Screenindia-Sanskar family melo- drama

Armu4eva thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#1

Family melodrama

By Kshama Rao | Posted: Mumbai, Fri Feb 08 2013, 19:51 hrs
A A

Jay Soni and Aruna Irani in Sanskaar Dharohar Apnon Ki

Mumbai: Sanskaar Dharohar Apnon Ki

Colors, Mondays to Fridays, 9 pm

Cast: Aruna Irani, Swapna Waghmare Joshi, Jay Soni, Shamim Mannan

Sanskaar Dharohar Apnon Ki reminds you of those 1980s films, in which the hero is a perpetual loser with a heart of gold and his family (a joint family with too many dependents) pinning all their hopes on him. There is a debt to clear, promises to be kept and family legacy to be upheld and so you know how exactly it's all going to pan out unless the serial doesn't get abruptly pulled off air. There is also that whole 'Mera Bharat Mahaan' angle to it (Manoj Kumar would be proud), with every two minutes, our hero saying lines like 'Hum Indians galti karke sorry bolna jaante hain', 'Hum Indians itne meethe hain ki saamnewale ko diabetes ho jaati hai' (and we thought it was our poor lifestyle that did us in!).

Did you ask for the story? Jai Kishan Vaishnav is a textile designer whose family includes a matriarch, parents, uncles, aunts, cousins etc. The matriarch having lost her husband has only one dream - of keeping the family legacy alive, a kapde ka mill which has shut down because of rising debts. The workers are a disgruntled lot and there is a son, the black sheep of the family who doesn't quite understand his mother's grand ambition of resurrecting the mill. But there is Kishan, the grandson who wants to keep his grandparents' legacy alive. So he takes up a job in a New York fashion magazine for a hefty salary, hoping he would earn enough to come back to India after three months and clear all the debts and reopen the mill. But he end up getting his bag with his work documents stolen as his mother told him to pray at a temple in New York! He gets three days from his employer to search the bag even as he bumps into the mysterious girl, who has taken his bag, time and again, but due to the silly twists and turns in the plot, it's always a hit and miss.

What's annoying about Sanskaar is its painful effort to be holier than thou. Each character, save the cunning uncle, is ideal and perfect. There is an extremely irritating daughter-in-law who comes with a background score 'aee chaapli' (which roughly translates into mischief-maker). And the wimp-like character of Jai Kishan doesn't do anything to lift the show. Here's hoping he gets more dashing in the future episodes. Luckily, the lead female character, Bhoomi is easy on the eye and brings in the necessary respite.

Co-produced by Swapna Waghmare Joshi (as a director, she's given us fairly watchable shows before), the show tries to tug at your heartstrings with every scene, every line possible; it gets tedious after a point.The performances range from over-the-top to mildly amusing. Jay Soni as Kishan seems to have mastered the stereotype of an 'innocent, ideal good boy' to his own disadvantage. Shamim Mannan as Bhoomi is likeable, Rajendra Chawla as Hasmukh kaka, is falling into the stereotype of 'grey' characters and Aruna Irani as Ansuben Vaishnav, the matriarch, is thankfully restrained and wears lovely saris! Sanskaar Dharohar Apnon Ki would have worked beautifully had the makers chosen to keep it real and not turn it into a too- perfect-for-your-comfort family drama. The effort jars!

Verdict: A crashing bore

Created

Last reply

Replies

15

Views

2.8k

Users

12

Likes

21

Frequent Posters

SuShaanRocks thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#2

Originally posted by: Armu4eva

Family melodrama

By Kshama Rao | Posted: Mumbai, Fri Feb 08 2013, 19:51 hrs
A A

Jay Soni and Aruna Irani in Sanskaar Dharohar Apnon Ki

Mumbai: Sanskaar Dharohar Apnon Ki

Colors, Mondays to Fridays, 9 pm

Cast: Aruna Irani, Swapna Waghmare Joshi, Jay Soni, Shamim Mannan

Sanskaar Dharohar Apnon Ki reminds you of those 1980s films, in which the hero is a perpetual loser with a heart of gold and his family (a joint family with too many dependents) pinning all their hopes on him. There is a debt to clear, promises to be kept and family legacy to be upheld and so you know how exactly it's all going to pan out unless the serial doesn't get abruptly pulled off air. There is also that whole 'Mera Bharat Mahaan' angle to it (Manoj Kumar would be proud), with every two minutes, our hero saying lines like 'Hum Indians galti karke sorry bolna jaante hain', 'Hum Indians itne meethe hain ki saamnewale ko diabetes ho jaati hai' (and we thought it was our poor lifestyle that did us in!).

Did you ask for the story? Jai Kishan Vaishnav is a textile designer whose family includes a matriarch, parents, uncles, aunts, cousins etc. The matriarch having lost her husband has only one dream - of keeping the family legacy alive, a kapde ka mill which has shut down because of rising debts. The workers are a disgruntled lot and there is a son, the black sheep of the family who doesn't quite understand his mother's grand ambition of resurrecting the mill. But there is Kishan, the grandson who wants to keep his grandparents' legacy alive. So he takes up a job in a New York fashion magazine for a hefty salary, hoping he would earn enough to come back to India after three months and clear all the debts and reopen the mill. But he end up getting his bag with his work documents stolen as his mother told him to pray at a temple in New York! He gets three days from his employer to search the bag even as he bumps into the mysterious girl, who has taken his bag, time and again, but due to the silly twists and turns in the plot, it's always a hit and miss.

What's annoying about Sanskaar is its painful effort to be holier than thou. Each character, save the cunning uncle, is ideal and perfect. There is an extremely irritating daughter-in-law who comes with a background score 'aee chaapli' (which roughly translates into mischief-maker). And the wimp-like character of Jai Kishan doesn't do anything to lift the show. Here's hoping he gets more dashing in the future episodes. Luckily, the lead female character, Bhoomi is easy on the eye and brings in the necessary respite.

Co-produced by Swapna Waghmare Joshi (as a director, she's given us fairly watchable shows before), the show tries to tug at your heartstrings with every scene, every line possible; it gets tedious after a point.The performances range from over-the-top to mildly amusing. Jay Soni as Kishan seems to have mastered the stereotype of an 'innocent, ideal good boy' to his own disadvantage. Shamim Mannan as Bhoomi is likeable, Rajendra Chawla as Hasmukh kaka, is falling into the stereotype of 'grey' characters and Aruna Irani as Ansuben Vaishnav, the matriarch, is thankfully restrained and wears lovely saris! Sanskaar Dharohar Apnon Ki would have worked beautifully had the makers chosen to keep it real and not turn it into a too- perfect-for-your-comfort family drama. The effort jars!

Verdict: A crashing bore


Hummm...
sitakshii thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#3
Till now i hv found the show emotional and refreshing types...
hope the makers pay more attention on the love story of Jay and bhoomi ...that will give a cute tatse to the show ...
serialduniya thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#4
it is too early for the comment*boring*

most the stories and scenes in all the serials across all channels remind us of Bollywood films or

Other shows ..so that is nothing new..

Jay-Bhoomi love story may be cute


but usually This 9 p.m slot is reserved for emotional family drama across all prime channels

The producers might not take risk by showing too much of their love story or for that matter

any love story in the show for long time in an episode and in one shot

..It might come in between assorted scenes
Edited by serialduniya - 12 years ago
SuShaanRocks thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#5
Somewhere dey right... As imo der is nothin wrong in screen play & der presntation... D problem is only dis MELODRAMATIC STORY...
I agreed wid d writer dat... D MAKERs shild show some REAL thing in d show... As stickin wid dis family drama & whatevr else...
But more luk"MERA BHARAT MAHAN" types dialoges really killing d realism of d show.
As people can't stick wid dis story 4 long... :-(
luckym2012 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#6
Oh dear. New formula's + Plots for drama only work if the stories are pin pointed early on. I guess this is the kind of drama where you hae to follow it from the beginning to understand, unless the characters are not given a solid foundation and depthness very soon, i fear the worst for the show. Critics often criticize without having watched the entire episodes so for now we can only keep our hopes and hope that the time for critical approval comes very soon.
Edited by luckym2012 - 12 years ago
.FearlessSoul. thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#7
i'm watching the show for jay but i can't lie.. the show is actually really boring 🥱
The_May_Rose thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 12 years ago
#8
Most of us are watching the show for either Jay or Yashashri...The story had potential, but is being shown as sentimental and boring...
I was recently reminded, that the co-producer of SDAK, is the daughter in-law of a very powerful political family...So is this show a platform for propaganda material?...
I can't pinpoint anything exactly, but how can they present the issue of dowry so lightly?...As if that is acceptable practise...How can Indian values be promoted, but the west shown as harsh and uncaring?...
I am not sure...But I have a strange feeling about the message this show is trying to give😕...
In addition to this, we are shown examples or a set of values, but the story seems to be lost?🤔...
Edited by The_May_Rose - 12 years ago
svpg thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#9
The son of the house Hasu is betraying his own family, his wife and daughter in law are partners in crime. From the IF Synopsis, it seems like the other son Ankit is another useless character who tries to rape Bharti plus there is Bharti's would be in-laws who are so shameless that they want their dowry inspite of knowing the Vaishnav's condition and then here is Jai Kishan in America preaching "Mera Bharat Mahaan" values which are so contradictory to the values in his own family. On top of that, he very conveniently criticizes the western culture. I would have liked the serial if the OTT melodrama in U.S. and the value preaching (that does not even exist in his own home) was not there.
I actually like the story in Gujarat a lot more, atleast there is a story!
jsrkfan thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#10
Every story takes it's own time to build-up. Every character will take it's own time to get attached to the audience. Once this happens the show will catch more eye-balls. So let's be optimistic guys 😊. It's too early to give any verdict about the show

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".