Gayatri's reaction was unbelievable, what crap

kanhaiya244 thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#1

Gayatri's reaction today left me stunned. I can't think of a woman who would react that way to the news that her husband had an affair, had a child as a result of the affair, and the woman who had the child switched her child with Gayatri's. Who is buying this? Most women would be livid at being lied to and their child being kidnapped from them. (Remember Arti's reaction when Ansh was taken from her).

The story line is compelling, there are lots of skeletons in people' closets because "log kya kehenge" and it leads people to be silent instead of speaking their truths.
Her husband had an affair yrs ago. First of all, when a man has an affair, is it usually limited to just one woman? Exactly. Most people understand, that generally isn't a one time occurence. Most men (and women) who have extramarital affairs, generally don't limit themselves to one person. Secondly, her husband got the woman pregnant and refused to take care of the child or take responsibility for it in any way. Kind human being? One would argue that question. Then that woman confronts him decades later and he lies about it in public and in private.
The only reason he admits to it is that he realizes his wife got jipped of her own child. Radha switched the babies. So now, he feels he can't hide anymore. To show Gayatri, a spitfire under most conditions, to be so completely docile and accepting was ridiculous beyond measure. And for her to buy the argument that it was "just one time that I made a mistake" made it even worse. The very first thing a rational human being would think was "how many others were there?". They didn't bring up her issues with trust or honesty that she is sure to have now. I felt like they were showing a person who felt their feelings or emotions meant nothing at all.
I think Yash's reaction was normal and he portrayed that well. By the way, I just read the other post by someone who had a conversation with the actor Gurmeet who plays Yash, and honestly, it was a little concerning, unless its a kid of course. Fans need to remember, you don't love the actor, you love the character they are portraying. This is their work. You don't know this person. How would you feel if a complete stranger told you that they loved you? This actor is busy, he has no time to read your letter and he appreciates that you are a fan of the show, but he probably doesn't have enough time to spend with his own family/friends for him to have time to read fan mail. Just a thought. I think when I see public adulation for actors/actresses it makes me quite guarded about the sanity of fans. I was at a conference years ago where the actress Madhuri Dixit was part of a panel. It was a professional group of people in the room, maybe several hundred people. Yet when she arrived, grown men and women, many in their 50s and 60s, rushed towards her just to try and touch her. I was just embarassed to be part of that audience that was behaving that way. It would have been more appropriate for people to sit in their seats and allow her to be comfortable and to engage her in conversation during the panel, there was plenty of opportunity to do so. I saw her husband trying to protect her, and he must think people are mad. Sorry got off track, but when I see posts with such adulation for actors, I wonder why. We don't know these people. Let them be.
Sorry for the rant. Just irritated with various parts of this show. They could have done a much better job and trying to realistically portray this type of an event in a family, which by the way, is SO common everywhere. People have extramarital affairs abundantly. It was hard to buy Gayatri's reaction at all, this affects her, Yash, and Akash the most.

Created

Last reply

Replies

9

Views

3.6k

Users

9

Likes

14

Frequent Posters

gmhatcher thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#2
I have to say that you made some valid and (up until the Madhuri Dixit part) concise points and in essence I agree with them but I would respectfully like to make the following observations.
1. Gayatri just found out in the most public way possible minus the cameras that her husband cheated on her and wether it is the 1st or 50th time the thing she has to process is that she has been betrayed.
2. Generational thinking would play a very large part in the way she responds to the betrayal and what she has been shown doing is falling into a preprogrmmed "perfect wife" mode. She even says " a husband is God and God doesn't make mistakes". Nice in sentiment, impractical in the real world, but safe in an emotionally fragile state (which everything in her carrage says she is).
3. Aakash as a person or her biological son has not registered yet. For however long it took them to clear everyone out and various family members to find places to brood, Aakash is still a non-issue for her. Her husband's betrayal is, the hurt of the son she raised is, but the young man that she goaded her sons into humiliating still is not on her radar. That she is the mother of a son she doesn't know maybe but I'm still not really sure about that.
4. Yash's hurt has been duly noted by his mother (Gayatri). She has always had a soft spot for him, he has been her favorite and she has let everyone know it and she just found out he's not hers (again this is only biology). For her beyond the betrayal the fact that Yash is not hers through biology has to be devastating. And the look on his face alone was enough to break a mother's heart.
Finally I would like to point out that what is happening is a form of grieving and for as many books, DVDs, CDs, and customs that surround grieving and the grieving process everyone does it differently and separately from others and this woman has a lot to mourn.
So ultimately I would have to say her behavior was understandable for me at least.
In life there are a lot of things to overcome but the hardest thing to overcome is the loss of faith.



Edited by gmhatcher - 13 years ago
psaniya thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#3
I don't agree with you completely.

I know that G3 is hurt, feels betrayed but she is from the era where husband is looked as a God. So even if he makes any mistake, their wives do not break relations . That's why she said ' Mai mera dharm marate dum tak nibhaungi".

A you don't know, probably SP is right, this may be the only mistake he had commited. Most of the people in society keep quiet after this n SP did the same.

What would Pari had done if she would have been pregnant after the CON with producer?
gmhatcher thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: psaniya

I don't agree with you completely.

I know that G3 is hurt, feels betrayed but she is from the era where husband is looked as a God. So even if he makes any mistake, their wives do not break relations . That's why she said ' Mai mera dharm marate dum tak nibhaungi".

A you don't know, probably SP is right, this may be the only mistake he had commited. Most of the people in society keep quiet after this n SP did the same.

What would Pari had done if she would have been pregnant after the CON with producer?

I would think that the one thing Pari has learned from all of this is just what we've seen from her lately...
"Keep your head down and your mouth shut".😆
Chitra_11 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 3 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#5
Respect your POV - and I believe the character they are playing - G3 - is coming from a background/era where their belief is not modern and continue to live in that world and more so - she has 3 grownup sons and she has become a grandma and so she has no other choice but to accept the situation and act maturely as she knows her family is in a state of shock.
Surish thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail Networker 3 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#6
Gayatri can't help it! It's part of India's culture!
palbhar thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#7
Yes, she was not screaming her heart and lungs out but I felt the few lines she uttered spoke volumes!!!!!
She acted in a very dignified manner and that itself is a great slap to SP!!!!!!!
..Comrade4eva.. thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#8
SP thought that G3 would overreact. That's why he hid it.She proved him wrong which was a direct slap in his face. The lines she said meant a lot and she doesn't want this to break a relationship that is dear to her, hence her reaction. Plus she is still in shock, you never know what her reaction will be later on.
jyoti01 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#9

I suppose that is how most women who have been leading her sort of life wud react. If you remember, in the earlier episodes, SS wud hardly allow her to speak and he wud be very dominating with her.

Her dialogue and composure reminded me of Jaya Bachchan, in Kabhi Kushi Kabhi Gham, where she says to Amitabh Bachchan (her husband in the film) "maa hamesha keheti thi ki pati, Parmeshwar hota hai...par Parmeshwar se kabhi galti nahin hoti, tho aap sirf Pati rahe, parmeshwar nahin (it was something like this..._
anushaarja thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#10
well... you can see sarcasm in every bit of words she uttered to SP...she did lose the respect she had for him... it is just that she is trying to act sane for the sake of the family... you can clearly see sarcasm of her words that husbands are meant to be treated as gods... clear and transparent in her hatred... but she has a family to look after and she can't see it be dispersed... and separated... so she needs to be the way she was...
coming to your adulation part... people don't love only the characters the love actors too... they love the characters coz they love the actors who played those characters... i love maan singh khurana the character played by gurmeet coz i love gurmeet who did it... i love the character yash coz i love gurmeet... hope you get want i wanna convey...
Edited by anushaarja - 13 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".