should know he deserved it naa.

We can also get into a debate that should the goverment have the right to kill those who have harmed others. That is also what I meant by Sultan taking the law into his own hands. and he got pushed into it at a very young age. Most kids that grow up on streets that are full of crime are more likely statically to be criminals. Im not justifying it but it is true. A kid gets their confidence from their home or theri street.

Madhu did her job as witness and Sultan came to help Madhu. There are many ppl who come in my way for an example I got into an accident at the parking lot a witness reported but the car owner said it was fine because it was a mere scratch. But I had to go through a lot because of the witness? Does that mean I go and create trouble for the witness because I have the power and money too?

If he is trying to woo Madhu he should start by respecting her and apologizing. not treating her like an object. I have to go! good night

Originally posted by: Gurtiluv

Whether RK decided to take the case back was his decision his philosphy for taking it back should not apply to everyone else. My take is he was trying to woo Madhu so he could take revenge. He even called Shamsher being the killer a gift from God when he was narrating Madhu his revenge plan. He said to Bittuji that he was wrong in the hit and run case but did he ever apologize to Mukand. If he knew he was wrong than why did spread false rumors about Madhu for filing a complaint. He should know he deserved it naa.

We can also get into a debate that should the goverment have the right to kill those who have harmed others. That is also what I meant by Sultan taking the law into his own hands. and he got pushed into it at a very young age. Most kids that grow up on streets that are full of crime are more likely statically to be criminals.

Madhu did her job as witness and Sultan came to help Madhu. There are many ppl who come in my way for an example I got into an accident at the parking lot a witness reported but the car owner said it was fine because it was a mere scratch. But I had to go through a lot because of the witness? Does that mean I go and create trouble for the witness because I have the power and money too?

If he is trying to woo Madhu he should start by respecting her and apologizing. not treating her like an object. I have to go! good night

Originally posted by: Gurtiluv

that one time hit and run could have very well killed Mukand and he would have been charged with manslaughter. They didnt do this but RK would very well have been considered liable for what his men did to shamsher, beating almost to near death. The way he kidnapped Madhu and took her to his house against her will is very well illegal even if she is married to him legally she still has a right to decide whether or not she wants to stay with him.

Yes Sultan is a registered criminal because he got pushed into crime at very young age when his mother got murdered in front of him. He has stated while talking to Bhujang that he only harms those who harm others. If RK's past justifies him intentionally harming innocents to gratify his ego than why cant Sultan's past justify him harming those that harm others.

there's no real point in bringing up 'what if's" since a lot of things that weren't even on the cards happened. i.e revenge track. that's why it's safe to assume that not everything RK did was purely out of revenge, since the cvs never meant the story to go in that direction to begin with and only added that in when they exhausted all efforts of continuity with plot. and i've never used RK's past to excuse of away all his actions, however criminal you may categorize them out to be, but Sultan is an out and out criminal. the only thing we know about him is what he's said himself, and how much of that is true? does anyone know, do they even care to hypothesize that there may be darker undercurrents to his criminal career besides his tragic childhood? i can see you're inherent distaste for RK's character, as he's being portrayed now, prevents you from delving too deep into his psyche but that's not the case with me and Sultan. i've given him many chances, so many, and each time i end up more dissatisfied with the outcome. but yeah, let's just agree to disagree and leave it at that; kind of over discussionizzzing when we've both already picked which side of the fence to sit on.

Originally posted by: Sagar21

Reported