Who is responsible for Shubra's situation

Is Karan really to fault? I think that to some extent Karan is innocent. I mean he was provoked and insulted in a really, really bad way by Shubra. I don't know if anyone remembers but this is before Nahar and Saloni were married and Shubra was in love with Karan. When Nahar's proposal came in for Shubra she rejected Karan and really, really insulted him infront of everyone because he threw a party for her in happiness that she had been named Miss College or something. I mean had that not happened maybe Shubra wouldn't be how she is right now. She could have told him off nicely or something like that. I hope you guys see what I'm saying. I'm not saying Karan is right or anything but to some extent he was provoked and instigated. I'm setting up a poll in relation to this. Please vote.

wwould say both are equally responsible!!

yes, at first place shubhra is at fault with her situation today, & i would say Karan & Kaveri are very much responsible for her too. and also she was unlucky to mess up with a guy like karan during college days. She had a huge attitude, & though karan started it with her, but she handled it in a very bad way that instigated karan for revenge. and on top on all this kaveri plays a very big role behind her current situation. she knew karan is a bad guy, & will only harm the girl, still she did her best to make shubhra run away with him, each & every step she helped karan to do the worse with shubhra. i would say the whole narpat family is unlucky to have a daughter-in-law like kaveri, who helps those who hurt the family.

Shubhra herself,she also got lot of chances to change things but still she always went in wrong direction.

Originally posted by: 12234

Is Karan really to fault? I think that to some extent Karan is innocent. I mean he was provoked and insulted in a really, really bad way by Shubra. I don't know if anyone remembers but this is before Nahar and Saloni were married and Shubra was in love with Karan. When Nahar's proposal came in for Shubra she rejected Karan and really, really insulted him infront of everyone because he threw a party for her in happiness that she had been named Miss College or something. I mean had that not happened maybe Shubra wouldn't be how she is right now. She could have told him off nicely or something like that. I hope you guys see what I'm saying. I'm not saying Karan is right or anything but to some extent he was provoked and instigated. I'm setting up a poll in relation to this. Please vote.

First of all, Shubhra did not love Karan. If you remember in the first two episodes, they showed Karan's advances towards Shubhra and she didn't like him - she kept avoiding him and Saloni also had told Karan to leave Shubhra alone, even though Shubhra didn't like Saloni's interference. Shubhra also slapped Karan when Karan tried to show off to her at one point in the the first few episodes. Shubhra only went to Karan when Nahar rejected her for Saloni. That is when she fell in Karan's love trap and ran away with him, acted horrible towards her sister and family only to end up pregnant, and then Karan and Kaveri hatched their schemes along side to ruin both Saloni and Shubhra. So no, Shubhra did not LOVE Karan until later - and even now, with her own foolishness, she was stupid enough to leave Neel and go to Karan, ruining Neel's life and hurting his heart more then anyone else.

Therefore, Shubhra is at fault for everything because she never thought sensibly. She was upset and jealous at her sister for getting Nahar and never respected Saloni anyway. Karma - what goes around definitely comes around later on.

her mother is totally responsible 4 her charecter 😡

Originally posted by: avtab

her mother is totally responsible 4 her charecter 😡

Its the Director and Writer who have written that script . :)

and all the people who encourage them to write such story lines. :)

Shubra herself is resposible. Then her mother. Kaveri, karan, to a degree Saloni too. When someone makes mistake let them suffer consequences. One can take stand eventually person will learn.But some people never learn. So let them suffer for the mistakes they made rather than helping them out every step of the way.

okay, ramas brought up a good point. to a degree saloni is responsible? is that true? Personally, I don't think so. I don't believe that it is up to others around you to help get you back in line.I think that once a person commits a mistake. Seeing the consequences they themselves should realize not to do that again? I mean Saloni brought Shubra back. But that was Saloni's duty/resonsbility as an older sister. I mean if you sister shows up on your doorstep after having a near accident with your fiance what else can you tell her. Go back? That eventually would just bring Shubra against Saloni in a bad, bad way. What do you guys think?