Some questions about MS episode..

jasw thumbnail
21st Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#1
1. Why did not Zoya tell everyone why the marriage is not accepted by the bride? Why did she had to run away? The intention should have been to disgrace the boy who committed rape and his wrong intentions should have been made public by Zoya. But running like this puts the blame to the girl. Everyone would think the girl eloped with another guy.

2. Without knowing the reasons, Asad came to Zoya's rescue but then he barges into the police station saying kuch goonde hamare peeche hai? How can he address his uncle as goonda? or for that matter the groom side! Since he is still unaware of the entire rape incident.

I think the scene would have made more sense, if Zoya had made the entire incident with the girl public and asked for justice. Then they could have shown the groom becoming violent and threaten Zoya. Now Asad could have come to the rescue and both could have run from that place. His dialog about goons after them would have made more sense!

Created

Last reply

Replies

14

Views

1.9k

Users

5

Likes

28

Frequent Posters

Drama-Fan thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#2
this could have possible if it was a normal epi or exclusive ME of QH.
since it was a MS we had 2 co operate PV too. & had 2 follow many things like timings 4 both shows scenes, etc. so it was done in such a manner where the timings gets managed & the couples meets as shown & how the first part of the MS ended. otherwise it would hav take one episode's time only 4 tat...& the cross over wouldn't have completed in monday too...i hope u got it.
now i can only say about this much...& about Asad knowing truth, etc etc...wait & watch...ok dear...
Laila2009 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#3
Exactly what I thought as well. Poorly written scenes.
Laila2009 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: SaRun_ArHi

this could have possible if it was a normal epi or exclusive ME of QH.

since it was a MS we had 2 co operate PV too. & had 2 follow many things like timings 4 both shows scenes, etc. so it was done in such a manner where the timings gets managed & the couples meets as shown & how the first part of the MS ended. otherwise it would hav take one episode's time only 4 tat...& the cross over wouldn't have completed in monday too...i hope u got it.
now i can only say about this much...& about Asad knowing truth, etc etc...wait & watch...ok dear...


Don't make excuses for such poor writing. Those lines take hardly 30 second to put into a show. It was a major flaw and made it look very amateurish.
Champa2012 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: jasw

1. Why did not Zoya tell everyone why the marriage is not accepted by the bride? Why did she had to run away? The intention should have been to disgrace the boy who committed rape and his wrong intentions should have been made public by Zoya. But running like this puts the blame to the girl. Everyone would think the girl eloped with another guy.


2. Without knowing the reasons, Asad came to Zoya's rescue but then he barges into the police station saying kuch goonde hamare peeche hai? How can he address his uncle as goonda? or for that matter the groom side! Since he is still unaware of the entire rape incident.

I think the scene would have made more sense, if Zoya had made the entire incident with the girl public and asked for justice. Then they could have shown the groom becoming violent and threaten Zoya. Now Asad could have come to the rescue and both could have run from that place. His dialog about goons after them would have made more sense!



My thoughts:
1. zoya wanted to buy as much time as possible for Mariyam to run away. Farther she goes, harder it is for these people to find her and get her back.
2. Asad came to help her because he feels she is his responsibility since she is a guest of his mom. He doesn't agree to what she does, but wants to protect her for the same reason. It was not his uncle who came behind them. If I have watched it carefully, it was the sarpanch or someone of the village along with groom's side people. One need not know if a person has done something wrong to call a person a gunda. Their weapons and chasing is enough.
If Zoya had made it apparent to everyone that she was not the bride and what the groom has done to Mariyam, she would've been killed and they would've gone after Mariyam and brought her back and either killed her or get her married to the same guy.

At the end of the day, it is fiction. We all need to remember that.


Drama-Fan thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: Laila2009


Don't make excuses for such poor writing. Those lines take hardly 30 second to put into a show. It was a major flaw and made it look very amateurish.


i really didnt get u.
u said it was major one & also u r saying it could hav put within 30 sec.s. really?
this seems more amateurish 4 me...sorry!
Drama-Fan thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: Champa2012



My thoughts:
1. zoya wanted to buy as much time as possible for Mariyam to run away. Farther she goes, harder it is for these people to find her and get her back.
2. Asad came to help her because he feels she is his responsibility since she is a guest of his mom. He doesn't agree to what she does, but wants to protect her for the same reason. It was not his uncle who came behind them. If I have watched it carefully, it was the sarpanch or someone of the village along with groom's side people. One need not know if a person has done something wrong to call a person a gunda. Their weapons and chasing is enough.
If Zoya had made it apparent to everyone that she was not the bride and what the groom has done to Mariyam, she would've been killed and they would've gone after Mariyam and brought her back and either killed her or get her married to the same guy.

At the end of the day, it is fiction. We all need to remember that.




thank u so much dear..😊... u r mature enough 2 understand all these...hope every1'll understand too.!
-.Kangan.- thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: jasw

1. Why did not Zoya tell everyone why the marriage is not accepted by the bride? Why did she had to run away? The intention should have been to disgrace the boy who committed rape and his wrong intentions should have been made public by Zoya. But running like this puts the blame to the girl. Everyone would think the girl eloped with another guy.

Basically because the girl told her parents that she doesn't want to get married and if her parents aren't listening to her, saying all this in public would have angered the groom's family which would have created even more chaos! And her mum was coming into the room, they would have taken her by force even if zoya had tried to make them understand. AND remembering that zoya always tries to make things right, however, her action isn't always the best choice. This has happened in the past episodes, many examples of it!


2. Without knowing the reasons, Asad came to Zoya's rescue but then he barges into the police station saying kuch goonde hamare peeche hai? How can he address his uncle as goonda? or for that matter the groom side! Since he is still unaware of the entire rape incident.

He wasn't addressing his uncle but the groom's side. And they all had swords and guns! What else was he supposed to call them? And he had to rescue zoya as she is his responsibility in a sense! She ran away from there and everybody ran behind her to catch her, so obviously he had to save her.

I think the scene would have made more sense, if Zoya had made the entire incident with the girl public and asked for justice. Then they could have shown the groom becoming violent and threaten Zoya. Now Asad could have come to the rescue and both could have run from that place. His dialog about goons after them would have made more sense!



Not forgetting that it was a village and these kind of matters aren't always solved in the girl's favour! And if she had made it public that they wouldn't had been able to run away as everyone would be aware of the situation. And if the bride's parents aren't saying anything to the groom then I don't think others would have done anything! They would have forced mariyaam into it.

The biggest point is that it was done by zoya and so far if you've understood anything about her then that is that she does the right things but not in the best way! It's always a drama!!..

Your way was a way to go too but they had to match timing with PV scenes. I agree though, it could have been better at points but it was a MS and another one to come. they had to buy time. It happens in every show! 😊

jasw thumbnail
21st Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: SaRun_ArHi

this could have possible if it was a normal epi or exclusive ME of QH.

since it was a MS we had 2 co operate PV too. & had 2 follow many things like timings 4 both shows scenes, etc. so it was done in such a manner where the timings gets managed & the couples meets as shown & how the first part of the MS ended. otherwise it would hav take one episode's time only 4 tat...& the cross over wouldn't have completed in monday too...i hope u got it.
now i can only say about this much...& about Asad knowing truth, etc etc...wait & watch...ok dear...


Thanks for your answer, Sarun_arhi. I was complaining about the concept rather than the execution part. There were several execution problems in the episode, but I understand the time pressure and integration hassle of two shows, so have not mentioned those editing flaws! The creatives if they had thought about exposing the groom, could have done it in 5 minutes. In a serial one incident can be stretched to several episodes and on the other can take few minutes. It is upto the director and the creative team!

I was more interested in exposing the rapist than Asad knowing the truth. Asad will eventually know.
jasw thumbnail
21st Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: Laila2009

Exactly what I thought as well. Poorly written scenes.


I can understand your frustrations, Laila2009 😊

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".